HBO casting Snape as Black in Harry Potter reboot draws criticism
HBO's highly anticipated Harry Potter reboot is making waves with its latest casting decision: British-Ghanaian actor Paapa Essiedu, known for his standout performances in I May Destroy You and The Lazarus Project, will take on the iconic role of Severus Snape.
While many fans are praising the move as a bold step toward inclusion, others are raising concerns about what they see as forced racial diversity and how it may unintentionally alter the character's background.
Critics of the casting argue that transforming Snape into a Black character adds new racial implications to his backstory, especially his history of being bullied by James Potter and the Marauders at Hogwarts — a white James Potter tormenting a Black Severus Snape. What was once a morally gray school rivalry now risks being read through a racial lens. Without meaning to, the story introduces the dynamic of racial power imbalance into a narrative that originally centered on social exclusion, not race.
James Potter bullying the only black student at hogwarts in the 70's yeah sounds like a good idea https://t.co/wPz2mAoStn pic.twitter.com/ml1MTP7HED
— NoSoyDany (@_NoSoyDany) March 7, 2025
James Potter and Co weren't nice to Snape but this casting will fundamentally change the whole point of those characters if you give their bullying a racist undertone. https://t.co/mleXnS1bgb
— dr. a (@academicsheep) April 14, 2025
HBO will have a very bad reputation by the time they are on Prisoner of Azkaban!
Here me out.
Neville is afraid of Snape, hence his boggart is: Snape. Who comes out of a wardrobe? Snape... who now happens to be black.
Neville is afraid of a black man. pic.twitter.com/JzZWCG2hAS
— BlabberingCollector (@BlabberingC) March 21, 2025
I can't wait to see James Potter and his other white friends to bully Snape, who is now black. I wonder how that'll go!
Leviosa... pic.twitter.com/2JKDl8bH1G
— Pacosith (@Pacosith) April 14, 2025
Critics have also pointed out that instead of race-swapping a central character, the series could have explored the stories of existing Black characters already present in J.K. Rowling's universe—such as Dean Thomas, Angelina Johnson, Lee Jordan, and Kingsley Shacklebolt—who were often underdeveloped in both the books and films.
Paapa Essiedu should not have been cast Severus Snape in the Harry Potter TV series.
pic.twitter.com/VMI5y8KXce
— Goat Herder 101 (@BillyGoat838) April 14, 2025
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Al Bawaba
30-05-2025
- Al Bawaba
Russell Brand pleads not guilty to rape and assault charges, trial set for 2026
ALBAWABA - Russell Brand pleads not guilty in London court amid rape allegations Actor, comedian, and conspiracy-theorizing YouTuber Russell Brand entered a not guilty plea to several rape and sexual assault allegations on Friday in a London courtroom. The presiding judge, Tony Baumgartner, stated after a brief hearing that Mr. Brand will be put on trial on June 3, 2026, for four to five weeks. Due to the backlog of cases in the British legal system, defendants frequently have to wait between tendering a plea and going to trial. Mr. Brand, 49, is charged with two charges of sexual assault, one crime of oral rape, one count of rape, and one act of indecent assault. Four ladies are involved in those five charges. The episodes, according to the prosecution, took place between 1999 and 2005. One of them involves Mr. Brand allegedly raping a lady in a hotel room when she was attending a Labour Party political meeting. British comedian and actor Russell Brand (Photo by HENRY NICHOLLS / AFP) Wearing a dark gray suit and a striped shirt that opened to display his chest, Mr. Brand stood in a Plexiglas box at the back of the courtroom throughout the 10-minute session, which was attended by tens of journalists. He answered, "Not guilty," as each of the allegations was read out. News organizations are prohibited by British law from identifying anyone who accuses someone of sexual assault unless the accuser agrees to give up their right to anonymity. Strict regulations also prohibit the publishing of case-related material that can sway a jury during a trial once criminal procedures have begun. Mr. Brand had vehemently refuted every claim before Friday's hearing. He claimed to have been a "drug addict, a sex addict, and an imbecile" in a video he uploaded to social media in April, but he had "never engaged in nonconsensual activity." Mr. Brand has been a British celebrity for decades. He rose to stardom as a stand-up comedian and as a BBC and MTV radio and television host. He also became well-known in the US after the criminal trials ended because of his roles in popular films like 2008's "Forgetting Sarah Marshall." Additionally, he was temporarily wed to pop sensation Katy Perry. Mr. Brand's most well-known role these days is that of a politically charged YouTuber. With more than 11 million followers on X and more than 6.7 million subscribers to his channel, he frequently discusses religion, conspiracy theories, and conservative talking points in his videos.
Ammon
29-05-2025
- Ammon
Beethoven's true face is revealed for first time in 200 years
Ammon News - The true face of Beethoven has been revealed almost 200 years after his death – and it's every bit as 'intimidating' as his reputation suggests. Despite his status as one of history's great composers, Beethoven is also remembered for his surly disposition and unkempt appearance. 'He was indeed irritable, untidy, clumsy, rude, and misanthropic,' wrote British composer Mark Wigglesworth in a blog post. It's a reputation often reflected in his portraits, which invariably depict him as an unsmiling man with an icy gaze. Now a scientific reconstruction of his face has revealed what he actually looked like – and it seems he really did look that grumpy. Cicero Moraes, lead author of the new study, has completed the first ever reconstruction of the composer's appearance based on his skull. 'I found the face somewhat intimidating,' he admitted. To complete the work, Mr Moraes used historical photographs of the musician's skull provided by the Beethoven House in Bonn, Germany. Along with the images, which were taken by Johann Batta Rottmayer in 1863, he used measurement data collected in 1888. He said: 'The facial approximation was guided solely by the skull. 'First I created 2D outlines – frontal and lateral – from the skull photographs. 'Then I modelled the skull in 3D using a virtual donor's tomography, adjusted to match the photos' proportions. 'I then added soft tissue thickness markers based on data from living Europeans, projected the nose, and traced the facial profile. 'I interpolated all these projections to form the basic face.' With the objective face complete, Mr Moraes added subjective features like clothes and hair, using as his guide a famous portrait of Beethoven painted in 1820 by Joseph Karl Stieler.
Al Bawaba
19-05-2025
- Al Bawaba
Identity of Youmi Beauty's fiancé revealed, who is he?
ALBAWABA - Youmna Khoury, commonly known as Youmi, surprised her fans yesterday and shared a photo from her Katb Al-Kitab announcing that she is getting married. After her Katb Al-Kitab post, she also shared a photo of her "enormous" ring and mimicky wrote: "The ring is a little small, it should have been bigger". The couple wore the same watches but with different colors; yellow and pink. In the Instagram posts, her fiancé, didn't fully appear in the picture, but she only shared the first letters of their names, which were "Y" and "G", and kept the groom's identity unknown, raising multiple questions and triggering curiosity among her fans. In the photo on Instagram, Youmi wore a below-the-knee dress while covering her arms with a mint green scarf. Her appearance was both exquisite and modest. A photo shared by Youmi Beauty on her Instagram shows her big engagement ring Who is Youmna Khoury's groom? Many rumors emerged on social media regarding the identity of Youmi Beauty's groom after the influencer kept his name a secret from her fans. However, many suggested that Youmi's groom is likely Kuwaiti, based on the sheikh who appeared in the video, whom followers likened to preacher Othman Al-Khamis. On the other hand, many others claimed that Youmna Khoury's fiancé is a Turkish businessman, who has British citizenship as well. According to allegations online, Youmi got married to Turkish businessman Gurhan Kiziloz, 35, who has a net worth of about $700 million. It is worth noting that Gurhan Kiziloz is the entrepreneur behind Lanistar, a London-based challenger bank. Despite rumors and allegations regarding the identity of Youmna Khoury's groom, nothing was confirmed by an official source. Who is Youmna Khoury? Youmna Khoury is a very famous entrepreneur and beauty expert, and the founder of Youmi Beauty, a cosmetics company. Youmi Beauty is one of the influencers and was ranked among the top 30 entrepreneurs in the Middle East under the age of forty.
