How long will Baltimore police's federal oversight last in the aftermath of Freddie Gray's death?
The Department of Justice found police committed widespread civil rights violations after Freddie Gray's death and placed the Baltimore Police Department under federal oversight eight years ago to correct the problems.
The city has spent millions of dollars on police reform during that time, and while some say there is still a long way to go, the commissioner sees a transformed department.
On Thursday, April 17, the
police department was found compliant in two areas of its consent decree
-- the transportation of detainees and officer wellness.
"That was bound to come because what they did to Freddie Gray was uncalled for," said Thomas Guinn, who lives in West Baltimore's Sandtown community.
Guinn remembers being hurt and angry over Freddie Gray's death in police custody. He believes that over the decade since, the way officers interact with the people they serve is getting better here.
"I've been victimized by police before, pulled over just because I'm a young Black man. Freddie Gray changed that. They give us much more respect now," he said.
Baltimore Police Commissioner Richard Worley told WJZ bluntly, "We're not the department we were in 2015."
"I think it shows that the men and women have changed the culture of the BPD to the point that now we are the guardians and not the warriors who go in and take the area by storm," the commissioner said.
A scathing Department of Justice report commissioned after Gray's death exposed the extent of the problems, documenting what many in the neighborhood where Gray grew up had been saying for years: Baltimore police engaged in "unconstitutional" policing with a "pattern and practice" of retaliation, excessive force and unconstitutional stops, searches and arrests—
particularly targeting Black residents.
You can read that
2016 report here.
Among the outrageous violations detailed in the DOJ investigation:
And that was before a 2017 indictment revealed the stunning abuses by the Gun Trace Task Force (GTTF), the specialized unit whose members robbed citizens and covered it up.
In court, testimony revealed the lead detective, Wayne Jenkins, took drugs looted from pharmacies and elsewhere in the unrest following Gray's death and sold them through his friend,
bail bondsman Donald Stepp
.
According to federal prosecutors:
"From 2015-2017, Stepp obtained significant quantities of narcotics from Jenkins and robbed citizens of their property, including drugs, cash, and watches.
To facilitate the robberies and drug trafficking, Jenkins brought Stepp to search locations in Baltimore City and Baltimore County, and falsely represented to other law enforcement agencies that Stepp was an officer with BPD. Jenkins would travel to Stepp's residence after he had robbed citizens and Stepp would store the stolen drugs in his tool shed. Stepp then sold the stolen drugs and returned hundreds of thousands of dollars in cash proceeds to BPD officers. Jenkins took a portion of the proceeds from the drug sales and paid other officers in the BPD who participated in the robberies with Jenkins and Stepp.
On December 14, 2017, law enforcement executed a search warrant at Stepp's residence and recovered approximately 423 grams of crack cocaine, 262 grams of cocaine, 14 grams of heroin, 28 grams of MDMA, digital scales, packaging material, a large sum of cash, and several high-value watches."
In June 2015, police blamed the looted narcotics on a surge in
shootings and killings
.
There would have been no Department of Justice investigation without Freddie Gray's tragic death.
WJZ Investigator Mike Hellgren:
"Can you think of another incident that changed policing more than that one?"
BPD Commissioner Richard Worley:
"For us, no."
"I think if it didn't happen at Freddie Gray, it would have happened at George Floyd," Commissioner Worley said. "I think it was bound to happen at some point. We were moving further apart from the community, as opposed to coming together with the community. And the police department and the city could never succeed when your police department and the community can't get along."
Worley said community engagement is a key component of reform, and morale among officers is better within the department today.
"It was really bad, and I think it has improved. Commissioner Harrison came in. He got us on the right track, and then he turned it over to someone from within the department," Commissioner Worley said. "And the fact that I came up through the ranks helped with morale. But I also had to prove myself because I was also here during the bad times, and I know when I went through those town halls, people thought we were going to revert to the old way, and were not going to revert to the old way. We want to provide a better police department, and I think that's what we're doing."
Body cameras, new transport policies, and a drastic reduction in arrests without probable cause are some of the successes.
"There have been changes, but I want to see more change, and I think I'm in good company," said Billy Murphy, who represented Gray's family.
WJZ Investigator Mike Hellgren:
"Could you see it happening all over again?"
Gray family attorney Billy Murphy:
"I don't think it can happen the way it happened in the Freddie Gray case because there are too many checks and balances that have been implemented."
James Bredar, the judge overseeing police reform, recently warned the department it was "playing with fire"
because of severe understaffing
.
That is a problem the commissioner acknowledges, being more than 500 officers down on a force that's smaller than when Gray was arrested. There were roughly 3,000 officers then. There will be almost 2,000 in 2025.
The biggest strides have been made in training and the
transport of detainees
.
Commissioner Worley believes federal oversight has turned a troubled department into a touchstone.
"Never did I ever think the Baltimore police department would be the agency that other agencies around the country and the world are coming to see how to do things right," Worley said.
Police Commissioner Worley is hopeful the judge will find the city fully compliant and remove Baltimore from federal oversight by the time his contract is up in 2028.
But there are no guarantees, and Judge Bredar has given no timetable on when he will find the city fully compliant.
You can read the consent decree
agreement here
.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
15 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Professor: Los Angeles …You Are Becoming The Exact Thing Trump Needed
Hate to say this but Los Angeles…you're not helping. Before you get mad and turn off your phone, let me explain. Last week, U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents (ICE) arrested 118 immigrants during operations in L.A. Since then, protests have erupted in the city that Mayor Karen Bass says has turn the entire metropolitan area into a 'tinderbox.' In one confrontation, police employed tear gas and pepper spray as protestors gathered outside a detention center on Sunday. President Trump said he would deploy 2,000 National Guard soldiers to respond to the protests. In a post on Truth Social, Trump attacked what he called 'Radical Left protests' by 'instigators and often paid troublemakers.' OK. Listen. We are all sympathetic to the reason why these protests are happening. Treating immigrants this way is not American. This country is unique in that it is one made up of people from other countries. But…these riots and protests? They are doing nothing but distracting us from the sneaky sh*t Trump is doing right in front of our faces. The One Big Beautiful Bill Act, passed by the House in May, includes tax cuts, spending cuts, and policy changes that would devastate many Americans, especially Black folks. It would strip millions of heath care and drive many people who look like us into crippling debt. Then there is the travel ban that Trump unsuccessfully tried to implement in his first term that he has gotten little to no resistance on in this second one. People were marching in the streets outraged in 2016, now he has implemented it with little to no pushback. And even though Trump has fallen out with Elon Musk, DOGE is still running roughshod through the federal government. Just a few days ago, the department got access to our SOCIAL SECURITY NUMBERS. (Yes. Had to write it like that because it is a big f**kin' deal.) That means that they have all our sensitive data which is…great. And all the while, Black folks are still being killed by police. Health outcomes of Black people are worse now because public health research is dwindling. And even the wigs and weave will go up because of Trump's Tariffs. So, look. We are with you, Los Angeles. We support your anger. But all these violent clashes with ICE agents and the police? You are exactly the kind of distraction Trump has been needing so he can do what he wants without anyone noticing.
Yahoo
16 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Tacoma ex-deputy police chief had ‘pattern of disrespect' to women, inquiry says
The Tacoma Police Department's former deputy chief, Paul Junger, wasn't fired for one egregious incident, an investigation report shows, but because of consistent demeaning behavior that created a hostile work environment for women. One instance, in which Junger downgraded a patrol officer's punishment for creating a meme that disrespected his commanding officer and three other women, was described as appearing to be part of a 'pattern of disrespect' to women. That pattern included belittling comments Junger made to Assistant Chief Crystal Young-Haskins, who brought a Human Resources complaint against him in November, weeks after she reported his behavior to former Police Chief Avery Moore. It also entailed questioning her judgment in front of her peers, interrupting her in meetings, not accepting her advice but taking it from men and undermining Young-Haskins by offering support to her in private but then withdrawing it in public. One witness said Junger's treatment was 'death by a thousand cuts.' Those are some of the findings outlined in a March 26 report authored by an attorney with the Seattle-based law firm Ryan, Swanson & Cleveland, PLLC detailing an investigation into Junger's behavior in the workplace. The 21-page report was released to The News Tribune through a public records request with some redactions. It determined that allegations of a hostile work environment and gender discrimination were true. Interim Police Chief Patti Jackson chose to terminate Junger's employment March 31 based on the external investigation. 'The evidence provided by [redacted] and other witnesses was of numerous incidents, actions and comments, most of which if taken individually would be considered unpleasant, derogatory and/or inappropriate, but would not, taken alone, constitute a hostile work environment,' the report states. 'However, the events and actions must be considered together, to show the 'totality of the circumstances.'' Junger did not respond to a request for comment about the investigation Tuesday. The report notes that after he returned to work from administrative leave last year, he apologized to several people individually for the way he had treated them. 'Junger explained that his leadership style is building trust and relationships, and so after being placed on administrative leave he felt this was the appropriate way to try and rebuild relationships with individuals in the department,' the report states. The witnesses who spoke to the investigator about the apologies were all Black women, according to the report, and several described it as an 'apology tour.' Most thought it was too little, too late, but one said Junger's apology felt sincere. As deputy chief and the department's second in command, Junger was responsible for assisting in the overall direction of the department's internal operations. He reported to the chief of police, and the department's three assistant chiefs reported to him. According to The News Tribune's salary database, his total pay in 2023 was $272,455.60 Young-Haskins also did not respond to a request for comment Tuesday. Although it was Young-Haskins who filed a complaint with the city's HR department, the investigator described how multiple women were subjected to discriminatory behavior. According to the report, three women who left the Police Department tied their departures, in part, to how Junger treated them. 'A witness who left the department after 35 years told me that she was treated extremely disrespectfully and condescendingly by Junger, including an incident where he was angry about something she and AC [redacted] had done, and he approached them, pointing his finger and saying 'You. Down the hall. NOW.'' Young-Haskins now leads the Investigations Bureau for the Police Department. She came to Tacoma in summer 2022 from Little Rock, Arkansas, where she served as the city's interim police chief. Junger joined the Tacoma Police Department around the same time from the Dallas Police Department, where he worked with Moore. Young-Haskins complained of Junger's harassing behavior about two years after she began working in Tacoma, but her emailed report to HR said the hostile work environment began shortly after she was hired. She said she feared coming forward about Junger because she wanted to be a team player and of a desire to do her job to the best of her ability. Not all of Young-Haskins' allegations about Junger were substantiated by workplace investigation. The claim that Junger engaged in race discrimination was not sustained, and allegations of age discrimination and that he retaliated against Young-Haskins were deemed to be unfounded. The report said it was difficult to determine whether race played a factor in Junger's treatment of employees, noting that the treatment was directed toward a white woman as well as several Black women, but it wasn't directed toward all white women in the department. Instead, the treatment seemed directed toward women who reported directly to Junger, and it appeared more aligned with gender differences. One man interviewed for the investigation recalled a time when Junger referred to the women assistant chiefs as 'the girls' in a private meeting in 2024 where no women were present. A man also reported that Junger commented to him that one of the women assistant chiefs wasn't really sick when she called out of work for a sick day. Young-Haskins reported that Junger gave her unequal treatment for her use of leave. The investigation found examples of male employees receiving less scrutiny for leave requests, and it described one incident that escalated to Junger contacting a deputy city attorney. That incident appears to have prompted Young-Haskins to report Junger's behavior to the police chief. In October 2024, according to the report, Young-Haskins was scheduled to attend a conference that required her to travel from Seattle to Boston. Her leave request was for the dates of the conference, Oct. 18-22, but she didn't include time needed to travel to and from the conference, which required an extra day before it started and after it ended. Young-Haskins notified the person who was covering for her that she needed the extra time, and she sent a memo via email about the correct dates of her absence, which Junger received, according to the report. On Oct. 23, while Young-Haskins was on her flight out of Boston, Junger emailed and texted her to ask her if she would be attending the one-on-one meeting they had scheduled that day. Young-Haskins tried to respond to the text, but it didn't go through, according to the report, and she wasn't able to respond to him until her plane landed hours later. When Junger was interviewed about that for the investigation, he said he believed Young-Haskins was 'AWOL' or absent without leave. According to the report, he repeatedly questioned her about the absence and talked to the deputy city attorney assigned to the Police Department. Young-Haskins asserted that Junger was being unreasonable and treating her differently than her male counterparts. 'She noted that when Junger did not know where one of his team members were, he would ask around, but never implied or stated that the person was AWOL,' the report states. When Junger was interviewed, he said he relied on the dates in the leave request, and, when she was absent, he was concerned. The day after Young-Haskins got back from Boston, she reported to Moore that she felt Junger had created a hostile work environment and subjected her to unlawful harassment, according to her email to HR. An embarrassing image depicting a caricature of Young-Haskins and three other women in the department was another subject of Junger's investigation because of his decision to downgrade the punishment of the patrol officer who made it. The investigation doesn't show the meme or describe it in detail, but an internal investigation about it reportedly found it was offensive to women and constituted insubordination toward one of the women it depicted. 'The creator of the meme was unapologetic about it and stated the women deserved it,' according to the report. A bureau-level reprimand was recommended for the patrol officer, which stays on file for five years. Typically the decision of whether to discipline an officer and how severe that punishment should be is up to the police chief, but Moore was on leave when the investigation concluded. Junger was entitled to make the decision himself as acting chief in the meantime, and he decided to instead give the officer who created the meme an oral reprimand, which stays on file for one year instead of five. That outcome 'surprised and upset' two people interviewed for Junger's workplace investigation. One said Junger's actions indicated the department doesn't support women in leadership. Another said his actions were a 'slap in the face.' Junger said he believed the five-year reprimand was too harsh, and he considered the fact that the patrol officer didn't have any prior disciplinary matters. Junger also said the officer would have to take some form of training, which he felt was consistent with the department's progressive discipline policy.
Axios
20 minutes ago
- Axios
Riot reignites scrutiny at one of largest prisons in Tennessee
A riot erupted at one of Tennessee's largest prisons late Sunday, injuring a guard and reigniting calls for an overhaul of prison leadership. Why it matters: This marks the latest example of violent conditions at Trousdale Turner Correctional Center, which is overseen by the publicly traded company CoreCivic. Critics, including state lawmakers and local district attorney, say conditions are perilous for staff and inmates. State of play: The riot began late Sunday and lasted for hours, according to law enforcement. A "large group of inmates from several housing units" got out of their cells and got into part of the prison yard, according to a CoreCivic spokesperson. The inmates tried to destroy security cameras, started fires and tried to damage other property. They attacked one guard, who was treated and released at an area hospital, the spokesperson said. Three inmates were treated for injuries. Prison staff used tear gas to quell the conflict and regain control. All inmates remained on prison grounds during the riot. The Tennessee Department of Correction is investigating. The big picture: Violence at Trousdale Turner is well documented. It is the subject of several wrongful death lawsuits and an ongoing Department of Justice investigation. Understaffing and mismanagement have been noted in state audits. Yes, but: Heightened scrutiny has done little to address the problem. Zoom out: The state has contracted with the Brentwood-based CoreCivic to manage operations at Trousdale Turner since the prison opened in 2016. The state has doled out millions of dollars in penalties against CoreCivic amid understaffing and other problems. What they're saying: High-profile critics responding to the riot said the state should take over operations at Trousdale Turner. Trousdale County District Attorney Jason Lawson said a new charge related to criminal conduct at the prison emerges every four days. " The continual problems demonstrate that CoreCivic is unable to address the issues," Lawson said in a statement. "It is long overdue that the State of Tennessee shifted the management of Trousdale Turner from CoreCivic into the direct hands of the Tennessee Department of Correction. I am confident that Commissioner Strada and the Tennessee Department of Correction could manage this situation far better than what is being done by CoreCivic." State Sen. Heidi Campbell (D-Nashville) said keeping CoreCivic in charge is "profoundly unfair to the sheriff of Trousdale County, to the employees working in that dangerous environment, and certainly to the people incarcerated there."
