logo
India's heatwaves worsening, but no one knows how many dying

India's heatwaves worsening, but no one knows how many dying

The Printa day ago

An investigation by PTI reveals that disjointed, outdated reporting systems are obscuring the true toll, weakening both public awareness and policy action.
'The family rushed him to the hospital,' says Majida Begum, a sanitation worker who witnessed it. 'But he was declared dead on arrival. They had no proof that he died due to heat, so they were not given any compensation.' His death was never officially counted, just one of the countless lives lost in India's intensifying heatwaves that go unrecorded and uncompensated.
New Delhi, Jun 9 (PTI) On a scorching May afternoon last year, a ragpicker in Delhi's Ghazipur area collapsed from heat exhaustion.
Accurate data on heat-related deaths helps identify who is most at risk.
Without it, the government cannot plan effectively, create targeted policies or take timely action to save lives.
But behind the missing numbers are real people, many poor and undocumented, whose deaths routinely slip through the cracks of India's incoherent reporting system.
Currently, at least three separate datasets attempt to monitor heatstroke or heat-related deaths. The two most-commonly cited in the media are maintained by the National Centre for Disease Control (NCDC) under the health ministry and the National Crime Records Bureau (NCRB) under the home ministry.
The India Meteorological Department (IMD) also carries figures on deaths caused by 'heatwaves' in its annual reports, drawing data primarily from media coverage.
However, these three sources report widely-varying numbers.
For instance, data obtained through an RTI query from the health ministry shows 3,812 heat-related deaths recorded between 2015 and 2022 under the Integrated Disease Surveillance Programme (IDSP), managed by the NCDC.
In contrast, NCRB figures, cited in Parliament many times by Union Earth Sciences Minister Jitendra Singh, put the number at 8,171 deaths from 'heat/sunstroke' during the same period.
Meanwhile, the IMD's annual reports record 3,436 deaths due to 'heatwave' between 2015 and 2022.
While the NCDC and the IMD have already released the figures for 2023 and 2024, the NCRB is yet to publish the data for these years.
Since 2015, the health ministry has been collecting data on heat illness and deaths from April to July. In 2019, this was extended to March through July, covering 23 states.
The NCRB has recorded heatstroke deaths since 1995, listing them as 'accidental deaths from forces of nature' since around 2010.
PTI spoke to government officials and healthcare-policy experts to understand the large discrepancies between these datasets.
A senior Delhi Police official explained that the NCRB data largely reflects the number of unattended individuals found dead by police at public spaces, homes and elsewhere.
Such bodies are taken to hospitals where doctors conduct autopsies to determine the cause of death.
According to the NCRB, 730 people died from 'heat/sunstroke' in 2022, 374 in 2021 and 530 in 2020.
By contrast, the NCDC data shows just 33 heat-related deaths in 2022, none in 2021 and four in 2020, as many states failed to report their figures.
These states included Delhi, Uttar Pradesh, Rajasthan, Punjab, Haryana, Madhya Pradesh, Chhattisgarh, Bihar, Jharkhand, Karnataka, Kerala, Andhra Pradesh, Telangana, West Bengal and Tamil Nadu.
A health ministry official, speaking on the condition of anonymity, said the data from the NCRB and the NCDC are 'not directly comparable' because they originate from different sources.
'The NCDC reports deaths of patients who come to hospital OPDs or are admitted. But if a person dies and is brought for autopsy, that data goes to the forensic medicine department, which may not always share the information with the NCDC,' the official said.
He acknowledged the existence of multiple datasets on heat deaths in India and noted that 'none of those alone gives the full picture'.
'While knowing the actual number of heat deaths is important for policy making, confirming such deaths is difficult even with health ministry guidelines,' he added.
The official said surveillance systems often capture only a fraction of actual cases for other communicable and non-communicable diseases. 'We have some numbers, but never the full picture,' he said.
One major challenge in data collection is the absence of an electronic record system.
'Healthcare facilities still enter data manually. Confirming heat-related deaths is already difficult and manual data entry makes accurate reporting even harder,' said another official.
Though the Integrated Health Information Platform (IHIP) enables digital submission of surveillance data like that of heat-related deaths, the hospital staff manually enter the information into online forms. There is no automated data transfer from hospital records.
Officials also said that while states are mandated to report data, compliance is poor. For example, the hospital staff sometimes omit reporting if temperatures drop due to cloudy weather.
A senior doctor from a central government-run hospital in Delhi, speaking anonymously, said most hospitals are understaffed which hampers proper data collection and timely reporting.
The doctor also alleged that authorities may suppress death figures to avoid compensation liabilities.
At the India Heat Summit 2025 in May, health ministry Advisor Soumya Swaminathan highlighted the weaknesses in the country's death-reporting systems.
'I have been saying this since my time at the Indian Council of Medical Research — death-reporting systems need strengthening because they provide the best source for the government and policymakers to understand causes of death, which should inform policy,' she said.
Abhiyant Tiwari, Lead for Climate Resilience and Health at NRDC India, said attributing deaths directly to heat remains a global challenge, not just in India.
Tiwari, who has contributed to heat action plans at city and district levels, said the all-cause mortality data is more reliable for assessing vulnerability and setting early-warning thresholds, as it captures the total number of deaths during heat events, not only those officially classified as heatstroke deaths.
Many heat-related deaths go unrecorded or are misclassified as heart attacks or other causes. By comparing mortality during heatwaves to normal periods, experts estimate that the excess deaths are likely attributable to extreme heat, he said.
He stressed the need to improve the reporting of the all-cause mortality data and suggested appointing a single department responsible for its collection and dissemination.
As climate change intensifies heatwaves, Avinash Chanchal, deputy programme director at Greenpeace South Asia, called for urgent reforms in how heat-related deaths are recorded.
'Discrepancies between departments and widespread underreporting mean the true toll of extreme heat often remains hidden. The government must understand that hiding or ignoring the true numbers delays the urgent action needed to address heat,' he said.
Until India fixes its fractured data system, the dead will remain just a number or worse, not counted at all, Chanchal said. PTI GVS RC
This report is auto-generated from PTI news service. ThePrint holds no responsibility for its content.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

XFG: What Is The New Covid Variant Detected In India Amid Rising Cases? Explained
XFG: What Is The New Covid Variant Detected In India Amid Rising Cases? Explained

News18

timean hour ago

  • News18

XFG: What Is The New Covid Variant Detected In India Amid Rising Cases? Explained

Last Updated: Amid this surge, the new variant of the SARS-CoV-2 was detected with as many as 163 cases reported so far, of which the most are from Maharashtra at 89 India recorded a total of 6,815 active coronavirus cases with three deaths in the last 24 hours. Amid this surge, XFG – a new variant of the SARS-CoV-2 – was detected with as many as 163 cases reported so far. According to data from the Indian SARS-CoV-2 Genomics Consortium (INSACOG), the XFG variant has been found in a total of 163 samples – highest (89) in Maharashtra, followed by Tamil Nadu (16), Kerala (15), Gujarat (11), and Andhra Pradesh, Madhya Pradesh and West Bengal (six each). A RECOMBINANT VARIANT: WHAT DOES THIS MEAN? An article in Lancet stated that the recombinant XFG variant harbours four key spike mutations and has achieved rapid global spread following its initial detection in Canada. Data shows that in May, as many as 159 samples were detected with the XFG variant while two samples were tested for this variant in April and two in June. It is essentially the result of two earlier strains — LF.7 and LP.8.1.2 — merging together. A recombinant variant like XFG emerges when someone is infected with two different versions of the virus at the same time, allowing it to 'mix and match" its genetic code. The Lancet study points out that this variant shows 'strong immune evasion". WHAT IS THE CENTRE DOING? According to the Union health ministry data released on June 8, Kerala continues to be the most affected state, followed by Gujarat, West Bengal and Delhi. Official sources have said due to the rising cases, the Centre is conducting mock drills to check facility-level preparedness and has instructed all states to ensure availability of oxygen, isolation beds, ventilators, and essential medicines. They maintained that most cases are mild and managed under home care. Since January this year, 65 deaths have been reported in the country. There were a total of 257 active patients in the country on May 22. A series of technical review meetings were held on June 2 and 3 under the chairpersonship of Dr Sunita Sharma, Director General of Health Services, to evaluate the Covid situation and preparedness measures. Representatives from the Disaster Management Cell, Emergency Management Response Cell, National Centre for Disease Control, Indian Council of Medical Research, Integrated Disease Surveillance Programme, central government hospitals in Delhi, and all states and Union Territories were part of the meeting. State and district surveillance units under the Integrated Disease Surveillance Programme are closely monitoring Influenza-Like Illness (ILI) and Severe Acute Respiratory Illness (SARI). 'Testing is recommended for all admitted SARI cases and 5 per cent of ILI cases as per guidelines, and positive SARI samples are sent for Whole Genome Sequencing through the ICMR VRDL network, " an official source said. First Published: June 10, 2025, 19:34 IST

Ensure medicines reach Anganwadi centres, panchayats for sickle cell care: UP Governor
Ensure medicines reach Anganwadi centres, panchayats for sickle cell care: UP Governor

Time of India

time5 hours ago

  • Time of India

Ensure medicines reach Anganwadi centres, panchayats for sickle cell care: UP Governor

Lucknow: Uttar Pradesh Governor Anandiben Patel on Monday emphasised the need for ensuring the availability of medicines for sickle cell anaemia patients at Anganwadi centres and panchayat offices, saying treatment alone is not enough unless access and awareness are improved at the grassroots level. Chairing a high-level review meeting at Raj Bhavan on the Sickle Cell Anaemia Elimination Mission, the governor said a holistic approach was necessary to rid tribal communities of the disease. Deputy Chief Minister Brajesh Pathak, who also holds the Health portfolio, also attended the meeting. "Merely giving medicines will not suffice. We need a comprehensive strategy to eliminate the disease from society," she said. She recommended multiple measures to strengthen the response to sickle cell anaemia, including providing nutritious food to patients, offering support under adoption and mass marriage schemes for affected youth, and launching awareness drives involving senior citizens in tribal areas. Governor Patel also called for structured counselling, provision of bone marrow transplants, and promotion of testing and research at major hospitals. She issued directions to improve the sex ratio in certain districts, ensure mandatory registration of private hospitals, collect and analyse delivery and infant health data, and crack down on doctors involved in female foeticide. Surprise inspections by senior officers were also stressed to monitor public healthcare services , according to a statement issued by the Raj Bhavan here. Highlighting the role of traditional medicine, the Governor suggested greater outreach of AYUSH and Homeopathy , including the distribution of homeopathic medicines at Anganwadi centres and primary schools, and preparing lists of essential drugs and dosage charts for each centre. She also instructed officials to organise seminars and workshops for doctors, focusing on the effectiveness of different treatments for specific illnesses. Stressing early childhood education, she said school enrolment and attendance must be ensured through better coordination between Anganwadi centres and primary schools. PTI

India's heatwaves worsening, but no one knows how many dying
India's heatwaves worsening, but no one knows how many dying

The Hindu

timea day ago

  • The Hindu

India's heatwaves worsening, but no one knows how many dying

On a scorching May afternoon last year, a ragpicker in Delhi's Ghazipur area collapsed from heat exhaustion. "The family rushed him to the hospital," says Majida Begum, a sanitation worker who witnessed it. "But he was declared dead on arrival. They had no proof that he died due to heat, so they were not given any compensation." His death was never officially counted, just one of the countless lives lost in India's intensifying heatwaves that go unrecorded and uncompensated. An investigation by PTI reveals that disjointed, outdated reporting systems are obscuring the true toll, weakening both public awareness and policy action. Accurate data on heat-related deaths helps identify who is most at risk. Without it, the government cannot plan effectively, create targeted policies or take timely action to save lives. But behind the missing numbers are real people, many poor and undocumented, whose deaths routinely slip through the cracks of India's incoherent reporting system. Currently, at least three separate datasets attempt to monitor heatstroke or heat-related deaths. The two most-commonly cited in the media are maintained by the National Centre for Disease Control (NCDC) under the Health Ministry and the National Crime Records Bureau (NCRB) under the Home Ministry. The India Meteorological Department (IMD) also carries figures on deaths caused by "heatwaves" in its annual reports, drawing data primarily from media coverage. However, these three sources report widely-varying numbers. For instance, data obtained through an RTI query from the Health Ministry shows 3,812 heat-related deaths recorded between 2015 and 2022 under the Integrated Disease Surveillance Programme (IDSP), managed by the NCDC. In contrast, NCRB figures, cited in Parliament many times by Union Earth Sciences Minister Jitendra Singh, put the number at 8,171 deaths from "heat/sunstroke" during the same period. Meanwhile, the IMD's annual reports record 3,436 deaths due to "heatwave" between 2015 and 2022. While the NCDC and the IMD have already released the figures for 2023 and 2024, the NCRB is yet to publish the data for these years. Since 2015, the Health Ministry has been collecting data on heat illness and deaths from April to July. In 2019, this was extended to March through July, covering 23 states. The NCRB has recorded heatstroke deaths since 1995, listing them as "accidental deaths from forces of nature" since around 2010. Experts' view PTI spoke to government officials and healthcare-policy experts to understand the large discrepancies between these datasets. A senior Delhi Police official explained that the NCRB data largely reflects the number of unattended individuals found dead by police at public spaces, homes and elsewhere. Such bodies are taken to hospitals where doctors conduct autopsies to determine the cause of death. According to the NCRB, 730 people died from "heat/sunstroke" in 2022, 374 in 2021 and 530 in 2020. By contrast, the NCDC data shows just 33 heat-related deaths in 2022, none in 2021 and four in 2020, as many states failed to report their figures. These states included Delhi, Uttar Pradesh, Rajasthan, Punjab, Haryana, Madhya Pradesh, Chhattisgarh, Bihar, Jharkhand, Karnataka, Kerala, Andhra Pradesh, Telangana, West Bengal and Tamil Nadu. A Health Ministry official, speaking on the condition of anonymity, said the data from the NCRB and the NCDC are "not directly comparable" because they originate from different sources. "The NCDC reports deaths of patients who come to hospital OPDs or are admitted. But if a person dies and is brought for autopsy, that data goes to the forensic medicine department, which may not always share the information with the NCDC," the official said. He acknowledged the existence of multiple datasets on heat deaths in India and noted that "none of those alone gives the full picture". "While knowing the actual number of heat deaths is important for policy making, confirming such deaths is difficult even with health ministry guidelines," he added. The official said surveillance systems often capture only a fraction of actual cases for other communicable and non-communicable diseases. "We have some numbers, but never the full picture," he said. One major challenge in data collection is the absence of an electronic record system. "Healthcare facilities still enter data manually. Confirming heat-related deaths is already difficult and manual data entry makes accurate reporting even harder," said another official. Though the Integrated Health Information Platform (IHIP) enables digital submission of surveillance data like that of heat-related deaths, the hospital staff manually enter the information into online forms. There is no automated data transfer from hospital records. Officials also said that while states are mandated to report data, compliance is poor. For example, the hospital staff sometimes omit reporting if temperatures drop due to cloudy weather. A senior doctor from a Central government-run hospital in Delhi, speaking anonymously, said most hospitals are understaffed which hampers proper data collection and timely reporting. The doctor also alleged that authorities may suppress death figures to avoid compensation liabilities. At the India Heat Summit 2025 in May, Health Ministry Advisor Soumya Swaminathan highlighted the weaknesses in the country's death-reporting systems. "I have been saying this since my time at the Indian Council of Medical Research — death-reporting systems need strengthening because they provide the best source for the government and policymakers to understand causes of death, which should inform policy," she said. Abhiyant Tiwari, Lead for Climate Resilience and Health at NRDC India, said attributing deaths directly to heat remains a global challenge, not just in India. Mr. Tiwari, who has contributed to heat action plans at city and district levels, said the all-cause mortality data is more reliable for assessing vulnerability and setting early-warning thresholds, as it captures the total number of deaths during heat events, not only those officially classified as heatstroke deaths. Many heat-related deaths go unrecorded or are misclassified as heart attacks or other causes. By comparing mortality during heatwaves to normal periods, experts estimate that the excess deaths are likely attributable to extreme heat, he said. He stressed the need to improve the reporting of the all-cause mortality data and suggested appointing a single department responsible for its collection and dissemination. As climate change intensifies heatwaves, Avinash Chanchal, deputy programme director at Greenpeace South Asia, called for urgent reforms in how heat-related deaths are recorded. "Discrepancies between departments and widespread underreporting mean the true toll of extreme heat often remains hidden. The government must understand that hiding or ignoring the true numbers delays the urgent action needed to address heat," he said. Until India fixes its fractured data system, the dead will remain just a number or worse, not counted at all, Mr. Chanchal said.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store