logo
Illinois man convicted of murder and hate crimes in stabbing of 6-year-old Palestinian American boy

Illinois man convicted of murder and hate crimes in stabbing of 6-year-old Palestinian American boy

Yahoo28-02-2025

JOLIET, Ill. — An Illinois man was found guilty Friday in the fatal stabbing of a 6-year-old Palestinian American boy and the wounding of his mother, an attack that prosecutors said was motivated by anti-Muslim hate and just days after Hamas attacked Israel in October 2023.
Joseph Czuba was convicted of first-degree murder, attempted murder, aggravated battery and hate crimes in the Oct. 14, 2023, killing of Wadee Alfayoumi, who was stabbed 26 times, and in the wounding of his mother, Hanan Shaheen, who was stabbed more than a dozen times in suburban Chicago.
The jury deliberated for just over an hour.
The mother and son rented two rooms from Czuba and his then-wife in Plainfield Township, about 40 miles southwest of downtown Chicago, where the attack took place.
Shaheen, 33, testified that Czuba, 73, turned on her shortly after Hamas attacked Israel on Oct. 7, 2023. She said he and his then-wife were aware that she is Muslim and of Palestinian descent before they agreed to rent the rooms to her, and that she didn't previously have any issues in the two years she rented from them. She was the prosecution's first witness.
Shaheen and Czuba's ex-wife, Mary Connor, who also testified for the prosecution, said that in the week leading up to the stabbings, Czuba was outraged about the war between Israel and Hamas. Shaheen said he began speaking hatefully about Muslims. Shaheen testified that Czuba told her 'your people' are killing Jewish people and babies in Israel, that Muslims were not welcome in his home and that she needed to move out.
'I told him, 'Pray for peace,'' Shaheen testified.
Days later, Shaheen said, Czuba forced his way into her room, held her down, stabbed her with a knife and tried to break her teeth, as her son, Wadee, watched in fear. At one point, she said, she was able to get ahold of the knife and stab Czuba with it before he seized it from her.
She said that when she went into a bathroom to call 911, Czuba moved on to Wadee, who had just celebrated his birthday. She said she could hear him shouting, 'Oh no, stop!'
A knife with a 7-inch blade, which prosecutors held up to show jurors multiple times during closing arguments, was still lodged in Wadee's body when first responders arrived and was later removed. Shaheen was hospitalized and received 19 stitches on her face, as well as staples on the back of her head.
The killing of Wadee and attack on Shaheen drew international attention and left many people in Illinois' large Muslim and Palestinian communities frightened. Heena Musabji, legal director at CAIR Chicago, said Friday it 'is the most heinous of hate crimes to impact Chicago's Muslim community in recent history.'
Czuba, who did not testify at his trial, will be sentenced May 2.
In court documents, prosecutors said he became obsessed with the war in the Middle East.
'This happened because this defendant was afraid that a war that had started on Oct. 7, 2023, a half a world away in the Middle East, was going to come to his doorstep,' prosecutor Michael Fitzgerald, a Will County assistant state's attorney, told jurors in his opening statement. 'This happened because Hanan and Wadee were Muslim.'
Connor, 64, testified that he had become paranoid about his personal safety and believed that their lives might be in danger because of Shaheen. She said that they both had a good relationship with Shaheen, whom she said she considered a friend and good tenant. Czuba tried to make the home enjoyable and would sometimes bring home toys for Wadee, she said. Days after the war, she said, Czuba became withdrawn and told her that he wanted Shaheen to move out of their home.
'Hanan needs to move because her friends could come and do us harm,' Connor testified Czuba had told her.
But Connor, who was married to Czuba for 30 years, said she disagreed. She believed they should adhere to the terms of Shaheen's lease, and give her 30 days notice to move, and told Czuba that Shaheen had never had a guest in the home.
'I was angry,' Connor testified. 'In my mind, there was no reason for her to move.'
She said Czuba also talked of an upcoming 'day of jihad' and withdrew $1,000 from his bank account because of fears the U.S. banking system would fail.
Prosecutors played for jurors a conversation between Czuba and a Will County sheriff's sergeant, in which Czuba compared Wadee and Shaheen to 'infested rats.'
'What do you do when you have an infested rat situation? You exterminate them. And that's what he did that day,' prosecutor Chris Koch said in his closing argument Friday. 'That was his thought process.'
In his closing argument, George Lenard, one of Czuba's attorneys, invoked O.J. Simpson's trial attorney Johnnie Cochran, telling jurors that there had been a rush to judgment in Czuba's case.
Lenard also questioned why Shaheen retreated to the bathroom, evidence from the scene, the location of some of her wounds and appeared to suggest she had a financial interest in the case, something he tried to question her about under cross examination. Shaheen filed a wrongful death suit against Czuba and his ex-wife that is still pending.
'You know this is a half-baked case that the prosecution is giving you,' he said.
He urged the jurors to 'have the courage' to find Czuba not guilty.
Prosecutor Christine Vukmir rebutted his argument, calling the suggestion that Shaheen stabbed Wadee and then framed Czuba as 'outlandish.'
'That is the plot that he is presenting to you,' she told jurors. 'It is ridiculous.'
Czuba was found on the ground outside when deputies arrived at the house.
Jurors heard from police officers, firefighters and other first responders, as well as from a physician assistant who treated Shaheen at a hospital. They also heard Shaheen's 911 call to police, in which Wadee's cries could also be heard and she repeatedly told the dispatcher, 'He is killing my baby.'
One of the Will County sheriff's deputies who found Wadee's body cried on the stand as jurors watched footage from her body-worn camera. Some of the footage and images were so graphic during the trial, that Judge Amy Bertani-Tomczak granted a defense request that the courtroom television monitor be turned away from the gallery, where members of Wadee's family sat during the trial, so that only the jurors could see it.
Wadee's father, Odai Alfayoumi, said outside the Will County Courthouse in Joliet that he felt "like this decision came a little too late."
'I don't know if I should be pleased or upset, if I should be crying or laughing," he said in Arabic through a translator. "People are telling me to smile. Maybe if I were one of you, I would be smiling. But I'm the father of the child, and I've lost a child.
'I pray that this loss, this senseless loss, is the last that we will see, that no child would suffer what my beloved little Wadee had to go through.'
Ahmed Rehab, the executive director of CAIR Chicago, who translated his remarks, said Shaheen was not present when the verdict was announced because it was too difficult, but she wanted him to relay that she prays only for peace and love.
Selina Guevara reported from Joliet, Ill., and Janelle Griffith from New York.
This article was originally published on NBCNews.com

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

A Ukrainian fled to Israel. An Iranian missile shattered her new life
A Ukrainian fled to Israel. An Iranian missile shattered her new life

San Francisco Chronicle​

time22 minutes ago

  • San Francisco Chronicle​

A Ukrainian fled to Israel. An Iranian missile shattered her new life

TEL AVIV, Israel (AP) — When Tetiana Kurakova fled Ukraine weeks after Russia invaded in 2022, she thought she had left behind buildings with gaping holes, streets lined with rubble, and the fear felt while hiding from airstrikes. In Israel, friends helped the 40-year-old makeup artist relaunch her career, and she slowly built a life in the coastal city of Bat Yam. But early Sunday, an Iranian missile tore through the building next to hers, killing nine people, wounding dozens, and damaging or destroying hundreds of homes, including Kurakova's. It was the deadliest single strike from Iran in seven days of conflict, which began Friday when Israel launched airstrikes targeting Iranian nuclear and military sites as well as top generals and nuclear scientists. Iran has fired some 450 missiles and hundreds of drones in retaliation. Days later, staying in a hotel in nearby Tel Aviv with 250 other evacuees from Bat Yam, Kurakova cried when she recalled the strike, which sheared the face off of a multistory apartment building and destroyed many buildings around it. 'It felt like a nightmare. I can't even describe how big it was,' she said. 'I had a panic attack. I just sat on the road, leaned on (my friend) Masha, and started to cry, to sob from all the misery that had happened.' Thousands of Ukrainians fled their country for Israel Kurakova is one of around 30,000 Ukrainians who have made Israel their home since Russia's war in Ukraine began, about half of whom have gained citizenship through their Jewish heritage, according to Israel's Ministry of Aliyah and Integration. Kurakova, who does not have citizenship, left home via Poland after about a month spent hiding from constant strikes in early 2022. She ended up in Israel, where she had a number of friends and some professional contacts. Five of the victims in the Bat Yam strike were Ukrainians from the same family who had come to Israel to escape the war and receive medical treatment for a 7-year-old girl who had blood cancer, Israeli media reported. The Ukrainian Embassy in Israel would not provide details on individuals, citing privacy concerns. It said it was working to repatriate the bodies, but faced challenges because Israel's airspace is closed due to ongoing attacks. Still fearing bombs and drones Bat Yam has a large population of residents from the former Soviet Union, many of whom emigrated in a wave in the early 1990s, and was a natural place for many newly arrived Ukrainians to settle. The working-class city is centrally located but the cost of living is lower than in Tel Aviv, next door. But older buildings in such cities — and in Arab towns and rural arras — often lack adequate shelters, though anything built since 1993 is required to have reinforced safe rooms. More than a year after Kurakova arrived in Israel, Hamas attacked the country's south, igniting a war in the Gaza Strip. She recalled being frightened in the early days after the militants' Oct. 7, 2023, attack. The fighting was just 60 kilometers (37 miles) to the south, and some nights, she could hear the booms from Gaza. But she wasn't prepared for it to hit so close to home. In the fighting between Israel and Iran, 24 people in Israel have been killed and hundreds injured. Missiles have struck 40 sites, including apartment buildings, offices and a hospital, according to Israeli authorities. Air raid sirens have repeatedly forced Israelis to run for shelter. Meanwhile, panicked residents of Iran's capital have spent restless nights in metro stations and thousands have fled. More than 600 people, including over 200 civilians, have been killed in Iran and more than 1,300 wounded, according to a Washington-based Iranian human rights group. Kurakova said the past few days have brought her right back to the early days of Russia's invasion. 'I don't even stop seeing dreams that I'm hiding somewhere, running from Shahed drones, bombs, and looking for shelter somewhere,' she said, referring to the Iranian-made drones used against both Israel and Ukraine. A choice between two conflicts In Bat Yam, the force of the blast blew out windows and damaged the walls of Kurakova's second-floor apartment. She was able to salvage a few belongings, but because of structural concerns, it isn't clear if she will be able to return home. Some 5,000 Israelis have been displaced across the country after missiles destroyed or damaged homes, according to the prime minister's office. Kurakova's mother, still living in the part of the Donetsk region of Ukraine under Russian occupation, has urged her daughter to leave Israel and move somewhere, anywhere else. Kurakova still hasn't decided what to do. 'I feel terrified inside and outside. I feel terrified by the hopelessness,' Kurakova said, adding that while she had previously taken comfort in Israel's air defense systems, now she wasn't so sure. 'That was the reason I left Ukraine," she said. "I didn't understand that it was possible here.' ___ Novikov reported from Kyiv, Ukraine.

A Ukrainian fled to Israel. An Iranian missile shattered her new life
A Ukrainian fled to Israel. An Iranian missile shattered her new life

The Hill

time36 minutes ago

  • The Hill

A Ukrainian fled to Israel. An Iranian missile shattered her new life

TEL AVIV, Israel (AP) — When Tetiana Kurakova fled Ukraine weeks after Russia invaded in 2022, she thought she had left behind buildings with gaping holes, streets lined with rubble, and the fear felt while hiding from airstrikes. In Israel, friends helped the 40-year-old makeup artist relaunch her career, and she slowly built a life in the coastal city of Bat Yam. But early Sunday, an Iranian missile tore through the building next to hers, killing nine people, wounding dozens, and damaging or destroying hundreds of homes, including Kurakova's. It was the deadliest single strike from Iran in seven days of conflict, which began Friday when Israel launched airstrikes targeting Iranian nuclear and military sites as well as top generals and nuclear scientists. Iran has fired some 450 missiles and hundreds of drones in retaliation. Days later, staying in a hotel in nearby Tel Aviv with 250 other evacuees from Bat Yam, Kurakova cried when she recalled the strike, which sheared the face off of a multistory apartment building and destroyed many buildings around it. 'It felt like a nightmare. I can't even describe how big it was,' she said. 'I had a panic attack. I just sat on the road, leaned on (my friend) Masha, and started to cry, to sob from all the misery that had happened.' Kurakova is one of around 30,000 Ukrainians who have made Israel their home since Russia's war in Ukraine began, about half of whom have gained citizenship through their Jewish heritage, according to Israel's Ministry of Aliyah and Integration. Kurakova, who does not have citizenship, left home via Poland after about a month spent hiding from constant strikes in early 2022. She ended up in Israel, where she had a number of friends and some professional contacts. Five of the victims in the Bat Yam strike were Ukrainians from the same family who had come to Israel to escape the war and receive medical treatment for a 7-year-old girl who had blood cancer, Israeli media reported. The Ukrainian Embassy in Israel would not provide details on individuals, citing privacy concerns. It said it was working to repatriate the bodies, but faced challenges because Israel's airspace is closed due to ongoing attacks. Bat Yam has a large population of residents from the former Soviet Union, many of whom emigrated in a wave in the early 1990s, and was a natural place for many newly arrived Ukrainians to settle. The working-class city is centrally located but the cost of living is lower than in Tel Aviv, next door. But older buildings in such cities — and in Arab towns and rural arras — often lack adequate shelters, though anything built since 1993 is required to have reinforced safe rooms. More than a year after Kurakova arrived in Israel, Hamas attacked the country's south, igniting a war in the Gaza Strip. She recalled being frightened in the early days after the militants' Oct. 7, 2023, attack. The fighting was just 60 kilometers (37 miles) to the south, and some nights, she could hear the booms from Gaza. But she wasn't prepared for it to hit so close to home. In the fighting between Israel and Iran, 24 people in Israel have been killed and hundreds injured. Missiles have struck 40 sites, including apartment buildings, offices and a hospital, according to Israeli authorities. Air raid sirens have repeatedly forced Israelis to run for shelter. Meanwhile, panicked residents of Iran's capital have spent restless nights in metro stations and thousands have fled. More than 600 people, including over 200 civilians, have been killed in Iran and more than 1,300 wounded, according to a Washington-based Iranian human rights group. Kurakova said the past few days have brought her right back to the early days of Russia's invasion. 'I don't even stop seeing dreams that I'm hiding somewhere, running from Shahed drones, bombs, and looking for shelter somewhere,' she said, referring to the Iranian-made drones used against both Israel and Ukraine. In Bat Yam, the force of the blast blew out windows and damaged the walls of Kurakova's second-floor apartment. She was able to salvage a few belongings, but because of structural concerns, it isn't clear if she will be able to return home. Some 5,000 Israelis have been displaced across the country after missiles destroyed or damaged homes, according to the prime minister's office. Kurakova's mother, still living in the part of the Donetsk region of Ukraine under Russian occupation, has urged her daughter to leave Israel and move somewhere, anywhere else. Kurakova still hasn't decided what to do. 'I feel terrified inside and outside. I feel terrified by the hopelessness,' Kurakova said, adding that while she had previously taken comfort in Israel's air defense systems, now she wasn't so sure. 'That was the reason I left Ukraine,' she said. 'I didn't understand that it was possible here.' ___ Novikov reported from Kyiv, Ukraine.

Decision day approaches for Trump admin on controversial UN force that failed to disarm Hezbollah
Decision day approaches for Trump admin on controversial UN force that failed to disarm Hezbollah

Fox News

time2 hours ago

  • Fox News

Decision day approaches for Trump admin on controversial UN force that failed to disarm Hezbollah

JERUSALEM—The scandal-plagued U.N. mission set up to stop Hezbollah rocket attacks on Israel will know in late August if the Trump administration plans to vote to discontinue its mandate at the U.N. Security Council. In interviews with Fox News Digital, several leading American and Israeli experts on the mandate have called for the U.S. government to pull the plug on the mandate because the United Nations Interim Force in Lebanon (UNIFIL) is an example of the U.N.'s ineffectiveness in stopping the Iran-backed Lebanese terrorist movement. "Among countless failures by the United Nations in the Middle East, UNIFIL may be the most spectacular. Tasked with ensuring that Hezbollah would not rearm after the 2006 war, it patiently watched as Hezbollah became the largest non-state terrorist and military organization in the world. Stability in Lebanon — within reach only now that Israel has decapitated Hezbollah's leadership — will not be achieved through UNIFIL," the former U.S. Ambassador during the first Trump administration, David Friedman, told Fox News Digital. After the conclusion of the Second Lebanon War in 2006 between Israel and Hezbollah, the UNSC passed Resolution 1701, which outlined that the international force UNIFIL, along with the Lebanese Armed Forces (LAF), was supposed to block Hezbollah's activity in southern Lebanon. Hezbollah joined Hamas in its war on the Jewish state a day after the Iranian regime-backed terrorist organization in Gaza invaded Israel on October 7, 2023, and slaughtered over 1,200 people, including more than 40 Americans. In October, Fox News Digital reported that UNIFIL soldiers had failed to stop Hezbollah's massive rocket and military weapons expansion since the mandate was implemented in 2006. Israel's U.N. Ambassador Danny Danon at the time accused UNIFIL of failing to enforce its mission to prevent the U.S.-designated terrorist movement Hezbollah from establishing military outposts on the border with Israel. Israel's incursion into southern Lebanon has revealed a military outpost about a mere 300 yards north of the border with the Jewish state that is filled with explosives and mines, according to Israel Defense Forces (IDF). ISRAEL ORDERS IDF TO SEIZE MORE GAZA TERRITORY IF HAMAS DOESN'T RELEASE HOSTAGESWhen asked if Israel seeks an end of the UNIFIl mandate, Jonathan Harounoff, international spokesperson for Israel's Mission to the United Nations, told Fox News Digital this week that "Israel is still evaluating the situation." A U.S. State Department spokesperson told Fox News Digital that "We have nothing to announce at this time" about a vote against continuing the UNIFIL mandate. Dr. Zoe Levornik and Sarit Zehavi, from the Israel Alma Research and Education Center—one of the top think tanks assessing UNIFIL and Hezbollah—wrote on the organization's webpage on June 10: "Over the years, UNIFIL has had numerous opportunities to improve and fulfill its role, particularly in light of Israel's repeated warnings. Yet no real attempt has been made to alter the organization's conduct. There is no reason to believe that renewing the mandate—even with improvements—will bring about the necessary change that would make UNIFIL's presence in southern Lebanon relevant and effective in maintaining the security of both Israel and Lebanon." When confronted with the criticism from Alma about UNIFIL, the peacekeeping force's spokesman, Andrea Teneti, told Fox News Digital "The LAF continues to benefit from UNIFIL's support—not only to ensure full deployment in areas currently occupied by Israel, but also through training, capacity-building, and the development of essential capabilities needed to take over our mandated tasks on land and at sea. "The mission's relevance remains vital in maintaining an impartial international presence on the ground, helping to monitor the situation and reinforce the efforts of the LAF. Additionally, UNIFIL is providing essential support to local communities during this particularly challenging period, contributing to stability in the area despite the numerous shelling monitored and reported since 27 November 2024." He added "Implementation of 1701 is not with UNIFIL but with the parties. We are supporting the parties in the implementation of the mandate, but commitment is needed from both sides. In recent months, during this new political environment, LAF and UNIFIL have been recovering a large number of ammunition caches as well as positions used previously by Hezbollah. The situation is more stable than earlier, but air strikes are continuing and the stability is still fragile." Zehavi, who lives in northern Israel, where Hezbollah has caused severe destruction with missile fire, countered the UNIFIL spokesman's comments. She told Fox News Digital that all the things mentioned by UNIFIL "are secondary to the primary issue of the mandate, which is the disarmament of Hezbollah." Zehavi added that despite the UNIFIL spokesman claiming that UNIFIL seized ammunition used by Hezbollah, she noted that UNIFIL has provided no evidence. She asked "in which towns" Hezbollah is being disarmed. She stressed, "Where are the pictures? How come there are no proofs and only statements that they are doing that? As a resident of the north, I want to see proofs to remind everybody that the IDF showed proofs of the arms of Hezbollah in south Lebanon and brought them into Israel." She also asked where has UNIFIL been over the last 18 years in training the Lebanese army?" I think the United States and France can do that better than UNIFIL," mentioning the new mechanism set up to address violations via U.S. and French Generals who are in the region, she said. Zehavi said UNIFIL over the years "tied our hands" during the Israel-Hezbollah war. She added that Israel is enforcing the disarming of Hezbollah via continued military strikes in the south. The Biden administration and France brokered a fragile ceasefire in November between Hezbollah and Israel. The language of the ceasefire states it aims to "promote conditions for a permanent and comprehensive situation." The ceasefire ended 14 months of high-intensity warfare between Israel and Hezbollah. When asked about Zehavi's questions, Teneti said "All our findings—whether related to activities conducted with or without the Lebanese Armed Forces—are shared with the members of the Security Council and also transmitted to the Mechanism, as agreed by both Lebanon and Israel. This is our authorized reporting line. Additionally, all detailed information is published quarterly in the Secretary-General's report on the implementation of Resolution 1701, which is a public document." Pro-Hezbollah officials and soldiers within Lebanon's Army also remain a core problem, according to experts and media reports. In late January, a LAF chief reportedly sent a classified document to Hezbollah. The LAF's Suhil Bahij Gharb, who oversees military intelligence for southern Lebanon, secured the confidential material from a military facility run by the U.S., France and the U.N. interim force in Lebanon (UNIFIL). The White House and the U.S. National Security Council did not immediately respond to Fox News Digital press queries.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store