Girl knocked down when confession box door fell on her settles case for €25,000
A girl who was knocked down and hit her head when the door of a church confession box fell on her during mass has settled a
High Court
action for €25,000.
Zofia Adamczyk was two years old when the confessional door – which, it was claimed, was unhinged − fell on her, trapping her underneath.
Her counsel, Robert Beatty SC, with Mark Doyle BL, told the High Court the girl had been attending mass with her mother when the incident happened at Oblates Church of Mary Immaculate, Inchicore, Dublin, 14 years ago.
Counsel said the door to the confession box weighed about 15kg and it was a 'traumatising incident' for the child.
READ MORE
Some men had to lift the door off the child, who had also struck her head on the stump of a decorative Christmas tree. A section of the church was under renovation at the time.
Ms Adamczyk (16) of Saggart, Co Dublin had, through her father Andrzej Adamczyk, sued Fr Oliver Barry over the accident on March 4th, 2011.
It was claimed that the door to the confessional fell on top of the toddler after she allegedly tried to open it.
It was claimed there was an alleged failure to take any or any adequate precaution for the child's safety and there was an alleged failure to take any reasonable care to ensure she would be reasonably safe whilst in the church.
It was further contended that there was an alleged failure to ensure that adequate warnings or signs were in place around the confessional while it was under renovation.
Counsel told the court he did not think liability was an issue but causation was at issue in the case.
The little girl was later diagnosed as suffering from head pain and she had bumps to her head, along with some restriction in side-to-side movement, bruising and tenderness. She later had panic attacks and claustrophobia which, it was claimed, had a severe impact on her daily life.
Approving the settlement, Mr Justice Paul Coffey said he was satisfied, considering the difficulties in relation to causation in the case, that the offer was fair and reasonable.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
2 hours ago
- Irish Times
Jozef Puska's sisters-in-law could not have known about murder when they burned clothes, court hears
Jozef Puska's sisters-in-law could not have known and did not believe he murdered Ashling Murphy when they burned the clothes he was wearing at the time he murdered the schoolteacher, defence lawyers have told the Central Criminal Court . Lawyers for Jozefina Grundzova (32) and Viera Gaziova (40) delivered their closing speeches to a jury on Tuesday afternoon. The two women are on trial with their husbands, Marek Puska (36) and Lubomir Puska jnr (38). Jozef Puska, a brother of Marek and Lubomir jnr, murdered Ms Murphy (23) on January 12th, 2022 by stabbing her on the canal towpath outside Tullamore, Co Offaly. Marek and Lubomir jnr are on trial accused of withholding information relating to the murder while Ms Grundzova and Ms Gaziova are accused of impeding Puska's apprehension or prosecution by burning his clothes. READ MORE All accused have pleaded not guilty to all charges. They were all living with Puska, his partner Lucia, and 14 children at Lynally Grove, Mucklagh, Co Offaly when the offences are alleged to have occurred. The trial heard that in a statement to gardaí, Ms Gaziova said that on the night of the murder, Lubomir jnr and Marek spoke to Puska in his bedroom and afterwards, Lubomir jnr told her that Puska had 'confessed that he killed a girl'. Paul Murray SC, for Ms Grundzova, on Tuesday told the jury that for his client to be guilty, the jury must be satisfied that she knew what Puska had done when she helped Ms Gaziova to burn the clothes. Counsel told the jury that 'hindsight is a wonderful thing' but they must look at the circumstances in the Puska household in the immediate aftermath of the murder. When his client burned Puska's clothes, she did not have any of the evidence that would later prove his guilt, Mr Murray said. The nub of the prosecution case, counsel said, is that Ms Grundzova knew or believed Puska to be guilty of the murder at a time when gardaí had arrested a different person. Mr Murray asked the jury to return a verdict of not guilty. Prosecutor Anne Marie Lawlor SC previously told the jury that all the accused knew what Puska had done shortly after 9.30pm on the night of the murder. She said Jozef told Lubomir jnr and Marek, who then relayed it to the others in the house. Ms Lawlor said the only reason for the withholding of evidence or burning of clothes was that they didn't want Puska to be apprehended or prosecuted for murder. Damien Colgan SC, for Ms Gaziova, told the jury that the 'crux of the case' is whether his client knew that Puska had stabbed Ms Murphy. Her view at that time, Mr Colgan said, was that Puska had been the victim of an assault. When she was told what Puska had said he did, she didn't believe it because she 'didn't believe Jozef was capable of killing anybody'. Kathleen Leader SC, for Lubomir jnr, said her client delayed but did not withhold information. She said he had a reasonable excuse for the delay and asked the jury to consider the 'natural sense of protection for his younger brother'. She said it is understandable he was reluctant to accept his brother had 'committed a truly horrific murder'. Ms Leader said that by January 18th, Lubomir jnr was 'squarely supporting the prosecution', telling them everything he knew. Ms Leader said the law does not require people to be 'superhuman' as she asked the jury to acquit her client. Ms Justice Caroline Biggs has begun her charge to the jury and will continue tomorrow.
Irish Times
2 hours ago
- Irish Times
US woman awoke in Boston hotel to ‘somebody on top' raping her, jury in Dublin firefighter trial told
The Boston woman who claims she was raped by a Dublin firefighter told a US court she woke up in a hotel room to find 'somebody on top of her' raping her. The 29-year-old attorney testified for a second day in the trial of Terence Crosbie (39) in Suffolk superior courthouse in Boston on Tuesday. She claimed she was raped by Mr Crosbie, who was visiting the US city with the Dublin Fire Brigade, while his colleague slept in a shared hotel room. Mr Crosbie (39) was arrested on rape charges over St Patrick's Day weekend last year. He denies the charges and has pleaded not guilty. READ MORE His accuser previously testified to meeting Liam O'Brien at The Black Rose bar on March 14th, 2024. Mr O'Brien and Mr Crosbie had flown into Boston with their fire brigade colleagues to march in Boston's St Patrick's Day parade. The complainant testified on Tuesday that she didn't know Mr O'Brien was sharing a room when she returned with him from the bar to the Omni Parker House hotel after an evening of dancing. She testified that she and Mr O'Brien had consensual sex and then she went to the bathroom. When she came back from the bathroom, she said Mr O'Brien was asleep 'taking up the majority of the bed' and was snoring loudly, so she slept in the other bed, getting under the covers naked with the bathroom light still on. She told the court in tears that she 'woke up to somebody on top of me' and they were raping her. 'This person was taller than Liam and was not bald and I could hear Liam snoring,' she said. The trial had previously heard that Mr O'Brien, unlike Mr Crosbie, was bald. She testified that Mr O'Brien snored 'continuously' throughout the alleged assault. She testified that the man, later identified as Mr Crosbie, also disparaged Mr O'Brien while assaulting her. She claimed that while Mr Crosbie was having sex with her, he said: 'I know you want this; [Mr O'Brien] can't even do this for you – what a loser.' 'What are you doing?' she said she asked Mr Crosbie when she realised what was happening. 'I also did say: 'Stop!'' she told the court. She said she felt Mr Crosbie's weight on top of her and tried to get away, eventually managing to manoeuvre her legs off the side of the bed and break free. She testified that Mr Crosbie continued to follow her around the hotel room, trying to kiss her. She said she was able to collect her clothes and went to the bathroom. Mr Crosbie tried to get in and 'was jiggling the handle' after she locked the door, she told the court. She then left the hotel and texted a friend at 2:18am about the alleged assault , according to testimony. 'I hate everyone,' she wrote. 'What the f**k is wrong with people.' She told her friend that she woke up and a guy was having sex with her, 'telling me I wanted it and telling me how pathetic it was that his friend couldn't give that', the court heard. She then walked home and took an Uber taxi to a hospital. On cross-examination by Mr Crosbie's defence team, she was asked about her level of intoxication, psychiatric medication and alleged discrepancies in her accounts to medical staff, law enforcement and the grand jury. Defence attorney Daniel C Reilly asserted that she walked rather than ran out of the hotel, as stated previously. The woman replied that this was a 'figure of speech'. Mr Reilly questioned the complainant repeatedly about her accounts of the lighting in the hotel room and noted that her testimony did not include details about the defendant's birthmarks or tattoos. 'But again, you didn't notice any body marks or tattoos,' Mr Reilly said. 'I was trying not to look,' the complainant said. The trial continues in Boston.
Irish Times
2 hours ago
- Irish Times
More than 90 personnel involved in Cab searches targeting suspected drug trafficker
More than 90 personnel were involved in a series of searches by the Criminal Assets Bureau (Cab) in Co Kerry on Tuesday, resulting in the seizure of more than €200,000. The searches carried out on Tuesday targeted the assets of an individual suspected of involvement in drug trafficking. Cab officers, gardaí from the Kerry division, the Garda Armed Support Unit and the Customs Dog Unit conducted searches at residences and businesses across the county. During the operation, Cab officers seized more than €200,000 in cash, electronic devices and 'documents of evidential value', a Garda representative said. READ MORE 'This investigation remains ongoing,' they said.
