Jury Produces $10 Million Verdict Against Grocery Store Ownership
DALLAS--(BUSINESS WIRE)--A Dallas County jury has returned a $10 million verdict against the shipping arm of the El Rancho Supermercado chain, finding the organization which operates under the corporate name of Mexico Foods breached contractual agreements and promises with Dallas-based Skyward Transportation.
'We're pleased that the jury carefully considered the evidence that Heritage management intentionally breached agreements, broke promises, and betrayed the longstanding and productive business relationship between Skyward and El Rancho.'
According to court documents, Skyward, founded by Curtis Lawrence when he was 19 years old, managed the majority of grocery delivery and backhaul services for the chain for more than a decade and enjoyed a mutually positive relationship until the acquisition of El Rancho in June 2023 by Heritage Grocers, a portfolio company of private equity firm Apollo Global Management.
Shortly following that sale to Heritage, a California-based company with a recent record of purchasing regional Hispanic-focused grocery chains, Skyward began receiving what the company believed to be a series of falsified records and fabricated complaints, while unpaid invoices began totaling hundreds of thousands of dollars.
Despite the attempts by Skyward to salvage the relationship, the Skyward contracts were terminated and the company, with more than 90% of its business devoted to serving El Rancho, was replaced as the chain's preferred transportation provider in favor of companies already serving other Heritage brands.
'We're pleased that the jury carefully considered the evidence that Heritage management intentionally breached agreements, broke promises, and betrayed the longstanding and productive business relationship between Skyward and El Rancho,' says Michael K. Hurst, Skyward's legal counsel.
'Skyward's performance and commitment was exceptional, but the new ownership was determined to create new `synergies' because it believed it could save costs and make more profits, notwithstanding the 5-year contracts and 10-year relationship with Skyward. Now they have to pay the price. Most people and companies wouldn't dare take on a business giant like Apollo, but most people aren't Curtis Lawrence,' says Hurst.
El Rancho operates 27 stores, with 18 locations in North Texas and others in Austin, Houston and Liberal, Kansas.
The verdict does not include attorney fees and interest to be awarded to Skyward at a later date. Other attorneys representing Skyward included Jared Eisenberg, David Coale, Jamie Drillette, and Andy Kim, all with Lynn Pinker Hurst & Schwegmann LLP, and Anthony Farmer with the Farmer Law Group.
The case is Skyward Transportation LLC v. Mexico Foods LLC et al., No. 23-15759, in the160th District Court of Judge Aiesha Redmond.
Lynn Pinker Hurst & Schwegmann is a Dallas-based, nationally recognized commercial litigation firm whose philosophy is based on trial-tested experience, creativity and an uncompromising will to win. The firm has a consistent track record of success, trying business disputes of all types, including breach of contract, intellectual property and trade secret, class action, financial services, securities, breach of fiduciary duty, employment, and professional malpractice cases. To learn more, visit http://www.lynnllp.com.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New York Post
24 minutes ago
- New York Post
Why NYC's most exclusive social clubs are hot with investors
Not since the 19th century have New Yorkers been so keen on clubs. Suddenly, everybody who is anybody has joined up with a schmoozy society outlet catering to seemingly every interest and income bracket — from Casa Cipriani for the social set, to the Leash Club for canine parents. Even the old guard along West 44th Street, aka Club Row, as well as other yesteryear organizations like the National Arts Club, Lotos Club and University Club, are attracting fresh faces anew. 'I'm a wonderful guest at most of the city's clubs, but I tend to be drawn to the old-school clubs of New York where you are stepping back in time,' said residential broker Mike Fabbri of the Agency, who lives in Gramercy Park and is joining the nearby National Arts Club. 'After COVID, there's been a resurgence of people wanting to belong and have a community.' 5 Even heritage haunts like the National Arts Clubs are booming. Getty Images for The National Arts Club But it's not just a spirit of bonhomie or overcrowded restaurants that are driving New Yorkers into exclusive sets — it's smart money. Unlike a typical restaurant, bar or gathering space, a membership model allows founders and operators to avoid taxes. That's because social clubs are considered nonprofits, where the Benjamins remain in the club's pockets and fund member benefits. As long as earnings aren't used to the private benefit of any particular person, a club is in the clear per the IRS. Better still, 35% of a social club's revenue can even come from non-member sources, including investment income. But taxes must be paid on up to 15% of the income from non-members who are not a guest of members — i.e. public walk-ins. And there's absolutely nothing on this earth that real estate investors love more than saving on taxes. Financier John Paulson, who recently purchased the storied Princeton Club's defaulted mortgage, told Page Six he may turn it into a place for 'vibrant 20- and 30-year-olds' as 'their place to go.' And no wonder Jeff Klein dropped $130 million to build out the new 'it' club, the San Vicente West Village in the Jane Hotel. 5 The new San Vicente West Village club cost $130 million. Helayne Seidman Initiation costs a reported $3,200 to $15,000 with annual dues of $1,800 to $4,200 depending on age. 'We've gotten a lot of inquiries from social clubs for properties we represent,' said Lee Block of RTL (previously Winick). 'There's a lot of activity for that in the city.' London's celebrity haunt Anabelle's opened in 1963 and has had several iterations. But the founder's son, Robin Brierly, has now collaborated with stateside owners the Reuben Brothers on Maxime's, which opened in March in the former Westbury Hotel at 848 Madison Ave. The Twenty Two, another London-based club, opened late last year in the Reuben Brothers' 16 E. 16th St. in the Flatiron District by Union Square and includes a public restaurant and hotel along with the private club and rooftop nightclubs. Meanwhile, Miami hotspot Casa Tua opened at the new Surrey hotel at 20 E. 76th St. It has an annual fee of $4,300 that rises to $7,000 if you want to visit its other locations in Aspen and Miami (after initiation fees). But the restaurant is open to non-members. 5 It costs $3,400 a year to party at Casa Tua in the Upper East Side. Olga Ginzburg for NY Post 'Casa Tua is the new hot spot,' said Lisa Simonsen, a residential broker with Brown Harris Stevens who belongs to 'a lot' of clubs. 'I join the ones that fit me and my family.' Social clubs hunting for a house have been eyeing 26 Little W. 12th St. in the Meatpacking District, brokers said. 'There's a lot of action on it from various member clubs looking to expand here or coming here from overseas,' said Jared Epstein of Aurora Capital Associates. 'It makes a lot of sense because it looks over the Hudson River.' 5 Thank city real estate players who see private clubs like Jean-Georges Vongerichten's Chez Margaux as surefire assets with guaranteed revenue. WWD via Getty Images Nearby, Jean-Georges Vongerichten turned his former Spice Market restaurant at 403 W. 13th St. into the elegant Chez Margaux dining club. Fees range from $1,800 to $2,600 annually, depending on age, with an initiation of $1,000 to $2,000. Chez Margaux is not far from where the now publicly traded global Soho House and its celebrity-packed rooftop heated pool became the club du jour when it opened in 2003 at 29-35 Ninth Ave. Fittingly, Vongerichten's partner in the club is developer Michael Cayre of Midtown Equities who bought Soho House from Ron Burkle in 2012. He's also a partner in the luxurious redevelopment of the Lower Manhattan Battery Maritime Building into the private and successful Casa Cipriani. 'If you travel a lot, Soho House has sites globally but it went public and doesn't feel as exclusive and culturally relevant anymore and has lost its luster,' opined Brandon Charnas, a commercial broker with Current Real Estate Advisors. 5 Zero Bond helped prove the club business model to investors. dzobel Charnas rebranded and leased Zero Bond and then helped prominent night club founder Scott Sartiano launch the club during COVID in 2020. Zero Bond's 'no photos' policy helped it become a celebrity haunt for Taylor Swift and Leonardo DiCaprio. Elon Musk threw a party here in 2021, the same year frequent late-night Zero Bond flier, Mayor Eric Adams, held his Election Day night victory party and hosted folks in a VIP room unlocked with a fingerprint scanner. Midtown building owner Craig Deitelzweig of Marx Realty is currently negotiating leases with two different social clubs for his office properties in New York and DC. 'Our buildings have a social club kind of feel and there is a natural gravitation to them by the clubs that adds to the cache of the building,' Deitelzweig said. 'The clubs like buildings that have some heritage and a cool vibe.' 'Being in a real members club is like belonging to a community — it's not selling immediate access but selling relationships.' Brandon Charnas, commercial broker with Current Real Estate Advisors Each of the clubs will have their own restaurant, Deitelzweig said, while the DC club will allow all tenants to use their terrace. 'People love them in the post-COVID world because they want to be social and form their own networks,' he said. Most building owners believe social clubs are a 'solid amenity,' explained Robert Gilman, a CPA with the accounting firm Anchin. For instance, at Hudson Yards, Gilman says ZZ's Club has been 'a standout.' Operated by Major Food Group, in 37 Hudson Yards, its moniker comes from founder Jeff Zalaznick's nickname. It includes a Japanese restaurant, a cigar terrace, a lounge with music programming and has a private location for its restaurant Carbone. The website shows $20,000 for initiation and $10,000 in annual fees. Developer Rabina's hot new residential and office tower in Midtown at 520 Fifth Ave. will also open a five-story social club, Moss, that will have a sauna, a cold plunge pool and a hammam plus spaces for podcasting, dining and events. But the sheer number of new clubs has some in the biz worried. Charnas warns members clubs are swelling into a 'dotcom bubble.' 'Everyone is launching them,' Charnas said. 'Not all of them will survive. They are getting their upfront dues while restaurants are calling themselves 'member clubs.' Being in a real members club is like belonging to a community — it's not selling immediate access but selling relationships.'
Yahoo
27 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Mother of 5-year-old girl killed in Franklin crash by accused drunk driver has also died, DA says
A vigil is planned for the mother of a 5-year-old girl killed in a crash by an accused drunk driver in Franklin over Memorial Day weekend who has also died. Minaben Patel, 38, of Franklin, has died days after the May 24 crash that killed her daughter, Krisha Patel, 5, according to the district attorney and a Facebook post by the SAFE Coalition on Tuesday afternoon. 'The Norfolk District Attorney's Office and the Franklin Police Department are saddened by the loss to Minaben's family and we extend our heartfelt condolences,' Norfolk District Attorney Michael Morrissey and Franklin Police Chief Thomas Lynch said in a statement Tuesday. A vigil for Minaben Patel is planned for 6 p.m. Thursday at the crash site on Grove Street in Franklin, The SAFE Coalition, a Franklin-based nonprofit group, said in its Facebook post. Another vigil was held for her daughter, Krisha Patel, at the site last Wednesday. 'We would like to share, through the families wishes, that Minaben Patel, mother of sweet Krisha, has passed away,' the SAFE Coalition said in its post. 'Minaben's family is again deeply thankful for all the love and support shared over the last week,' the group said. 'They invite the community to honor this amazing Mother, Wife, Family Member and friend this Thursday for a service of remembrance.' The driver accused in the fatal crash, James Blanchard, 21, of Franklin, was ordered held on $250,000 cash bail following his arraignment on May 27. A not guilty plea was entered on Blanchard's behalf. He is charged with motor vehicle homicide while driving negligently and under the influence of alcohol, three counts of driving under the influence of alcohol and causing serious bodily injury, negligent driving, driving a motor vehicle with an open container of alcohol, and marked lanes violation, according to Norfolk District Attorney Michael Morrissey. It was immediately unclear Tuesday if Blanchard would face additional charges in the case. Boston 25 has reached out to Morrissey's office for comment. During his arraignment, prosecutor Christopher Meade said Blanchard told police he had two beers while at a landscaping job on Saturday, May 24 after working that morning at his job as a mechanic. When he left his landscaping job, he opened a 1.75 liter bottle of Tito's vodka. He began drinking straight out of the bottle and drove home in his truck, Meade said during the arraignment in Wrentham District Court. Investigators later found a second, empty 1.75 liter bottle of Tito's in his truck that Blanchard told police was 'from the night before,' Meade said. While driving home around 6:22 p.m. Saturday, May 24, Blanchard crashed into a Honda Accord carrying a family of four on Grove Street in Franklin, Meade said. They were going to Blackstone for a family birthday party. The 5-year-old girl died following the crash, Meade said. Her mother and brother were taken to a local hospital in critical condition. The brother's condition was not known on Tuesday. Her father, the driver of the Honda, was treated and released. Defense attorney Timothy Flaherty had asked the court during Blanchard's arraignment to impose a lesser amount of $10,000 cash bail, with conditions for his release to include electronic monitoring and that he enter an alcohol rehabilitation center. 'It's probably the right place for this young man at this time,' Flaherty said during the arraignment. 'It's a significant case but significant penalties. But I can tell the court that this young man is not a risk of flight.' An autopsy will be performed to determine a cause of Minaben Patel's death, the district attorney said. Meanwhile, services were held for Krisha Patel on May 31, according to the girl's obituary. 'Our hearts are broken as we say goodbye to such a precious little soul. In her short time with us, she filled the world with laughter, wonder, and love,' her obituary states. 'Her smile could brighten the darkest day, and her kind heart touched everyone she met.' 'Though her time here was far too brief, her spirit will forever live on in the hearts of all who loved her,' her obituary states. 'We will carry her memory with us always - like a beautiful, shining star in the sky. May she rest peacefully, wrapped in love and light.' The crash remains under investigation by Franklin Police, the Norfolk District Attorney's Office and the Massachusetts State Police Collision Analysis and Reconstruction Section. This is a developing story. Check back for updates as more information becomes available. Download the FREE Boston 25 News app for breaking news alerts. Follow Boston 25 News on Facebook and Twitter. | Watch Boston 25 News NOW
Cosmopolitan
32 minutes ago
- Cosmopolitan
Paige DeSorbo Is Launching Her Own Sleepwear Brand
Instead of buying Loverboy and selling it (IYKYK), Paige DeSorbo is building a business empire of her own. Bravo's resident "bed bug"-slash-fashion girly is capitalizing on her sleepy on-screen persona with the launch of her own loungewear label—and everything about it is sooo on brand for the Summer House star. On Tuesday, Paige announced the news of her direct-to-consumer sleepwear line, dubbed Daphne, and spilled all the tea on her new venture. "Made my bed now I'm gonna lie in it," she joked on Instagram, alongside a sneak peek of the collection. And while it hasn't quite made its debut (next week! June 10! Mark your cal, besties!), the preview alone is evidence enough that the Giggly Squad host is really that girl. "As someone who's always believed that style should never be sacrificed for comfort, Daphne was born out of my desire to make high-quality, stylish loungewear accessible, empowering, and fun," Paige said in the press release. "Whether you're on a Zoom call, or spending a slow Sunday morning in bed—I want everyone to feel their most confident and chic." The burgeoning businesswoman tapped Proenza Schouler and Club Monaco alum Katie Serva as lead designer to bring her vision to life. The result? A collection of sleep cardigans, camis, matching sets, and even oversized sleep tees (inspired by her IRL bestie and podcast co-host, Hannah Berner), ranging in price from $58 to $230. Daphne's colors are muted, and the silhouettes feel classic but with a modern twist. The whole point is that you can wear each style from bed to the coffee shop and then back to bed. Paige teamed up with award-winning venture studio, Concept Brands, and its veteran fashion strategist Kyle DeFord for the project. And when I say veteran, I mean veteran. He's worked with Jenna Lyons' beauty brand LoveSeen, and Alex Mill. "From day one, Paige had an incredibly clear vision for Daphne," DeFord says. "She knew exactly the kind of pieces she wanted to bring to market. It's been inspiring to help bring her vision to life. With Daphne, we're creating loungewear that reflects Paige's modern, elevated approach—made for women who want to feel confident and chic whether they're staying in or stepping out." Paige's first collection will be available to shop on June 10. And while I don't have the offish drop timing, you can toss your deets into the Daphne site so you're notified ASAP. Bed rotting is about to look so much more chic. Megan Schaltegger is an NYC-based writer. She loves strong coffee, eating her way through the Manhattan food scene, and her dog, Murray. She promises not to talk about herself in third person IRL.
