Sandipan Dhar's father accuses Joondalup Health Campus doctors of lies over toddler's death
The father of a toddler who died at a Perth hospital after presenting to the emergency department two days earlier has walked out of a coronial inquest into his son's death, accusing medical staff of lying in their evidence.
Sandipan Dhar was 21 months old when he died at Joondalup Health Campus on March 24 last year.
An autopsy later revealed he died due to complications from undiagnosed leukaemia.
Sandipan's father Sanjoy Dhar left the court as hospital doctor Dr Yii Siow was giving evidence.
'I cannot take anymore lies,' he told the court.
'I am just exiting myself.
'It's too much for me to take.'
The WA Coroner's Court inquest is trying to discern whether blood tests could have detected the blood disease earlier and spared Sandipan's life.
Sandipan had a fever for about three weeks after he received routine vaccinations.
One GP told the court on the first day of the inquest he 'just couldn't ignore the parental concern' and sent the family to Joondalup Hospital with a letter requesting blood tests on March 22.
His parents took Sandipan to the ED that day but left the hospital after about five hours, without his bloods being taken.
Sandipan was brought back two days later and died that evening.
The allocated nurse and junior doctor on duty told the inquest on Tuesday they didn't recall Saraswati and Sanjoy Dhar insisting on blood tests.
Dr O'Hearrain told the court on Wednesday he also did not remember Mr Dhar asking for the blood tests, referring to Sandipan's parents as 'very reasonable' and 'patient.'
Coroner Sarah Linton suggested cultural differences could have influenced the degree of concern expressed by the parents.
'There certainly seems to be disconnect between how concerned they say they were … and how they seemed to you,' she told Dr Caolan O'Hearrain incourt.
Mr Dhar said he did not know he had to demand his child's needs in a specific way.
'We've been polite. We didn't consider to raise our voice because other patients are in the other beds,' he said outside court.
Mr Dhar said he asked Dr O'Hearrain 'minimum, three times' to ask Dr Siow, to take a blood test.
Dr Siow told the court Sandipan looked well and his parents were calm on March 22.
'They appeared really calm and relaxed to me. I didn't think there was a heightened level of concern,' she told the court.
Dr Siow told the court she and the family even joked at one point about mothers always being right.
She said the family did not ask for a blood test and if they had insisted on one, it would have been an 'easy decision' to complete it.
The court heard there was conflicting evidence on whether the family were told to leave the ED on March 22, or whether they left of their own accord.
Mr Dhar said outside court Dr Siow had asked the family to leave, but she was not questioned on that on Wednesday.
She will continue to be questioned on Thursday, when the inquest continues.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
ABC News
35 minutes ago
- ABC News
GoodSam app volunteer Ashlin Fisher saves neighbour in cardiac arrest
When Geoff Percival collapsed in cardiac arrest and his partner called triple-0, it was not a paramedic who was the first responder; it was neighbour Ashlin Fisher. A few months earlier, the young mum from Broulee on the New South Wales south coast had downloaded NSW Ambulance's GoodSam responder application to her phone. The time had come to put it to the test. "It's a very loud, alarming alert … and I realised what it was and I had to run out the door," Ms Fisher said. When she arrived that fateful day in March last year, the 63-year-old was unconscious, and his partner was performing cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR). "I explained as best I could who I was and what I was … I asked her to put the phone on loudspeaker … and very quickly I didn't have to make any real decisions, triple-0 was just giving me instructions on what to do," she said. The frantic triple-0 call recorded the moment Ms Fisher arrived, with the operator responding: "We've got a GoodSam here? OK, alright … we're up to 300 compressions, I need you to keep going until that ambulance arrives." As Ms Fisher counted the compression alongside the operator, ambulance sirens blared in the background, and within two minutes a paramedic was in the room. Then the operator said, "Is that the paramedic on scene with you? OK, I'll leave you with them, you've all done a really good job, all the best now." Mr Percival recently got the chance to thank his good Samaritan. "I just think it was so lucky that she was able to respond. [My partner] was doing CPR on me … and Ashlin came along and I think you said, 'Can I take over?' and she said, 'Yes, please,'" he said. "It was good to have a third person come in and have some idea what to do until the paramedics arrived. According to NSW Ambulance, it takes a paramedic an average of nine to 10 minutes to reach a heart attack case. The GoodSam app aims to bridge that gap and is available to anyone 18 or older and able to perform CPR. When needed, an alarm on the responder's phone rings, and the person is asked if they can help. If they can, they receive the patient's address along with the location of any nearby defibrillator. GoodSam began in NSW in 2023, and so far about 9,600 volunteers have registered. NSW Ambulance GoodSam project officer Monika Sitkowski said volunteers had given CPR to 54 patients who had survived. "They're not getting oxygen into their vital organs, especially their brain, so we need to get volunteers who are nearby to start that CPR process and keep them alive until paramedics arrive. "[GoodSam] is about saving your neighbours. It's about saving your friends and family. There's a huge increase in survival when you've got early CPR to that person in need." NSW Ambulance said it was aiming for 50,000 registered volunteers across the state. "That would probably mean that there's a GoodSam responder nearby to every person who goes into cardiac arrest," Ms Sitkowski said. Versions of the GoodSam app are also used in South Australia and Victoria, while Western Australia's St John Ambulance has a similar app.
SBS Australia
36 minutes ago
- SBS Australia
As I turned 50, I was doing everything right. Then it all went so wrong
Unexpected challenges arose for Snezana right before she was due to go on an overseas trip for her 50th birthday. Source: Supplied SBS turns 50 in 2025 and so do hundreds of thousands of Australians. Insight asks — is turning 50 a big deal? From mid-life crises to menopause, finding undiscovered family members and starting afresh, watch Insight episode Turning 50 Tuesday 10 June at 8.30PM on SBS or live on SBS On Demand . Turning 50 was an exciting time for me. Two years earlier, I contracted a rare form of double pneumonia (simultaneous infection in both lungs) that sent me into respiratory and heart failure . After coming out of an induced coma, I had to learn to read, walk and talk again. I was finally bouncing back to my normal self. So, with a dream family holiday to Italy planned as a 50th birthday celebration, there was a lot to look forward to. This was about to change drastically. There was absolutely no reason for any concern when I sent it off. I had no signs or symptoms of bowel cancer; I was very health conscious and active with swimming, hiking, and long walks with my dogs Daisy and Olly. Plus, my husband Dave had already done three tests with no issues. About a month later, the results came back positive for me needing to get a colonoscopy. After the colonoscopy, I was told that with many suspicious polyps, it looked like I had cancer. At this stage, we all believed it was likely to be stage 1 or possibly stage 2 cancer. The plan was to remove a section of the sigmoid colon and 14 lymph nodes. At the surgery appointment, the specialist said we'd need to schedule the operation for two weeks' time. I said that we'd have to postpone it as I was going to Italy with my husband and our daughter Emma on a holiday that had been years in the making. We left the meeting that day in high spirits. Our Italy trip was only weeks away and the surgery and estimated recovery time seemed relatively straightforward. Rome, Venice, Florence, Sorrento, and the Amalfi Coast were amazing. We arrived home refreshed, tanned and relaxed and in a good headspace to cope with what was to come. A few days before surgery, I was sent for an MRI to double-check something that they had seen on my liver in a previous scan. Prepped and ready to go — still feeling good — the MRI results came back the morning of surgery. There was a lesion on my liver. Although it was not confirmed by pathology until later, in my heart, I knew straight away that I had gone from possibly stage 2 (at the worst) to stage 4 metastatic cancer. I had no time to process this and went into theatre knowing that my husband and daughter had no idea of the challenges we were about to face. This surgery, that was meant to take six hours, took 10 as they also had to remove a quarter of my liver. And then came the news that I would be starting 12 rounds of chemotherapy. No one can really prepare you for chemotherapy. The chemotherapy process itself and its side effects were tough — including neuropathy (nerve damage and pain) and neutropenia (an abnormally low count of white blood cells). The pain would be triggered from even touching the kitchen bench or turning on the tap, but I challenged myself to work out different ways of managing it. Wearing gloves and using elbows became well-honed skills. Some days were unbearably painful; the sheer lack of energy and strength to get up each day and endure the side effects was difficult. Almost three-quarters of the way through treatment, I got a chest infection and bilateral blood clots in my lungs. This set back my recovery and forced me to rest much more. I would really listen to my body and rest when I was struggling with the physical symptoms. I would think about all the things I have to be grateful for in my life. I could still cook each day, catch up on all the shows I never had time for before, and appreciate the beauty of the sunrise. Mentally, I felt strong and kept a positive outlook. Focusing one day at a time would help me get through it. I don't have extended family in Australia, so my friends are a true extension of my family. Without my dear friends Noeline, Helen and my second mum Millie, who I call Aunty, I would have been a recluse during treatment. They insisted on taking me to my appointments so I would never be alone. We'd also often go to the beach or park to walk, enjoy the sea air, sit and talk. Just being out in nature gave me the strength to keep fighting. Without the unwavering support and love of my family and core group of friends, my journey would be so much harder. It's with absolute joy I say that as of 19 May of this year, I am officially in remission. We will continue to monitor every three months, but for now, the treatment has worked. Being 'cancer-free' does not mean I am out of the woods. Anyone facing stage 4 cancer would also know this. It means that in this moment, I can focus on healing, recovering and enjoying the little things in life. I haven't been able to return to work but am now able to take my dogs out for walks twice a day now, which is something I couldn't muster before. We're also planning another trip to Europe next year — this time to Amsterdam. Going through cancer treatment in my 50th year made me realise you just don't know when your time is up. So, enjoy it and don't get bogged down in what you can't control. I now might be clicking, clacking and cracking as I roll out of bed each day. But it's an extra day I once might not have had. Your stories have shaped SBS for half a century. Together, we're just getting started. Join us as we celebrate 50 years of belonging on our SBS50 portal and SBS50 content hub . Share this with family and friends
ABC News
an hour ago
- ABC News
Doctor banned for sexual relationship and inadequate care provided to vulnerable patient
A "selfish, cruel and calculated" GP has been banned from practising for four years for having sex with a vulnerable, mentally-unwell patient who he also "dangerously" prescribed high-risk medication. South Australian doctor Indren Moodley's registration as a medical practitioner was suspended in late 2021 over allegations he "comprehensively breached the boundaries of the doctor-patient relationship". The Medical Board of Australia referred a complaint about the then-doctor on three grounds, alleging professional misconduct to the South Australian Civil and Administrative Tribunal, which has cancelled his registration until February 2029. In its ruling, published this month but delivered in February, the tribunal found Mr Moodley preyed on the "serious and complex" vulnerabilities of the young adult female patient, who was more than two decades younger than him. "We are satisfied that the respondent used the position of trust he had developed with the patient to exploit those vulnerabilities and to manipulate her, essentially in a calculated campaign to groom her to satisfy his own needs," the tribunal found. The ruling noted the then-doctor obtained the patient's mobile phone number from her medical records three weeks after she first saw him, and they exchanged 909 text messages involving "inappropriate, personal, non-clinical and sexual" content over 12 days. The tribunal noted Mr Moodley had invited the patient to his home and offered her alcohol despite knowing she had recently attended an alcohol detox program. He also had sexual intercourse with her. "It is particularly egregious that, despite the respondent's knowledge of the patient's alcohol addiction and her recent discharge from hospital for alcohol detoxification, he supplied and encouraged the patient to drink wine on the occasion they had sexual intercourse," the tribunal found. It also noted the then-doctor's care of the patient was inadequate as he failed to take a detailed medical history, a mental health referral lacked necessary details and he prescribed "high-risk" benzodiazepines inappropriately, including while she was in hospital under the care of other medical practitioners. "The respondent took advantage of the patient's multiple vulnerabilities and abused the power imbalance between them for his personal sexual satisfaction," the tribunal's ruling states. "His conduct was seriously unethical, predatory and cruel. "As her treating practitioner, the respondent was well aware of her vulnerabilities." The ruling also published an excerpt of a statement from the patient, in which she said Mr Moodley's conduct had "a big impact" on her, including causing sleeping problems and a distrust of men. "I am absolutely hurt and feel used and manipulated by a person who knew my physical and mental illnesses," she said in the statement. The tribunal noted no complaints had been previously made about Mr Moodley, but there was a "limit to the positive weight we can place on this given our findings as to the selfish, cruel and calculated campaign the respondent engaged in to satisfy his needs to the patient's serious detriment". It also noted he had admitted the grounds of complaint made against him and had shown insight and remorse. In the ruling, the tribunal said a "strong sanction" against Mr Moodley was necessary to protect the public, and acknowledged he had struggled with his mental health, professional and personal embarrassment and unemployment since his suspension in 2021. The tribunal reprimanded the doctor, cancelled his registration and banned him from providing any health service or applying for registration for four years from the date of the ruling on February 10, 2025. He was also banned from using the title "doctor" or "Dr" while unregistered.
