Nurse Sandie Peggie demands answers from nursing union over single-sex spaces row
Sandie Peggie is suing NHS Fife after sharing a female changing room with a transgender doctor.
A nurse suing NHS Fife after sharing a female changing room with a transgender doctor has demanded clarity from the nursing union about whether it raised concerns regarding single-sex spaces.
Sandie Peggie's solicitor sent a letter to the associate director of the Royal College of Nursing (RCN) Scotland, Norman Provan, calling for industrial intervention from the union on single-sex spaces.
It said Ms Peggie is 'surprised but nevertheless delighted' that on March 27, the union wrote to the director of workforce at County Durham and Darlington NHS Foundation Trust telling them they were breaking the law by failing to provide single-sex changing rooms for staff, according to reports.
The English trust is facing similar litigation to NHS Fife, regarding nurses sharing a changing room with a transgender colleague, however Ms Peggie was not given industrial support when her case was raised in 2024, according to the letter.
Ms Peggie has taken the health board and Dr Beth Upton to tribunal, lodging a complaint of sexual harassment or harassment related to a protected belief under section 26 of the Equality Act 2010 regarding three incidents when they shared a changing room: indirect harassment, victimisation and whistleblowing.
The tribunal resumes in July.
The nurse was suspended on January 3, 2024, after Dr Upton made an allegation of bullying and harassment, the tribunal in Dundee heard earlier this year.
Ms Peggie has been a member of the RCN for 30 years and her solicitor Margaret Gribbon said the nurse is 'not asking the union to intervene in her ongoing litigation', which is not supported by it.
The letter said Ms Peggie had been signed off with stress from February 2025, the same month the tribunal began.
It said: 'As you are aware, Sandie was suspended by the board in early 2024, subject to a year-long disciplinary investigation and is to face a disciplinary hearing to answer allegations of 'gross misconduct', mainly because she objected to the board's decision to permit a trans-identifying male colleague access to a female-only workplace changing room.
'Since February 2025 Sandie has been absent from work suffering from stress. The board has recently been advised that before Sandie can even consider returning to work, she needs assurances that no male colleagues, irrespective of their gender identity, will be permitted to use female-only workplace changing rooms. A response from the board is awaited.
'As the union is aware following my letter of February 13 2024, it is Sandie's understanding that the board did not consult with either the union or female staff about the decision and nor was the decision risk, or equality impact assessed (in breach of the public sector equality duty provisions in the Equality Act 2010 and the Equality Act 2010 (Specific Duties) (Scotland) Regulations 2012).
'When we first spoke around mid-February 2024 I made clear Sandie's expectation that the union exercise its industrial muscle to challenge the decision which was adversely impacting her and other female union members.
'To Sandie's knowledge and disappointment, the union has made no attempt to resolve this matter industrially with the board.
'On April 16 2024, I wrote to the union highlighting, once again, the concerns of Sandie and other female colleagues about the decision. I stated that it was unclear why the board was not taking a common-sense approach to the matter by providing unisex changing room facilities. I asked the union to let me know if it intended to raise this matter with the board but received no reply.'
However the letter cited media reports about the RCN intervening at County Durham and Darlington NHS Foundation Trust, stating it 'expected the trust to abide by the Workplace (Health, Safety and Welfare) Regulations 1992 – and provide single-sex changing rooms without delay'.
The letter said: 'It appears the union was prompted to take these steps as a result of ongoing litigation against by a group of nurses who, like Sandie, claim their employer's decision to permit men into female-only changing rooms is unlawful discrimination and harassment in breach of the Equality Act 2010.'
Ms Gribbon said she is asking two questions on behalf of Ms Peggie: 'Has the union written to the board regarding the existence of the 1992 regulations, the board's present failure to comply, and the union's expectation that the board provides single-sex changing rooms without delay, ie has the union written to the board in the terms that it has written to the trust in the Darlington nurses' case?
'If not, does the union intend to do so in future?'
The Royal College of Nursing, County Durham and Darlington NHS Foundation Trust, and NHS Fife have been contacted for comment.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
5 hours ago
- Daily Mail
NHS bosses who denied boy, 8, treatment because he attends a private school could be guilty of 'indirect discrimination' says barrister
NHS bosses may have 'indirectly discriminated' against a boy by denying him treatment because he went to private school, a barrister has said. Daniel ShenSmith, a practising lawyer and internet personality, said such a move would be 'unethical' and could breach the Equality Act 2010. It comes after the Mail on Sunday revealed the boy, eight, was denied occupational therapy for this hypermobility syndrome because he is not state-educated. The website of his local NHS Trust, in west London, confirms 'referral criteria' limits the service to children attending a 'state-maintained Richmond school'. On his YouTube channel, Mr ShenSmith explained that such a policy would be potentially 'indirectly discriminatory' because it puts some people with a disability at a disadvantage. He added: 'It's just unethical. How can you justify not treating a child because they go to a private school? 'In my view there is no possible justification for this. 'I think this is indirectly discriminatory. It is a practise that needs to stop. They need to treat all these children in the same fair way, which you might expect an NHS trust to do.' The website of Kingston and Richmond NHS Foundation Trust confirms 'referral criteria' limits occupational therapy to children attending a 'state-maintained Richmond school' He pointed out that the policy is even 'spelt out' on the trust's website, and added: 'I don't think the lawyers looked at this one – and if they did... they need to look at it again.' The intervention comes after the Mail on Sunday revealed the family of the child, who asked to remain anonymous, believe a 'two-tier system' is now at play. However, the Department of Health and Social Care (DHSC) has said any suggestion school choice was a factor was a 'miscommunication'. According to the boy's mother, he was referred to a paediatrician at Kingston Hospital in south-west London after she noticed he was 'struggling to hold the pen well enough to write properly', along with other mobility issues. At the hospital appointment she was asked to fill in a form which asked: 'Where does your child go to school?' She had been hoping to get an appointment with Richmond children's occupational therapy service that would have been the 'most important stage' of his assessment. However, days later, she received a text message saying the child had been 'declined' the crucial next appointment with occupational health therapists. She then discovered that the specialist unit had written a letter to her GP saying: 'We are unable to see this child as we do not provide a service to school age children who attend an independent schools [sic]. 'We are only commissioned to provide a service to the mainstream schools.' The boy's older brother – who has the same condition, had been treated without issue several years earlier. In his video about the case, Mr ShenSmith said: 'Why should it make any difference whatsoever whether they attend a state-maintained school as opposed to an independent school?' He said one possible reason for the policy may be to do with administrative processes related to funding. However, he added: 'That's wrong in my view, because that then excludes anyone that goes to an independent school that their parents pay for, and in my view that could be at the very least indirectly discriminatory.' He said under the Equality Act, a blanket policy can be potentially indirectly discriminatory if it 'has an effect which particularly disadvantages people with a protected characteristic'. This would include people with disabilities. Mr ShenSmith, who runs ShenSmith Law, is registered with the Bar Standards Board and was called to the Bar in 2018. He works in a wide range of fields including family, commercial and intellectual property law. In addition, he runs the YouTube channel BlackBeltBarrister, which aims to 'help people understand law'. He added that the Richmond policy was also in breach of the general statutory duty under the current legislation - the National Health Service Act 2006. He told Mail Online: 'This establishes the framework for NHS England to provide universal and free at the point of use service to all eligible individuals including children, regardless of where they attend school.' Health Secretary Wes Streeting was urged this week to 'act swiftly' to intervene in the case. A spokesman for Kingston and Richmond NHS Foundation Trust said the boy had not been denied treatment because of his school. They said occupational therapy services are provided to all children who hold an education, health and care plan (EHCP), regardless of their school. For those without an EHCP, some state schools provide an on-site NHS occupational therapy advice. The spokesman added: 'We are sorry if the wording of our correspondence has caused upset and confusion; we will amend it prospectively.' It is understood anyone without an ECHP who attends a private school would not be able to use on-site services at state schools. A DHSC spokesman said: 'NHS services are free at the point of use to all. 'NHS occupational therapy services are provided for all children with an EHCP. 'For those without an EHCP, some schools provide on-site NHS occupational therapy. 'The Trust has apologised for any miscommunication in its correspondence with the family and is amending its wording to avoid any confusion in the future.' In a separate case, families are currently awaiting a judgement from the High Court on the Government's decision to impose VAT on private school fees. To view Mr ShenSmith's full commentary visit the BlackBeltBarrister YouTube channel.
The Herald Scotland
2 days ago
- The Herald Scotland
When a Glasgow teacher gives a young scholar dietary advice...
A Glasgow English teacher decided to give one of her young scholars dietary advice, and warned the youngster: 'If you don't eat veggies, you'll get scurvy.' 'Who's Scurvy?' replied the suspicious kid. 'Why's he coming at me?' Grinderman Yesterday morning reader Phil Hazelton was up bright and early, and eager to schlurp a black coffee in his local Costa. Why he was up so early we won't bother to explain, because it has no bearing on the story. What is important to our narrative, however, is what Phil spotted while queuing for his java jolt… the café was selling chewing gum. And not just any chewing gum. This was a product called Milliways Plastic Free Gum, which gave our reader pause for thought. 'I've heard of sugar-free gum,' he concedes, 'but never plastic free.' Drawing the inevitable conclusion, Phil says: 'Does this mean that all the other gum I've chewed over the years was packed with plastic? Have I been naively noshing reconstituted Lego bricks?!' Adds Phil: 'No wonder my teeth are in a piteous state. Obviously nothing to do with all the chocolate I've been munching…' Read more: Titillating tome may prove as controversial as Lady Chatterley's Mollusc Age-appropriate material Cafe culture, continued. Samantha Cushing was enjoying a cuppa in a Glasgow cafeteria when she overheard a proud father discussing his young daughter with a pal. At one point the bloke said: 'Just the other day she said to me, 'I'm four now, and I'm going to do four-year-old things.' 'And d'you know what? The next moment I saw her running. And I thought, she IS running like a four year old. She really was!' (The Diary will leave it up to the perambulatory experts amongst our readership to decide whether a four year old runs in a particular fashion, specific to themselves. Though we have a lurking suspicion that it isn't very different from how a 3-and-¾ year old runs...) Burnt offering Inquisitive reader Alex Hale says: 'Did you know a candle flame smells exactly like burnt nose hair?' Flight of fancy Enjoying a stroll with his grandson in Rouken Glen Park, reader Roger Burns passed a teenager flying a kite. 'What's that?!' asked Roger's grandson, clearly confused by the strange spectacle. 'That,' said Roger, 'is an early version of TikTok. How you kept kids quiet in the good old days.' Hard-hitting story A tragic occurrence. 'My gran died on her 97th birthday,' sobs reader Jennifer Barnett. 'And we were only halfway through giving her the bumps...'
The Courier
2 days ago
- The Courier
How a Kinross woman's beloved pet dog is inspiring bid to change law
A campaigning mum from Kinross hopes the memory of her much-loved dog will help change the law for people who need 'emotional support animals'. Elizabeth Crammond took up the challenge to change UK equalities law after sadly losing Daisy in March. The Yorkshire terrier, who joined the family in 2009, was a constant companion and helped Elizabeth cope with stressful situations. She has fybromialgia and other debilitating conditions, and was diagnosed with post-traumatic stress disorder. The presence of her canine companion was a constant source of comfort after her own mother died from cancer in 2011. Daisy, classed as an emotional support animal with a doctor's note to prove it, would still be turned away from places including restaurants and public venues. 'After my mum passed away, Daisy was my emotional support,' Elizabeth told The Courier. 'She was the tiniest thing, she went everywhere with me to the point I lived my life around her. 'I was having a lot of anxiety and panic attacks, and that's where my fybromialgia would come in.' The condition flared up under stress, she says, causing even more anxiety about leaving the house and living a normal life. 'Daisy knew when an attack was coming and she would bring me back into the zone,' Elizabeth said. Daisy would even help support her own little daughter, now four, as she was growing up. Elizabeth, 42, who works in education, realised she would have to change the Equality Act 2010 to put support animals on the same footing as guide dogs. She's doing that by enlisting help from her local MP Pete Wishart and lodging a petition at Westminster to show UK-wide support. Elizabeth says the change of the law will also help people with unseen conditions, avoiding embarrassing situations in public places. Her petition – called Daisy Companion Law – is live on the Commons website.
