‘Dangerous data void': Number of B.C. residents on extended leave from involuntary care unknown
Concerns are being raised after the provincial government admitted it does not know how many people are on extended leave from involuntary care stays in B.C.
On April 30 it was revealed that the suspect in the Lapu Lapu festival tragedy, Kai-Ji Adam Lo, 30, was under the care of a mental health care team but he was on extended leave at the time.
Angela Russolillo, assistant professor in nursing at the University of British Columbia, told Global News that involuntary care and extended leave are not new, however, the lack of data on the number of people is an issue.
'It's concerning that the province actually doesn't have a lot of transparent data on who is certified under the Mental Health Act and who is on extended leave in the province,' she said.
Story continues below advertisement
'We're actually operating in a very dangerous data void in terms of transparent data that's available to inform care decisions and ultimately, the lack of data doesn't allow us to, ultimately, design care and interventions for folks that require services.'
According to Fraser Health, extended leave means the person continues to be certified under the Mental Health Act after being discharged from a designated facility.
Get weekly health news
Receive the latest medical news and health information delivered to you every Sunday. Sign up for weekly health newsletter Sign Up
By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy
Reasons for the extended leave are not disclosed but may include: 'The person needs further treatment but they lack the insight into their need for continued treatment and are unwilling to continue treatment in the community; The person's mental and physical health may deteriorate (get worse) without the certification but they don't have to be in a designated facility.
In a case of an extended leave, Fraser Health states that the person is still supported by a community mental health team that monitors their mental health and well-being and provides treatment and support as necessary.
1:34
New questions surround investigation of Lapu Lapu Day suspect Adam Lo
Russolillo said one of the best ways to inform health care and make decisions is by using data-driven materials.
Story continues below advertisement
'Unfortunately, what we're seeing a lot right now in the province is a large reliance on involuntary mental health care in order to provide patients, who might need services, with that care,' she said.
'What we really want to see is more access to community-based mental health care, so that folks can access services in their communities voluntarily and get access to a range of services that might include medication supports but also mental health supports.'
In a statement on April 30, the B.C. Ministry of Health said there was no indication of violence in Lo's presentation to his mental health team.
It also said there was no recent change in his condition or non-compliance with his treatment plan that would have warranted involuntary hospitalization.
Eleven people were killed at the Lapu Lapu festival on April 26 and dozens more were injured.
Lo has been charged with eight counts of second-degree murder and remains in custody.
The provincial government was not available on Tuesday to answer questions about people who are on extended leave from involuntary care stays in B.C.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Global News
2 hours ago
- Global News
Why are fire-related deaths higher in Indigenous communities?
Laura McComber's mind is more at ease. On Wednesday, the resident in the Mohawk community of Kahnawake, south of Montreal, had a smoke detector installed in her home, where her parents lived. It's her first one. 'There was never any alarm systems,' she told Global News. 'I don't think they had anything like that back in the day.' Fire officials estimate that only about half the homes in that community have smoke detectors, and that the smoke detector shortage also exists in Indigenous communities across Canada. 'Part of it comes down to education,' explained Arnold Lazare, Indigenous fire marshal for Canada. 'People don't knowingly not install smoke alarms. We found out that in many instances it comes down to economics where people have other priorities.' Get daily National news Get the day's top news, political, economic, and current affairs headlines, delivered to your inbox once a day. Sign up for daily National newsletter Sign Up By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy It's why a coalition of private and and Indigenous groups have launched a pilot project to distribute and install more than 6,000 smoke alarms for Indigenous families across the country. They're distributing the alarms to 16 Indigenous communities, including Kahnawake, which is getting just over 500. Story continues below advertisement 'While [Indigenous Peoples] only make five per cent of the population in Canada, they make about 20 per cent of fire related deaths,' Ivanette Bonilla explained. She's chief communications & government relations officer for Kidde, the company providing the devices. 'There's a great need to raise awareness of fire safety education, but also access to working smoke alarms.' Lazare agrees. 'There was a fire in Kahnawake recently that the family didn't have a working detector,' he recalls. 'Their injuries are probably graver than what would've happened if they had a working detector.' Included in the pilot project is fire safety education, without which the distribution of equipment would not be as effective, officials say. 'That includes our tool kit,' said Bonilla. 'It has information on how to create a family escape plan so that everyone in the home knows what to do, including children.' The groups want to expand the project if this first phase goes well. Story continues below advertisement
Global News
10 hours ago
- Global News
After otter pup's death, Vancouver Island dog owners urged to control their pets
An animal rescue society on Vancouver Island is pleading with dog owners to be more responsible, after an off-leash dog attacked an otter, leading to its death. The Mars Wildlife Emergency Hotline in Comox was called to Goose Spit Park on Sunday, after someone reported an injured otter on the shoreline. When a rescue team arrived, the dog had chased the otter back into the water. It eventually came back out, suffering from bite wounds, along with injuries suggesting it might have also been attacked by another otter. 4:56 Safety tips while walking your dog It's the second otter pup confirmed to have been attacked by a dog so far this year, but junior rehab assistant Natasha Davies said the hospital has also treated seal pups and raccoons chased by dogs. Story continues below advertisement 'So far this year, all of our intakes for confirmed dog attack patients have either died in care or been euthanized on arrival due to the extent of their injuries,' she said. Get breaking National news For news impacting Canada and around the world, sign up for breaking news alerts delivered directly to you when they happen. Sign up for breaking National newsletter Sign Up By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy 'We are just urging for a high quality of pet ownership, really. It's largely on the people who allow dogs to chase wildlife.' Kristen Nicholson, who runs Fit Fido Dog Training, said owners who want to take their dog out off-leash should ensure they have control of their pets. 'It's really important to have that solid foundation of recall and having your dog want to come to you,' she said. 'Realistically, we want to have our dogs off doing fun things with us … but if you don't have that solid foundation and that training of recall, especially, you can't have your dog off a leash.' She added that animals are never perfect, and there are just some places you cannot take your dog off leash because you can't be sure they won't chase something. That's the case at least part of the year at Goose Spit Park, where signs are posted warning owners to keep their dogs leashed between March 1 and May 20. However, despite specific leash rules, allowing a dog to chase wildlife is always illegal.
Vancouver Sun
12 hours ago
- Vancouver Sun
New report finds wait times in B.C. emergency rooms continue to climb
British Columbians are waiting longer to get care in emergency rooms and the situation is the worst it's been in the last five years, according to a new national report looking at emergency room wait times across the country. The report by the Montreal Economic Institute found that the median length of stay in a B.C. emergency room — calculated from the time a patient registers to when they are discharged or are admitted to the hospital — was four hours and 13 minutes in 2024, up from just over three hours in 2019. 'Throughout the years, B.C. has remained somewhere in the middle of the pack, never the worst, never the best,' said report author and economist Emmanuelle B. Faubert on Wednesday. 'But while they're not doing the most poorly out of the provinces, there's still improvement that can be done.' Start your day with a roundup of B.C.-focused news and opinion. By signing up you consent to receive the above newsletter from Postmedia Network Inc. A welcome email is on its way. If you don't see it, please check your junk folder. The next issue of Sunrise will soon be in your inbox. Please try again Interested in more newsletters? Browse here. The median wait time indicates that 50 per cent of patients waits more and 50 per cent waits less. The longest waiting times in the country were in Quebec, where ER patients' median wait was nearly 5 1/2 hours and shortest in Newfoundland and Labrador, where the median wait time was two hours and 45 minutes. Saskatchewan and Nova Scotia were not included due to lack of submitted data. Reports of long waiting times at emergency rooms in B.C. are not new. A patient visiting Eagle Ridge Hospital in Port Moody shared a photo of a handwritten sign posted at the ER early Tuesday morning that said the wait time to see a doctor was 12 hours. Fraser Health said the sign was not made or posted by the health authority, although it acknowledged the emergency department saw 'higher-than-normal patient volumes' and 'unexpected staffing challenges.' A 'significant' number of patients did not require urgent care, and many of them had to wait longer to get care, it said in a statement. This isn't the first time rogue signs have appeared at Eagle Ridge, which has consistently reported some of the longest ER waiting times among Metro Vancouver hospitals. It placed 20th out of 29 emergency rooms in B.C. with a median wait time of four hours and 24 minutes, according to the report from the Montreal think-tank. Late last year, photos of signs saying the hospital's ER was closed due to overcapacity circulated on social media. The sign was false Fraser Health said at the time. It was unclear who wrote the note, but it appeared to be from frustrated staff who urged the public to contact Port Coquitlam MLA Mike Farnworth to 'help us advocate' to keep the ER open 'so that we can do our jobs and attend to every patient requiring emergency care in a timely fashion.' In 2023, doctors at Eagle Ridge, along with colleagues at Royal Columbian Hospital, penned an open letter sounding the alarm over long waiting times, overcrowding and patient safety at the two hospitals' emergency departments due to a shortage of ER doctors and nurses. In B.C., the shortest ER waiting time was at Providence Health's Mount Saint Joseph Hospital in Vancouver (a median wait of two hours and 54 minutes), said the report. Fraser Health's Fraser Canyon Hospital in Hope (three hours) had the next shortest waits followed by Vancouver Coastal's UBC Health Sciences Centre (three hours and six minutes). The worst performer was Abbotsford Regional Hospital and Cancer Centre (six hours and 36 minutes), followed by Island Health's Royal Jubilee Hospital (six hours and 18 minutes) and Vancouver General Hospital (five hours and 18 minutes). The report chalked up longer waiting times partly to a lack of access to primary care and lack of options for people with minor emergencies. It recommended Canada adopt clinics similar to ones operating in France called immediate medical care centres to fill in what it called the missing middle of emergency care to treat low priority cases, such as fractures or infections. Faubert said the French clinics are similar to B.C.'s urgent care centres but are privately run, which Faubert argued would face less bureaucratic red tape to get set up and operating and have more flexibility in terms of scheduling and staffing. 'Also, having clinics run and operated by government means it can be slower to spread across the province and the country,' she said. 'There's limitations when you have control that is very centralized.' At an unrelated news conference on Tuesday, B.C. Health Minister Josie Osborne said the long waiting times at B.C. emergency departments speak to the larger context of the global shortage of health care workers. She said that's why the provincial government has been working to build up its primary care system, establish urgent care clinics, fast-tracking credentials of U.S.-trained doctors and U.S.-registered nurses, and ramping up recruitment efforts to attract U.S.-based health care workers to come work in B.C. chchan@
