logo
I know civic technology. This is not civic technology.

I know civic technology. This is not civic technology.

Technical.ly20-04-2025

Defined in the 2010s, civic technology describes efforts to use digital tools and design processes to improve the effectiveness of government, nonprofit and community efforts.
Elon Musk's DOGE is formally a rebranding of the US Digital Services, an Obama-era unit that sparked today's civic technology efforts.
From afar, Musk's use of startup culture and engineers to 'traumatize' bureaucrats might seem a part of civic technology. Instead, its leaders call DOGE a corruption of their movement.
In February 2011, Technical.ly co-hosted a community listening event for one of the first local cohorts from Code for America, the organization that largely defined what we today call civic technology: using digital tools and design processes to improve resident outcomes.
The national nonprofit got its start by recruiting civic-minded software developers to accept below market-rate salaries for a year of service with willing city governments. Their remit? Make stuff work better.
At that event, we put 50 residents into small breakout groups led by these new Code for America 20- and 30-something software builders. Attendees identified big problems and tiny annoyances. Several became projects that CfA group developed across their year of service.
Technocratic optimism was alive in American cities then. The economy was slowly rebounding from the Great Recession. Many regions were retaining do-gooder millennial college graduates. The Obama administration was credited with following its data-backed presidential campaign with digital-leaning government reforms. That included the US Digital Services (USDS), a unit launched in part by tech industry exec Jen Pahlka — who later founded Code for America.
Computing, internet databases and accessible websites have a decades-long tradition in federal, state and local government. In the 2010s, the practice of leveraging code, web services and emerging user experience and design processes there started going by the name civic technology. Inspired by leadership at the federal level, city champions followed, with a similar assumption — that lots of systems for residents could be improved with a sprinkle of the era's tech and innovation pixie dust.
Alongside startups and software jobs, how technology could be used to make government more responsive and effective was a cornerstone of Technical.ly's earliest coverage.
Elon Musk, the world's richest man, repeat entrepreneur and self-styled engineer, is crashing the federal government via his Department of Government Efficiency, which is formally a rebrand of Pahlka's USDS. Amid a slew of constitutional crises, DOGE could fade from a top alarm. Worse, to those farther from the conversation, one could reasonably connect the dots between the 20-something tech entrepreneurs and software builders of the 2010s to Musk and his team of 20-something technologists of today.
So is DOGE a continuation or a corruption of civic technology? If the answer is obvious to you, then here's your chance to spread the differences more widely.
'Civic tech is an enabling function for the public good,' said Christopher Whitaker, executive director of the Alliance of Civic Technologists. 'It's not about efficiency. It's about helping your neighbors.'
Not all broken systems are accidents
A US Army veteran, Whitaker started his career as an Illinois bureaucrat, working in the state unemployment office during the Great Recession — using a system built in the 1970s.
'You'd log in and see a blinking green DOS screen,' he told me. 'Then you'd print out a ream of paper the next morning to check if anything was rejected. That's how we knew if someone would actually get their benefits.'
Like thousands of other technologists, his frustration is what led him into civic tech. Whitaker later worked at Code for America, which evolved its model to include 'brigades,' semi-autonomous groups of local civic technologists spread around the country (Code for DC and Code for Philly, for example). In the 2010s, lots of well-paid and highly-skilled software builders wanted to volunteer their expertise to help their neighbors. Code for America helped thousands of them do that better.
It seemed as if civic technology spirit was already taking hold at the federal level, so it was time to extend that approach to state and local governments. I first met Whitaker in 2017 when Technical.ly helped him organize Code for America's first national summit for local civic tech leaders. That brigade summit was a kind of pep rally for tech-enabled, responsive city government, which the largely politically progressive attendees needed.
Years into local civic tech organizing and under the first Trump presidency, Whitaker, his local 'brigade captains' and a growing coalition of supporters were confronting something insiders already knew: not all broken resident services are accidents.
'Some government systems don't work by design, ' Whitaker said.
I had lunch last week with a social entrepreneur, one of hundreds of founders Technical.ly follows whose company's intent is to address some social ill by fulfilling a market niche. Social entrepreneurs are civic technologists with cap tables. Sometimes government lacks the know-how or the focus to improve a system, the entrepreneur told me, and that's when civic technology can work well. Other times, though, government is broken exactly because someone wants it to be broken. Civic technology is much harder to take root there.
Unemployment systems, for example, are often complicated because enough local leaders want it to be difficult to collect benefits. In this way, these systems are working exactly as intended. Academics Don Moynihan and Pam Herd call this 'administrative burden' — deliberate friction to reduce program usage.
This isn't about ineffective government. It's about political intent.
DOGE is not civic tech
If DOGE really is about the efficiency of government, laying off revenue-generating IRS agents would be an unexpected choice. If DOGE really is about the effectiveness of government, effectively shuttering 18F, the federal government's tech consultancy, would be a strange decision.
'A good product manager always asks, 'What problem are you trying to solve?'' Whitaker told me. 'DOGE doesn't seem to be asking that.'
Or, DOGE is addressing a very different problem than more effective government services. In February, Whitaker and fellow technologist Derek Eder published a call to action: Civic tech must focus on harm reduction. Not systems for their own sake, but work that directly helps the vulnerable.
'If food prices go up, helping a food pantry get food on the table is a win,' they wrote. 'If the administration targets our cities for mass deportation campaigns, every door that doesn't open without a warrant is a win.'
They highlighted Civic Tech Atlanta, which recently helped a local food pantry prepare for a data migration — by cleaning up spreadsheets and validating addresses. No big reveal. Just real work. The kind that actually helps.
In spring 2023, Code for America announced it was ending its formal relationship with its brigades, sending 60 or so local civic tech organizations on their own. Several changed their names, others folded other organizations, most are evaluating their place in the world.
Next month, Code for America will host its annual national conference, a few miles from where DOGE's young technologists are sleeping in offices. Both groups say they're making government work better for the American people.
Once its inspiration, the federal government is now civic technology's most divisive battleground.
'What civic tech learned again and again, is that it isn't just what you build,' Whitaker said, 'But how you build it.'
Let's remember what we're for
I got my civic tech start attending and hosting weekend hackathons, mostly in Baltimore and Philadelphia starting around 2010, not long after launching Technical.ly. Looking back, we were generating hundreds of hours of free consulting from what were then some of the most in-demand professionals. And we mostly did it for pizza and a sense of community.
Government, at the federal, state and local levels, will always need reform and modernizing. These systems are designed for stewardship, not disruption. The Clinton-era 'reinventing government' initiative cut federal workers, slashed spending and brought in emerging digital tools. It was controversial in its day, but was done legally, and now is fairly well-regarded.
Those Code for America fellows I followed in 2011 were like so many other civic technologists I've come to know: smart, nerdy, motivated by a satisfaction that better systems can help more people — and cautious of how technology can be destructive. 'This is not a good-faith effort,' Whitaker wrote in January of DOGE. 'They've said they want bureaucrats to be traumatically affected. Civic tech has no business working with bullies.'

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

US travel ban on Libyans and citizens of 11 other countries takes effect
US travel ban on Libyans and citizens of 11 other countries takes effect

Libya Observer

timea day ago

  • Libya Observer

US travel ban on Libyans and citizens of 11 other countries takes effect

The executive order signed by US President Donald Trump officially came into effect on Monday morning, barring nationals from 12 countries—including Libya—from entering the United States. Last Wednesday, the White House announced in a statement that President Trump had signed an executive order restricting the entry of nationals from the following 12 countries: Afghanistan, Burma, Chad, the Democratic Republic of the Congo, Equatorial Guinea, Eritrea, Haiti, Iran, Libya, Somalia, Sudan, and Yemen. The White House justified the decision by saying the U.S. administration had conducted a thorough risk assessment of these countries, particularly regarding terrorism and national security. The statement explained that the listed countries fail to meet the necessary security requirements and pose a significant threat to the United States. In Libya's case specifically, the White House said the complete suspension of travel by Libyan nationals was due to the absence of a central, competent, and cooperative authority responsible for issuing passports and civil documents. It added: 'A history of terrorist activity within Libyan territory increases the risk of admitting its nationals into the US.' Despite the ban, the statement noted exceptions for individuals holding valid permanent residency or visas, specific visa categories, and individuals whose entry serves US national interests. As for implementation, US Secretary of State Marco Rubio signed a diplomatic cable providing instructions to American diplomatic missions on how consular officers should handle visa applications from nationals of the banned countries. Tags: USA Travel Ban US President Donald Trump

GEC 2025: What the Global Entrepreneurship Congress says about American entrepreneurial leadership
GEC 2025: What the Global Entrepreneurship Congress says about American entrepreneurial leadership

Technical.ly

timea day ago

  • Technical.ly

GEC 2025: What the Global Entrepreneurship Congress says about American entrepreneurial leadership

Among the greatest of American exports, hip-hop and basketball have gone entirely global. Entrepreneurship too. Back to antiquity, the first businesses were in Africa and the Arabian Peninsula. The modern corporation is a European invention, and the longest running company is Japanese. But the Americans made it cool. From the 1980s-era 'greed is good' to post-Great Recession social entrepreneurship, the United States put get-rich businesses on magazine covers and humble small business owners on primetime reality TV. Fitting, then, that the Global Entrepreneurship Congress is an American product that has been mostly held abroad. With origins in the early 2000s, this first-of-its-kind globally-minded pro-startup conference was held in 2009 for 200 attendees in Kansas City, with funding from the entrepreneurship-obsessed Kauffman Foundation. Founded by trained economist and policy wonk Jonathan Ortmans, the conference is organized by what is now called the Global Entrepreneurship Network (or GEN, pronounced like the name Jen), which Ortmans leads. This year boasted more than 3,000 attendees. 'Entrepreneurs are the new diplomats of the world.' Jonathan Ortmans, Global Entrepreneurship Network Over the following 15 years, the Congress was held the world over, including Brazil, Saudi Arabia and Australia. Last week, GEC was held in the United States for the first time since its start — in Indianapolis, a growing city in a Midwestern state with bipartisan support for business growth and a hook into federal research dollars. 'Entrepreneurs are the new diplomats of the world,' Ortmans said on stage. His opening remarks lamented fading enthusiasm for an interconnected global economy. Elsewhere, he spoke optimistically of what remains bipartisan support for business creation. In the conference's keynote conversation with entrepreneur-turned-celebrity investor Mark Cuban, Ortmans boasted that GEC was held in Moscow in the weeks that followed the Russian invasion of Crimea. Back in March 2014, for the conference-attending entrepreneurs and their supporters from around the world, 'nothing was different.' Whether that sounds like a hardworking ethic or aloof indifference, Ortmans argues entrepreneurs crave stability, clarity and transparency, which benefits everyone else. Alongside Ortmans, Cuban presented as even more optimistic, and idealistic, for Entrepreneur The Diplomat. Cuban gushed about the promise of artificial intelligence to unlock the entrepreneurial spirit around the world, leveling the playing field with just an internet connection. Famously, Silicon Valley notables broke toward supporting Donald Trump in the 2024 presidential election, but Cuban was a prominent outlier and frequent MAGA critic. He was less directly critical at nonpolitical-striving GEC, and Ortmans encouraged him to widen his lens to consider a global audience in the convention hall that came from at least 130 countries. Tellingly, there was no formal delegation from the American federal government, nor its DOGE-cost-cutting Small Business Administration. (One member of a GEC advisory group politely declined to comment and sensibly encouraged this reporter to focus on the international presence and bipartisan support among state and local American officials.) 'There are plenty of places to talk about politics. If you're an entrepreneur, be an entrepreneur. If your business succeeds, the politicians will come to you,' Cuban advised. 'You want your business to outlast any one politician.' In some sense, it's a hopeful throwback to a more innocent time when a jet-setting elite believed commerce would lead to peace and prosperity. That's the optimistic worldview that led the American government to welcome the Chinese Community Party into the World Trade Organization, and the same that encouraged the German government to rely on the Russian state for its energy security. In recent years, there's been a reversal: Global citizens of international capitals have been humbled into a choice, say more, or say less. During the pandemic, social justice protests demanded that entrepreneurs speak out on a growing list of political issues. Ortmans, Cuban and the spirit of GEN's GEC seem to say something different. As one GEC collaborator has told me: 'Entrepreneurship is my politics.' Informed by the modest, Midwestern style of the Kauffman Foundation, the conference was filled with practical advice for entrepreneurs and local economic development leaders. Common-sense policy discussions happened alongside meet-and-greets between commerce ministers from dozens of countries. Each GEC features a dedicated 'compass room' with a UN-style circular white table with microphones. Its orientation stands in contrast to the Silicon Valley investor-catwalk startup conferences, Austin's hipper-than-thou SXSW and and the sprawling and showy Las Vegas consumer technology shows. Ortmans hopped between sessions and off-site events. He addressed both the launch of a national campaign to center entrepreneurs in next year's anniversary of the American Revolution and at a working session of 'national ecosystem resource providers' — of which Technically is one. 'This is one way back,' Ortmans said of a more pro-growth time. 'Customers matter. Failure doesn't.' Mark Cuban Cuban, who knows something about hip hop and basketball, embodies a brighter optimism than most American elites of late. A thousand of us overflowed conference chairs, and clapped and chuckled at his folksy charm, embodied by the carefully chosen polo-shirt he wore from his Indiana University alma mater,. As ready-for-TV as Cuban is, he still offers practical advice for founders: 'Raising money isn't an accomplishment. It's an obligation.' And in practiced, self-effacement: 'Customers matter. Failure doesn't.' (In contrast, another main-stage panel of Colorado-bred tech startup notables was a snoozefest of self-congratulation from a bygone era.) Cuban advised policymakers and economic development leaders to invest in community, rule of law and lifestyle to attract and retain entrepreneurs: When he chose where to start his businesses, first Indiana and later Texas, 'not one single time did I look at the tax rate first.' Speaking to a crowd with attendees from countries including Iraq, Nigeria and France, he personified his role as the commonsense sage of American-style center-left techno-optimism. Said Cuban: 'An entrepreneur is always an entrepreneur first.'

This Week in Jobs: Take these 24 tech career opportunities for a spin
This Week in Jobs: Take these 24 tech career opportunities for a spin

Technical.ly

time03-06-2025

  • Technical.ly

This Week in Jobs: Take these 24 tech career opportunities for a spin

Happy World Bicycle Day! The celebration was originated by Professor Leszek Sibilski, a Polish-American social scientist and cyclist whose academic project on bicycles and sustainability became a global initiative in the 2010s. It was declared by the United Nations in April 2018. Bicycles, invented in Germany more than 200 years ago, have stood the test of time as a simple, affordable and reliable means of transportation that is good for environmental sustainability and health. Since 2020, the popularity of bicycles, including electric bikes, has exploded. During the COVID lockdowns, when people were seeking safe outdoor activities for fitness and mental health, many cities saw record-breaking purchases and rentals — notably, the Citi Bike system in New York City saw a 67% increase during the early part of the pandemic. The popularity of bike-sharing programs didn't end with the lockdowns. In fact, their popularity continues to rise: Between March 2024 and March 2025, docked bike-share trips in major U.S. cities experienced a 17.5% increase. Riding a bike is kind of like a job search: balance, momentum and the occasional hill climb are part of the ride. The News Check out this roundup of South Philly small business entrepreneurs, including artists, chefs, activists, app developers and more. Track Pittsburgh aerospace startup Astrobotic's rise from CMU spinout to NASA moon partner. Philly's Fore Biotherapeutics raises another $38M for cancer drug trial. Developers aren't discounting the tech industry — but say companies must value humans over AI. What does Pennsylvania stand to lose if federal research dollars dry up? More than just the funding itself. Client Spotlight 'What's great about being at Comcast is that we can turn an idea into a product,' said software development engineer Jaylen Sanders. 'I brought an idea to my manager, we demoed it across the organization, and a year later, we were able to create, ship and launch the product.' The Jobs Greater Philly Penn Medicine is seeking a Senior Manager Data Engineering and a Cybersecurity Identity Management Senior Engineer. Law firm Morgan, Lewis & Bockius is looking for an IT Product Manager. CubeSmart is hiring a Database Engineer and a Technical SEO Analyst. Vanguard has several listings open: Machine Learning Engineer Public Relations Consultant, Senior Specialist Senior Product Manager The CIGNA Group needs a hybrid Workday Talent Solutions Analyst. DC + Baltimore Kite Pharma in Frederick is seeking a Senior IT Engineering Specialist Microsoft is hiring for hybrid Technical Support Engineering in DC. Maryland Department of Information Technology is hiring an IT Accessibility Specialist. Siemens in Chantilly is looking for a Building Automation Service Specialist. Software company Navigator in Frederick needs a Client Software Specialist. Pittsburgh Ford Office Technologies is hiring an IT Technical Account Manager. The City of Pittsburgh has a listing for a Technology Implementation Specialist. Meta is searching for a Technical Program Manager, XR Tech. Biotech company Softwriters needs a hybrid Technical Support Specialist. Remote Brooksource is looking for a remote Salesforce Helpdesk Technician. Bath & Body Works is looking for a remote Lead UX Designer. MrBeast is in need of a remote Netflix has a listing for a remote Full Stack Engineer (L5), N-Tech Software Engineering. The End In the words of Professor Sibliski: 'Have passion, perseverance, and be relentless!'

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store