EPUT: Neglect at mental health unit led to death of Elise
Neglect at a mental health unit contributed to the death of a "happy and outgoing" 16-year-old, an inquest jury has heard.Elise Sebastian, from Southminster near Maldon, Essex, was found unresponsive in her bedroom at the St Aubyn Centre in Colchester, in April 2021.The teenager was supposed to have been receiving one-to-one care but, the inquest heard, an infrared alert system - which warned staff if she had been in her bathroom for too long - was muted, and she had been left alone for 28 minutes.An inquest jury at Chelmsford Coroner's Court unanimously agreed that Elise's death could have been prevented if it were not for multiple failures in her care.
The St Aubyn Centre, described in the hearing as "chaotic", is run by the Essex Partnership University NHS Foundation Trust (EPUT), currently the subject of an ongoing public inquiry.Pravin Fernando, representing EPUT, admitted that Elise's room should have been locked to prevent the teenager entering alone, adding: "The trust accepts that these failings were causative of her death."
The inquest heard Elise had secured a place at Writtle College to work with animals and her parents described her as a "happy, outgoing, funny little girl".She had been diagnosed with autism and her parents has become increasingly concerned about her anxiety and depression.On 4 March 2021, after she had self-harmed a number of times, she was admitted for the second time to a ward at the unit.
'Poor Wi-fi'
Essex area coroner Sonia Hayes heard how Elise had asked to go to the toilet, and although some doors may have been left open, others needed a staff swipe card to let her through.The ward had introduced an infrared monitoring system two months earlier as part of a trial, to reduce the risk of patients self-harming in isolated areas.Handheld monitoring tablets were not working because of poor Wi-fi, and the unit's clinical lead, Brian O'Donnell, did not think having someone allocated to monitoring the alerts on the main computer would be a "good use of their time".
During the inquest, expert witness Prof Jasmeet Soar said that when Elise was found, she had been in cardiac arrest for nine minutes.He said there had been a four to five minute delay in staff using an oxygen mask, and a defibrillator took seven minutes for staff to use, instead of the three minute maximum mentioned in guidelines."Someone should have got the defibrillator and started it earlier," he added.Prof Soar said the defibrillator also did not appear to have been used properly, from the readings he obtained, and had been switched on and off.He said: "Some of the delays could have been avoided if staff would have known how to use the equipment."
The inquest also heard how the majority of staff in the unit were bank and agency workers who would not have known the children well.Ms Hayes said she heard the ward "was clearly short staffed" and described how medical records appeared to be incomplete at times.Mr O'Donnell said he had "constantly" raised concerns about staffing numbers with senior management, adding: "Our budget would always be overspent - my argument was that we were underfunded."The inquest heard how observations should have a therapeutic interaction but some thought that was impossible to achieve.Consultant child and adolescent psychiatrist Dr Malcolm Bourne also told the hearing that "staff needed support to deal with children who were challenging and that autism could make depression more difficult to treat".
Shortly after Elise's death, the ward at the St Aubyn Centre was closed to new admissions by the Care Quality Commission.The CQC report found understaffing was a "significant concern" made worse by managers not ensuring staff had the appropriate skills and experience to look after vulnerable patients.
'Deepest condolences'
The jury foreman told the inquest there were two main factors that may have caused the teenager's death.The first was "poorly administered observations due to poor staffing levels and falsified information on observation forms".He said the second was "Elise being able to gain access into her room and her observation level in an isolated area not being considered", which the jury believed had directly led to Elise's death.
The coroner said she would write a prevention of future death report (PFDR) which would recommend changes to make sure failures were not repeated.Paul Scott, chief executive of EPUT, said: "I want to say sorry to Elise's family and to everyone who loved her that she did not receive the care she deserved, and I offer my deepest condolences."
Follow Essex news on BBC Sounds, Facebook, Instagram and X.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BBC News
40 minutes ago
- BBC News
Ban 'no ball games' signs to get children off devices, play experts say
Play experts want to ban "no ball games" signs and protect playtime during school breaks, to reduce the time children spend on are being forced "indoors on to digital devices", according to the Raising the Nation Play Commission, whose year-long inquiry calls for an end to "anti-play culture".It warns outdoor play in England has declined by 50% in a generation because of streets dominated by traffic, fear about crime and "public spaces where young people are not welcome".The government says it is working with experts to develop a framework to improve access to activities outside of school. The report is calling for a national Play Strategy for England and has made a number of recommendations including:A national ban on "no ball games" signsUpdating planning policy to require developers to consult with children on all new developmentsGovernment guidance protecting play at break time and lunchtime in schools and banning practices like withdrawing playtime for poor behaviourOpening up school playgrounds to the community outside of school hoursRaising the digital age of consent to 16 and a ban on phones in schoolsChair of the commission, Paul Lindley, says in England "we've made it incredibly hard for children to play"."Creating truly playful communities is not just about better street design, traffic management, and reduced crime, but also about a reversal of the growing culture of intolerance towards children playing."In London, there are more than 7,000 signs limiting play for more than half a million children, according to the councils are beginning to remove signs amid concerns that children are exercising less. For Samantha and her four-year-old son Chester, who live in Blackpool, having a playground far away from traffic is vital."It's free," she says and it's somewhere her son can play without having to worry "about someone coming to tell him he can't"."A lot of children are growing up and don't have the opportunity to be able to go to other places or travel, so having somewhere close to home, that is free, is so important."More than 400 playgrounds closed in England from 2012 to 2022 and annual park budgets have fallen, the report Better Start, which helps families with young children like Chester, has been working to transform the city's less used parks and green spaces over the last ten years."It is so important for families to have safe spaces to play. Families identify with the park. They feel a sense of ownership and they feel like it belongs to them," director Clare Law explains. And there are calls for changes in schools 1995, break times in schools were around 23 minutes longer for young children than they are now, the report found. The commission wants to see playtime during breaks and lunchtime at St Ambrose Catholic Academy in Liverpool are guaranteed an hour's quality play every Tracy Moorcroft says it is a massive part of the school day."If they are building, we see them as future architects, if they're in the kitchen, could they be the next future chef? We try to link their play with aspirations for later in life."But Ms Moorcroft is less convinced about the idea of having "always-active uniforms" which have already been introduced in some says the school has "very high standards" for the uniform, as the children are being prepared for life beyond the get to wear their PE kit some days and wear wellies and coats so they can go outside regardless of the weather. General Secretary of the Association of School and College Leaders, Pepe Di'Iasio agrees that playtime has been squeezed "by the drive to improve academic outcomes", but cautioned against an "overly prescriptive approach to play" as this may impact on other areas of the Wales and Scotland have already made it a legal requirement for local authorities to ensure enough opportunities for children to commission in England is calling for a national play strategy with an annual budget of £125m, led by a minister with a responsibility for Anne Longfield from the Centre for Young Lives think tank, who worked on the report, said it should provide a "blueprint for how we can get children playing again and also tackle the scourge of addictive doom-scrolling".A government spokesperson said its Plan for Change was "setting young people up to achieve and thrive – both inside and outside the classroom", and that it is investing in grassroots sports facilities and in a programme to help turn "grey school spaces green". "From July, new rules under the Online Safety Act will require social media platforms to protect children in the UK from seeing harmful content online," the spokesperson reporting by Hayley Clarke and Rahib Khan
Glasgow Times
44 minutes ago
- Glasgow Times
Starmer and Reynolds meet US commerce secretary in push to implement trade deal
The Prime Minister dropped in on a meeting between Howard Lutnick and Business Secretary Jonathan Reynolds in Downing Street on Tuesday. Mr Lutnick was in London for talks with China on resolving the trade war between Washington and Beijing, and Mr Reynolds took the opportunity to meet him in person to push for the UK-US trade deal announced last month to be implemented as soon as possible. The meeting follows talks between the Business Secretary and US trade representative Jamieson Greer in Paris last week. Under the terms of the agreement announced by Sir Keir and Donald Trump, the US will implement import quotas that will effectively eliminate tariffs on British steel and cut the levy on vehicles to 10%. But the deal has yet to be implemented and tariffs on both steel and cars remain at 25%, although the UK has been spared the increase on steel duties to 50% that Mr Trump imposed on the rest of the world last week. In a post on social media, Mr Reynolds said he had discussed 'progress on our trade deal – including UK autos and steel' with Mr Lutnick. UK officials remain hopeful that the deal will be implemented soon, but Tuesday's meeting does not appear to have moved the issue beyond both sides agreeing the need to move quickly. Speaking in the Commons last week, Sir Keir said he was 'very confident' that tariffs would come down in line with the deal 'within a very short time'. Implementing the deal will require the UK to pass legislation, likely to involve regulations rather than a full Act of Parliament, while the US will also need to create a legal mechanism to bring steel and vehicle quotas into effect.
Powys County Times
an hour ago
- Powys County Times
Starmer and Reynolds meet US commerce secretary in push to implement trade deal
Sir Keir Starmer has met the US commerce secretary as the Government continues to push for its American trade deal to come into force. The Prime Minister dropped in on a meeting between Howard Lutnick and Business Secretary Jonathan Reynolds in Downing Street on Tuesday. Mr Lutnick was in London for talks with China on resolving the trade war between Washington and Beijing, and Mr Reynolds took the opportunity to meet him in person to push for the UK-US trade deal announced last month to be implemented as soon as possible. The meeting follows talks between the Business Secretary and US trade representative Jamieson Greer in Paris last week. Under the terms of the agreement announced by Sir Keir and Donald Trump, the US will implement import quotas that will effectively eliminate tariffs on British steel and cut the levy on vehicles to 10%. But the deal has yet to be implemented and tariffs on both steel and cars remain at 25%, although the UK has been spared the increase on steel duties to 50% that Mr Trump imposed on the rest of the world last week. In a post on social media, Mr Reynolds said he had discussed 'progress on our trade deal – including UK autos and steel' with Mr Lutnick. UK officials remain hopeful that the deal will be implemented soon, but Tuesday's meeting does not appear to have moved the issue beyond both sides agreeing the need to move quickly. Speaking in the Commons last week, Sir Keir said he was 'very confident' that tariffs would come down in line with the deal 'within a very short time'. Implementing the deal will require the UK to pass legislation, likely to involve regulations rather than a full Act of Parliament, while the US will also need to create a legal mechanism to bring steel and vehicle quotas into effect.
