
When will a team from North America, Asia or Africa win the men's World Cup?
We're now a year-ish from the World Cup. The tournament is still dominated by European and South American teams. But which continent without a winner (Asia, Africa, Central and North America and, I guess, Oceania) has the best chance of lifting the trophy first?
– Stacey
This is a fascinating question and one that brings a wide range of factors into play. To start, what difference will the expansion of the tournament make? On one hand, extending the tournament so the winner will have to get through eight games rather than seven probably makes shocks less likely, but on the other hand an extra knockout round adds another layer of randomness. Even with four knockout rounds, most champions usually had at least one game of significant jeopardy – a win on penalties, or an edgy one-goal victory after extra-time. Winning all five knockout games in 90 minutes, I suspect, will prove extremely rare but the likelihood is still that the winner will be one of the major European powers – France, Spain, Germany, England, Portugal, Italy and the Netherlands – or one of the big two from South America – Argentina and Brazil.
On a similar note, weight of numbers should help the other confederations: 15 of the 32 qualifiers in 2022 were from outside Uefa and Conmebol; in 2026 either 25 or 26 of 48 will be. That should increase the chance of a side hitting a run of exceptional form at the right time.
But this isn't just about confederations. Between 2006 and 2018, 13 of 16 semi-finalists in the World Cup were European. There was a clear sense within the game that the major western European nations had in effect industrialised youth production – to the extent that the majority of, say, Morocco's squad in 2022, had been trained in France. Add a wealthy league in which the best of a nation's youth can gain an exceptional and immediate education and the advantage enjoyed by western Europe is clear. Argentina bucked that trend in 2022, in part because of the brilliance of Lionel Messi, and in part because of its remarkable reserves of coaching talent (seven of the 10 Conmebol nations are managed by Argentinians, and that's without counting Óscar Ibáñez, who was born in Argentina but played for and now manages Peru).
But to return to the specifics of the question: money helps, so the USA, Mexico and Canada have at least a slim chance of success. Africa has the talent but its football – and this is obviously a generalisation – is beset by poverty and corruption. Morocco showed their capacity in Qatar, and if, say, Nigeria or Senegal managed to find an enlightened coach who could bypass all the political issues at the same time they had a gifted generation, there's no reason there couldn't be an African winner – although it doesn't feel imminent.
Asia, perhaps, is most likely, although we're probably only talking about three countries at the moment. Japan and South Korea have been regular World Cup qualifiers, their level has improved dramatically, there is money to invest, a deep-rooted passion for the game, and their players are increasingly gaining experience at the best clubs.
Or there's Saudi Arabia, a traditional power in the Asian game, and hosts in 2034. We're yet to see what impact all the Saudi PIF's investment in football will have, but money, a political will to succeed, an improving league must give them at least an outside chance with home advantage in eight years.
As an American, I defy anyone to argue the 1994 World Cup jersey is not the best in soccer history. Do you have any personal favorites?
– Matt
I confess I find the fetishisation of shirts a little odd. I hate over-fussy shirts, and I wish Sunderland would go back to black socks, but I'm not sure there are any shirts I really love. I was talking to a friend about this on the way to the Championship play-off final, looking at the masses of red-and-white all around while we were both wearing very neutral check shirts. We wondered whether it's because in our formative years of going to games, away games especially, in the late 80s and early 90s, it was useful to be able to blend into the background if any violence kicked off.
But I suppose if pressed, I always quite liked the simple Adidas, early 80s, plain colour with three stripes along the sleeves – the pale-blue West Germany goalkeeper's top in particular.
It's probably my age – I've watched football for nearly 70 years – but I really miss old-fashioned wingers, playing on the 'correct' wing, beating their defender on the outside and providing crosses for their fellow attackers. The case for inverted wingers seems to be that coming 'inside' on to their stronger foot increases their chances of shooting and scoring. It's now de rigueur for wingers to be inverted. Does the likelihood of inverted wingers scoring goals by coming inside really compensate for the fewer effective crosses they make for their fellow attackers?
– Derek
I agree that there remains something aesthetically very pleasing about a centre-forward meeting an outswinging cross with a header – Alexander Isak's goal from Anthony Gordon's cross for Newcastle against Arsenal last season, for instance – but I suspect that ship has sailed.
Herbert Chapman was arguing that a focus on wingers crossing for forwards was inefficient 100 years ago, and most modern theory seems to agree with him. The preference now is either for wide players cutting infield – Peter Taylor was a pioneer in England, but Dennis Tueart and others did it as well – or to work the ball to the goalline for a low cutback – the classic Manchester City goal of a couple of seasons ago.
Sign up to Soccer with Jonathan Wilson
Jonathan Wilson brings expert analysis on the biggest stories from European soccer
after newsletter promotion
One of the reasons wide forwards now cut inside is the explosion in attacking full-backs, who now provide most of the width. A full-back could go inside, as say Trent Alexander-Arnold or João Cancelo do, but that is relatively rare and if the full-back is going on the outside, the wide forward has go inside to create space for him. I think there's also a recognition that forwards cutting in, often against the defender's weaker foot, is very hard to combat – hence the rise in the sort of goal Lamine Yamal seems to score every week, whipping the ball into the far corner.
Kevin Keegan was perhaps the first English player, certainly in the postwar years, to make a success of a move to a European giant. He left Liverpool in 1977 for Hamburg, where he won the league in 1978-79 and was twice named European Footballer of the Year. He also marketed himself with an eagerness unusual in English players of the time, becoming a bona fide celebrity. And, on 9 June 1979, he released his second, but by some distance his most successful single, Head Over Heels in Love.
His first single, It Ain't Easy, had been released in 1972, just a year after he'd moved to Liverpool from Scunthorpe and made very little impression. But Head Over Heels reached No 31 in the UK charts, and No 10 in Germany. And this is where those of a nervous disposition should look away. Keegan gave a preview of the song on Das Aktuelle Sport-Studio. His German seems very good, but that thought soon fades as he gets to the performance …
This is an extract from Soccer with Jonathan Wilson, a weekly look from the Guardian US at the game in Europe and beyond. Subscribe for free here. Have a question for Jonathan? Email soccerwithjw@theguardian.com, and he'll answer the best in a future edition.

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


BBC News
an hour ago
- BBC News
Palestine FA makes complaint as penalty ends World Cup dream
The Palestine Football Association (PFA) has made an official complaint to world football's governing body Fifa and the Asian Football Confederation after a controversial late penalty ended their hopes of qualifying for the 2026 World Palestine leading 1-0 in Tuesday's tie, Iranian referee Mooud Bonyadifard gave Oman a penalty in the seventh minute of injury time. Issam Al Sabhi converted from the spot to make it 1-1, a result that sent Oman into the next phase and knocked Palestine out of contention.A statement from the PFA said: "Following a thorough review of the official match footage, and various replays shared across media platforms and social networks, it has become evident the penalty decision lacked the necessary refereeing criteria and did not meet the technical standards required to justify such a call. "This decision was clearly unfair to our national team."The complaint calls for a comprehensive investigation into the circumstances surrounding this incident and a review of all related refereeing procedures. This step aims to uphold sporting justice and ensure the integrity of international competition."Neither Palestine nor Oman have ever qualified for a World Cup, with Oman still hopeful of being one of 48 countries to play in the 2026 tournament, which is being held in Canada, the United States and will now play in a three-nation group in October, facing two of Indonesia, Iraq, Qatar, Saudi Arabia and the United Arab Emirates, and will qualify if they win their section.


The Independent
an hour ago
- The Independent
Tottenham appoint Brentford's Thomas Frank as new manager
Tottenham Hotspur have appointed Thomas Frank as their new head coach on a deal running until 2028. Spurs will reportedly pay Brentford a compensation fee of £10m for the 51-year-old Dane, who replaces Ange Postecoglou at the club. Postecoglou was sacked despite ending Tottenham's 17-year wait for a trophy after a dismal Premier League season which saw Spurs finish 17th. Frank was Tottenham's top target after taking Brentford from the Championship and turning them into an established Premier League side in seven years. Tottenham released a statement confirming the appointment, saying they were 'delighted' to have the Dane join the club. 'Thomas has extensive experience in English football having joined Brentford in 2016 - since becoming one of the longest-serving current managers in the Premier League. During his time at Brentford he transformed the Club, moving them up from the Championship to an established Premier League side, consistently and significantly outperforming expectations for an extended period of time. 'In Thomas we are appointing one of the most progressive and innovative head coaches within the game,' the club added. Frank joined Brentford in 2016 as assistant head coach and replaced Dean Smith as head coach two years later. He oversaw a remarkable rise in the Bees' fortunes, guiding them to promotion to the top flight in 2021, and he holds the record for most wins in his first 200 games at the club, with 90. They reached the Championship play-off final at the end of the 2019-20 season, losing to Fulham, but beat Swansea City in the final the following year, and have solidly established themselves as a Premier League side with 13th, ninth, 16th and 10th-place finishes since promotion. 'Everyone connected with Brentford would like to thank Thomas for the incredible impact he has had on the club's history,' Brentford said in a statement confirming his departure. The Bees' director of football, Phil Giles, said: 'From the moment he replaced Dean Smith, he understood what we were trying to build and his wisdom, coaching ability and emotional intelligence have helped transform the club. 'But it's not just what you see on the pitch. He forged a special connection with our fans, helped develop and improve players, and was instrumental in implementing the culture that has seen Brentford go from strength to strength. 'We will never forget Thomas, but now it is time to thank him and take the next steps in our journey with a new leader who we believe can be just as successful and influential.' Highly-rated first-team assistant coach Justin Cochrane will join him, alongside head of first-team performance Chris Haslam and first-team analyst Joe Newton. Cochrane also joined Thomas Tuchel's England coaching set-up earlier this year alongside his role at the London club. In their statement, Tottenham added that Manchester United's Andreas Georgson would also be joining as a first team assistant coach.


Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
Cuba soccer player refuses to play for his country amid fears he won't be allowed back in the United States
As Donald Trump 's policies on immigration and the border continue to cause chaos across the country, professional athletes are in fear that they cannot return to their homes if they wish to play in the United States. According to James Nalton of the Morning Star, Raiko Arozarena - the brother of Seattle Mariners star Randy Arozarena - did not travel to his native Cuba to take part in a CONCACAF qualifier for the 2026 FIFA World Cup. Raiko, who is a goalkeeper playing for Las Vegas Lights FC in the USL Championship, didn't make the journey out of fear that he wouldn't be allowed back into the United States if he took part in the match. Trump instituted full travel bans for 12 countries while also placing heightened restrictions on seven others - including Cuba. Las Vegas Lights FC and the USL did not immediately respond to a request for comment from at the time of publishing. With Arozarena not on the roster, Cuba lost their final game of qualifying 2-1 to Bermuda - eliminating them from the World Cup by one point. Earlier in this same window, the Cayman Islands - playing in the same qualifying group as Cuba - forfeited their match against the Cubans to avoid traveling to the country. There was fear that if players from the Cayman Islands - an overseas territory of the UK - traveled to the country, that they would not be able to return to the United States. A statement from the Cuban FA (via Nalton) read: 'Arozarena's actions demonstrate how much the climate of uncertainty and pressure generated by these [US government] measures and campaigns orchestrated in this regard threaten sport.' Among the nations who have been issued full bans, the USL Championship has one player from the Republic of the Congo, two players from Somalia, and seven from Haiti. Regarding those with heightened restrictions, there are five players from Cuba (including Arozarena), one from Burundi, three from Sierra Leone, and five from Venezuela. Currently, Las Vegas is tenth in the USL Western Conference standings - with 12 points in 12 matches and is on a four match losing streak.