
RTI reveals ₹46.59L spent on salaries for vacant Sector 31 Group Home
An RTI query has revealed that the Chandigarh administration has spent ₹ 46.59 lakh in staff salaries for the Group Home in Sector 31 during 2024–25—despite the facility still being non-operational. The disclosure has sparked concerns among parents and caregivers of persons with mental illness, intellectual disabilities, and autism spectrum disorder, for whom the home was built as a long-term residential care facility.
Filed by 78-year-old BK Chadha, a parent of a boy with mental illness, the RTI reply from the social welfare department stated that 18 staff members—including one manager, nine security guards, six safai karamcharis and two malis—were deployed at the facility on July 15, 2024. Hired through a manpower agency via the Government e-Marketplace (GeM) portal, the staff continues to draw salaries amounting to ₹5 lakh per month, even though the home has not welcomed a single resident since its completion in July 2024.
The prolonged delay in operationalising the Group Home, the controversial ₹20 lakh security deposit for admission and the absence of trained caregiving staff have drawn sustained criticism from the public.
Another RTI filed by Harsharan Kaur, a Sector 37-D resident, disclosed that 216 representations were submitted in 2024–25 concerning the Group Home. Among these, 37 came from family representatives and independent mental health professionals who are part of the governing and executive bodies of the UTTHAAN Society—tasked with overseeing the facility's operations.
Following an interim order from the Punjab and Haryana high court urging a review of the security deposit clause, a meeting of the 13-member governing body headed by the UT advisor is expected soon. 'We are seeking time from the advisor for the governing body meeting. As of now, our stance on the security deposit remains the same. We are examining the court order and will see what can be done,' said Palika Arora, director, social welfare and secretary of the governing body.
Despite the controversy, the social welfare department went ahead with its admission process. A public notice invited applications by April 10, 2025, and 33 entries were received, including from economically weaker sections (EWS). These applicants have begun a mandatory 45-day medical assessment at the Mental Health Institute, Sector 32, and GRIID, Sector 31, starting May 7.
The department confirmed that the assessment schedule remains unchanged and will be followed by a 45-day day-care programme before full residential enrolment begins.

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


India Today
20 hours ago
- India Today
Centralised procurement in Delhi's healthcare: A necessary reform facing resistance?
The Delhi government's recent decision to mandate the Central Procurement Agency (CPA) as the sole body responsible for procuring medicines, medical devices, and equipment for state-run hospitals has been hailed as a transformative step toward transparency and efficiency in healthcare delivery. However, the move has reportedly faced resistance from Dr Rati Makar, Director General of Health Services (DGHS), raising concerns about potential vested interests disrupting a system designed to curb corruption and streamline CPA represents a systemic overhaul aimed at fixing a broken procurement process. While resistance from within the system is not uncommon during such transitions, the focus should remain on whether the agency delivers on its promises: fair pricing, timely supplies, and better patient care. If Dr Makar's objections are procedural, they should be addressed transparently. But if the pushback stems from vested interests, it would only reinforce the need for the CPA's stricter THE CPA MATTERSThe CPA was introduced to address longstanding issues in Delhi's healthcare procurement: Price Inflation & Discrepancies: Hospitals previously procured supplies directly or via the Government e-Marketplace (GeM) portal's cart feature, leading to inflated prices and audit irregularities .Administrative Burden: Doctors and hospital staff were bogged down by procurement tasks, diverting attention from patient care. The CPA centralises demands, allowing medical professionals to focus on treatment .Transparency & Accountability: By consolidating procurement under one agency, the government aims to eliminate price manipulation and ensure compliance with financial regulations .ALLEGED RESISTANCE FROM DGHSadvertisementDespite the CPA's clear benefits, reports suggest that Dr Rati Makar, DGHS, is attempting to obstruct its implementation. While no official statement from Dr Makar has been cited, sources indicate concerns over:Loss of Discretionary Powers: The shift to centralised procurement removes individual hospitals' autonomy in purchasing, potentially disrupting existing Influence of Drug Mafias: Critics speculate that resistance could stem from entrenched interests benefiting from the older, less regulated procurement system .A NEUTRAL PERSPECTIVEWhile the BJP government frames the CPA as a pro-patient reform, the resistance highlights a broader debate:Efficiency vs. Autonomy: Centralisation can reduce corruption but may also slow emergency procurements. The CPA does allow exceptions for urgent needs, but bureaucratic delays remain a concern.


The Hindu
a day ago
- The Hindu
Information Commission rejects society's contention; orders appointment of SPIO
Rejecting the contention of the Sree Avittom Thirunal Hospital Health Education Society (SATHHES) that it did not come under the purview of the Right to Information (RTI) Act, the State Information Commission on Thursday issued directions to immediately appoint a State Public Information Officer (SPIO) in the institution. The order was issued by State Information Commissioner Sreekumar M. based on an appeal filed by Thiruvananthapuram native Sindhu S. In her RTI application, she had sought detailed information about gratuity disbursed to employees of SATHHES between January 2017 and September 2021, including names, addresses, amounts and dates of payment. The society administration had initially denied the request, stating that SATHHES does not fall under the ambit of the RTI Act. This was reiterated by the appellate authority. However, the Commission ruled otherwise after a hearing held recently. Intertwined with govt. The order states that while SATHHES is registered under the Travancore - Cochin Literary, Scientific, Cultural and Charitable Societies Registration Act, 1955, its executive and administrative structure is intertwined with the State government. The institution's executive council and governing body comprise government officials, including the Principal of the Thiruvananthapuram Government Medical College, the superintendent of Sree Avittom Thirunal Hospital, and officials from the Ministry of Health and Family Welfare. The Commission also observed that the society operates from government-owned premises without paying rent and is administered by government employees. As a result, the argument that SATHHES is not a public institution cannot be accepted as it functioned under the direct control of the State government. This made the society obligated to disclose information under the RTI Act, the order stated.


The Hindu
a day ago
- The Hindu
Supply shortage forces SCTIMST doctors to call off neuro-interventional procedures indefinitely
Shortage or near-total unavailability of necessary materials for neuro Cath laboratories—high-end specialised catheters, stents and specialised soft platinum coils used for endovascular coiling to treat brain aneurysms—has led clinicians at the Sree Chitra Tirunal Institute for Medical Sciences and Technology (SCTIMST) to call off all scheduled neuro-interventional procedures from next week, throwing patient care into disarray. Many patients who were scheduled to undergo interventional procedures from this weekend, after being on the waiting list for long, were informed in the eleventh hour that their procedures were being suspended and that they would have to seek treatment elsewhere. The decision to suspend all peripheral and neuro-interventional procedures at the SCTIMST from June 9 was taken by the doctors at the Department of Imaging Sciences (IS) and Interventional Radiology (IR). They pointed out that they were unable to perform routine and emergency interventional procedures because the manufacturers had withdrawn all supplies from the Cath labs. In a letter to the Director of the SCTIMST on Friday, the doctors said that they had been repeatedly reminding the administration since November 2023 that essential intervention materials for the Cath labs of the IS and IR department were going short. They said that they were using the bare minimum resources to continue doing the neuro-intervention procedures. The doctors pointed out that they had taken up this issue with the administration multiple times and even suggested possible solutions. Yet, 'the current administration had not been able to maintain the operational needs of one of the institute's key departments, one that has played a foundational role in advancing endovascular interventions in the country,' they said. They refused to resume interventional procedures till regular and adequate supply of necessary materials was restored. Mostly imported According to sources, the problem of shortage of supplies arose because the rate contract for medical supplies was not renewed after 2023 and the contract rates were being extended. Most of the materials used for neuro-intervention procedures are imported and after import prices went up, the manufacturers and suppliers refused to continue supplying the same at the rates quoted in 2023. 'The Union government wants all public procurement to go through the Government e-Marketplace (GeM) portal for more streamlined and transparent procurement but there have been many quality concern issues, technical rejections due to non-conformance to specifications and so on, leading to huge delays in procurement. On the other hand, there are no Indian-made substitutes for the kind of Cath lab materials that the IR dept needs. It is unusual for doctors at the SCTIMST to show open defiance but the Radiology department felt that they were driven to the wall,' a senior doctor at the SCTIMST told The Hindu. The SCTIMST administration officials said that till now, as an autonomous institution, the doctors at the SCTIMST had a say regarding purchases. 'However, from May 2023, it is mandatory that all public procurements be made through the GeM portal. The current stalemate over procurement has all to do with the shifting over to the new purchase system. It is very cumbersome and there are many process delays, especially when some of the items that Radiology needs are customised. Our doctors are very upset and it is hurting our patients but we need time to tide over this mess,' an administrative official said. Institute's statement The SCTIMST later issued a statement that due to the ongoing streamlining of the procurement process of interventional devices, 'there will be a rescheduling of certain neuro-interventional procedures.'