Setting the Stage for Hate: Kneecap and Coachella's Collapse of Conscience (Opinion)
Coachella stands at the epicenter of global music culture — a world stage where performances reverberate far beyond the desert. Such a platform demands responsibility, one that Paul Tollett and festival promoters AEG/Goldenvoice abandoned when they handed the stage to Kneecap, an Irish band with a public record of cheering on terror groups and promoting hate. In my view, it wasn't a mistake. It was a choice.
And when the hate speech poured out from the stage, it wasn't just heard by the thousands in attendance. It was broadcast across social media, third party livestreams, and endless reposts, amplifying their venom to millions. This wasn't fringe noise in a dive bar heard only by their fans. It was onstage at Coachella's global megaphone.
More from The Hollywood Reporter
Ed Sheeran, Jelly Roll Join Post Malone to Close Out Coachella
Irish Band Kneecap Displays Anti-Israel Messages During Coachella Weekend 2 Set 'Blindsiding' Festival Organizers
Maren Morris Talks Coachella Sets With Zedd and the LA Philharmonic: "I Feel Like I Just Got My Voice Back"
What did Paul Tollett expect?
Tollett, the founder of Coachella, has spoken about the festival's cultural significance, about his responsibility to the audience, about creating a space that is 'safe,' and 'inclusive.' So where was that responsibility when the bright red flags around Kneecap were raised — again and again — by people in our business who knew what was coming?
Kneecap's affiliations, politics, and tactics are not secrets. And they are not subtle. Their ideology and provocations have long been part of their brand. Paul and Goldenvoice had ample warning. They didn't act. They didn't speak. And worse — they still haven't.
Let's be clear: this isn't about artistic freedom. I'm a First Amendment near absolutist. This is about enabling hate speech. This is about aligning a painstakingly curated and coveted brand — and its audience — with a group whose words and symbols glorify violence and celebrate those who commit it. This is about re-traumatizing Jewish attendees — and others, many of them teenagers. This is about rhetoric that that ripped open the wounds left by the sexual assault and slaughter of young music lovers at the Nova Festival, people not unlike those standing in that desert crowd.
The audience was forced to participate in a display that wasn't just offensive — it was dangerous.
So, what now?
What does accountability look like when a $600 ticket buys you fear instead of joy, hostility instead of unity? What is the responsibility of an organizer when they provide a platform to groups that violate the very principles music is meant to uplift?
Tollett doesn't get to hide behind silence. Neither does Goldenvoice, nor AEG. And neither does the music industry. As a Jewish executive who has spent my lifetime in this business. I've celebrated its power to uplift, to inspire, to unite. But I watched this moment in stunned disbelief. And I have heard the silence of those responsible.
I think every link in the chain failed. From the booking agents to the stage managers, from the brand partners to the artist liaisons. Each had a chance to say this isn't right. And no one did. The result? Coachella became a vehicle not for joy, but for intimidation. Not for healing, but for harm. It didn't have to happen.
We pride ourselves on being cultural leaders. Let's focus on building bridges not burning them. So now the question is: What will we do about it? Will Tollett address the uproar? Will Goldenvoice apologize — not just with corporate platitudes, but with meaningful action? Visiting the Nova Exhibition as Tollett did doesn't absolve him of responsibility. If anything, the fact that he had a window into the horrors those festival-goers endured makes his decision to turn a blind eye to this all the more disappointing. Will the industry stand up and draw a line between freedom of expression and platforms of hate?
We'll see. But know this: the silence of those responsible in our industry is no longer ignorance. It's complicity. And I for one won't forget.
Lee Trink is a music industry veteran who was previously the president of Capitol Records and a former manager of major artists. As the co-founder of esports and entertainment brand FaZe Clan, he's spent his career at the intersection of music, media and youth culture.
Best of The Hollywood Reporter
Most Anticipated Concert Tours of 2025: Beyoncé, Billie Eilish, Kendrick Lamar & SZA, Sabrina Carpenter and More
Hollywood's Highest-Profile Harris Endorsements: Taylor Swift, George Clooney, Bruce Springsteen and More
Most Anticipated Concert Tours of 2024: Taylor Swift, Bad Bunny, Olivia Rodrigo and More
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Hamilton Spectator
an hour ago
- Hamilton Spectator
Mikhail Brat was celebrated HPO violinist who emigrated from Soviet Union
Celebrated violinist Mikhail Brat's move to Canada from the former Soviet Union wasn't just Canada's gain and that country's loss, but also Israel's. When Brat and his wife Alla told Soviet authorities they wanted to emigrate — not a thing the state looked kindly on — there was some belief the Jewish couple and their 10-year-old son Alex would move to Israel like other Soviet Jews. 'Israel is already full of musicians,' Brat jokingly told the Hamilton Jewish News in 1976, the year the family arrived in Hamilton. Mikhail Brat was a celebrated violinist who came to the Hamilton Philharmonic Orchestra in 1976 from what was then the Soviet Union. He played with the HPO until he retired in 2016. He is pictured here in 1979 as a soloist with the McMaster Symphony Orchestra. But it was not a laughing matter that brought the family here. Brat told The Spectator in 1979 that while he loved Russian culture, he was frustrated by political restrictions and discrimination against Jews. He and his wife lost their teaching jobs when they sought exit visas. Brat — who died Feb. 2 at age 87 — was a welcome addition to the city's classical musical scene. He had an audition before Boris Brott and was hired to play with the Hamilton Philharmonic Orchestra six months after arriving here. He remained a fixture until he retired in 2016. Brat served in the orchestra's first violin section and was one of its principal players. When the HPO went under in January 1996 because of $1.2 million in red ink, he was quickly snapped up by the former McMaster orchestra, Symphony Hamilton. A year later, he was playing with the New Hamilton Orchestra, which was renamed HPO in 2000. He was part of the HPO string quartet The Orpheus, which also consisted of Sonia Vizante, Marie Pebbles and Marsha Moffit. Apart from Hamilton Place, he played concerts in the Church of the Ascension, the Main-Hess Community Centre and the First Place Auditorium. Mikhail Brat plays the violin with fellow members of the Hamilton Philharmonic Orchestra in a photo that was likely taken not long after he arrived in Hamilton from the Soviet Union in 1976. In 1997, he was the concertmaster for the Symphony in the Barn Festival in Grey County, off Highway 6 near the town of Durham. He also appeared as a soloist with the National Chamber Orchestra of Canada. 'He was a very kind person and had a huge heart,' said his son Alex, senior executive director of labour relations at the University of Toronto. 'He was very well-liked. He was a person who wanted to make people feel good, not just by his music, but he would tell jokes. He didn't have a mean bone in his body.' His daughter Katya, a clinical research co-ordinator at St. Joseph's Hospital, said her father 'was very studious, loving and artistic. He was also very adventurous. I really admired his drive to move from the Soviet Union to here, and then learn the language as well. He was a wonderful dad.' In a statement, the HPO said 'Misha graciously' devoted 40 years of his life to the orchestra and that it was 'honoured to have worked with Mikhail Brat.' In 1986, Spectator reviewer Ken Gee attended a HPO candlelight concert at the Royal Botanical Gardens, featuring Brat as a soloist. He said Brat shone playing Prokofiev's Violin Concerto No. 2 in G minor. 'It's tricky to set tempos in Prokofiev,' wrote Gee. 'To his credit, Brat took a freewheeling approach which let the varying moods of the music find their own speeds. He gave time for the more beautiful melodies to breathe.' Brat was born June 11, 1937, in Odessa to a pair of music teachers. The family was relocated to Siberia when the Germans invaded the Soviet Union in 1941, but returned after the war. He studied at the Odessa Conservatory and the Leningrad Conservatory before going to Lviv to work with its symphony and teach at the conservatory. Brat arrived in Hamilton with $300, a violin and a pile of concert posters. He said he was not permitted to bring newspaper clippings of his reviews because Soviet authorities feared they contained messages in code. Brat is survived by son Alex, daughter Katya and a grandson. He is also survived by his first wife Alla and his second wife Theresa. Error! Sorry, there was an error processing your request. There was a problem with the recaptcha. Please try again. You may unsubscribe at any time. By signing up, you agree to our terms of use and privacy policy . This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google privacy policy and terms of service apply. Want more of the latest from us? Sign up for more at our newsletter page .
Fox News
4 hours ago
- Fox News
The Quiz #438 - Miss Susie Had a Steamboat
Think you can dance your way through trivia? Play. Share. Listen with choreographer and former Dancing with the Stars pro dancer Maksim Chmerkovskiy. Israel vs. Iran
Yahoo
9 hours ago
- Yahoo
The 5-Ingredient Salad Natalie Portman Ate For Breakfast, Lunch, And Dinner As A Kid
Natalie Portman is an iconic American actress, but like many great Americans her story did not begin on these shores. Portman was born in Jerusalem to Jewish parents, and all of them left Israel for the U.S. when she was four years old. But the family didn't leave all the ways of the Old World behind, including -- of course -- food. On an episode of Dish Podcast, Portman joined its hosts for a wide-ranging discussion about food, including common dishes from her childhood. Portman quickly jumped to a simple chopped salad with a few ingredients. "My mom was just constantly making that salad," she laughed. The childhood salad, according to Portman, was "usually just cucumber and tomato. Sometimes parsley, but often just cucumber and tomato with lemon, olive oil, salt. And it's just all we eat, all the time, every meal." All of these are common salad ingredients in the Mediterranean basin -- think a fattoush salad with tomatoes, cucumbers, and parsley -- and they're likely staples for Portman's Israeli family. Read more: 6 Kirkland Olive Oils, Ranked Worst To Best Natalie Portman is famously vegan, meaning her diet excludes animal meat and products, including cheese, yogurt, and other items commonly found in Mediterranean cuisine. However, the Mediterrranean diet is a way of life that's already heavily focused on seasonal produce for rich flavor. A typical Mediterranean dinner is not necessarily as animal-dependent as, say, a classic American meal. Mediterranean food is therefore very easy to make vegan-friendly. Check out these five recipes for heart-healthy vegan Greek and Mediterranean dishes, like a classic red pepper hummus that is naturally vegan or a vegan spanakopita recipe that uses rice instead of feta cheese. Portman isn't the only American actress connected to both salads and Mediterranean ancestry. Jennifer Aniston's viral daily salad inspired our tabbouleh-like salad recipe, tweaking her plate with cucumbers, parsley, an olive oil-lemon dressing, and more. Aniston's father, a Greek immigrant and actor in his own right, likely would have recognized many of these flavors from his youth, similar to Portman's salad memories today. Hungry for more? Sign up for the free Daily Meal newsletter for delicious recipes, cooking tips, kitchen hacks, and more, delivered straight to your inbox. Read the original article on The Daily Meal.
