£1 ketchup beats big brands and posh sauces in blind taste test
Online shopping and budget supermarkets mean traditional brands face more competition than ever for their products.
In theory, having so much choice is great news for the consumer - but it does make it tricky working out where the best quality and value lies.
In our new Our Verdict feature, Sky News' Money team will be blind-testing popular products to help you make informed decisions.
Our six-strong team of expert tasters are starting with a staple that many people feel strongly about: ketchup.
Children across the UK may refuse it unless it's their favourite brand - but when you peel off the label, which really comes out on top?
We sampled 14 different ketchups - from own brands to high-end makers - marking for taste, balance and texture.
With high scores across the board, M&S's own brand came out on top - and the good news is it costs just a fraction of the price of some traditional brands at £1.
Of the "posh" brands we sampled, Wilkin and Sons blew away the rest and came in third overall.
At the other end of our league table came Aldi, which is also the cheapest bottle at 89p - with Tesco's own and Daddies also judged poorly in the blind test.
How did your favourite perform? Here are the results...
A thick but still smooth sauce perfect for scooping with chips. It is rich in colour and has a natural taste of tomatoes. This sauce comes with a subtle kick but its overall balance makes it a strong choice for the entire family.
Rich, smooth and good body. This is an all-rounder: a balanced flavour and likely to please everyone.
Price: £3.14
Average score: 7.3
The highest scoring "disruptor". It has a deep colour, a discreet tang and thick, slightly bitty texture. The closest in our test to tasting homemade. A great choice if you're looking to impress with something different.
Fourth place: Morrisons
Good balance, with vinegar and smokiness coming through. Our testers noted a strong sweetness, while its texture and colour fared well compared with other own-brand ketchups.
A decent everyday ketchup that lost marks due to its pale colour and thin texture. Our testers noted that sweet and acidic flavours were dominant over the tomato taste.
Sixth place: Sainsbury's
This divided out testers, with scores ranging from 10 to three. Those who loved it praised its thick texture, balance and deep colour - but the tangy, smoky notes weren't for everyone.
An average scorer - but well ahead of its Aldi equivalent. Testers thought it lacked anything to make it stand out.
This middle-class favourite scored disappointingly with the majority of our testers, who felt it lacked the balance of the sauces above. Its thick texture appeals, but you might expect more tomato flavour.
This sauce was an all-rounder with a deep colour - but testers felt it was too sweet and sharp, evoking memories of takeaway ketchup eaten with chips in a park.
A lighter sauce that lost marks for its runnier texture. Our testers felt it lacked flavour compared with many of the other sauces, but its balance of sweetness was a strong point.
Eleventh place: Dr Wills
Price: £3
Average score: 5.2
The least ketchup-like of the ketchups, this is a room splitter. The natural tomato flavours come through and it tastes homemade, but a notable fruitiness and zing might put off traditionalists.
Several testers commented that it tasted like "café ketchup", with a dominant vinegar profile and too much sweetness.
Joint twelfth: Daddies
Price: £1.50
Average score: 4.3
Across the board, our testers felt this was too sweet, with an artificial and unbalanced flavour.
While not eliciting some of the very low marks of its rivals, this scored poorly across the board, with testers noting a lack of tomato flavour and an inescapable sweetness.
Here are the full results...
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
28 minutes ago
- The Independent
Anglian Water profits go up after price increases as debt swell to £7.7bn
Anglian Water has revealed stronger profits on the back of price increases for households, as the water supplier also reported another jump in debts over the past year. The utilities firm, which provides services to seven million people in the east of England, also revealed an increase in pollution incidents over the year. Anglian revealed on Friday that revenues grew by 7.5% to £1.75 billion for the year to March 31, compared with a year earlier. The rise was linked to price increases of 8.6% during the year. Earlier this year, the company said it was putting up bills by a further 19%, to an average of £626 a year, for the 2025/26 financial year from April. The firm also reported that operating profits grew by 15.2% to £496.5 million for the year to March. Meanwhile, the group said its net debts before derivatives grew by more than a tenth to £7.72 billion by the end of the year. Anglian said it grew its debt burden in order to help fund more than £1 billion in capital spending over the year for improvements to water resources and infrastructure in the region. The company is privately owned by a consortium including major pension funds and investment firms. Meanwhile, Anglian reported that its total pollution incidents increased last year, although serious ones were down 36% year-on-year. It also highlighted that the group's leakage performance fell below its individual target. Mark Thurston, chief executive of the business, said: 'We recognise the challenges ahead. 'The strategies and plans being implemented give us confidence in our trajectory and provide a clear road map for delivering consistent, high-quality outcomes for customers, colleagues, regulators, investors and the environment. 'In summary, 2024/25 has been a year of transition, focus and progress, setting firm foundations for a strong and successful AMP8 (Asset Management Period 8).' Last month, the water supplier was fined a record £1.42 million for drinking water failures that affected around 1.3 million people.
The Independent
28 minutes ago
- The Independent
Business news live: Oil prices surge after Israel attacks Iran, FTSE 100 falls after all time high
The FTSE 100 hit a new closing record after investors continued to look for opportunities outside the US, despite the UK economy shrinking by more than expected in April. The index of the UK's leading shares rose 0.23% to close at 8,884 on Thursday, topping a previous high of 8,871.31 on March 3. Shares have rallied in recent days and that continued on Thursday despite Chancellor Rachel Reeves acknowledging 'clearly disappointing' new gross domestic product (GDP) figures, which fell 0.3 per cent in April. But the FTSE 100's global footprint, with constituents including mining and energy giants, helped lift it to new heights. Asia stocks have mostly fallen overnight, the Nikkei 225 and the Hang Seng both close to 1 per cent down as they head toward closing. There is no major UK economic data expected today. The Independent brings you the latest business news and stock market updates today.
The Sun
30 minutes ago
- The Sun
Millions of Nationwide customers to nab £100 Fairer Share payment in DAYS – check if you'll get the cash
NATIONWIDE customers will start getting £100 free cash in a matter of days. Millions of customers will receive the payment through its Fairer Share scheme, which rewards loyal members who save or borrow with the building society. 1 The first payments will hit bank accounts on June 18 - meaning there's less than a week to go. Nationwide has said the payments will be made between then and July 4. However not all Nationwide customers will be eligible. To receive the payment you will need to have opened a current account with Nationwide on or before March 31, 2025. You must have also had at least £100 in savings, or owed £100 or more on a mortgage by that same March deadline. Plus you'll need to have used your account between January 1 and March 31 this year. Still, about four million customers are set to benefit from the cash payment. A total of about £410million is being paid out. The building society has run its Fairer Share scheme for three years in a row now, so if you open a current account now you may have a chance of getting the free cash next year. However there is no guarantee Nationwide will run the scheme again. Last year, Nationwide paid out £385million to 3.85million people. Separately, it also paid out £50 to around 12million customers between April and May. Nationwide also recently offered exclusive access to a top savings account rate for its customers. Those who already bank with the building society can open up a Member Exclusive Bond account which has a very attractive 5% interest rate. The 18-month-fixed term account will net you £759 in interest if you put in the maximum £10,000. What other banking perks can you get? Banks often pay you to switch to their current accounts, and there's four currently offering switching freebies. First Direct is giving away £175 to people who switch to its 1st Account. You just need to open an account and set up at least two direct debits or standing orders within 45 days. You will also need to pay in £1,000 and make five debit card payments within the same timeframe. TSB is handing out £100 cash but £15 a month in cashback for six months to those who switch to its Spend and Save account. Plus you can get either £120 credit towards a hotel booking via Expedia's Travel Credits website or 12 months of activity tickets with the National Activities Network. Where to find the best savings rates Many savings accounts offer miserly rates meaning that money is generating little or no return. However, there are ways to get your cash working hard. Sun Savers Editor Lana Clements explains how to make sure you money is getting the best interest rate. Easy access savings accounts offer flexibility for customers, meaning they can dip in and out of cash when needed. However, the caveat is that rates can change at any time. If you're keeping your money in an easy access account, you'll need to keep checking whether it's the best paying account for your circumstances and move if not. Check in at least once a month to see what is happening in the market. Check what is offered by your bank - sometimes the best rates are for customers only. But do search the wider market as often top savings accounts are offered by lesser known providers. Comparison sites are a good place to check for the top rates. Try or Moneysupermarket. You can search by different account type. You'll usually get a better interest rate if you can lock your money away for a fixed amount of time, but it's always a good idea to keep some money in an easy access account in case of emergencies. Don't overlook regular savings accounts often pay some of the best rates, but you'll need to commit to monthly payments. This can be a great way to get into a savings habit while earning top rates at the same time.
