Sandipan Dhar's father accuses Joondalup Health Campus doctors of lies over toddler's death
The father of a toddler who died at a Perth hospital after presenting to the emergency department two days earlier has walked out of a coronial inquest into his son's death, accusing medical staff of lying in their evidence.
Sandipan Dhar was 21 months old when he died at Joondalup Health Campus on March 24 last year.
An autopsy later revealed he died due to complications from undiagnosed leukaemia.
Sandipan's father Sanjoy Dhar left the court as hospital doctor Dr Yii Siow was giving evidence.
'I cannot take anymore lies,' he told the court.
'I am just exiting myself.
'It's too much for me to take.'
The WA Coroner's Court inquest is trying to discern whether blood tests could have detected the blood disease earlier and spared Sandipan's life.
Sandipan had a fever for about three weeks after he received routine vaccinations.
One GP told the court on the first day of the inquest he 'just couldn't ignore the parental concern' and sent the family to Joondalup Hospital with a letter requesting blood tests on March 22.
His parents took Sandipan to the ED that day but left the hospital after about five hours, without his bloods being taken.
Sandipan was brought back two days later and died that evening.
The allocated nurse and junior doctor on duty told the inquest on Tuesday they didn't recall Saraswati and Sanjoy Dhar insisting on blood tests.
Dr O'Hearrain told the court on Wednesday he also did not remember Mr Dhar asking for the blood tests, referring to Sandipan's parents as 'very reasonable' and 'patient.'
Coroner Sarah Linton suggested cultural differences could have influenced the degree of concern expressed by the parents.
'There certainly seems to be disconnect between how concerned they say they were … and how they seemed to you,' she told Dr Caolan O'Hearrain incourt.
Mr Dhar said he did not know he had to demand his child's needs in a specific way.
'We've been polite. We didn't consider to raise our voice because other patients are in the other beds,' he said outside court.
Mr Dhar said he asked Dr O'Hearrain 'minimum, three times' to ask Dr Siow, to take a blood test.
Dr Siow told the court Sandipan looked well and his parents were calm on March 22.
'They appeared really calm and relaxed to me. I didn't think there was a heightened level of concern,' she told the court.
Dr Siow told the court she and the family even joked at one point about mothers always being right.
She said the family did not ask for a blood test and if they had insisted on one, it would have been an 'easy decision' to complete it.
The court heard there was conflicting evidence on whether the family were told to leave the ED on March 22, or whether they left of their own accord.
Mr Dhar said outside court Dr Siow had asked the family to leave, but she was not questioned on that on Wednesday.
She will continue to be questioned on Thursday, when the inquest continues.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
News.com.au
an hour ago
- News.com.au
‘Being punished': 35-year-old Aussie reveals rental nightmare
A single mum who spends over 60 per cent of her income on rent says her own home has made her physically ill. Genevieve, 35, lives in a small apartment with her 10-year-old son in Queensland, and almost all her money goes towards keeping a roof over their heads. Genevieve is just trying to survive, so when she discovered mould in her rental, she had no financial options. She couldn't afford to rush out and buy a dehumidifier or a bunch of fans, so she contacted her real estate agent. However, nothing was done, and in the meantime, she and her son got sick. 'There have always been ongoing issues with moisture on the carpet,' she said. 'I raised the issue last November that there was quite a lot of mould and black mould, but I haven't heard anything back. 'Then I noticed more mould on our clothes, shoes and bags.' The young mum's rent is $453 weekly, and she earns around $750 weekly, leaving her with less than $300 to cover everything else. 'I feel like I spend 90 per cent of my income on rent,' she told 'Fortnightly, it is about $1500, and then I'm paying close to $1000 on rent, and the rest goes on bills.' Genevieve said it isn't uncommon for her to end up in a 'deficit' after spending money on the essentials. 'If I'm not in the deficit, I use the rest on groceries,' she said. To make the $300 she's left with stretch, she's cancelled subscriptions and her health insurance, bought as much as she could second-hand, and often relied on charities for food and basics. She said two contractors were sent out to the property and confirmed there was a 'long-serving mould' issue, but nothing further has been done. Meanwhile, she noticed her and her son's health started to go downhill. 'He started waking up with nose bleeds like twice a week. He has asthma so I am concerned about him,' she said The mum has also noticed that if she and her son are out for most of the day, their breathing improves and then declines if they spend more time in their rental. It also wasn't just the mould in general; the rental she was spending most of her money on wasn't comfortable to live in – the damp carpet was a major issue. 'If you walked around in socks, you had to change them after about an hour because they'd get wet,' she explained. Genevieve's said fixing the mould issues would involve extensive work to address the damp problem, and there's certainly nothing she can do as a tenant. It's not a simple fix of scrubbing away the mould. 'It'd be s**tfight for them and they're going to have to pull up the carpet plus treat the slab underneath for mould,' she said. Genevieve felt helpless because she could not fix the mould issue and create a better living situation for her son. 'I feel like I am being punished because I'm not earning enough, and so, therefore, I don't deserve a healthy standard,' she said. 'I just don't have the income and stability to do much. I'm already getting food vouchers and stuff like that from our local food services.' The 35-year-old said if she 'had the money', she'd have paid to pull up the carpet herself, but she's not in a financial position to do that. Ms Genevieve's financial situation is so dire that she launched a GoFundMe to raise funds to move into a new rental. She's thrilled and excited to move somewhere that doesn't have a damp carpet, but she's also saddened she spent months suffering and couldn't afford to make a change sooner.
ABC News
4 hours ago
- ABC News
The women of the 'sandwich generation' caring for young and old
I started to notice my 81-year-old mother, Di, struggling just under a year ago, when she texted me late on a Saturday night worrying about some legal paperwork and I could not get her to calm down. After that, she became increasingly anxious and depressed. She no longer took pleasure in the things she loved and began having trouble looking after herself day to day. Realising that mum needed serious professional help, we checked her into a psychiatric hospital for a short stay that turned into six months. Her decline was rapid. She seemed to wither before our eyes. There were falls, a broken arm, delirium, COVID, and, most likely dementia. She couldn't walk from bed to the toilet unaided. Only months prior, mum had lived alone and was independent. She had always been fearsome, a former school principal with a booming laugh and a single mother who made sure I had everything — a picture of self-sacrifice. We love each other to pieces, but also annoy each other like no-one else can. When I realised mum wouldn't be able to live on her own anymore, we planned for her to move into a granny flat at the back of our place when she left the hospital. I suddenly found myself part of what is sometimes called the "sandwich generation": people (mostly women) who have the task of being the primary carer for the generations on either side. My life was hectic even before mum became unwell. I'm an executive producer on the podcast Ladies, We Need to Talk and a parent to my two lovely and spirited neurodivergent kids, who are nine and 11. I knew it was going to be hard work, but nothing prepared me for the difficulty of trying to look after everyone all at once. Every day is spent frantically managing other people's needs, and our time spent together is mostly functional, keeping everyone warm, medicated, fed and showered. As well as helping mum after her release from hospital and getting the kids ready for school, a team of support workers for mum came and went daily, which required a tonne of admin and endless time on the phone. I often feel tired, and like my emotional reserves are used up on everybody else. It could break me on some days. But I'm not alone. There are around 1.5 million Aussies who are in this situation, and the numbers are rising. The 2022 Income and Labour Dynamics in Australia (the "HILDA") Survey, found that women were "considerably more likely" to be carers than men. As Australia's population ages, by 2050 the 85+ age group is expected to triple. We're also having babies later, which means women are often at the peak of their careers when they need to start caring for their kids and their elderly parents too. So, I wanted to find out what the sandwich generation can do to take care not only of the people around them, but of themselves. And for those not at that stage yet, how can we set ourselves up to survive this period? I met with Nasalifya Namwinga, a clinical psychologist and burnout researcher, who often sees how women carry most of the caregiving load, and how heavy this can be for them. "I think there's an expectation that as a woman, you'll provide this care. You're being pulled in three different directions and you are being stretched to meet the needs of these particular roles [as a mother, carer and partner]," she says. Namwinga says it can be helpful to have conversations about expectations of who does the care work early on, "while the parent actually has the capacity to engage or contribute". I've used the word burnout a lot in the past year. But I've often wondered how you know you are experiencing carer burnout as opposed to just being a bit tired and over it? Namwinga says there are three components to burnout: exhaustion, low efficacy and cynicism. I identify with "low efficacy" — stuff like missing kids' appointments, or being late on paying my bills — things that are not the norm for me. Namwinga says cynicism is also one to keep an eye on. "[Cynicism] might play out as anger or intense emotions that don't match how you feel about the thing that you're doing. Those are the feelings that come up that; 'I just wish I didn't have to do any of it.' That's probably a sign you're experiencing carer burnout." I think a lot of mothers and carers struggle with asking for help, because we're used to doing it all, and we are really good at juggling a million things. Namwinga says protecting ourselves from burnout is ultimately about "scaffolding" ourselves with support from others. "So if I start experiencing exhaustion to the point that I'm struggling to get out of bed, who can I call? And asking them for support when you need it. And that means you have to prioritise yourself." Phyllis, who is looking after her mother and children, thinks the term "sandwich generation" needs a rebrand. I spoke to Phyllis because I wanted to hear about women going through similar experiences. She is in the thick of it right now, caring for her 94-year-old mother, Barbara, and two teenage sons, who are 15 and 18, while also working four days a week. She's been her mum's main carer since Barbara's husband died 13 years ago. "He was the filter through which mum saw the world, so when he passed, I had to step into that role," she says. Barbara is in great health for a nonagenarian, but she doesn't drive anymore, and Greek is the language she's most comfortable with. So Phyllis is Barbara's emotional support, her taxi driver, her translator and personal assistant. She tries to see her mum twice a week, and they stay in constant phone contact. But she has set clear expectations with Barbara about how much she can offer as a carer while also trying to parent two teenagers. "My sons come first," she says. "You cannot in this day and age take your hands off the wheel. You can't just say 'hey they're teenagers now, go be free'. It adds a whole other layer of complexity to the parenting equation." As the primary carer, Phyllis can sometimes feel the pressure of non-stop demands from her mum. Coupled with exhaustion, it means Phyllis can sometimes lose her cool with her mum. "The boys have been present when I've argued with my mother and we've gone hammer and tongs and it's been really ugly. But then they also see when we make up," she says. The women staying single by choice in a world of relentless dating pressure The idea of modelling healthy relationships to your kids is something Namwinga leans into in her practice. "When we mess up as parents, it actually provides a beautiful moment for repair with our children, which teaches them something about relationships. It teaches them that you are not perfect," she says. "You can get things wrong. [Saying] 'I was wrong and I'm sorry', is a really powerful experience for a child to learn that if my parent doesn't have to be perfect, then maybe I don't have to be perfect either." Phyllis says there can also be little moments of beauty with her mother. "She can be a really complex, difficult character, but she's very loving and she's very kind and beneath all the bluster, is a very frightened, vulnerable little girl," she says. "And that's what I try and hold onto when times can be tough. "And it makes me emotional because, she's just such a force of nature. She's been through a lot of rejection and pain, and yet she's still who she is unapologetically. She's dealing with her frailties of aging with as much grace as she can muster." I recently spent the day with mum after she had been in respite care for about three weeks. I took her shopping and I could tell she thought she felt good about herself for the first time in a long while. It was so great to see her sparkling a bit. We went out for lunch and she told me about some friends she made in care, and how they get together to complain about the food. Having a chat with me was out of the ordinary for her; normally it's just a list of worries. It made me feel a bit lighter, like there was a light at the end of the tunnel. I know there'll be many more bad days ahead, but she's in a good place right now, and we've just signed the paperwork for her to stay in care permanently. But I'm also battling with something more existential as I watch my mum get older — a living grief for the woman she once was. A part of me is also preparing for the end. "It is a complex grief to be watching someone you love slip away from you," Namwinga tells me. "If they experience things like dementia, they're losing memories, they're losing mobility, [and] watching that process can be quite heartbreaking." It is a privilege to be in a position where I can care for my mum and be able to pay her back for a lot of the stuff she did raising me. If I was going to give any advice, it would be that it's going to happen way faster than you think. You think you've got years, but one event can just send everything spiralling out of control and change the whole world for them and for you. So talk to your parents early about their power of attorney, their enduring guardianship, about their will and final wishes. They're hard conversations to have, but it's much easier to have them sooner than later. The host of the Ladies, We Need To Talk, Yumi Stynes, once gave me some words of advice when I was having a bit of a shitty week: "Don't be heroic." So I've taken those words on board and it's now my current Sandwich Gen motto.
ABC News
4 hours ago
- ABC News
Australia's LGBTQIA+ youth report physical, verbal assault — but also queer joy
One in 10 LGBTQIA+ young people say they have been physically assaulted in the last year, according to a new landmark study. More than a third of those interviewed nationally had experienced physical harm for their identity in their lifetime. Minus18, a mental health charity for queer youth, released the data as part of their national Queer Youth Now survey. Almost 3,000 LGBTQIA+ young people aged between 13-25 were interviewed across Australia. Public discourse and debate surrounding Australia's queer community made the numbers unsurprising for project lead Alvi Ahmed. "It's still really confronting that we found nine in 10 LGBTQ+ young people in our survey had faced bullying, harassment, or violence due to their identity," he told the ABC. "[The reports of violence] are sadly consistent with previous studies done in this space as well. "And so the message is still loud and clear that these experiences are still happening. "Over half of young people [surveyed] had experienced verbal harassment as well in the past year, which is a big finding. "But importantly, there's so much that we can do to help combat anti-LGBTQ+ hate. "There's small actions people can take [to] make a real difference in the lives of queer young people." I came out to my first university class and a woman from class came to talk to me because her 10-year-old transgender son had never met another trans person. I was able to show a 10-year-old kid that there is a future for us. — National Youth Survey participant ❝ When my best friend came out to me it made me feel so proud because without each other we wouldn't have had the courage to be ourselves. I found euphoria through my friendship with her and my own unique relationship with gender through my autism. I feel things so different and it's beautiful. — National Youth Survey participant ❝ I feel the most happy and proud when I am walking around with my partner's hand in mine. — National Youth Survey participant ❝ My queer alliance at school is one of my favourite places to be at school. Love you guys!! — National Youth Survey participant A snapshot of Australia's young queer community Of the 2,724 young people aged between 13 to 25 surveyed, 64 per cent were transgender, gender-diverse or non-binary. Almost half were still in high school and more than a third lived in rural, regional or remote areas. The majority said they had first questioned or realised their identity about the age of 12. Minus18's chief executive Micah Scott said the data affirmed the "lived experience" of Australia's young LGBTQIA+ community. "It [also] gives us clear, actionable direction to improve the support systems they rely on," he said. "It tells us where to focus, what needs to change, and how we can better show up for queer youth across the country." The report, supported by the Telstra Foundation and aided by more than 20 community organisations, is the largest national survey of LGBTQIA+ youth in recent years. It provided a "vital" snapshot of the community, according to Minus18. Only six per cent of respondents felt the Australian government understood and listened to people like them. Many said they did not feel safe being completely open about their identity at school, in sports settings or at home. Having access to inclusive facilities and seeing visible support — like lanyards, posters and flags at school — also helped them feel accepted, according to the report. Where an LGBTQIA+ student group was available, 71 per cent said they got involved — but only half of the respondents had access to that kind of group. Mr Ahmed said there was a "discrepancy between what young people want and what they actually see on the ground". He added there were also differences between the experiences of those aged under 18 and those aged 18-25. "[There are] different ways in which people engage with community in terms of the events that they attend," he said. "Under 18s are more likely to attend queer formals or rainbow balls, and over 18s are more likely to attend public pride events. "Our interpretation of that is that often some public pride events aren't catered to those who are under 18, and so at Minus18 we base a lot of our events on the premise of creating a space for young people to connect." Finding queer joy in 'being seen and being celebrated' Amid reports of violence, harassment and fear, the survey also gave a spotlight to something "deeply" important — queer joy. A total of 79 per cent of LGBTQIA+ young people said they had felt a sense of "acceptance and inclusion" relating to their identity in the last year. A similar number said they had felt "pride or euphoria" for their identity. Despite 10 per cent of those surveyed saying they had "no-one" as a role model in their lives, others looked to friends, family, teachers, coworkers — as well as influencers and celebrities — for inspiration. Mr Ahmed said he wanted the report to show "what the future can be". "It shows us that queer young people are finding queer joy everywhere," he said. "They find it in friendship. They're finding it in support. They're finding it in being seen and being celebrated. "So we know that these moments matter deeply to young people. "By highlighting these queer joy experiences, we're trying to show that there is a future where queer young people can experience joy and euphoria and be celebrated for who they are. "So we hope these findings can help queer young people now, but also … into the future and help create a better environment for young people in a more safe and welcoming world."
