
From ‘Infinite Jest' to Oprah's Book Club, 1996 changed the (literary) world
Computers were ugly hulking gray or beige boxes then, taking up so much desk space. In 1996 I worked at Disney Interactive, my Windows 95 operating system skinned with an 'X-Files' theme; when I arrived early, the TV show's eerie chimes echoed across the empty office. Work was a lot like now, doing things using the computer and answering and sending emails. Important people flexed by doing none of that — they showed off by not having computers on their desks at all. At the end of the day, those of us with computers waited for them to shut down, slowly, before leaving. And then work was behind you.
Maybe you'd meet somebody out, remotely checking the answering machine plugged into your landline for messages. Maybe you'd go home to make dinner and catch the news on TV or NPR. Then, if you were into computers, you might turn on the one you had at home and dial in to the baby internet via modem and read funny things or post on message boards, waiting, always waiting, for the pages to load, line by line.
Did we have more time to read books then, or does it just seem that way? More time to consume news on a slower timetable, for sure. 1996 was an election year; Bill Clinton was running for his second term as president, and much of the conversation was dominated by political books. Colin Powell had fanned the flames about a possible run with his 1995 memoir, 'My American Journey,' putting him on bestseller lists and the 1996 interview circuit. 'There were some days I wished I had never started it,' he told C-SPAN, the universal writer's lament. But he didn't join the race.
That was just the preamble. The scores of others that followed included Newt Gingrich's 'To Renew America' and, from Republican nominee Bob Dole, 'Unlimited Partners,' written with his wife, Elizabeth. 'Jesse: The Life and Pilgrimage' by Marshall Frady burnished the reputation of Jesse Jackson, a potential Democratic challenger who decided not to run.
A popular incumbent, Clinton published a book to accompany his campaign, 'Between Hope and History: Meeting America's Challenges for the 21st Century.' He wasn't the only one writing at the White House; Hillary Clinton released 'It Takes a Village,' which topped bestseller lists.
The first couple also had bestselling detractors. 'Blood Sport: The President and His Adversaries' by James B. Stewart was a salacious Whitewater exposé, while former FBI agent Gary Aldrich's 'Unlimited Access' was a vitriolic take on the Clintons' failings in the White House.
But the biggest political book of them all was a novel. Technically. Roman-à-clef 'Primary Colors' hit shelves in January, clearly based on Clinton's 1992 presidential campaign. It was authored by 'Anonymous' — and the question of who might have written it set off a feeding frenzy of speculation. The book topped bestseller lists and the Anonymous pursuit stayed in the headlines for months. People were obsessed. In February, New York Magazine published a cover story saying Newsweek columnist and CBS News contributor Joe Klein was the author, but he denied it so vehemently that speculation about others continued for months. In July, the Washington Post reported that, based on a handwriting analysis, it believed it was Klein after all. He called a press conference to admit it, facing down a crew of angry journalists. But his publisher was delighted, saying, ''Primary Colors' has become once again a media event.'
While all this political reading was in overdrive, people were still buying other books. The usual suspects (Michael Crichton, John le Carré and Tom Clancy) all published bestselling thrillers in 1996. Dean Koontz hit the bestseller list with 'Ticktock,' a horror-comedy. That year, Danielle Steel published not one but two bestselling books. Terry McMillan scored a second bestseller with 'How Stella Got Her Groove Back,' just as the film adaptation of her first, 'Waiting to Exhale,' hit movie screens. Bestselling mysteries came from Scott Turow and Sue Grafton, whose 'M Is for Malice' marked the midpoint of her alphabet series.
It's remarkable that many of these authors are still writing, still hitting bestseller lists, 30 years later. Even those who have died are still publishing — Le Carré's son Nick Harkaway, a novelist in his own right, continued his father's George Smiley legacy with a new novel last year. Crichton, who died in 2008, has published four books posthumously, most often with credited co-authors. And although Clancy died in 2013, the Tom Clancy brand has continued, with his name prominently displayed on the book or two a year that have been published ever since.
One of the reasons these authors have such staying power may be the way the market was shaped in 1996. If you wanted to buy a book, it was easy to get to one of five huge national chain stores: B. Dalton, Barnes & Noble, Crown Books, Waldenbooks and Borders Books & Music. Their market dominance was so complete that publishing business watchers cautioned that they might have too much power. And if you were a real book lover in Los Angeles, you'd go to one of the independents — Vroman's, Skylight (which opened that fall, after Chatterton's closure in 1994) and Book Soup (albeit with different ownership) are still selling books today. 1996 bookstores that are no longer with us include Dutton's, Eso Won, A Different Light, Sisterhood Bookstore, Brentano's, Village Books, the Bohdi Tree and Midnight Special.
The extinction event looming on the horizon was Amazon, of course, which launched its website in 1995 and would grab the public's attention in 1997 with its wildly successful initial public offering. In 1996, many retailers remained skeptical of online shopping and didn't have full-fledged websites; customers were concerned about the security of online purchases. While that was soon to change, it meant that for books especially, 1996 was an eddy of calm before the meteor storm arrived.
And first, a dazzling ship arrived: Oprah's Book Club. Announced in September, Oprah Winfrey had just two book-club sessions in 1996, but they were a genuine indicator of her power. After being selected by Oprah, Jacquelyn Mitchard's 'The Deep End of the Ocean' reached bestseller lists months after its debut. Toni Morrison's 'Song of Solomon,' published 19 years earlier, got a new paperback release that was an overnight bestseller. 'I want to get the country reading,' the popular television host said, and she did. In later years, her choices would become instant bestsellers. Some literary types worried that TV and books were somehow at odds, that her tastes weren't highbrow enough.
But readers who wanted highbrow had other places to turn. Wisława Szymborska, the Polish poet, won the 1996 Nobel Prize in literature 'for poetry that with ironic precision allows the historical and biological context to come to light in fragments of human reality.'
The Pulitzer Prize for poetry went to Jorie Graham for her collection 'The Dream of the Unified Field.' The Times' Jack Miles won the Pulitzer in biography for his weighty book 'GOD: A Biography.'
On the fiction side, the winner of the Pulitzer was Richard Ford for 'Independence Day.' The winner of the National Book Award was Andrea Barrett's 'Ship Fever and Other Stories,' beating out finalists 'Martin Dressler: The Tale of an American Dreamer' by Steven Millhauser, 'Atticus' by Ron Hansen, 'The Giant's House' by Elizabeth McCracken and 'The River Beyond the World' by Janet Peery.
Puzzlingly absent from those lists was what we can now see was one of the most important novels of 1996. 'Infinite Jest' by David Foster Wallace is a work of generational genius. The novel is more than 1,000 pages long, funny and brilliant; despite its annoying fanboys, the book's reputation gets ever brighter. 'David Foster Wallace's 1996 opus now looks like the central American novel of the past thirty years, a dense star for lesser work to orbit,' Chad Harbach wrote in n+1 in 2004.
Though some critics at the time were exasperated by having to read such a big, wordy book, The Times selected it as one of the best books of the year. Reviewer David Kipen celebrated Wallace's 'stupendously high-toned vocabulary and gleeful low-comedy diction, coupled with a sense of syntax so elongated that he can seem to go for days without surfacing.'
At the time, Wallace was living and teaching in Illinois, and instead of finding an agent in New York, he'd connected with Bonnie Nadell in Los Angeles. That westward shift was one of those quiet things that happened in 1996 whose repercussions would be felt in unexpected ways far into the future.
Like the first L.A. Times Festival of Books.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Fox News
25 minutes ago
- Fox News
Cuomo hit by fellow Dems for dodging questions about sexual harassment during time as NY governor
Andrew Cuomo dodged questions throughout Wednesday evening's New York City mayoral debate regarding sexual harassment allegations against him, which the former New York governor insisted were false. "Every woman watching tonight should listen right now," said Michael Blake, a former state assemblyman from the Bronx who is running against Cuomo. "Andrew Cuomo would not respond when had a chance about sexual harassment – every woman watching tonight – he was just given a chance to actually address the clear claims that were stated, and he ignored it." Cuomo was accused of multiple incidents of sexual harassment that ultimately led to his resignation as governor in 2021. A subsequent report from New York Attorney General Letitia James confirmed Cuomo "sexually harassed multiple women from 2013 through 2020," while in January 2024, the U.S. Department of Justice announced it had reached a nearly $500,000 settlement with Cuomo's executive office over one of the claims. However, no criminal charges were ever filed against Cuomo, with some district attorneys citing insufficient evidence. "The people who don't feel safe are young women, mothers and grandmothers around Andrew Cuomo," Blake added in his criticism of Cuomo during the Wednesday night debate. "That's the greatest threat to public safety in New York City." Cuomo was given multiple opportunities to address the allegations, but he frequently dodged questions on the matter by pivoting to other issues, like public safety. However, Cuomo's opponents and the moderators would not let him get away without engaging with the question. "Mr. Cuomo. I'm sorry. I'm sure that people at home must be wondering about your answer to this question, because we speak to voters throughout the city and quite a few of them will say, I'm not sure exactly what happened with those sexual harassment cases," one of the moderators told Cuomo amid questions about whether the candidates had any regrets regarding their past political tenures. "What do you say to voters now looking ahead to your potential mayoralty? Are you doing anything differently? And why should they believe that that same situation won't happen again?" In response, Cuomo addressed the question, but insisted the allegations against him were "political" and "false." "Let's just make sure we have the facts," Cuomo shot back. "A report was done four years ago making certain allegations. I said at the time, that it was political and it was false. Five district attorneys, Democratic, Republican, short, tall, looked at it all across the state, found absolutely nothing. One case has been resolved. I was dropped from that case. I said at the time that if I offended anyone, it was unintentional. But I apologize."


Politico
35 minutes ago
- Politico
Jolly takes the plunge into wide open field
BREAKING LAST NIGHT — 'President Donald Trump on Wednesday issued a sweeping new travel ban for people from 19 countries, citing national security risks,' reports POLITICO's Myah Ward. The ban fully restricts people from Haiti and partially restricts entry for nationals of Cuba and Venezuela. Good morning and welcome to Thursday. Zero Democrats in statewide office. An electoral shortfall of 1.3 million voters. The home for much of President DONALD TRUMP's staff and his 'Winter White House.' The testing ground for MAGA. It's how Florida looks for Democrats. And running for Florida governor in that kind of environment, where fundraising is sputtering and the party has immense hurdles to overcome? Seemingly no one would rush to take that on. Except for DAVID JOLLY. The former Republican congressman, who was a politically independent voter since 2018 and registered as a Democrat in April, has officially filed to run for governor. The biggest challenger on the Republican side so far is Trump-endorsed Rep. BYRON DONALDS. But the Democratic field has been full of only crickets thus far. Those who openly expressed interest in running a year ago have since stepped back, underscoring just how bleak the landscape appears after Trump won Florida by 13 points in 2024. 'People who might have been very strong candidates would want to see the party infrastructure build up and be a better atmosphere to run,' said state Sen. TINA POLSKY (D-Boca Raton). 'But then it kind of takes someone maybe a little bit different, a little bit out of the norm — like David Jolly is — to upend the system. If anyone's going to do it, I think he has a better chance than a run-of-the-mill Democrat.' A lot could change ahead of the August 2026 primary. But the dearth of interest — or of candidates even at the very least floating trial balloons to gauge reaction — stands in contrast to what's happening at the national level, where Democratic hopefuls are already making moves to signal their 2028 presidential interest. The last time Florida had an open seat for governor, in 2018, seven Democrats competed for the nomination. But Jolly could help unify the party with an easy path to the nomination. He told Playbook in an interview that he's hoping the 2026 cycle will be a 'change election' in which voters are driven to outside-the-norm candidates given Trump's policies and how unaffordable Florida has become under GOP leadership. He said he's going to try to bring together not just Democrats but unaffiliated voters and Republicans. 'The ones we've spoken to have either indicated they're not running or they'll support us, either privately or publicly,' Jolly told Playbook of top Florida Democrats. While he does anticipate a primary, he added: 'What I know is we have to unify this primary early if we want to win next November.' Of course, the primary would have been contested early if state Sen. JASON PIZZO had remained a Democrat. Now, they'll just be delaying a showdown. Pizzo plans to run as an independent in a move that has many Democrats concerned he'll serve as a spoiler and deliver the governor's mansion to Republicans. But Jolly and Pizzo have had a chance to talk, and it seems there's no bad blood there. While Jolly didn't disclose details of the conversation, he said he respected 'anyone who follows their convictions,' and that he thinks Pizzo is 'doing what he believes he can do to change Florida.' 'You won't hear me say an ill word about Jason Pizzo,' Jolly said. 'I respect his decision.' Reached by text, Pizzo called Jolly 'bright' and said their conversation went well. 'I commend him for the endeavor,' he said, 'and wish him well.' WHERE'S RON? Gov. DeSantis will speak at the Florida Professional Firefighters convention in Palm Beach Gardens at 9:45 a.m. Have a tip, story, suggestion, birthday, anniversary, new job, or any other nugget that Playbook should look at? Get in touch at: kleonard@ ... DATELINE TALLAHASSEE ... FLORIDA'S NEW EDUCATION COMMISSIONER — 'The state Board of Education on Wednesday unanimously backed Anastasios Kamoutsas, the governor's deputy chief of staff who has long played a key behind the scenes role, to lead the agency. Kamoutsas, in accepting the position, pledged to follow through on Florida's reforms on parental rights and school choice that have thrust the state into the national spotlight,' reports POLITICO's Andrew Atterbury. 'During his time with the agency, Kamoutsas, who is known as 'Stasi,' helped the state carry out policies bolstering parental rights, quashing 'wokeness' in education and battling with school districts that pushed pandemic student masking.' TIME IS TICKING — 'State lawmakers forged through a second day of Florida budget negotiations Wednesday, reaching accords on several significant items including how much money they will steer into a program designed to help homeowners hurricane-proof their homes,' report POLITICO's Gary Fineout and Bruce Ritchie. 'Lawmakers are racing to wrap up their budget work in time for a mid-June vote — about two weeks before the end of the fiscal year. The two sides agreed to spend half of the $200 million proposed by Senate President Ben Albritton, a citrus farmer from Wauchula, to boost the state's ailing citrus industry. That includes $70 million for replacement trees, less than the $125 million he had proposed.' STATE PARK SLASHES — 'Florida's renowned state parks would suffer under state House and Senate proposals for the 2025-26 state budget, supporters of the public lands said this week,' reports POLITICO's Bruce Ritchie. 'Budget negotiators from both chambers met publicly Tuesday for the first time on a 2025-26 state budget. The House proposal that passed in April would slash 25 vacant positions in the Florida Park Service as part of a workforce reduction across state government.' RESERVOIR CLAW BACK — 'State House and Senate budget negotiators agreed this week to revert $400 million in spending approved last year for a controversial Central Florida reservoir to appropriations for the coming year,' reports POLITICO's Bruce Ritchie. 'The two sides also got closer on slashing funding from the 2023 state budget for the Florida Wildlife Corridor, a priority of then-Senate President Kathleen Passidomo (R-Naples).' NEW LIFE FOR AP AND IB — 'The Florida Legislature's latest budget proposal could relieve concerns of local schools that feared devastating funding losses were coming for top programs like Advanced Placement and International Baccalaureate,' reports POLITICO's Andrew Atterbury. 'A Tuesday offer by the state Senate scraps a previous plan that would have reduced by half the bonus funding levels schools receive for a list of popular programs, replacing the idea with a new section of the budget for these costs. Lawmakers say this proposed change would ensure schools can still score coveted extra cash for AP, IB, Advanced International Certificate of Education, dual enrollment and early graduation, while giving the state a clearer picture of where the money is going.' STILL FAR APART — 'The state House and Senate made some progress Wednesday in hammering out the state health care budget for next year, but the two chambers' proposals are still more 2,000 vacant agency jobs apart when it comes to possible cuts,' reports POLITICO's Arek Sarkissian. 'The latest budget offer presented to the Senate by House Health Care Budget Subcommittee Chair Alex Andrade (R-Pensacola) on Wednesday afternoon called for cuts of more than 2,900 vacant jobs, still well over 2,000 more than the 454 cuts proposed by the Senate. Andrade had asked the health care agencies facing the proposed job cuts to justify why those positions should exist. None of the agencies offered a justification, and the state Department of Children and Families, which could lose 802 vacant jobs under the latest House offer, did not respond.' NO HOPE FOR HOPE? — State Rep. ALEX ANDRADE (R-Pensacola) proposed cutting millions of dollars from Hope Florida's state funding early on in the dedicated two-week budget conference which started on Tuesday, Alexandra Glorioso and Lawrence Mower of the Miami Herald report. Andrade spent a good deal of the session investigating Hope Florida, the state program spearheaded by Florida first lady CASEY DESANTIS intended to gradually get Floridians off government assistance. The cuts would affect 20 Hope navigator positions who work on a helpline that connects Floridians in need to nongovernment assistance. MUSEUM DISCONNECT — 'The House is failing to go along with proposed funding for several Holocaust museum projects across the state,' reports Gabrielle Russon of Florida Politics. 'St. Petersburg's Florida Holocaust Museum was chosen to hold a permanent exhibit to preserve the legacy of Elie Wiesel, a Holocaust survivor who later won the Nobel Peace Prize. The Senate is proposing to fund the exhibit with $850,000 while the House doesn't want to fund it at all.' LAND ON CABINET AGENDA — The governor and Cabinet next week will consider buying 75,000 acres of conservation easements in rural north central Florida. The state would pay $93.6 million to Weyerhaeuser Forest Holdings, Inc. for an easement over 61,389 acres in Baker and Union Counties. And the state would pay Blackbottom Holdings LLC $24.3 million for an easement over 14,743 acres in Baker and Bradford counties. The Tampa Bay Times reported that the Cabinet also will consider a proposal by Cabot Citrus Farms, a golf course developer, to sell 340 acres in Hernando County near where it sought to acquire state forest land in a controversial 2024 trade deal that was recently scrapped. — Bruce Ritchie BALLOT INITIATIVE LATEST — 'A federal judge on Wednesday placed a temporary halt on part of a new law tightening Florida's control over ballot initiatives. But he refused to press pause on the entire measure,' reports POLITICO's Arek Sarkissian. 'A group called Florida Decides Health Care filed a lawsuit in Tallahassee federal court about a month ago challenging a new state law. The measure has been heralded by DeSantis and other state GOP leaders as the solution to fraud allegations made by state elections officials as campaigns gathered enough voter-signed petitions to qualify for the ballot. The new restrictions also come with hefty penalties and tight deadlines critics believe were designed to make the state's citizen-led initiative process unaffordable for most groups.' TALLAHASSEE ICE RAID — The families of more than 100 ICE detainees say they are struggling to locate their loved ones, Ana Goñi-Lessan and Valentina Palm of USA Today Network — Florida. The detainees, construction workers who were arrested at their job site, were taken into custody by ICE during the largest immigration raid in Florida this year. Some remain in Florida, some were sent to El Paso, Texas, and some are already in Mexico less than a week after being detained. Family members' questions about the whereabouts of some of the detainees have been unanswered since May 29. — 'Florida quickly appeals injunction against law aimed at keeping kids off social media,' reports Jim Saunders of News Service of Florida. — 'Florida's National Guard will soon leave state prisons,' reports Romy Ellenbogen of the Tampa Bay Times. PENINSULA AND BEYOND NO IMMIGRATION ENFORCEMENT — The Jacksonville Sheriff's Office says it is following city attorneys' legal advice by not enforcing the city's two-month-old immigration enforcement law which serves to punish people who enter Jacksonville while they are in the country illegally, reports David Bauerlein of the Florida Times-Union. City Councilor KEVIN CARRICO, who introduced the legislation, said the lack of enforcement undermined the will of City Council and the state Legislature by siding with 'open-border politics.' — 'Hialeah's $45,000 farewell to Bovo: When public money pays for private parties,' by Verónica Egui Brito of the Miami Herald. — 'It's not just his wife. Lee County undersheriff has another relative on the payroll,' by Bob Norman of the Florida Trident. TRUMPLANDIA AND THE SWAMP FREE LAND FOR PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY — 'Of the locations considered, FAU in Boca Raton, Fla., emerged as the preferred site because of its proximity to Mar-a-Lago, a private Trump club,' report The Wall Street Journal's Meridith McGraw, Josh Dawsey and Annie Linskey. 'A person familiar with the negotiations said that Trump's team is nearing a deal with FAU — which has offered a 100-year lease at no cost — and that Trump expressed interest in the university during a meeting with lawyers at Mar-a-Lago earlier this year.' ODDS, ENDS AND FLORIDA MEN BIRTHDAYS: Former Chief Financial Officer and gubernatorial candidate Alex Sink, founder of Ruth's List … former State Rep. Seth McKeel … Heidi Otway, president and partner at SalterMitchell PR. CORRECTION: Wednesday's newsletter incorrectly stated that the Stanley Cup finals began in Florida on Wednesday. The first game was in Edmonton.
Yahoo
39 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Conflicted Tennessee Senate overwhelmingly passed business tax refund
Sen. Shane Reeves, R-Murfreesboro, received a $1 million grant from the Tennessee Department of Economic and Community Development to start a business which has since received a tax rebate from the state. (Photo: John Partipilo/Tennessee Lookout) Thirteen of Tennessee's 33 senators declared a conflict of interest before voting on a $1.9 billion business tax break in 2024, including one whose companies reaped the benefits of the cut and a prior state grant. Two years before winning the seat in 2018, Republican Sen. Shane Reeves of Murfreesboro received a million-dollar FastTrack grant from the state Department of Economic and Community Development when he opened TwelveStone Health Partners in Rutherford County in 2016. The company invested nearly $15 million to create 200 jobs for the packaged medication, healthcare services and medication equipment company. A pharmacist by trade, Reeves started the business after he and his former business partner, Rick Sain, sold Reeves-Sain Drugstore and EnTrustRx, a specialty pharmacy business, to Fred's Inc. for $66 million. TwelveStone has expanded several times over nine years, opening infusion centers in multiple locations, including Virginia and Georgia. Senators declaring a conflict of interest with tax rebate bill: Paul Bailey, R-Sparta Ferrell Haile, R-Gallatin Joey Hensley, R-Hohenwald Jack Johnson, R-Franklin Adam Lowe, R-Calhoun Jon Lundberg, R-Bristol (no longer in office) Bill Powers, R-Clarksville Kerry Roberts, R-Springfield Paul Rose, R-Covington John Stevens, R-Huntingdon Page Walley, R-Savannah Bo Watson, R-Hixson Dawn White, R-Murfreesboro Ken Yager, R-Kingston Nearly a decade later, TwelveStone Health Partners and TwelveStone Holdings are two of 16,000 Tennessee businesses receiving a franchise tax refund of more than $10,000 after Republican lawmakers pushed the measure backed by Gov. Bill Lee through the legislature last year. Reeves told the Lookout this week that TwelveStone met all requirements for receiving the 2016 grant and now employs nearly 300 people. Asked whether he's concerned about the appearance of double-dipping, Reeves described himself as a 'part-time citizen legislator' the first four months of the year and chief executive officer of TwelveStone the rest of the time. 'My job is to do what's best for our company. I would never expect any more or less for my business than anyone else's,' Reeves said in a text statement. Chairman of the Senate Energy, Agriculture and Natural Resources Committee, Reeves said he is 'comfortable' with the reporting ranges in the refund law, calling them a 'fair compromise' for transparency. Listings on the state Department of Revenue website show categories for companies receiving refunds up to $750, between $750 and $10,000 and more than $10,000. The lists totaling 60,000 companies were posted May 31 and are to remain available to the public for 30 days. Senators were reluctant to publicize any of the companies when they took up the bill last year, passing it 25-6, with former Sen. Art Swann of Maryville the only Republican to vote in opposition. Two members did not vote. But the House demanded some form of transparency, though Democrats and public records advocates say the ranges aren't specific enough considering the amount of money rebated to some of the world's largest companies, including FedEx and 13 subsidiaries, Ford Motor Co. and AT&T. The House passed the measure 69-23, largely along party lines. The Tennessee Senate uses a policy called Rule 13 as part of its code of ethics that allows senators to declare a conflict of interest, without giving details, but allowing them to vote based on their conscience and obligation to constituents. The House has no rule requiring members to state a conflict of interest before votes that could affect them or their businesses financially. In addition to Reeves, Democratic Sen. Jeff Yarbro of Nashville, who voted against the tax cut and refund, declared Rule 13 before last year's vote. World's top businesses, Lee Company receive biggest Tennessee tax rebates Yarbro told the Lookout this week he pulled out of the partnership track at Bass, Berry & Sims law firm so he wouldn't be part of its financial decisions. 'I'm not opposed to any business or citizen taking a refund from the government. Who wouldn't? If I qualified for a refund, I'd take it. But I still think it's bad public policy,' Yarbro said in a statement to the Lookout. Yarbro added that, while he felt the bill ran contrary to public interest, he understood it would benefit many businesses in his Senate district, including the firm where he works, thus he declared the potential conflict of interest before the vote. Yarbro and state Rep. John Ray Clemmons of Nashville also proposed a bill they said would enable the state's franchise tax law to withstand constitutional muster without making rebates. Republican leaders declined to consider it. When the matter arose last year, the Department of Revenue told lawmakers it received a challenge to the state's franchise tax on business property, leading most to say the tax cut and refund was justified in averting an expensive legal fight. Attorney General Jonathan Skrmetti also advised lawmakers to avoid litigation. Other key legislators such as House Majority Leader William Lamberth of Portland said the reductions were simply good tax policy and not necessarily based on concern about a legal threat. No lawsuit was filed against the state in advance of the vote. Republican Sen. Brent Taylor, former owner of Brentwood Funeral Services in Shelby County, voted for the measure last year after declaring Rule 13 but didn't apply for the tax refund. 'I just didn't think it was appropriate for me to have voted for the franchise tax cut and then go out and benefit from it, because I knew I'd have reporters … calling and wanting to know if I thought it was appropriate to take the refund and also vote for it,' Taylor said.