Minister flags concern over BC Ferries' deal with Chinese state-owned shipyard
British Columbia's transportation minister has raised concerns with BC Ferries about its decision to have a Chinese shipyard build four new ferries for its passenger fleet, amid an ongoing trade conflict between Canada and China.
The winning bidder on the contract announced Tuesday is Chinese state-owned China Merchants Industry Weihai Shipyards.
Mike Farnworth said in a statement he was worried about procuring services from 'any country that is actively harming Canada's economy' with tariffs and protectionism.
ARTICLE CONTINUES BELOW
'BC Ferries is an independent company responsible for its own operational decisions. While BC Ferries has made its decision to purchase new vessels offshore, I am disappointed more involvement from Canadian shipyards was not part of the contract,' he said.
Farnsworth's office declined a request for an interview.
The minister's remarks came hours after the announcement by BC Ferries CEO Nicolas Jimenez that the Chinese shipyard had been chosen to build its vessels, with the first expected to come into service in 2029 and the others following in six-month intervals.
Jimenez said he wasn't worried about geopolitical tensions between Canada and China, adding his primary focus was getting the province a good deal.
'Customers expect us to go source the best possible deal, (the) highest quality, a yard that provides safety, a yard that provides the highest in standards when it comes to oversight (and) labour, and to get the best cost,' he said at a news conference Tuesday.
'When it comes to things like trade policy, industrial policy, geopolitics, I think we would really defer that to the federal and provincial governments and expect them to manage and work those issues.'
He said in a news release that the shipyard was 'the clear choice based on the overall strength of its bid.'
ARTICLE CONTINUES BELOW
ARTICLE CONTINUES BELOW
It said Weihai Shipyards has built vessels for Canada's Marine Atlantic ferry company and other operators such as Corsica Linea and Brittany Ferries of France.
Canada and China are engaged in a trade dispute, with Beijing imposing retaliatory tariffs on Canadian canola and meal, peas and seafood after Ottawa slapped levies on Chinese-made electric vehicles, steel and aluminum.
Jimenez said Tuesday that there are currently no tariffs associated with the import of vessels of this type into Canada and tariff disputes didn't factor into the decision.
The publicly funded BC Ferries is not releasing the value of the contract, other than Jimenez saying it fits within the budget approved by the BC Ferries Commissioner earlier this year.
He said releasing the deal before the project is complete could put future procurements at risk.
'To protect BC Ferries and our customers, we've structured the contract in a way that reduces our risk while increasing shipyard accountability. Most of the payment is tied to delivery, and that means the shipyard doesn't get fully paid until the vessels are delivered and meet the rigorous standards that we've laid out in the contract,' he said.
ARTICLE CONTINUES BELOW
ARTICLE CONTINUES BELOW
'There are also measures like refund guarantees and fixed price terms that will further protect BC Ferries and our customers.'
BC Ferries' head of fleet renewal, Ed Hooper, said no Canadian companies bid on the ships that will carry about 52 per cent more passengers and 24 per cent more vehicles than the ferries they are replacing.
When the request for proposals was issued last September, Canadian shipbuilder Seaspan said in a statement that 'Canadian shipyards and their supply chains cannot compete with low-wage countries that have lower employment standards, lower environmental standards and lower safety standards than Canada and B.C.'
Seaspan said in a statement Tuesday that it was currently building ships for the Royal Canadian Navy and the Canadian Coast Guard at its North Vancouver shipyard.
'We look forward to exploring how this capability can be leveraged to build future B.C. ferries here at home, and therefore generate the strategic industrial and significant socio-economic benefits associated with capital projects of this nature for British Columbians.'
Jimenez said 60 per cent of the world's ships are built in China, and BC Ferries did due diligence to make sure it understood the 'technical and delivery and country risks associated with making this decision.'
ARTICLE CONTINUES BELOW
ARTICLE CONTINUES BELOW
Hooper said the procurement process included teams of experts to evaluate bids from around the world on 30 different criteria and the top bidders were also visited in person.
BC Ferries said it will have its own team of experts on-site at the shipyard throughout construction to provide oversight and quality assurance.
In a statement, the Opposition BC Conservatives accused Premier David Eby of 'abandoning Canadian workers' by awarding a 'multibillion-dollar' contract to a Chinese state-owned enterprise.
B.C.'s aging fleet of ferries has faced lengthy, and costly, sailing delays and breakdowns in recent years.
Last year, the 61-year-old Queen of New Westminster was out of service for nearly 200 days after a mechanical failure, which Jimenez said cost $5.5 million in unplanned repairs and $8.5 million in lost revenue.
'Replacing the ships now ensures that we're set up to avoid service disruptions that are going to impact communities up and down our coast,' he said.
ARTICLE CONTINUES BELOW
ARTICLE CONTINUES BELOW
Along with the Queen of New Westminster, the Queen of Cowichan, Queen of Alberni and Queen of Coquitlam are also being replaced. Those ships all turn 50 next year.
BC Ferries had hoped to buy five new vessels and bring its fleet size from 10 to 11 but earlier this year the provincial regulator rejected the pitch, saying a fifth ferry 'is not in the public interest' as it is 'not essential for safe and reliable service and is not fiscally prudent.'
The parent company of China Merchants Industry Weihai Shipyards is China Merchants Industry Holdings.
The conglomerate's website describes it as a 'centrally administrated state-owned' enterprise with more than a 100 years of history, making it one of the oldest 'Chinese-funded enterprises' in existence.
The website says the company is based in Hong Kong and operates nine major shipyards across the Chinese coast as well as overseas subsidiaries and agencies in countries such as Finland and Germany.
This report by The Canadian Press was first published June 10, 2025.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Canada Standard
an hour ago
- Canada Standard
G7 Summit marks turning point in India-Canada relations, says former minister Ujjal Dosanjh
Vancouver [Canada], June 12 (ANI): As India cements its place as the world's fourth-largest economy, the global balance of power is shifting -- and Canada must take note, says Ujjal Dosanjh, former Canadian Minister of Health, senior lawyer, and vocal advocate against extremism. Speaking in the wake of Prime Minister Narendra Modi's participation in the G7 summit, Dosanjh says this moment offers a much-needed opportunity to reset strained India-Canada relations, particularly due to long-standing tensions over Khalistan-linked extremism. 'India, even before it became the fourth-largest economy, was being recognised by leaders like Carney as indispensable on the global stage,' Dosanjh remarked, referring to Prime Minister Mark Carney, who assumed office earlier this year. 'Now that India has moved up in global rankings, it only strengthens the case for deeper cooperation.' Dosanjh pointed out that G7 leaders are well aware of India's growing influence and are likely advising Canada not to let political disagreements override strategic and economic interests. 'Leaders know that even when they have issues with a country, they can't ignore its importance. They find ways to engage constructively -- and that's the approach Carney seems to be taking,' he said. Prime Minister Carney's invitation to Prime Minister Modi drew protests from several Sikh separatist groups in Canada. But Dosanjh, a long-time critic of extremism, questioned the seriousness with which these groups should be taken, especially given their historical role in damaging Canada's global reputation. 'These elements did massive damage to Canada's image when they bombed Air India Flight 182 in 1985,' Dosanjh said, referencing the worst act of aviation terror before 9/11. 'That wasn't India's wound -- it was Canada's wound. Those were Canadian citizens who died.' He also recalled the role of Khalistani militant Talwinder Singh Parmar, believed to be the mastermind of the Air India bombing. 'Parmar had earlier killed police officers in India and fled here. Indira Gandhi sought his extradition, but Canada didn't act, partly because there was no extradition treaty at the time. That failure had grave consequences.' Dosanjh emphasised that Canada has allowed such extremist elements to penetrate mainstream politics. 'Former Prime Minister Stephen Harper rightly said we shouldn't tolerate separatists in our political parties -- especially those seeking to break up allied democracies. I've always believed that, and I suspect Carney privately does too,' he added. India has sought the extradition of 26 fugitives, including several Khalistani extremists. On this issue, Dosanjh confirmed that there are signs of cooperation, although progress remains slow. 'I spoke with Mr. Verma, India's former High Commissioner to Canada, and he said publicly -- and to me privately -- that Canada has started moving on some of those cases,' he revealed. 'There is an extradition treaty in place. It now depends on the quality of the evidence provided, and on Canada's willingness to act on it.' With both countries being democracies and promoting strategic autonomy in foreign policy, Dosanjh sees a natural alignment between India and Canada, especially on trade and global issues. 'Canada exports a lot of lentils and grains to India. I know someone personally in that business who's been suffering because of the diplomatic chill -- no trains are moving from his location,' he said. 'It's critical for both countries to stabilise relations not just for trade, but also to collaborate on global challenges as democratic allies.' Dosanjh believes PM Modi's visit to the G7, hosted by Canada this year, is a promising step toward restoring ties. 'Mr. Carney signalled his intent to reset the relationship during his campaign. Inviting Modi to the G7 is the first concrete step in that direction,' he said. While tensions remain, especially around the killing of separatist figure Hardeep Singh Nijjar, Dosanjh believes these should not prevent broader cooperation. 'Countries always have disputes. But responsible governments work on multiple tracks: you can address law enforcement matters on one track and continue dialogue on trade, people-to-people ties, and international cooperation on other tracks.' On the recent attack on journalist Mocha Bezirgan in Vancouver -- where Khalistani supporters allegedly surrounded, threatened, and snatched his phone -- Dosanjh didn't mince words. 'Khalistanis have never shied away from violence. Air India was just the most dramatic example,' he said. 'Unless there are serious prosecutions, these incidents will continue. Canada has been slow to prosecute Khalistani violence, and that delay is hurting our society.' He stressed that the problem is not just about India's security. 'It's in Canada's own interest to control this menace, for the peace and safety of Canadians. We must protect journalists, uphold free speech, and prosecute threats without fear or political calculations.' The extradition of Pakistani national Muhammad Shahzeb Khan, accused of plotting an ISIS-inspired attack in New York, has raised further concerns about radicalisation in Canada. Dosanjh believes these fears are well-founded. 'Nearly 100 Canadians went to fight alongside ISIS. Some returned and were prosecuted, some are in jail. Canada is aware of the threat, but our responses are often too slow and reactive,' he said. 'The same lethargy we showed after Air India shouldn't be repeated with new threats whether from Islamist extremists or Khalistani groups.' Dosanjh also pointed to Pakistan's long-standing role in fuelling the Khalistan movement -- a connection made more visible during recent protests in Vancouver where Pakistani flags were seen alongside Khalistani banners. 'This isn't new. In the 1970s, Jagjit Singh Chohan declared Khalistan in a U.S. newspaper after returning from Pakistan. That declaration was funded by Pakistani money, funnelled in part by the CIA. I met Chohan in Canada back then,' he recalled. He warned that the ISI's hand remains visible today. 'Figures like Pannun are believed to be working with Pakistani handlers in the U.S. Indian officials know this. Many Canadian politicians, either gullible or ignorant, still look the other way. But now, with the Pakistani flag appearing openly in these rallies, the truth is harder to deny.' Despite all the tensions and painful history, Dosanjh remains hopeful. 'This G7 summit, hosted by Canada, is a turning point. Prime Minister Carney has taken the first step by inviting Modi. Now it's time for sustained engagement, honest dialogue, and zero tolerance for those who threaten democracy in any form.' He concludes with a clear message: 'Canada and India are both democracies. They may have their differences, but the shared values and the global stakes are too high to let those differences define the relationship.' (ANI)
The Market Online
an hour ago
- The Market Online
Middle Eastn Tensions Pull TSX Futures Down
Canadian index futures slipped Thursday as rising Middle East tensions rattled markets and early enthusiasm over cooling U.S. inflation lost steam. Market Numbers (Futures) TSX :Down ( 0.30%) 26,444.43TSXV: Down (0.59%) 721.52DOW: Down (0.70%) 42,612.00NASDAQ: Down (0.55%) 21,766.50 FTSE: Down (0.03%) 8,861.44 In the Headlines: Canada and the U.S. are fast-tracking high-stakes negotiations on a sweeping economic and security deal that could touch everything from critical minerals to defense supply chains, sources say. And Barrick has quietly cut its 2025 forecast after pulling the high-yield Mali gold complex, a 14% of expected output, during an escalating export standoff with the Malian government. Currencies Update: (Futures) The Canadian dollar gains 0.25% to $0.7350, falls to the Euro by 0.63% to $0.6286 and Bitcoin drops another 2.06% to 145,919.70 Commodities: (Futures) Natural Gas: Up (2.43%), 3.60WTI: Down (1.94%), 66.84Gold: Up (0.77%), 3,379.46 Copper: Down (0.14%) 6.03 To stay up-to-date on all of your market news head to Join the discussion: Find out what everybody's saying check out the rest of Stockhouse's stock forums and message boards. The material provided in this article is for information only and should not be treated as investment advice. For full disclaimer information, please click here
Winnipeg Free Press
an hour ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
Supreme Court of Canada to hear Facebook privacy case
OTTAWA – The Supreme Court of Canada has agreed to review a ruling that concluded Facebook broke federal privacy law by failing to adequately inform users of risks to their data when using the popular social media platform. Last September, the Federal Court of Appeal found Facebook, now known as Meta Platforms, did not obtain the meaningful consent required by the Personal Information Protection and Electronic Documents Act between 2013 and 2015. The decision overturned a 2023 Federal Court ruling. The Court of Appeal said Facebook invited millions of apps onto its platform and did not adequately supervise them. It found that the Federal Court's failure to engage with the relevant evidence on this point was an error of law. Privacy commissioner Philippe Dufresne called that decision an acknowledgment that international firms whose business models rely on users' data must respect Canadian privacy law. This report by The Canadian Press was first published June 12, 2025.
