logo
When will a team from North America, Asia or Africa win the men's World Cup?

When will a team from North America, Asia or Africa win the men's World Cup?

The Guardian4 hours ago

We're now a year-ish from the World Cup. The tournament is still dominated by European and South American teams. But which continent without a winner (Asia, Africa, Central and North America and, I guess, Oceania) has the best chance of lifting the trophy first?
– Stacey
This is a fascinating question and one that brings a wide range of factors into play. To start, what difference will the expansion of the tournament make? On one hand, extending the tournament so the winner will have to get through eight games rather than seven probably makes shocks less likely, but on the other hand an extra knockout round adds another layer of randomness. Even with four knockout rounds, most champions usually had at least one game of significant jeopardy – a win on penalties, or an edgy one-goal victory after extra-time. Winning all five knockout games in 90 minutes, I suspect, will prove extremely rare but the likelihood is still that the winner will be one of the major European powers – France, Spain, Germany, England, Portugal, Italy and the Netherlands – or one of the big two from South America – Argentina and Brazil.
On a similar note, weight of numbers should help the other confederations: 15 of the 32 qualifiers in 2022 were from outside Uefa and Conmebol; in 2026 either 25 or 26 of 48 will be. That should increase the chance of a side hitting a run of exceptional form at the right time.
But this isn't just about confederations. Between 2006 and 2018, 13 of 16 semi-finalists in the World Cup were European. There was a clear sense within the game that the major western European nations had in effect industrialised youth production – to the extent that the majority of, say, Morocco's squad in 2022, had been trained in France. Add a wealthy league in which the best of a nation's youth can gain an exceptional and immediate education and the advantage enjoyed by western Europe is clear. Argentina bucked that trend in 2022, in part because of the brilliance of Lionel Messi, and in part because of its remarkable reserves of coaching talent (seven of the 10 Conmebol nations are managed by Argentinians, and that's without counting Óscar Ibáñez, who was born in Argentina but played for and now manages Peru).
But to return to the specifics of the question: money helps, so the USA, Mexico and Canada have at least a slim chance of success. Africa has the talent but its football – and this is obviously a generalisation – is beset by poverty and corruption. Morocco showed their capacity in Qatar, and if, say, Nigeria or Senegal managed to find an enlightened coach who could bypass all the political issues at the same time they had a gifted generation, there's no reason there couldn't be an African winner – although it doesn't feel imminent.
Asia, perhaps, is most likely, although we're probably only talking about three countries at the moment. Japan and South Korea have been regular World Cup qualifiers, their level has improved dramatically, there is money to invest, a deep-rooted passion for the game, and their players are increasingly gaining experience at the best clubs.
Or there's Saudi Arabia, a traditional power in the Asian game, and hosts in 2034. We're yet to see what impact all the Saudi PIF's investment in football will have, but money, a political will to succeed, an improving league must give them at least an outside chance with home advantage in eight years.
As an American, I defy anyone to argue the 1994 World Cup jersey is not the best in soccer history. Do you have any personal favorites?
– Matt
I confess I find the fetishisation of shirts a little odd. I hate over-fussy shirts, and I wish Sunderland would go back to black socks, but I'm not sure there are any shirts I really love. I was talking to a friend about this on the way to the Championship play-off final, looking at the masses of red-and-white all around while we were both wearing very neutral check shirts. We wondered whether it's because in our formative years of going to games, away games especially, in the late 80s and early 90s, it was useful to be able to blend into the background if any violence kicked off.
But I suppose if pressed, I always quite liked the simple Adidas, early 80s, plain colour with three stripes along the sleeves – the pale-blue West Germany goalkeeper's top in particular.
It's probably my age – I've watched football for nearly 70 years – but I really miss old-fashioned wingers, playing on the 'correct' wing, beating their defender on the outside and providing crosses for their fellow attackers. The case for inverted wingers seems to be that coming 'inside' on to their stronger foot increases their chances of shooting and scoring. It's now de rigueur for wingers to be inverted. Does the likelihood of inverted wingers scoring goals by coming inside really compensate for the fewer effective crosses they make for their fellow attackers?
– Derek
I agree that there remains something aesthetically very pleasing about a centre-forward meeting an outswinging cross with a header – Alexander Isak's goal from Anthony Gordon's cross for Newcastle against Arsenal last season, for instance – but I suspect that ship has sailed.
Herbert Chapman was arguing that a focus on wingers crossing for forwards was inefficient 100 years ago, and most modern theory seems to agree with him. The preference now is either for wide players cutting infield – Peter Taylor was a pioneer in England, but Dennis Tueart and others did it as well – or to work the ball to the goalline for a low cutback – the classic Manchester City goal of a couple of seasons ago.
Sign up to Soccer with Jonathan Wilson
Jonathan Wilson brings expert analysis on the biggest stories from European soccer
after newsletter promotion
One of the reasons wide forwards now cut inside is the explosion in attacking full-backs, who now provide most of the width. A full-back could go inside, as say Trent Alexander-Arnold or João Cancelo do, but that is relatively rare and if the full-back is going on the outside, the wide forward has go inside to create space for him. I think there's also a recognition that forwards cutting in, often against the defender's weaker foot, is very hard to combat – hence the rise in the sort of goal Lamine Yamal seems to score every week, whipping the ball into the far corner.
Kevin Keegan was perhaps the first English player, certainly in the postwar years, to make a success of a move to a European giant. He left Liverpool in 1977 for Hamburg, where he won the league in 1978-79 and was twice named European Footballer of the Year. He also marketed himself with an eagerness unusual in English players of the time, becoming a bona fide celebrity. And, on 9 June 1979, he released his second, but by some distance his most successful single, Head Over Heels in Love.
His first single, It Ain't Easy, had been released in 1972, just a year after he'd moved to Liverpool from Scunthorpe and made very little impression. But Head Over Heels reached No 31 in the UK charts, and No 10 in Germany. And this is where those of a nervous disposition should look away. Keegan gave a preview of the song on Das Aktuelle Sport-Studio. His German seems very good, but that thought soon fades as he gets to the performance …
This is an extract from Soccer with Jonathan Wilson, a weekly look from the Guardian US at the game in Europe and beyond. Subscribe for free here. Have a question for Jonathan? Email soccerwithjw@theguardian.com, and he'll answer the best in a future edition.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Hibs striker's Scotland debut underlines challenge to nail down World Cup spot
Hibs striker's Scotland debut underlines challenge to nail down World Cup spot

Scotsman

time24 minutes ago

  • Scotsman

Hibs striker's Scotland debut underlines challenge to nail down World Cup spot

Former Fulham and Raith forward made step up from Under-21s with 12-minute cameo in Liechtenstein Sign up to our Hibs football newsletter Sign up Thank you for signing up! Did you know with a Digital Subscription to Edinburgh News, you can get unlimited access to the website including our premium content, as well as benefiting from fewer ads, loyalty rewards and much more. Learn More Sorry, there seem to be some issues. Please try again later. Submitting... A dozen minutes. Call it near enough a quarter hour, once you include time added on for fripperies at the end of a friendly of little note and limited import. Doesn't sound like much, does it? And you can certainly argue that Steve Clarke should have entrusted Kieron Bowie with a more central role, figuratively and positionally, over the course of two full fixtures made for handing out opportunities. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Still, there's always something special about a full international debut. Bowie, a player with serious ambitions to become Scotland's first-choice No. 9 in due course, will have enjoyed his late cameo in this afternoon's 4-0 scudding of lowly Liechtenstein. And he'll obviously be hoping that this is the start of a more lasting and rewarding relationship. The problem he faces, of course, is that Che Adams has just bagged a hat-trick. George Hirst also scored. Tommy Conway got on ahead of him. Leaving Bowie and young Hearts forward James Wilson to nervously eyeball each other as they wondered which bold stroke Clarke would play next … Given everything we know about the Scotland boss, a man who usually leaves room for just a single forward in his starting XI, you would have to assume that there are a lot of bodies standing between the Hibs striker and his ultimate goal. Being flung in for the final 12 minutes on the left of an improvised front three, something we'll probably NEVER see in a competitive international, suggests there's more chance of Lyndon Dykes – hamming it up for all his worth on TV coverage – reclaiming that lone attacker role when the World Cup campaign begins in earnest. This game has to be taken in isolation. A training exercise against a team who posed zero threat to Scotland. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad A palate cleanser after the grim fare of Friday night at Hampden, entirely unrelated to the serious business of a short, sharp and intense qualifying campaign just around the corner. An opportunity to go just a little bit wild before the serious business begins, right? Conservative Scotland boss Steve Clarke not prone to wild gambles The starting XI was probably as close as Clarke will ever get to taking a mad gamble with a selection. Given everything we've learned about his approach and philosophy in 67 games at the helm, did anyone really expect him to go with some all-or-nothing experiment built around youthful inexperience in fixture number 68? Forced into blooding a brand-new goalkeeper and boldly deciding that Lennon Miller deserved a first start in a midfield not exactly short on experience, the veteran gaffer did show a bit of gumption in deciding to pick not one but two strikers. Against a team ranked five places above dead last in the FIFA rankings, that hardly qualifies as a risk. And the identity of those two starting strikers, Adams and Hirst, merely underlined Clarke's aversion to pulling hare-like creatures out of dress bunnets. Again, did you expect anything else? Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad In handing Adams cap no. 39, the Scotland coaching staff were never going to learn anything new about a player who has been in this squad for over five years. Hirst may be at the other end of the scale when it comes to international experience but, having started against Iceland in Friday night's debacle of a defeat at Hampden, the only reason to stick with him was to boost his morale; that shouldn't be underestimated as a factor. Bowie, having proven himself at under-21 level AND put together some blistering form towards the end of the season, took his place on the bench. And waited. And waited. Would he get on at half-time? That wouldn't have been the worst shout, with Adams bagging two goals in the opening 26 minutes to give Clarke a perfect opportunity to make a change at the interval - without offending the senior man. But no, that was too early for a change. Hearts kid James Wilson left on bench What about when Hirst got his first international goal in the opening minutes of the second half, then? That could have been the trigger for a double change up front, giving Clarke the opportunity to give valuable international experience to a Hibs-Hearts strike duo who might – just might – be future regulars in years to come. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad But former Hibs left back Josh Doig, ex-Hearts midfielder Andy Irving, right back Nathan Patterson and then Middlesbrough forward Conway all got the nod before, eventually, the coaching staff signalled for Bowie and Rangers midfielder Connor Barron to ready themselves for action. At least, and at last, the former Raith and Fulham forward got on the park. His touches were limited, his involvement restricted to the periphery. After such a promising under-21 career, however, he's now a full international. He'll be back on club duty soon enough, either with the bulk of the squad at the end of next week or a little later as a reward for doing national service during what we're still laughably calling the close season. If the 22-year-old returns to East Mains with his confidence boosted, but also nursing a renewed determination to fight his way past the rivals competing for Scotland minutes on the road to the USA, Mexico and Canada next summer, Hibs can only reap the benefits.

Steve Clarke pays emotional tribute to Scotland right-hand man as he confirms departure after friendly win
Steve Clarke pays emotional tribute to Scotland right-hand man as he confirms departure after friendly win

Scotsman

time24 minutes ago

  • Scotsman

Steve Clarke pays emotional tribute to Scotland right-hand man as he confirms departure after friendly win

Assistant national team coach John Carver will leave the Scotland coaching staff after agreeing a permanent deal to remain in charge of Lechia Gdansk in Poland. Sign up to our daily newsletter Sign up Thank you for signing up! Did you know with a Digital Subscription to Edinburgh News, you can get unlimited access to the website including our premium content, as well as benefiting from fewer ads, loyalty rewards and much more. Learn More Sorry, there seem to be some issues. Please try again later. Submitting... Steve Clarke has revealed his assistant John Carver with leave his role as Scotland No.2 after accepting the offer of a permanent deal to remain in charge of Polish side Lechia Gdansk. The highly-regarded and popular Geordie coach has been a key part of Clarke's backroom team over the past five years, but will now return to his club duties on a full-time basis after leading Gdansk away from the relegation zone last season. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad There was speculation that Carver faced a big decision over his future involvement with the national team as a result, with club chiefs offering the 60-year-old a three-year deal. And Clarke confirmed his right-hand man will no longer be part of his coaching set-up going forward ahead of starting the 2026 World Cup qualifying campaign in September. 'I think the wave goodbye to the crowd was probably a giveaway,' Clarke said when quizzed on the Carver exit rumours after his side's 4-0 friendly win over Liechtenstein in Vaduz. 'Yeah, listen, the thing with John is when I approached him five years ago to come in and help us, I didn't think he'd be here for five years because he's such a talented coach. 'So, the fact it's taken five years for somebody to take him away from us, to offer him a full-time contract and a three-year deal is good for Scotland. Probably not good for John. As I said, he's a very talented coach and we'll miss him. We'll have to look to replace him and that will be one of my jobs over the summer.' Asked if he's got another coach to join his staff in mind, Clarke responded: 'I've got plenty of people in mind. I'll have a few conversations. But, like I say, John and I go back a long way. We first crossed paths back in 1998 at Newcastle when John was a young coach coming through and I'd moved there with Ruud Gullit. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad 'We always said that we'd work together. It took us ages to do that, but when we first worked together we didn't think John would be with us for that long because I was convinced somebody would come and take him. But we're pleased he's been here for five years and we wish him every success in Gdansk.' Former Southampton striker Che Adams bagged himself a hat-trick and George Hirst converted his first international goal as the Scots signed off their season with a comfortable win to ensure they build some positive momentum heading into the qualifiers. 'I'm happy to get on the scoresheet and help the team,' Adams stated. 'It's nice to score for Scotland, it's not happened much since I've been here. 'We knew it would be difficult, the conditions weren't great, but we were very professional and our mentality was spot on. It was important to sign off this year with the win. We're happy to put things right from the Iceland game.' Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Fellow hitman Hirst was delighted to get off the mark for his adopted country on his fourth cap. The Ipswich Town ace admitted: 'To get that first goal is massive for me, but it was a great team performance and very professional. 'It was very disappointing on Friday night, we had to look at ourselves, but the good thing in football is you always have another opportunity and today we had that chance to put things right. 'They made it difficult for us, it was a dry pitch, there were millions of excuses we could've thrown out there, but we played with the right mentality. It makes my running a little easier, sharing the workload with Che. If that's something to come moving forward then I'm not going to complain.'

Scottie Scheffler heavily backed favorite to begin U.S. Open week
Scottie Scheffler heavily backed favorite to begin U.S. Open week

Reuters

time26 minutes ago

  • Reuters

Scottie Scheffler heavily backed favorite to begin U.S. Open week

June 9 - Scottie Scheffler has won three of his past four starts, including the most recent major at the PGA Championship, so it's little surprise that he began U.S. Open week as the heavy pre-tournament favorite. Scheffler's short odds aren't dissuading the public so far. The No. 1-ranked player in the world is being offered at +275 at DraftKings, where he leads the field with 31 percent of the total bets and 33 percent of the money backing Scheffler to claim his first U.S. Open title this week. The next closest is two-time U.S. Open winner and defending champion Bryson DeChambeau, who has drawn 14 and 22 percent of the action, respectively, at +900. Interestingly, world No. 2 Rory McIlroy has received modest support with only 3 percent of the total bets and money while sporting the second shortest odds at +850. McIlroy won't his first Masters in April but missed the cut at the RBC Canadian Open after posting a T47 at the PGA Championship. The story has been largely similar at BetMGM, where Scheffler is the book's biggest liability as he leads the way with 31.3 percent of the money backing him while he odds have shortened from +500 to +275. DeChambeau is the second-biggest liability thus far, drawing 16.7 percent of the money and seeing his odds shift from +1400 to +750. However, McIlroy remains firmly in the picture at BetMGM. He is the third-biggest liability, having been backed by 8.4 percent of the money at +1200. The Northern Irishman opened at +900. Also seeing his odds lengthen is Xander Schauffele, who has struggled to regain the form that saw him claim a pair of majors last year. He opened at +1100 to win the U.S. Open but was sitting at +2200 by Monday. Perhaps no player has seen a bigger shift than Brooks Koepka, the two-time U.S. Open champ who opened at +1800. Having failed to win on the LIV Golf tour this year while missing the cut at the Masters and PGA Championship, Koepka's odds at BetMGM have ballooned to +6600. Another popular choice at both books has been young Swedish star Ludvig Aberg. He has yet to win a major, although he did finish second at last year's Masters and T12 at the U.S. Open. Aberg, who has posted a part of top-20s since missing the cut at the PGA, has drawn 4 percent of the total bets and money at +3500 at DraftKings. He also sports somewhat longshot odds at +2500 at BetMGM, where Aberg has been backed by 5.6 and 3.9 percent of the action, respectively, since opening at +1600. --Field Level Media

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store