Coercive control victims 'are not being believed' by authorities
An author and coercive control survivor who suffered years of abuse at the hands of a serving garda said abused women are 'not being believed' by the authorities.
Nicola Hanney spoke out after new figures provided by the DPP confirm there has been just 25 successful prosecutions since legislation making coercive control a criminal offence was enacted six years ago.
This is despite separate figures which confirm more than 60,000 calls alleging coercive control were made to garda stations across the country last year alone. Pic: AlvaroOut of the 25 convictions recorded since January 2019, just two people were convicted on a sole charge of coercive control. But in these two instances, which include Ms Hanney's case, the perpetrator was originally charged with more offences.
In her critically acclaimed memoir, Stronger: What Didn't Kill Me, Made Me, Ms Hanney detailed the living hell she endured at the hands of Garda Paul Moody, who was sentenced to three years and three months in prison for coercive control in 2023.
This abuse included smashing up her apartment, threatening to take their newborn son away while she received cancer treatment and isolating her from her friends and family. Nicola Hanney. Pic: RTÉ
Ms Hanney described coercive control an 'assault on the mind', and said it is 'shocking' more perpetrators have not been convicted.
She told Extra.ie: 'I'm one of the two [where the sole charge was coercive control]. There were more charges to start, but they were dwindled down to one charge of coercive control.'
The resolute mother, who was being treated for stage four cancer at the time of her abuse ordeal, said all women 'deserve to be free'. She added: 'It's a life sentence for women, but the evidence shows they aren't being believed. Domestic abuse is not being taken seriously in the country still. Pic: Getty Images
'Two convictions [for sole coercive control] is shocking. Coercive control is an assault on your mind, it's a horrible form of abuse.'
In response to queries from Extra.ie, the Office of the DPP confirmed 'the total number of convictions recorded on our case management system for the offence of coercive control contrary to section 39 Domestic Violence Act 2018, since the enactment of the Act is 25'.
Asked how many of these were for standalone coercive control convictions, a spokeswoman confirmed: 'Just two.' Nicola Hanney. Photo: RTÉ.
In stark contrast to the low level of convictions, gardaí confirmed that provisional figures show there 'in excess of 61,000 domestic abuse-related contacts in 2024' to stations across the country.
Ms Hanney, who continues to advocate for abused women, said she is 'not surprised at all by low levels of convictions' given the stories she hears from victims.
She added: 'People are begging me for help, they feel they are not being believed and some just give up because of that.
'I can understand why women give up and live a life of hell. It's like you're being defeated all the time.'
Ms Hanney warned that, unless the justice system changes, 'women are going to take their own lives. And what about the children who are witnessing the abuse? It will have a lifelong effect on them.'
She told Extra.ie: 'It should be a human right you're protected. But my heart is broken for these women. The lack of convictions in sending out terrible message.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Extra.ie
13 hours ago
- Extra.ie
Roz's plea for new leads to bring justice to victim of serial killers
Presenter Roz Purcell said she hopes potential new leads generated by her podcast on one of the country's most notorious murders will finally bring about justice for the family of Elizabeth Plunkett. It comes as Elizabeth's family have written to the DPP, Garda Commissioner Drew Harris and Justice Minister Jim O'Callaghan requesting a cold-case review into her death and a renewed public appeal for evidence. Englishmen John Shaw and Geoffrey Evans confessed to abducting, raping and murdering Elizabeth in Brittas Bay, Co. Wicklow, and also Mary Duffy in Connemara, Co. Galway, in 1976. Both men were initially charged with murder, rape and false imprisonment of Ms Plunkett and Ms Duffy. But when Shaw began a parole application nearly two years ago, it emerged he had never been convicted for Ms Plunkett's murder, despite previous reports. Roz Purcell said she hopes potential new leads generated by her podcast on one of the country's most notorious murders will finally bring about justice for the family of Elizabeth Plunkett. Pic: Instagram/ Roz Purcell It was also revealed to the Plunkett family that the State never held an inquest into the death of Ms Plunkett, and never issued a death certificate in her name. The Plunkett family are collaborating with the team at RTÉ's Documentary On One on Stolen Sister, a six-part podcast series, to raise awareness of Ms Plunkett's case, which led to an inquest being held into her death earlier this year. And Ms Purcell said the podcast team are hopeful the documentary will help the family's 'search for justice'. The model and presenter told 'We're retelling Elizabeth's life with her family. We want to do it in the right way, with the end goal of getting her family justice, and getting Elizabeth justice that she hasn't had in almost 50 years.' Geoffrey Evans died in 2012, and John Shaw remains in Arbour Hill Prison. Last week Shaw was denied parole. Members of Ms Plunkett's family were initially invited to provide impact statements to the court, but their statements were withdrawn when they were informed – for the first time – that while Shaw had been convicted of Elizabeth's rape and false imprisonment, he was never convicted of her actual murder. Englishmen John Shaw and Geoffrey Evans confessed to abducting, raping and murdering Elizabeth 'They are not recognised as relevant victims,' Ms Purcell said. The former Miss Universe Ireland said the podcast has resulted in an influx of reports from other potential victims and witnesses in the case. 'People are reaching out and getting in touch with new information. We've also had a good few people come forward with information on other attempted abductions,' she said. 'I'm doing this and Elizabeth's sisters are doing this because hopefully there's a conclusion, that we get them something, There's a mission for us, to have this case relooked at.' Documentary producer Nicoline Greer added: 'As a result of the podcast, we're getting people contacting us and saying that they were in Brittas Bay at the time. We're even getting people coming to us and saying that Shaw and Evans attempted to abduct them. Roz Purcell on Tommy Tiernan Show Pic: RTÉ 'They were young women at the time, so we've had quite a few contacts from people who we are in the process of verifying. 'It's unbelievable how predatory these guys seem to have been – way more so than we realised when we started this.' Because Shaw was not prosecuted for Elizabeth's murder, the case can be reopened if new evidence comes to light. 'The podcast is giving Elizabeth's story publicity and people are remembering things that happened back then that they haven't mentioned before,' Ms Greer said. When Evans and Shaw were arrested, the killers admitted their goal was to abduct, rape and murder one woman a week. 'They were always looking for women to abduct. They knew they were going to be caught… they just didn't care. They were doing what they wanted,' said Ms Greer. The producer said another woman in the Brittas area who was 18 at the time of Elizabeth Plunkett's murder approached them about her personal experience with the killers. 'She was walking home one evening… a car came along… she managed to run across fields to get away from them and got to her friend's house and closed the door. She was absolutely petrified. They were trying to get her into the car,' Ms Greer said. Elizabeth Plunkett. Pic: File She said another woman from Galway, also of student age at the time, 'managed to run as well, but they actually chased her'. An inquest was finally held into Elizabeth Plunkett's death in January, when the coroner officially gave the cause of death as 'unlawful killing'. The family were also issued a death certificate for the first time. Former State pathologist John Harbison initially found that Ms Plunkett hadn't died by drowning. 'She was dead before she went into the sea,' Ms Greer said, adding the inquest 'was the first official acknowledgement from the State that Elizabeth died, let alone at the hand of another'. The producer praised the Plunkett family for their bravery in helping to make the podcast. 'It is hard for the Plunketts to hear all this again, but they're being really brave and doing it for Elizabeth. They believe that Elizabeth would do it for them.' Presenter Ms Purcell also revealed she has a personal connection to the case: after the murders, Shaw and Evans hid out in Fethard, Co. Tipperary, close to where she grew up, and stayed there for 10 days. Roz Purcell. Pic: Discover Ireland 'The first thing I thought was, oh my God, my aunties would have been around her age. They would have been living in that area at that time. My Mum had just moved there. 'She became a teacher at the school and she was around the same age as Elizabeth. It makes you think… It's so horrific to think those things happened so close to a place where I call home.' ■ Stolen Sister is available on the RTÉ Radio Player or wherever you get your podcasts. It is continuing on RTÉ Radio 1 at 6.30pm for the next three Fridays.
Extra.ie
13 hours ago
- Extra.ie
Close associate of Annie suspect led to his arrest
Gardai decided to arrest the chief suspect in the Annie McCarrick murder case after travelling to another jurisdiction to speak with a close associate of the man, has learned. It is understood the arrest came as detectives worked on the theory that the 26-year-old American student was murdered by a 'jealous' man known to her. The first arrest in the 32-year-old case also came after gardaí crosschecked statements made at the time Ms McCarrick vanished in March 1993 with statements taken over the last two years. These included statements from the close associate and others known to the chief suspect. Annie McCarrick. Pic: An Garda Síochána In March 2023, Extra revealed a person of 'significant interest' to detectives was identified and that this was the reason the case was being upgraded to a murder investigation at the time. The development came more than 30 years after Ms McCarrick's friends originally told gardaí that they were concerned about the man, who was well known to her. They were worried that the man had been harassing their friend before she suddenly vanished without a trace. Witness statements from the now chief suspect were taken at the time. However, reported sightings of the young woman deflected attention away from the man. Ms McCarrick was reported to have been seen in Enniskerry and in the nearby Johnnie Fox's pub. These sightings became a focus for investigating detectives over the following years. In 1998, gardaí established Operation Trace amid growing concerns over several cases involving women who had vanished in the east of the country. It was set up to determine if any of the cases of these missing women were linked and whether a serial killer was to blame. This line of enquiry brought gardaí even further away from their now chief suspect. However, in March 2023, the case was to be upgraded to a murder investigation. Gardai decided to arrest the chief suspect in the Annie McCarrick murder case after travelling to another jurisdiction to speak with a close associate of the man, has learned. By that stage, these previous reported 'sightings' had been all but discounted by the new investigation team that was being led by Superintendent Eddie Carroll. Garda attention moved back to Ms McCarrick's inner circle at the time and the now chief suspect was examined more closely. This man went on to lead a full life in the time that elapsed: he married, had children and was successful in business. But this past week − in the first major development in the case − he was arrested. Another significant development came this week when the suspect's former family home in Clondalkin, Dublin, was cordoned off. Heavy machinery was moved in and the cadaver dog, Fern, who found Tina Satchwell's body buried under the stairs of her family home, was brought in. Searches of the house, which was significantly renovated 10 years ago, were still going on yesterday. The current owners of the property have nothing to do with the case. The chief suspect was released without charge on Friday, and he is understood to have returned to his home. Gardaí confirmed the man's release in a statement. Unusually in these cases, the statement did not refer to a file being prepared for the Director of Public Prosecutions. Annie McCarrick. Pic: Collins Photos Sources with knowledge of the case wonder now whether, if detectives had focused more on Ms McCarrick's personal relationships − as is usually the case when a woman is murdered − the three-decade long case would have been solved long ago. Despite the passage of time, Ms McCarrick's family's lawyer, US-based Michael Griffith, told Extra this week that he has not lost faith in seeing justice done for Annie. He said he and the family now await the 'next developments' in the investigation. 'I'm a very optimistic lawyer. I hope that one day it will have been solved, and over the years I've gone to Ireland, I've got some friends there,' he said. 'I've made it my business to be interviewed by the gardaí, by the local press, to try to keep the embers burning and I'm delighted to know that there's been an arrest, although there is no conviction at this point, there's only an arrest. 'So let's see what the next developments will be.'
The Irish Sun
a day ago
- The Irish Sun
Serial killer ‘fuming' after new light shined on crimes & Irish prison day release denied as behind bars life revealed
SERIAL killer John Shaw is blaming a new podcast for having a recent day release application turned down. The evil rapist and murderer had hoped to get out from Dublin's 5 Elizabeth Plunkett was murdered by Ireland's first serial killers on August 28, 1976 Credit: RTE Press Office Issue 5 John Shaw is said to be annoyed that the series is bringing his crimes to light once more Credit: RTE 5 Stolen Sister centres on his victim Elizabeth Plunkett Credit: RTE Press Office Issue The 78-year-old lifer has been granted permission in the past to leave the prison on temporary day release and walk around And Shaw is blaming a recent He believes Stolen Sister, which centres on his victim And Shaw is said to be annoyed that the series is bringing his The source said: 'Shaw is not a happy camper. He's fuming since he heard that there was a 'Unlike some killers who relish in the spotlight, Shaw wants his evil crimes to be forgotten. 'He is of the belief the recent attention the podcast has been gathering is part of the reason why he is not being granted day release. 'He had been getting out the odd time but that seems to have come to an end. He is really p****d off and blames the recent refusal by the IPS for day release on the podcast and all the newspaper articles it has been generating.' The source said Shaw doesn't do much inside They said. 'He works on the reception in the prison laundry and spends the whole day just sitting there making tea. It's about all he's capable of doing.' IRELANDS FIRST SERIAL KILLERS Shaw, along with accomplice Geoffrey Evans, became known as the country's first The career criminals met in an The pair, from northern England, travelled around Ireland in the Their twisted killing spree ended with the murder of young clerk Elizabeth, 23, in Co The two men were caged for life in February 1978 but shockingly, despite Shaw confessing to the killing of Elizabeth with his now deceased partner-in-crime, the pair were never convicted of the Dublin woman's murder. Ms Plunkett's sisters, Bernie and Kathleen, are now speaking out for the first time in Stolen Sister as they seek justice for Elizabeth. Speaking on the podcast, Bernie said: 'We had tried every avenue, everything. We appealed and appealed and appealed. We went to the DPP, they said no, the Earlier this year, Ms Plunkett's family urged Garda Commissioner 5 Sisters of Elizabeth Plunkett spoke for the first time in nearly 50 years Credit: RTE Press Office Issue 5 Geoffrey Evans murdered two young Irish women in 1976 alongside Shaw Credit: RTE
