Review launched after decision to put police dog to sleep despite 'great prognosis'
A review has been launched after a Dundee police dog was put to sleep despite vets giving her a 'great prognosis'.
PD Zara was taken to the vet after she was struck by a car on Couper Angus Road in Kirkhill on December 11, 2024.
The then two-year-old German Shepherd suffered a number of injuries, including a fractured hip bone. Vets indicated the dog would need to have the joint 'roughly reconstructed' or fully replaced.
The operation, which could be carried out in one or two stages, would've cost the force around £12,000.
During the days following the crash, Zara had walked outside and her condition was described as 'comfortable' with reflexes present. Thin Blue Paw Police Scotland says they are reviewing their processes following the death.
The report also stated on December 13 that her nerve function 'seemed ok' and the prognosis was 'great once recovered'.
A decision was later made to put Zara to sleep.
The Thin Blue Paw foundation, which is dedicated to police dogs, described the death of the young German Shepherd as a 'tragedy'.
The charity criticised the force's decision to euthanise the dog rather than authorise further CT scans.
Trustee, Dave Wardel, said: 'Police Dog Zara's independent veterinary report is clear. Her prognosis, as described by specialist veterinarians, was 'great', and following authorisation for further CT scans, Zara could and should have undergone surgery.
'The inspector of the dog unit failed to authorise these scans and instead authorised the euthanasia of Police Dog Zara. PD Zara's death is a tragedy, and we are fully committed to holding Police Scotland to account to ensure this never happens again.
'Police dogs play an invaluable role within policing and should be provided with the highest level of welfare and care in their time of need'. Thin Blue Paw The Thin Blue Paw foundation criticised the decision to put PD Zara to sleep.
Police Scotland has confirmed that they are reviewing their processes following the death. They have also welcomed the opportunity to speak to members of the Thin Blue Paw.
Chief superintendent Stevie Dolan said: 'Police dogs are a hugely important part of our police family we are totally committed to animal welfare and looking after those in our service.
'We are reviewing our procedures to ensure that any learning from the death of PD Zara is captured and we would welcome the opportunity to meet with representatives of the Thin Blue Paw Foundation to listen to their concerns and discuss our approach to incidents such as this in the future.'
Get all the latest news from around the country Follow STV News
Scan the QR code on your mobile device for all the latest news from around the country
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BBC News
an hour ago
- BBC News
Inverness priest's car targeted by vandals
Vandals left a priest's car unusable after throwing about 30 stones at the vehicle while it was parked overnight at an Inverness Domenico Zanré was planning to visit parishioners at the weekend when he discovered the windscreen, windows and bodywork said the vandalism likely occurred overnight Friday into Saturday, and believed it was an "act of mindless violence" and not Domenico told BBC News Scotland: "It was heart-breaking to see it. Once I got over the shock I was just thinking about all the people I had to go and see." The car was parked at St Columba's Roman Catholic Church in Domenico said he found about 30 large stones on the ground next to the vehicle. He was unable to drive the car because of the smashed windscreen and windows, and he was prevented from visiting several parishioners."People who were quite vulnerable or in very poor health, and at least one person who is towards the end of life," he said."I felt slightly powerless, and that I had let them down." Police Scotland said it was aware of the incident and its inquiries were at an early stage.
Glasgow Times
an hour ago
- Glasgow Times
Public inquiries placing pressure on Police Scotland
David Kennedy, general secretary of the Scottish Police Federation (SPF), said public inquiries were having a 'detrimental impact' on policing. He said the issue could lead to a cycle in which taking officers away from their duties to deal with inquiries could ultimately result in more inquiries in the future, as the force suffers from a lack of resources. Mr Kennedy called for a ring-fenced fund for public organisations involved in inquiries to ensure services are not harmed. READ MORE: Local bus operator axes all of its services after entering 'liquidation' READ MORE: Glasgow travellers heading to two cities warned of 'violent muggings' He told the Finance and Public Administration Committee: 'The amount of and the sheer task that public inquiries place on the police service, resource-wise, is quite extraordinary. 'And what I've certainly seen since taking up my post and being in the federation for nearly 20 years is that there's never any budget set aside for the police service to take up these inquiries.' Mr Kennedy said the Sheku Bayoh Inquiry – one of several costing tens of millions of pounds – has cost Police Scotland £25 million, although it directly involves the force. 'On that figure alone, on a light scale, would give you 500 police officers,' he said. 'And with the current resourcing levels within Police Scotland, it is having an absolute detrimental effect on policing.' Mr Kennedy said that came at the same time as one detective inspector was dealing with 176 rape inquiries. 'That shows you the knock-on effect that inquiries can have on the day-to-day running of policing,' he said. Mr Kennedy added that the Scottish Hospitals Inquiry had also used 60 detectives at one point, which he said would take away from Police Scotland's resources elsewhere. He said the number of inquiries, which has increased in recent years, had led to some officers taking sick leave from work. Mr Kennedy told MSPs: 'The knock-on effect is when you have so many officers going on to a day shift role doing inquiries, that leaves the operational roles short.' He warned that the issue could lead to more future inquiries, saying: 'My concern at the moment is that we're going to have more public inquiries in 10 years' time because of items and cases that have been missed now, while we are taking people off the operational side of policing to help with the public inquiries that are ongoing.' SNP MSP Kenneth Gibson, convener of the committee, said the situation could become a 'self-perpetuating, increased cycle'. Mr Kennedy said the system must be reformed, including Police Scotland receiving the full cost of engaging with inquiries. His appearance comes as the committee investigates the cost-effectiveness of public inquiries in Scotland. The total cost of the country's public inquiries since 2007 currently totals £240 million, including £95.3 million for the ongoing Scottish Child Abuse Inquiry. Meanwhile, the NHS has spent more than £3 million responding to inquiries since 2021, with the service now having established a dedicated team to respond to inquiries. Police Scotland and the Scottish Government have been approached for comment.
The National
an hour ago
- The National
Family 'utterly heartbroken' as man dies after Aberdeenshire crash
The collision happened on the A982 South Road at Peterhead, Aberdeenshire, on May 13. William John Horne, 67, who was driving a white Volkswagen, was taken to Aberdeen Royal Infirmary with serious injuries and died on Sunday, June 8, police said. READ MORE: Labour MSP Davy Russell sworn in to Scottish Parliament after by-election win The people in the other vehicles: a white Kia Ceed and a red Seat Alhambra; were treated for non-serious injuries. Horne's family paid tribute to him in a statement issued via Police Scotland. They said: 'Our family is utterly heartbroken by the tragic loss of William John Horne. 'We want to give our sincere thanks to the first responder, police, paramedics and all the wonderful staff at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary ICU for their care and attention to William.' Horne was from the Peterhead area. Constable John Grant, of the north east road policing unit, said: 'Our thoughts are with William's family who have asked for privacy at this difficult time. 'Inquiries are ongoing to establish the full circumstances and anyone with information who can assist and has not already spoken to officers is asked to get in touch.' Anyone with information is asked to call Police Scotland on 101, quoting incident number 2279 of Tuesday May 13 2025.
