EPUT: Neglect at mental health unit led to death of Elise
Neglect at a mental health unit contributed to the death of a "happy and outgoing" 16-year-old, an inquest jury has heard.Elise Sebastian, from Southminster near Maldon, Essex, was found unresponsive in her bedroom at the St Aubyn Centre in Colchester, in April 2021.The teenager was supposed to have been receiving one-to-one care but, the inquest heard, an infrared alert system - which warned staff if she had been in her bathroom for too long - was muted, and she had been left alone for 28 minutes.An inquest jury at Chelmsford Coroner's Court unanimously agreed that Elise's death could have been prevented if it were not for multiple failures in her care.
The St Aubyn Centre, described in the hearing as "chaotic", is run by the Essex Partnership University NHS Foundation Trust (EPUT), currently the subject of an ongoing public inquiry.Pravin Fernando, representing EPUT, admitted that Elise's room should have been locked to prevent the teenager entering alone, adding: "The trust accepts that these failings were causative of her death."
The inquest heard Elise had secured a place at Writtle College to work with animals and her parents described her as a "happy, outgoing, funny little girl".She had been diagnosed with autism and her parents has become increasingly concerned about her anxiety and depression.On 4 March 2021, after she had self-harmed a number of times, she was admitted for the second time to a ward at the unit.
'Poor Wi-fi'
Essex area coroner Sonia Hayes heard how Elise had asked to go to the toilet, and although some doors may have been left open, others needed a staff swipe card to let her through.The ward had introduced an infrared monitoring system two months earlier as part of a trial, to reduce the risk of patients self-harming in isolated areas.Handheld monitoring tablets were not working because of poor Wi-fi, and the unit's clinical lead, Brian O'Donnell, did not think having someone allocated to monitoring the alerts on the main computer would be a "good use of their time".
During the inquest, expert witness Prof Jasmeet Soar said that when Elise was found, she had been in cardiac arrest for nine minutes.He said there had been a four to five minute delay in staff using an oxygen mask, and a defibrillator took seven minutes for staff to use, instead of the three minute maximum mentioned in guidelines."Someone should have got the defibrillator and started it earlier," he added.Prof Soar said the defibrillator also did not appear to have been used properly, from the readings he obtained, and had been switched on and off.He said: "Some of the delays could have been avoided if staff would have known how to use the equipment."
The inquest also heard how the majority of staff in the unit were bank and agency workers who would not have known the children well.Ms Hayes said she heard the ward "was clearly short staffed" and described how medical records appeared to be incomplete at times.Mr O'Donnell said he had "constantly" raised concerns about staffing numbers with senior management, adding: "Our budget would always be overspent - my argument was that we were underfunded."The inquest heard how observations should have a therapeutic interaction but some thought that was impossible to achieve.Consultant child and adolescent psychiatrist Dr Malcolm Bourne also told the hearing that "staff needed support to deal with children who were challenging and that autism could make depression more difficult to treat".
Shortly after Elise's death, the ward at the St Aubyn Centre was closed to new admissions by the Care Quality Commission.The CQC report found understaffing was a "significant concern" made worse by managers not ensuring staff had the appropriate skills and experience to look after vulnerable patients.
'Deepest condolences'
The jury foreman told the inquest there were two main factors that may have caused the teenager's death.The first was "poorly administered observations due to poor staffing levels and falsified information on observation forms".He said the second was "Elise being able to gain access into her room and her observation level in an isolated area not being considered", which the jury believed had directly led to Elise's death.
The coroner said she would write a prevention of future death report (PFDR) which would recommend changes to make sure failures were not repeated.Paul Scott, chief executive of EPUT, said: "I want to say sorry to Elise's family and to everyone who loved her that she did not receive the care she deserved, and I offer my deepest condolences."
Follow Essex news on BBC Sounds, Facebook, Instagram and X.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BBC News
an hour ago
- BBC News
The World Tonight Will voters feel better off from Chancellor's spending plans?
What would you do with a trillion pounds of public money over the next four years? The Chancellor says "renewing Britain" is at the heart of her plans. So when will voters start to feel better off? We ask a Treasury Minister. Also on the programme: After the US Ambassador to Israel told us that Muslim countries should give up their land to create a Palestinian state - we get reaction from a senior Palestinian official. And one of the most influential figures in the history of pop music, Brian Wilson - the creative genius behind the Beach Boys - has died. The veteran DJ Bob Harris - who knew him for more than five decades - pays tribute.
BBC News
an hour ago
- BBC News
Aukus: US to review submarine pact as part of 'America First' agenda
The US has launched a review of its multi-billion dollar submarine deal with the UK and Australia, saying the security pact must fit its "America First" the trilateral pact, widely seen as a response to the growing power of China, Australia is to get its first nuclear-powered subs from the US, before the allies create a new fleet by sharing cutting-edge Australia and the UK - which did its own review last year - have sought to play down news of the US probe, saying it is natural for a new administration to move comes as Australia faces pressure from the White House to lift its military spending, from 2% to 3.5% of GDP, a push so far resisted by Canberra. The agreement - worth £176bn ($239bn; A$368bn) - was signed in 2021, when all three countries involved had different leaders."The department is reviewing Aukus as part of ensuring that this initiative of the previous administration is aligned with the President's America First agenda," a US defence official told the BBC."As [US Defense] Secretary [Pete] Hegseth has made clear, this means ensuring the highest readiness of our servicemembers, that allies step up fully to do their part for collective defense, and that the defense industrial base is meeting our needs."The review will be headed up Elbridge Colby, who has previously been critical of Aukus, in a speech last year questioning why the US would give away "this crown jewel asset when we most need it".Defence Minister Richard Marles, speaking to local Australian media on Thursday morning local time, said he was optimistic the deal would continue. "I'm very confident this is going to happen," he told ABC Radio Melbourne."You just need to look at the map to understand that Australia absolutely needs to have a long-range submarine capability."Some in Australia have been lobbying for the country to develop a more independent defence strategy, but Marles said it was important to "stick to a plan" - a reference to the previous government's controversial cancellation of a submarine deal with France in favour of Australian government spokesperson told the BBC it was "natural" that the new administration would "examine" the agreement, adding the UK had also recently finished a review of the security pact between the long-standing allies. There is "clear and consistent" support for the deal across the "full political spectrum" in the US, they said, adding Australia looked forward to "continuing our close cooperation with the Trump Administration on this historic project".A UK defence spokesperson told the BBC it was "understandable" for a new administration to look at the deal, "just as the UK did last year". Aukus is a "landmark security and defence partnership with two of our closest allies", the spokesperson said, and "one of the most strategically important partnerships in decades, supporting peace and security in the Indo-Pacific and Euro-Atlantic".
Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
PETER HITCHENS: The private school pupils refused NHS care show we're becoming a People's Republic by stealth - ruled by blank-eyed bureaucrats
We are becoming a People's Republic by stealth. The warnings are increasingly urgent, but is anyone listening? Last weekend The Mail on Sunday reported a deeply disturbing fact. An NHS bureaucrat had refused therapy to a young boy, saying, 'We are unable to see this child as we do not provide a service to school-age children who attend an independent school. We are only commissioned to provide a service to the mainstream schools.'
