What we know as Toby Carvery cuts down centuries-old tree in London
A row has broken out after Toby Carvery cut down a centuries-old tree close to one of its car parks.
The ancient oak tree had reportedly been assessed to be dying and dangerous, resulting in the company's owners, Mitchells & Butlers, felling it.
However, environmental campaigners described the felling as 'devastating' and Enfield Council have subsequently reported the matter to the Metropolitan Police.
Mitchells & Butlers defended the decision, saying it acted on the advice of employed tree experts.
But the Woodland Trust has argued that the old tree was still an important habitat, with ancient oaks supporting biodiversity like endangered dead wood beetles.
Mitchells & Butlers cut down the tree after tree experts they employed reportedly assessed that it was dying and a risk to the public.
The tree, which has a girth of 6.1 metres, is located in near the Whitewebbs House Toby Carvery car park and was felled on 3 April.
However, Enfield Council claim they were not told of the incident until after the tree was cut down and sent teams to assess the damage.
The felling is now being treated as criminal damage after Enfield Council reported the felling to the Met Police.
They have also imposed an emergency Tree Preservation Order has been put in place on the base of the stump.
Statement from the Leader of Enfield Council, Cllr Ergin Erbil, on the felling of an ancient oak tree at Whitewebbs pic.twitter.com/BdEXRpmVYf
— Enfield Council (@EnfieldCouncil) April 14, 2025
Ergin Erbil, leader of Enfield Council, said: 'Enfield Council cares deeply about protecting trees and green spaces in the borough.'
He added that the council 'are looking at ways to help it grow back'.
The Woodland Trust has argued that the old tree was still an important habitat, with ancient oaks supporting biodiversity like endangered dead wood beetles.
Ed Pyne, Woodland Trust senior conservation adviser for trees, said: 'This is the most shocking fell I think I've ever seen in more than a decade working with ancient trees…
'Ancient oaks are particularly rich in biodiversity with habitats that take centuries to develop. They simply can't be replaced by younger trees and can't be replaced quickly.'
He described the incident as 'ecologically much more significant' than the felling of the Sycamore Gap in Northumberland in 2023, adding that it is 'certainly a more irreplaceable tree'.
Payne added that the development of decaying tree habitats are a 'normal and healthy part of a tree's lifecycle – especially in the ancient phase'.
He said some of the biodiversity associated with ancient trees 'is amongst the most threatened in Europe'.
Campaigner Paul Powlesland, founder of Lawyers for Nature, said the felling was 'disturbing' and it showed that there is a 'desperate need for better protections for our veteran and ancient trees'.
He added that it was 'too soon' to say whether the tree could regrow or be killed by shock.
Mitchells & Butlers defended the decision, saying it acted on the advice of employed tree experts, arguing that the tree 'caused a serious health and safety risk'.
A spokesperson added: 'This was an essential action to protect our employees and guests, to whom we have a duty of care.
'Upon further inspection, our specialist arboriculture contractors made the assessment that the split and dead wood posed a serious health and safety risk and advised that the tree was unsafe and should be removed.
'We took every necessary measure to ensure all legal requirements were met. We are grateful to our expert contractors for warning us of this hazard so swiftly, allowing us to act before anyone was harmed.'
A tree preservation order (TPO) is issued by local planning authorities and is a way to legally protect specific trees, groups of trees, or woodlands that hold significant value for the community, whether for their beauty, environmental benefits, or cultural importance.
A TPO makes it illegal to cut down, prune, uproot, or deliberately damage these trees without first getting written permission from the local authority.
This ensures that trees contributing to the landscape or local ecosystem are preserved for future generations.
According to government figures, there are a total of 39,185 TPOs in place, each with start dates – and end dates, if applicable.
TPOs are carefully documented, often including details like the specific trees or areas covered, and are accessible to the public to promote transparency in managing protected green spaces.
Cutting down trees is governed by laws that aim to protect the environment and public spaces while at the same time respecting property rights.
Violating TPOs can lead to substantial fines, potentially up to £20,000 in a magistrates' court, or even unlimited fines for serious cases in a Crown Court.
Trees in conservation areas, which are designated for their historic or architectural importance, require six weeks notice in writing before cutting it down or pruning it If a tree in such an area has a trunk diameter exceeding 7.5cm (measured at 1.5m above ground).
Trees on private land, including in gardens, can generally be cut down without permission – unless they are protected by a TPO or located in a conservation area.
However, trees that are homes to nesting birds should not be disturbed and a survey may be needed before felling.
The incident has reminded many of the felling of the Sycamore Gap tree in Northumberland in 2023.
The 150-year-old sycamore beside Hadrian's Wall was a magnet for tourists before being chopped down in an incident that sparked widespread anger.
Planted in the 19th century, the tree stood within Northumberland National Park, a UNESCO World Heritage Site.
Its felling also caused minor damage to the adjacent Hadrian's Wall.
Two men from Cumbria – Daniel Graham, 38, and Adam Carruthers, 31 – were arrested and charged with criminal damage to the tree (valued at £622,191) and Hadrian's Wall (£1,144).
Both men pleaded not guilty and await trial.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
29-05-2025
- Yahoo
Warning as Britain's ‘most dangerous plant' spotted in an area of Bolton
A toxic plant which is known to cause severe blistering and burns to humans has been spotted growing in the Tonge Moor area. Hogweed plants, known as Britain's most dangerous, were spotted last week by a local resident on Cartmel Crescent and Firwood Lodges. John Frazer, 74, who is secretary of the Bradshaw Brook Fly Fishing Club, went to assess the area. The club has been working to push back hogweed plants from the Bradshaw Brook riverbank since 2022, and have so far cleared the area back to the River Tong. Hogweed is an invasive and poisonous exotic plant. It is a health and environmental risk. In humans, contact with giant hogweed sap, together with exposure to light (natural or artificial ultraviolet rays), causes skin lesions like burns. The plants were spotted by residents over the weekend. (Image: John Frazer) The plant can cause burns and blindness if humans come into contact with it. Hogweed was previously spotted in Longsight Park. READ MORE: Warning after Giant Hogweed burns girl John said: 'I know hogweed very well, it's related to cow parsley. 'It turns out there were dozens of plants in a 30m2 area down the slope from the path, with six seedlings traveling up as far as the path. Hogweed can cause burns and blindness if humans come into contact with it. (Image: John Frazer) 'Bolton Council need to deal with this before the hogweeds begin to flower, which usually occurs in July. 'With each flowerhead producing between 30,000 and 50,000 seeds it wouldn't take long for the plant to spread along Bradshaw Brook in the same way it has on Eagley Brook and the Rivers Tong, Croal and Irwell, with the resultant danger and environmental impact.' Local councillor has warned residents to stay away from the plants whilst plans are made to eradicate the hogweed from the area. Cllr Martin Donaghy said: 'I ask residents to be extremely careful not to handle the hogweed and not to go anywhere near it. 'These plants can lead to a very painful rash when touched. I urge residents to keep away from it and to let the council eradicate it as soon as possible.' A Bolton Council spokesperson said: 'An officer from the neighbourhoods team will attend as soon as possible.' The Woodland Trust outlines the appearance of Giant Hogweed so that you can better identify the dangerous plant. Hogweed usually flowers in June or July. (Image: John Frazer) Stems: the stems are green with purple blotches and stiff, white hairs. The stems are hollow with ridges and a thick circle of hair at the base of each leaf stalk. Leaves: the leaves are huge, and can measure up to 1.5m wide and 3m long, and are often divided into smaller leaflets. The Woodland Trust compares them to rhubarb leaves, with irregular and jagged edges, with the underside of the leaf being described as hairy. Flowers: the flowers of the Giant Hogweed appear in June and July, and are small and white and appear in clusters on 'umbrella-like heads' that face upwards. Seeds: the seeds are dry, flattened and an oval shape, almost 1cm long and tan in colour with brown lines. If you accidentally get Giant Hogweed sap on your skin, Healthline says that you should wash the area with mild soap and cool water as quickly as possible. Hogweed leaves are huge, and can measure up to 1.5m wide and 3m long, and are often divided into smaller leaflets. (Image: Getty images) You should keep the skin covered when you're outside to protect it from the sunlight. If a rash or blister begins to form, you should seek medical attention. Your treatment will depend on how severe your reaction is. 'Skin irritation that's caught early might be treated with a steroid cream and nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs, such as ibuprofen, to relieve pain,' Healthline explains. It adds: 'Severe burns could require surgery to graft new skin over the damaged skin.' Healthline also explains that the Giant Hogweed sap can damage more than just your skin - if the sap gets in your eyes, you can experience either temporary or permanent blindness. Similarly, breathing in sap particles can result in respiratory problems.
Yahoo
21-04-2025
- Yahoo
Oak felling: 'A crime against 500-year-old being'
There was anger and sadness among people who turned out over the Easter Bank Holiday weekend to protest at the destruction of a tree in Enfield thought to be up to 500 years old. "This is a crime against nature," said one campaigner. "It's a crime against a 500-year-old being." Hundreds of people gathered on Sunday to protest the felling of an ancient oak tree in Whitewebbs Park in north London. The pedunculate oak, which was cut down on 3 April, was located on the edge of an Enfield council-owned park in north London and overlooked the Toby Carvery pub. The council leased the land on which the tree stood to the Toby Carvery. The felling of the tree was not discovered by the council until last week. On Wednesday, Enfield Council's leader branded the felling "an outrage" and said all legal options were being considered. Mitchells & Butlers, the owners of the Toby Carvery pub chain, said they cut down the tree after being told it was dead. In a statement, the company said it had received advice from contractors, who said "the split and dead wood posed a serious health and safety risk". They subsequently added in a later statement that it had taken "necessary measures to ensure any legal requirements were met". Thousands of people have signed a petition that has asked Enfield Council for an independent investigation into what happened. Here were some of the reactions over the weekend to the felling of the tree. Independent tree consultation Russell Miller told BBC London: "We think this is one of probably less than 100 [trees] in London of this size, so it's a very significant loss. "It is possible the tree will shoot, but the chances are the wounds on it are so big it will desiccate, as although the shoots will grow, they will then die because the whole system fails." The tree, with a girth of 20ft (6m), was a nationally significant pedunculate oak listed on the Woodland Trust's ancient tree inventory. News of the destruction of the oak came just days after a report from the charity Tree Council and environmental group Forest Research warned that trees were only indirectly protected, with some "significant legal gaps". Listen to the best of BBC Radio London on Sounds and follow BBC London on Facebook, X and Instagram. Send your story ideas to Why are ancient trees important and what protection do they have? Toby Carvery owner 'sorry' over ancient tree felling Felled Enfield oak 'had hundreds of years to live' Enfield Council
Yahoo
20-04-2025
- Yahoo
Where the ancient tree felled by Toby Carvery once stood, people are reeling
Whether a tree falling in a forest makes a sound is a perennial subject of debate, but in one north London borough, it's certainly made a lot of noise. The felling of a 500-year-old oak tree earlier this month in Enfield has sparked outrage and a nationwide conversation. First came the felling itself on 3 April which, it seems, few people noticed. It wasn't until 12 days later that the news emerged in a flurry of national headlines, after council workers found the slain tree in Whitewebbs Park. Then came a plot twist that few would expect - the owners of Toby Carvery, a family pub chain specialising in budget roast dinners which has a restaurant overlooking the tree, admitted that they felled it after receiving advice it was dead. The saga is a stark reminder of the emotional place that trees occupy in Britain's national consciousness - coming not long after the iconic Sycamore Gap tree was felled at Hadrian's Wall in Northumberland. That's evident in Enfield, where BBC News visited on Friday and found Amanda Dudley gazing at the remains of the oak, its former parts scattered around a blunted stump and cordoned off with red and white tape. She lowered herself to sneak through and examine the tree's 6m (20ft) wide trunk more thoroughly. "I can't believe they've done this," she said. "This is a friend of mine." During lockdown Amanda, an artist, walked around Whitewebbs Park and says she looked at the tree every day. She has drawn sketches of it too. "It was a real comfort to me," she told me. "This is a place I've walked for years and years. I have quite a long relationship with this tree." Marina Cardozo, who walked around the area every day during lockdown, felt similarly. "It's just so shocking, absolutely shocking," she said. "500 years and they chop it down?" While I was talking to her, other people were passing through the area to walk their dogs in the sun and take a look at what remained of the tree. One of them was Fatma Safer who told me she's "heartbroken," while her friend Felicity Pegg added: "Once it's gone, it's gone." A steady stream of gathered at the tree throughout the day, some taking selfies or pictures of their relatives standing in front of it. A number of people who lived nearby told me that they couldn't remember that particular tree, but that they were still saddened that a part of the park's history had been destroyed. Other people were less interested. Pippa Chapman's young son had other thoughts, saying simply: "It's been blown out of proportion." On Wednesday, Enfield Council's leader branded the felling "an outrage" and said all legal options were being considered. It made a report of criminal damage to the police, but the Met is understood to view it as a civil matter. In a letter seen by the BBC this week, Mitchells & Butlers (M&B), which owns the chain, apologised over the upset caused and admitted "we need to tighten our protocols". M&B said it felled the tree on health and safety grounds after receiving advice from unnamed contractors that "the split and dead wood posed a serious health and safety risk," and stressed that "necessary measures to ensure any legal requirements were met". An Enfield Council planning document from March 2024 stated that the pedunculate oak - a species that can live for 1,000 years - was a "fine specimen" with high ecological and landscape value and had a life expectancy of at least five more decades. While much has been said by both the council and M&B since the felling, locals and campaigners alike want answers to the many remaining questions. Some people told the BBC that what surprised them most about the tree's felling was how healthy it looked. "It's just so obviously not dead," one resident claimed. "It's a disgrace." "There's nothing wrong with the tree," Derek, another local, said. "I can't see what problems it could have caused." They also question what the wood - currently still next to the remaining tree stump - will be used for. Locals say the tree saga points to bigger picture of what they worry is happening to Whitewebbs Park, a place steeped in history - it's home to Whitewebbs House which is where Guy Fawkes's Gunpowder Plot is thought to have been hatched in 1605, and formerly owned by Henry VIII's physician. "There's loads of controversy around here," says a middle-aged couple that live nearby. In February, Enfield Council gave Tottenham Hotspur football club a 25-year lease to build a new women's training ground on the site of a former golf course in the park, with 11 pitches and a clubhouse, despite campaigners fighting against the proposals. Opponents argued that it would limit people's access to green space and impact wildlife in the area. The Woodland Trust has called for more transparency from M&B and the club. In the planning process to date, Spurs commissioned contractors to assess the woodland there. There is no suggestion that Spurs knew of the decision to fell the tree or that it had any connection to it. A club spokesman told BBC News "the tree sits outside of our lease demise for our proposed Women's and Girls' Training Centre & Academy". Enfield Council and M&B did not respond to additional requests for comment. In time, council officials may well get some answers on what went wrong for the Whitewebbs oak, and some locals are more hopeful. A large portion of the tree's trunk remains, and people visiting the site told the BBC they hoped it would start to regrow, even if it took decades, or centuries. "I'm hoping I'll come back here in a couple months and I'll see some fresh shoots," Zack Whitbread told me. That's what is starting to happen with the Sycamore Gap, with multiple shoots growing out of the stump which experts hope could develop significant growth to form new trees around the stump. But perhaps the most impactful outcome of the felling in Enfield could be additional protections for Britain's ancient trees. An emergency tree preservation order has been imposed to preserve the remains of the Whitewebbs oak, given it is considered nationally significant. The Woodland Trust is now among the campaigners who want legally protected status for heritage trees. As Adam Cormack, from the charity, put it: "This depressing sight is a reminder to all of us that not every ancient tree is in a safe place."
