Abuse scandal in focus in search for new pope
In a meeting to prepare for the election of a successor to Pope Francis, in a conclave starting May 7, cardinals outlined "evangelisation, the relationship with other faiths (and) the issue of abuse" as the Church's most pressing challenges.
It was a statement welcomed by Anne Barrett Doyle, a long-time campaigner who co-founded BishopAccountability.org, which collates information on abuse.
"The Church worldwide, through its parishes, schools, hospitals and orphanages, cares for tens of millions of children," she told AFP.
"The next pope's most sacred obligation must be to protect them from abuse. Their safety is at stake, as is the moral authority of the church."
Francis, who died on April 21, did more than any other pontiff to tackle the scourge of abuse, which appeared to overwhelm his predecessor, German Benedict XVI.
But critics say the Argentine's actions during 12 years as pope fell well short of the "zero-tolerance" he promised.
"What we need from the next pope is meaningful action, not more rhetoric," said Barrett Doyle.
"We need him to enact a universal church law permanently removing all proven child molesters from public ministry.
"We need him to release the names of the thousands of priests found guilty to date under church law."
'Our shame'
When Francis took over in March 2013, the Church was struggling to respond to an avalanche of revelations, and many Catholics were horrified.
A turning point came in 2018, during a trip to Chile.
Francis, the Church's first Latin American pope, initially strongly defended a local bishop against allegations he covered up the crimes of an elderly priest.
But he went on to admit to making "grave mistakes" in the case -- a first for a pope -- and later forced the resignations of all Chile's bishops.
Within months, he showed he would take action, by defrocking US cardinal Theodore McCarrick after he was found guilty by a Vatican court of sexually abusing a teenager in the 1970s.
McCarrick died earlier this month in the United States, aged 94.
In 2019, Francis moved to make lasting changes in how the Church dealt with abuse, which he called "our shame".
The apostolic letter "Vos Estis Lux Mundi" made it mandatory to report sexual abuse of minors and vulnerable people, and any cover-up, and set out a procedure on how to deal with cases.
In a major shift, the pope also lifted the so-called "pontifical secret" surrounding accusations, trials and decisions relating to such abuse.
'Half-measure'
But clergy are still not obliged to report abuse to civil authorities under Church codes, and anything said in the confessional box remains sacrosanct.
Vos Estis Lux Mundi "didn't require external oversight," noted Barrett Doyle.
"It didn't require transparency to the public, disclosure to the public, and it didn't involve even reporting to law enforcement.
"It was, in a way, a continuation of what we have always had."
In a February 2025 stock-take, the SNAP victims' association said that in reality the Vatican continued to withhold documents on abuse cases, and also condemned the mandatory reporting as a "half-measure".
Both of them are now turning their attention to the next pope.
Barrett Doyle has travelled to Rome to press her case.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
France 24
4 hours ago
- France 24
Manhunt intensifies in US after lawmaker killed, another wounded
As the search stretched into its second day, police appeared to close in on the shooter, finding a car described as related to him, but not the man himself. America reeled from its latest spasm of political violence as lawmakers called for a return to civility in political discourse that has been overheated and angry for years. Authorities searched for a man identified as Vance Boelter, 57, who also allegedly shot and wounded another lawmaker and his wife early Saturday in the northern state bordering Canada. Officials said Boelter impersonated a police officer as he came to the homes of these couples near Minneapolis and shot them, and that officers found a manifesto and a list of other lawmakers and potential targets in his car. Boelter fled on foot after exchanging gunfire with officers after the second shooting. On Sunday officers located another car related to Boelter in a rural area about a 90-minute drive west of Minneapolis, the Sibley County Sheriff's Office told AFP. Residents were warned of the find and agents are scouring the area, the office said without explaining how the vehicle is related to the suspect. Officials have issued security alerts in South Dakota and other states as the hunt proceeds, US Senator Amy Klobuchar of Minnesota said Sunday as she mourned her slain friend, Democratic state representative Melissa Hortman. "I am concerned about all our political leaders, political organizations," she said. "It was politically motivated, and there clearly was some throughline with abortion because of the groups that were on the list, and other things that I've heard were in this manifesto. So that was one of his motivations." As speaker of the Minnesota House of Representatives from 2019 to January 2025, Hortman was committed to legislation that protected reproductive rights in the state, local media reported. 'Bring the tone down' America is bitterly divided politically as President Donald Trump embarks on his second term and routinely insults his opponents. Political violence is becoming more and more common. Trump himself survived an assassination attempt last year. An assailant with a hammer attacked the husband of then US House speaker Nancy Pelosi in 2022. And Pennsylvania Governor Josh Shapiro's home was set on fire this year. "We need to bring the tone down," Klobuchar said on CNN. US Senator Rand Paul of Kentucky, himself attacked by a neighbor in 2017, told NBC "nothing brings us together more than, you know, mourning for somebody else who's in political life, Republican or Democrats." On Saturday the FBI released a photo that appears to show Boelter wearing a mask as he stands outside the home of one of the lawmakers. It is offering a $50,000 reward for information leading to his arrest and conviction. The shootings came on the day a dramatic split screen showed America divided: hundreds of thousands of protesters across the country took to the streets to rally against Trump as the president presided over a big military parade in Washington -- a rare spectacle criticized as seeking to glorify him. Trump has condemned the killing of Hortman and her husband Mark and the wounding of state Senator John Hoffman and his wife Yvette. In a conversation Sunday with ABC News, Trump was asked if he planned to call Minnesota Governor Tim Walz, who was Kamala Harris's running mate in the election Trump won last year. "Well, it's a terrible thing. I think he's a terrible governor. I think he's a grossly incompetent person," the president said. "But I may, I may call him, I may call other people too." © 2025 AFP
France 24
6 hours ago
- France 24
India a voice for Global South at G7, says foreign minister
India is not a member of the G7 -- which comprises Britain, Canada, France, Germany, Italy, Japan and the United States -- but the world's most populous nation and one of its biggest economies has been invited to summits since 2019. "We have been an outreach country in the G7 for many years, and I think it brings benefits to the G7," he told AFP in Paris. "There are very strong feelings in the Global South about the inequities of the international order, the desire to change it, and we are very much part of that," he added. "It is important for us to organise ourselves and make our presence felt." The leaders of the G7 kick off a yearly summit in the Canadian Rockies on Sunday. They have invited Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi, along with the leaders of Ukraine, Mexico, South Africa and South Korea, to attend at a time of global turmoil and a radical new US approach to world affairs. The member nations are also expected to deliberate on troubled relations with China and Russia. India is a leading member of BRICS -- a bloc of leading emerging economies that includes Russia and China, whose leaders are set to meet in early July. BRICS has growing economic clout and is increasingly seen as a G7 rival. Jaishankar said India had "the ability to work with different countries in a way without making any relationship exclusive". "To the extent that that serves as a bridge, it's frankly a help that we do to international diplomacy at a time when, mostly what you see are difficult relationships and excessive tensions," he added. No need for 'more tension' The foreign minister said his country had been in favour of direct talks between Russia and Ukraine to end the conflict since 2022. But Jaishankar -- whose nation is a political ally of Russia and trades with Moscow -- said sanctions such as those against President Vladimir Putin's government did not work. "Where sanctions are concerned, you could argue that it has not actually had much impact on policy behaviour," he said. Europeans are in favour of a plan for a "secondary" sanctions plan, including a 500-percent tariff on countries that buy Russian oil, gas and raw materials. "The world does not need more tension, more conflict, more hostility, more stresses," the former Indian ambassador in Washington said. US President Donald Trump is expected at the G7 summit in Kananaskis, Alberta. Modi is expected to meet him to push a trade deal with the United States -- India's largest trading partner -- before the July 9 deadline when Washington's punishing 26 percent tariffs are set to resume. Jaishankar said Trump "clearly, in many ways, represents a discontinuity". "He is definitely a very nationalistic person who puts his country's interests very strongly ahead," he added. 'Stable relationship' with China As for China, it was a balancing act, said the minister. India and China, the world's two most populous nations, are intense rivals competing for strategic influence across South Asia, and their 3,500-kilometre (2,200-mile) shared frontier has been a perennial source of tension. Their troops clashed in 2020, killing at least 20 Indian and four Chinese soldiers, and forces from both sides today face off across contested high-altitude borderlands. Despite both country's differences, "we are also today the major rising powers in the world", Jaishankar said. "Where we (India) have to be strong and firm, we will be strong and firm. Where we have to forge a stable relationship, we are prepared to do that," he added. China has also been a staunch partner of India's arch-enemy Pakistan. Pakistan used Chinese jets against India when the nuclear-armed foes fought an intense four-day conflict last month in which 70 people were killed, their worst standoff since 1999. The fighting was triggered by an April 22 attack on civilians in Indian-administered Kashmir that New Delhi accused Pakistan of backing -- a charge Islamabad denies. The territory is claimed in full by both India and Pakistan, which have fought several wars over Kashmir since their 1947 independence from British rule. But Jaishankar dismissed fears at the time of a nuclear escalation. These were "only the concerns of people who were completely uninformed," he said.
France 24
7 hours ago
- France 24
Israel's strikes on Iran were years in the making: analysts
Israel said it hit hundreds of targets on Friday alone, and has since continued its attacks, striking a defence facility and fuel depots on Sunday. The fiercest-ever exchange of fire between the arch foes came in the midst of ongoing talks between Tehran and Washington seeking to reach a deal on Iran's nuclear programme. "Israel has been following the nuclear programme for 15 years," Israeli analyst Michael Horowitz told AFP. "The strikes we see are the result of years of intelligence gathering and infiltration of the Islamic republic." Israel has previously carried out more limited attacks against Iranian military sites, including in October last year. "It seems that this week's operation had been in preparation for months, with an acceleration after the operation last year significantly weakened Iranian air defences," Horowitz said. The United States and other Western countries, along with Israel, accuse Iran of seeking a nuclear weapon. Tehran denies that, but has gradually broken away from its commitments under a 2015 nuclear deal it struck with world powers, which the United States withdrew from during President Donald Trump's first term. The landmark accord had provided Iran sanctions relief in exchange for curbs on its atomic programme. 'Impressive' precision Israel is long believed to have carried out sabotage operations inside Iran through its Mossad espionage agency, but the attacks that started on Friday are by far the broadest in scope. The campaign has shown Israel to be capable of precisely locating and taking out high-ranking Iranian officials and nuclear scientists. A European security source said the strikes showed "an impressive degree of precision and mastery". Israel says it has killed 20 military and security targets, including the armed forces' chief of staff and the head of Iran's Revolutionary Guards, as well as nine nuclear scientists. Danny Citrinowicz, of the Tel Aviv-based Institute for National Security Studies, said the ability to take out high-ranking officials showed "intelligence, but also operational superiority of Israel over Iran". "It's highly connected to the ability to collect information, intelligence in Iran for years, excellent intelligence that actually allows you to detect where they're living, the seniors, also the nuclear scientists," he told AFP. The latest targeted strikes come after Israel killed Ismail Haniyeh, the political leader of the Palestinian militant group Hamas, in a Tehran guesthouse in July last year. Haniyeh had been in town for the inauguration of Iranian President Masoud Pezeshkian, and was reportedly killed by an explosive device that Israeli operatives had placed in the guesthouse weeks before. Analysts at the time saw the attack as a major intelligence failure by Iran. But "still Iran didn't learn and didn't have the ability to lock the holes in their system", said Citrinowicz. Smuggled drones News site Axios reported that Mossad agents inside Iran helped prepare Friday's strikes, pre-positioning weapon systems near air defence targets, including by hiding them inside vehicles, and launching them when the attack started. An Israeli intelligence official told Axios that Mossad had "established an attack drone base inside Iran with drones that were smuggled in long before the operation". A former Israeli intelligence official told The Atlantic that "Iranians opposed to the regime make for a ready recruiting pool", and that "Iranians working for Israel were involved in efforts to build a drone base inside the country". Alain Chouet, the former number three in the French intelligence, said he was convinced Israel had "half a dozen cells capable of acting at any moment" inside Iran. Iran regularly executes people it accuses of spying for Israel. It is unclear what role, if any, Israel's key military and diplomatic ally the United States had in the latest strikes. Before the attack early on Friday, Trump publicly urged Israel to allow time for diplomacy, as a sixth round of US-Iranian nuclear talks were set to be held in Oman at the weekend. The US president on Sunday said Washington "had nothing to do" with ally Israel's campaign. But Iran's Foreign Minister Abbas Araghchi on Sunday said Tehran had "solid proof of the support of the American forces and American bases in the region" for the attacks. And Israel's Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said on Saturday his country was acting with "the clear support of the president of the United States".
