Brownlow medallist Nat Fyfe benched for Fremantle's entire come-from-behind win over St Kilda
Dual Brownlow medallist Nat Fyfe has been benched for Fremantle's entire come-from-behind win over St Kilda on Sunday night, clocking up a rare appearance as an unused substitute.
The Dockers lost the lead in the third quarter before kicking four unanswered goals in the final term and then holding on for a 11.15 (81) to 9.15 (69) win at Optus Stadium.
And they did it all without Fyfe after the veteran, who is facing serious questions about his future beyond this year, sat for the full game.
Fremantle were two goals up with just under eight minutes remaining when it became clear the 33-year-old would not be called upon.
'He hasn't moved all day. I wouldn't be surprised if he's not coming on unless required (by injury),' Will Schofield said on Fox Sports.
Dockers great Matthew Pavlich described it as 'strange' before Fremantle star Jordan Clark, who had 31 disposals and a goal in the win over the Saints, defended the situation in a post-match interview.
'It's a luxury. I think that's the best place — if we don't need him, we don't need him,' he told Fox Sports.
'Fyfey's role's changed at the club now and he still adds such a great level head, experience, and when he comes on for little bursts he's still got it.
'He would've loved to get out there tonight but selfishly I don't want to put him out there and risk (injury) — I want to keep him for the back end of the year.'
The game will go down in the record books as Fyfe's fourth appearance of the season, all of which have involved the substitute role in some capacity.
He was subbed on in his first two games of the year then played three-quarters of the Dockers' win over Essendon before being pulled.
Fyfe managed just 11 disposals and one clearance, also spending periods stationed in attack to help fill the void left by Sam Switkowski (hamstring), but looked a shadow of the contested beast he once was.
Channel 7 commentator Kane Cornes cast doubt about the future of the modern-day great, who comes out of contract at the end of the season.
'There's a big decision for Fremantle. In fact, I don't think it is that big a decision,' Cornes said on The Agenda Setters last week.
'It was sad watching Nat Fyfe on Thursday night. He started as a forward, his first full game in a while. His kick-to-handball ratio is high because he doesn't trust his kicking and his kicking has absolutely deserted him.
'So champion of the game ... shouldn't have been given the two-year contract extension some time ago. We said that at the time and now I think they sit him down.
'If not today, it's got to be this week and just say, 'look, Nat, this group is young, it's dynamic, and unfortunately the role that you play, others have gone past you'.
'(Corey) Wagner's gone past you inside. Serong and Brayshaw, we know about. Hayden Young's going to come back.
'And performances like this don't do, I guess, his finish to an outstanding Hall of Fame-worthy career any justice.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
West Australian
3 hours ago
- West Australian
Kane Cornes gives thumbs up to impact of Fremantle Dockers ruck pair Luke Jackson and Sean Darcy in final term
The biggest critic of Fremantle's dual ruck policy has declared the Dockers wouldn't have come from behind to beat St Kilda on Sunday without both Luke Jackson and Sean Darcy in the team. Former Port Adelaide star and respected commentator Kane Cornes has long criticised the Dockers' decision to sign Jackson and Darcy to lucrative long term contracts. He's been adamant that Jackson should be left to play as the solo ruckman. But after watching them combine for 11 disposals, three goals, three clearances and five marks during the final quarter against the Saints, Cornes had a clear answer when asked if Fremantle would have won without them. 'No,' he said on SEN. 'I've been hard on the two rucks. For three quarters it was a complete and utter disaster. They were destroyed from stoppage but credit to them for not throwing in the towel and impacting the game in the last quarter in a big way. In a huge way.' Darcy and Jackson won the hit-out battle 57-26 against Rowan Marshall but couldn't turn that dominance into clearance wins. St Kilda led the clearances 39-16 at three quarter time before the Dockers fought back in the final term, winning the stoppage battle by eight for the remainder of the game. Dockers coach Justin Longmuir said the final quarter was a sign of what Darcy and Jackson could do for Fremantle. 'When I say horses for courses I think people assume I'm thinking to leave one out. Horses for courses means adjusting to what the game is telling us and who is having an impact,' he explained. 'My opinion was Sean was having more impact in the ruck for us and we opted to give him more minutes in the last quarter. The great thing about Jacko is he's able to impact in other areas of the ground. 'After they kicked a goal, he took a mark on the top of the 50 and passed it to Sean. That's a big play. Then for him to kick a goal out of the centre bounce was a big play. His ability to have impact in different areas of the ground gives us great flexibility. 'I thought Sean competed really well. He's getting stronger in the ruck. It was nice to see him work around the ground. I thought his aerial contests were really strong. 'That's improving. He played big minutes in the last. We're lowering his minutes, but but he played big minutes in the last and he saw that out well. He's taken steps forward.' While Jackson and Darcy were influential in the last quarter, another of Fremantle's biggest names was forced to watch the fightback from the bench. Dual Brownlow medallist Nat Fyfe was selected as the sub but reported calf awareness while warming up at half-time and the Dockers decided against putting him onto the field. Fyfe has had an interrupted season with knee surgery and a hamstring injury keeping him to only four games, and that included him not getting on the ground against the Saints. All eyes will be on Fremantle's injury report on Tuesday to see whether Fyfe will spend more time on the sidelines after the latest setback. But even if he is cleared, it is likely he will have to build match fitness in the WAFL instead of travelling to play Sydney. Fyfe is out of contract at the end of the season and Cornes expressed concern for him. 'You can't help but feel sorry for Nat Fyfe with what he's going through with his body,' he said. 'It's been a battle for him. He's such a superstar of our game, and it's a sad ending the way it's playing out unfortunately.'
The Advertiser
5 hours ago
- The Advertiser
AFL to inspect SCG after Freo coach's 'unsafe' claims
The AFL's independent turf consultant is part of a delegation sent to inspect the SCG after Fremantle coach Justin Longmuir added his voice to growing concerns over the venue's playing surface. Sunday's Sydney-Fremantle clash could be moved away from the SCG following uproar over players repeatedly struggling to keep their feet during the Western Bulldogs' win over the Swans on Friday night. The surface has been below its best since a concert at the venue by Italian tenor Andrea Bocelli in April, with particular concern over the Paddington end of the ground. Up to 90mm of rain is forecast for Sydney on Tuesday in what will further hamper hopes of having the SCG turf up to scratch. On Monday, the AFL said the independent turf consultant, members of the league's football department and AFL Players Association representatives would inspect the ground this week. The group will assist the ground's curator with ongoing management of the playing surface. Fremantle's finals hopes last year were torpedoed by a series of injuries to key players late in the season, and Longmuir fears his team will be put at elevated risk if they have to play at the SCG on Sunday. "I watched the game on Friday night, and we'll be led by the AFL, but the moment my brain goes to, 'That's unsafe for players', I have a concern," Longmuir said after his side's win over St Kilda on Sunday. "And I went there on Friday night. I thought it was a bit unsafe, especially down the left-hand side." Longmuir made specific mention of an incident in which Bulldogs defender Bailey Williams got his foot caught in the turf. "I think the Bailey Williams one - we just can't put players out there and risk their safety if the ground's not right," he said. Longmuir says he will abide by the AFL's decision. "If the AFL deem it safe to play, we'll play, and I won't speak another moment of it," Longmuir said. "The AFL approached us and they're going to look at it, like they should, and they've got the experts and will be guided by them. "But I thought it was unsafe the other night." Fremantle (10-5) are just percentage adrift of third spot following a six-match winning run. But their thrilling 11.15 (81) to 9.15 (69) victory over St Kilda on Sunday came with an injury cost, and in a bizarre manner. Nat Fyfe will be sidelined for up to four weeks with a moderate-grade calf strain sustained while he was warming up as the substitute at half-time. The 33-year-old veteran felt tightness at the time and the Dockers decided against sending him on, with the severity of the injury then confirmed on Monday. Fyfe had been set to feature in his fourth match back after recovering from a hamstring injury. The AFL's independent turf consultant is part of a delegation sent to inspect the SCG after Fremantle coach Justin Longmuir added his voice to growing concerns over the venue's playing surface. Sunday's Sydney-Fremantle clash could be moved away from the SCG following uproar over players repeatedly struggling to keep their feet during the Western Bulldogs' win over the Swans on Friday night. The surface has been below its best since a concert at the venue by Italian tenor Andrea Bocelli in April, with particular concern over the Paddington end of the ground. Up to 90mm of rain is forecast for Sydney on Tuesday in what will further hamper hopes of having the SCG turf up to scratch. On Monday, the AFL said the independent turf consultant, members of the league's football department and AFL Players Association representatives would inspect the ground this week. The group will assist the ground's curator with ongoing management of the playing surface. Fremantle's finals hopes last year were torpedoed by a series of injuries to key players late in the season, and Longmuir fears his team will be put at elevated risk if they have to play at the SCG on Sunday. "I watched the game on Friday night, and we'll be led by the AFL, but the moment my brain goes to, 'That's unsafe for players', I have a concern," Longmuir said after his side's win over St Kilda on Sunday. "And I went there on Friday night. I thought it was a bit unsafe, especially down the left-hand side." Longmuir made specific mention of an incident in which Bulldogs defender Bailey Williams got his foot caught in the turf. "I think the Bailey Williams one - we just can't put players out there and risk their safety if the ground's not right," he said. Longmuir says he will abide by the AFL's decision. "If the AFL deem it safe to play, we'll play, and I won't speak another moment of it," Longmuir said. "The AFL approached us and they're going to look at it, like they should, and they've got the experts and will be guided by them. "But I thought it was unsafe the other night." Fremantle (10-5) are just percentage adrift of third spot following a six-match winning run. But their thrilling 11.15 (81) to 9.15 (69) victory over St Kilda on Sunday came with an injury cost, and in a bizarre manner. Nat Fyfe will be sidelined for up to four weeks with a moderate-grade calf strain sustained while he was warming up as the substitute at half-time. The 33-year-old veteran felt tightness at the time and the Dockers decided against sending him on, with the severity of the injury then confirmed on Monday. Fyfe had been set to feature in his fourth match back after recovering from a hamstring injury. The AFL's independent turf consultant is part of a delegation sent to inspect the SCG after Fremantle coach Justin Longmuir added his voice to growing concerns over the venue's playing surface. Sunday's Sydney-Fremantle clash could be moved away from the SCG following uproar over players repeatedly struggling to keep their feet during the Western Bulldogs' win over the Swans on Friday night. The surface has been below its best since a concert at the venue by Italian tenor Andrea Bocelli in April, with particular concern over the Paddington end of the ground. Up to 90mm of rain is forecast for Sydney on Tuesday in what will further hamper hopes of having the SCG turf up to scratch. On Monday, the AFL said the independent turf consultant, members of the league's football department and AFL Players Association representatives would inspect the ground this week. The group will assist the ground's curator with ongoing management of the playing surface. Fremantle's finals hopes last year were torpedoed by a series of injuries to key players late in the season, and Longmuir fears his team will be put at elevated risk if they have to play at the SCG on Sunday. "I watched the game on Friday night, and we'll be led by the AFL, but the moment my brain goes to, 'That's unsafe for players', I have a concern," Longmuir said after his side's win over St Kilda on Sunday. "And I went there on Friday night. I thought it was a bit unsafe, especially down the left-hand side." Longmuir made specific mention of an incident in which Bulldogs defender Bailey Williams got his foot caught in the turf. "I think the Bailey Williams one - we just can't put players out there and risk their safety if the ground's not right," he said. Longmuir says he will abide by the AFL's decision. "If the AFL deem it safe to play, we'll play, and I won't speak another moment of it," Longmuir said. "The AFL approached us and they're going to look at it, like they should, and they've got the experts and will be guided by them. "But I thought it was unsafe the other night." Fremantle (10-5) are just percentage adrift of third spot following a six-match winning run. But their thrilling 11.15 (81) to 9.15 (69) victory over St Kilda on Sunday came with an injury cost, and in a bizarre manner. Nat Fyfe will be sidelined for up to four weeks with a moderate-grade calf strain sustained while he was warming up as the substitute at half-time. The 33-year-old veteran felt tightness at the time and the Dockers decided against sending him on, with the severity of the injury then confirmed on Monday. Fyfe had been set to feature in his fourth match back after recovering from a hamstring injury.
West Australian
6 hours ago
- West Australian
Nat Fyfe: Fremantle veteran to miss multiple weeks after suffering latest injury setback in substitute's role
Fremantle star Nat Fyfe has been dealt a savage blow with the veteran ruled out for up to four weeks after straining his calf while warming up against St Kilda on Sunday. Fyfe was named as the starting sub against the Saints but remained on the bench for the entire game. Coach Justin Longmuir revealed after the match that Fyfe had reported calf awareness while warming up at half-time but was hopeful he hadn't done too much damage. The news was all bad for the dual Brownlow medallist though after learning he had suffered a strain that will keep him out of action for between two and four weeks. 'Obviously frustrating for Nat after he was able to get some continuity with his body in the last month' said Fremantle Executive General Manager of Football Joe Brierty. 'He will now commence an offloading and reconditioning period and our performance health team will set the program with Nat to return to football in the next few weeks.' The injury comes at a horrible time for Fyfe. He worked hard to recover from knee and hamstring injuries and showed he could have an impact as the sub. But now he will almost certainly have to re-build fitness and confidence in the WAFL before having another opportunity to play at the highest level. The Dockers have won six games in a row and also have Jaeger O'Meara already trying to get back in the team. Star Hayden Young is on a similar timeframe to Fyfe adding more selection pressure. Fyfe hasn't played a final since 2015. He missed Fremantle's 2022 finals run due to injury. Out of contract at the end of the season, the injury will also make it hard for Fyfe to become just the fourth Docker to play 250 games behind David Mundy, Matthew Pavlich and Aaron Sandilands. He is currently sitting on 244 matches.
