Hospital bosses say new evidence casts doubt on UK nurse Letby's baby murder convictions
By Michael Holden
LONDON (Reuters) - A public inquiry examining how British nurse Lucy Letby was able to murder babies in her care should be suspended because new evidence casts real doubt on her convictions, the lawyer for the hospital's senior managers said on Tuesday.
Letby, 35, was found guilty of murdering seven children and attempting to murder eight more between June 2015 and June 2016 while working in the neonatal unit of the Countess of Chester Hospital (COCH) in northern England, making her Britain's most prolific serial child killer of modern times.
But medical experts have since publicly challenged the evidence on which she was convicted, casting doubt on whether the babies were murdered.
Letby's lawyer has applied to the Criminal Cases Review Commission (CCRC), which examines potential miscarriages of justice, to have her convictions re-examined.
"There now appears to be a real likelihood that there are alternative explanations for these deaths and unexplained collapses, namely poor clinical management and care and natural causes," Kate Blackwell, lawyer for the senior managers at the COCH, said in written submissions to the inquiry, set up to determine how the killings went undetected.
She asked for the inquiry to be paused until there was clarity as to Letby's involvement in the deaths, as determined by a proper appeals process.
"If there is evidence to indicate that there are alternative explanations, then it would be wrong for the inquiry to ignore it because it is inconvenient."
On Monday, the inquiry chair Kathryn Thirlwall said at the start of closing submissions she would hear arguments why the inquiry should be paused after the managers, a senior lawmaker and Letby's own lawyer asked for a suspension.
Amidst the doubts voiced about Letby's guilt, police are still investigating whether she murdered other babies, and have expanded their inquiry into possible corporate manslaughter at the COCH, which is focused on the hospital's senior leadership, to also consider gross negligence manslaughter by individuals.
Blackwell said senior managers accepted they had got things wrong, but hoped the evidence to the inquiry had shown their actions were made in good faith. The lawyer said the managers vociferously denied accusations they "deliberately and knowingly" protected a murderer.
She said if Thirlwall did not have the power to pause the inquiry, she should ask the health minister to do so.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Insider
an hour ago
- Business Insider
Kenya on edge as protesters and police have a go at each other
Kenya's civil order may be hanging by a thread following the suspicious death of blogger and educator Albert Ojwang in police custody. Videos of protesters being dispersed by tear gas highlight this point, given how reminiscent it is of the 2024 anti-bill protests, which eventually called for the resignation of President William Ruto. Kenya faces political turmoil following the death of blogger and educator Albert Ojwang in police custody. Protests erupted over the incident, leading to clashes with police using tear gas and resulting in property damages. Ojwang, known for his critical social media commentary, was arrested and later declared dead under contested circumstances. Kenya is on edge as public indignation mounts over the unexplained murder of blogger and educator Albert Ojwang while in police custody. On Thursday, Kenyan police fired tear gas at protestors in Nairobi, scattering crowds protesting what many are calling a state-sanctioned death. The protests on the day led to the destruction of properties, particularly vehicles, which had been set ablaze, as they called for the resignation of Deputy Police Chief Eliud Lagat, as reported by Reuters. However, later reports indicated that a police officer had been arrested in connection with the case. Additionally, the police revealed that they are investigating six cops, according to national broadcaster KBC. Despite these developments, the retainment of the police chief makes it uncertain how Kenyans would continue to react. The anti-bill protests that shook the country to its core last year, began as a protest against a new legislature and even when that was addressed, protests intensified, calling for the resignation of the president, William Ruto. Backstory of the current Kenyan protests Ojwang, a 31-year-old renowned for his politically inflammatory comments on X (previously Twitter) and Facebook, was detained last week in Homa Bay, a town in western Kenya, for reportedly attacking Deputy Inspector General of Police Eliud Lagat on social media. Days later, he was reported dead in police custody. Authorities first stated that Ojwang died as a result of head injuries caused by striking a cell wall. The day prior, Police Inspector General Douglas Kanja apologised for implying that Ojwang committed suicide. What William Ruto said Additionally, the president of the country, William Ruto, broke his 72-hour silence on the issue after outrage over the educator's death shifted towards him. 'I fully expect that the truth about what happened to Ojwang will be established in due course, and that justice will be served,' Ruto said. 'Like most Kenyans, and especially as a parent, I received the news of the death of Albert Ojwang while in police custody with utter shock and deep dismay.
Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
Starmer under pressure to reveal migrant crime numbers
Sir Keir Starmer will come under pressure next week to reveal the 'hidden' scale of migrant crime. Robert Jenrick, the shadow justice secretary, is to propose a law change that would force the Government to publish the data identifying the migrant nationalities with the highest crime rates. He is laying an amendment to Labour's Crime and Policing Bill that would require ministers to publish every quarter the nationality, country of birth, visa route, asylum status and method of entry of everyone convicted and sentenced to crimes in the Crown Court and magistrates court. Mr Jenrick plans to force it to a vote of MPs on the floor of the Commons and said that, if passed, it would end the 'shameful cover-up' by state authorities which has prevented the public from being told the scale of crime committed by foreign nationals. It would mirror an approach by some US states and Denmark, where league tables compiled from the government data show the crime rates of the top four nations – Kuwait, Tunisia, Lebanon and Somalia – are eight times those of Danish nationals. The Telegraph has previously published data on migrant crime rates but only as a result of the figures being released by Government departments under freedom of information laws. That research suggested that foreign nationals were convicted of up to a quarter of sex crimes despite census data showing that they made up just 9.3 per cent of the population. Mr Jenrick said: 'We need to know the truth about who is committing crime in our country so we can protect the British public. 'Right now we are importing a crime wave. Data that has been dragged out of the authorities shows migrants from some countries are enormously more likely to commit violent and sexual offences. 'Indicative statistics suggest Albanians are 153 times more likely to be convicted of drug offences, while Eritreans are 20 times more likely to commit a sexual offence. We need the full, unvarnished truth. 'Keir Starmer has a choice. Will he release the data about migrant crime, as countries like Denmark do, and act on it? Or will he instigate yet another shameful cover-up?' Credit: Robert Jenrick Labour has proposed its own league tables of migrant crime rates based on the nationalities and foreign criminals living in communities while awaiting deportation. Albanians, Romanians and Poles are expected to be among the top nationalities for crimes including violence, robbery, theft and drug production and dealing. It is understood Yvette Cooper, the Home Secretary, overruled Home Office officials who have previously claimed it is too difficult to provide quality data on foreign criminals. She has told them she wants it published by the end of the year. Her immigration white paper also proposed that the Home Office should be informed of all crimes committed by foreign nationals in the UK as part of a deportation crackdown. At present, foreign criminals are only reported to the Home Office if they receive a jail sentence. A year behind bars is the automatic threshold for deportation from the UK, although those with prison terms under one year can still be considered for removal. It is thought unlikely, however, that Labour will back Mr Jenrick's proposal although it is likely to be backed by Nigel Farage's Reform UK. Data previously published by The Telegraph and obtained through FOI legislation by the Centre for Migration control revealed that foreign nationals accounted for between one in eight (12.5 per cent) and as many as one in six (16.4 per cent) of all convictions in England and Wales. According to the new data, 872,488 convictions were recorded on the police national computer between 2021 and 2023, of which 833,522 had identifiable nationality information. Foreign nationals accounted for 104,000, but there were a further 38,966 where the nationality was 'unknown'. Broaden your horizons with award-winning British journalism. Try The Telegraph free for 1 month with unlimited access to our award-winning website, exclusive app, money-saving offers and more.
Yahoo
4 hours ago
- Yahoo
Kristi Noem Mocked With Awkward Visual Reminder After Her Clueless 2-Word Attack
Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem on Thursday accused Sen. Alex Padilla (D-Calif.) of 'political theater' for attempting to ask questions at a press conference. Padilla was roughed up, forced out, and handcuffed. 'Nobody knew who he was, he didn't say who he was,' Noem claimed during a Fox News interview, despite footage showing Padilla clearly identifying himself during the encounter. 'I would have loved to have sat down and had a conversation with him, that coming into a press conference like this is political theater.' Her agency sent a similar message on her behalf via Twitter, also calling it 'political theatre,' using the British spelling of the word. But critics were quick to point out that when it comes to 'political theater,' Noem seems to have her own costuming department. She's done a number of photo ops and other publicity stunts in a variety of uniforms and outfits, leading some to dub her 'ICE Barbie' and 'Cosplay Kristi.' Her critics fired back on X with some photographic evidence:
