Review launched after decision to put police dog to sleep despite 'great prognosis'
A review has been launched after a Dundee police dog was put to sleep despite vets giving her a 'great prognosis'.
PD Zara was taken to the vet after she was struck by a car on Couper Angus Road in Kirkhill on December 11, 2024.
The then two-year-old German Shepherd suffered a number of injuries, including a fractured hip bone. Vets indicated the dog would need to have the joint 'roughly reconstructed' or fully replaced.
The operation, which could be carried out in one or two stages, would've cost the force around £12,000.
During the days following the crash, Zara had walked outside and her condition was described as 'comfortable' with reflexes present. Thin Blue Paw Police Scotland says they are reviewing their processes following the death.
The report also stated on December 13 that her nerve function 'seemed ok' and the prognosis was 'great once recovered'.
A decision was later made to put Zara to sleep.
The Thin Blue Paw foundation, which is dedicated to police dogs, described the death of the young German Shepherd as a 'tragedy'.
The charity criticised the force's decision to euthanise the dog rather than authorise further CT scans.
Trustee, Dave Wardel, said: 'Police Dog Zara's independent veterinary report is clear. Her prognosis, as described by specialist veterinarians, was 'great', and following authorisation for further CT scans, Zara could and should have undergone surgery.
'The inspector of the dog unit failed to authorise these scans and instead authorised the euthanasia of Police Dog Zara. PD Zara's death is a tragedy, and we are fully committed to holding Police Scotland to account to ensure this never happens again.
'Police dogs play an invaluable role within policing and should be provided with the highest level of welfare and care in their time of need'. Thin Blue Paw The Thin Blue Paw foundation criticised the decision to put PD Zara to sleep.
Police Scotland has confirmed that they are reviewing their processes following the death. They have also welcomed the opportunity to speak to members of the Thin Blue Paw.
Chief superintendent Stevie Dolan said: 'Police dogs are a hugely important part of our police family we are totally committed to animal welfare and looking after those in our service.
'We are reviewing our procedures to ensure that any learning from the death of PD Zara is captured and we would welcome the opportunity to meet with representatives of the Thin Blue Paw Foundation to listen to their concerns and discuss our approach to incidents such as this in the future.'
Get all the latest news from around the country Follow STV News
Scan the QR code on your mobile device for all the latest news from around the country
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Herald Scotland
2 hours ago
- The Herald Scotland
Cammy Day complaints raises safe-guarding council issues, report says
The investigation focused on how the Council handled any allegations made, the policy and procedures in place to deal with similar types of allegations and what improvements could be made to safeguard against any inappropriate behaviour in future. The report makes a series of recommendations around the council's complaints procedures and whistleblowing policy with a focus on the safeguarding of victims. It comes after former City of Edinburgh Council leader resigned at the end of last year after two Ukrainian refugees who had settled in the city told a newspaper he repeatedly sent them inappropriate messages on a dating app. Since then, other complaints about Mr Day were revealed by the press. However, the former council leader has since been cleared of criminality in a separate Police Scotland investigation and has claimed he has been subject to a political plot against him. The inquiry published today by the council, however, found there is "no doubt" there is a "significant perceived power imbalance" around the complaints being made to Edinburgh City Council about the "alleged unwanted behaviour" of the former council leader. READ MORE: Cammy Day's conspiracy claims 'really wrong' says ex-Labour colleague Cammy Day probe widened to include all historic complaints The inquiry involved a detailed review of council policies, reports and other documents, webcasts of council meetings and 35 structured interviews. In his report, the author, Mr Dunion, who was appointed to the task in February, writes: "There which have apparently been reported up the management chain, such as alleged unwanted advances being made to junior staff but being treated as gossip, or concerns about a social relationship with a young member of staff being formed, but a procedural response taken, based around the narrow legal requirement for safeguarding." As part of its remit, his report considered whether the safeguards in the Council are sufficient to prevent behaviour such as that alleged in relation to Councillor Day occurring. Mr Dunion states: "The question has been posed in my remit as to whether the safeguards in the Council are sufficient to prevent behaviour such as that alleged in relation to Councillor Day occurring. "In short, the answer is no." Kevin Dunion (Image: supplied) He recommends further consideration of councillors' conduct, their interactions with staff and the appropriateness of some social events in the City Chambers. His comments come as in his review, he notes: "Several councillors and staff interviewed have commented adversely on this prevalent culture of hospitality, which can be taken to excess and have suggested that this practice cease completely." The report also includes a review of a 2018 complaint which involved a 15 year-old boy who was alleged to have been groomed online via email by the council leader and invited to his flat with "sexual intent" in 2010. Even in 2018, the complainant said he remained "fearful" of retaliation if the councillor concerned was made aware he was the complainant, according to the report. As is stated in the report, the complaint was not shared with the Chief Executive and Monitoring Officer. Commenting on the council's handling of this, Mr Dunion states: "There are some inadequacies in the handling of this complaint. "The seriousness of the claim of potentially criminal behaviour by a councillor, who might be the Deputy Leader, is such that the emails should have been shared by the Council Leader with the Chief Executive and Monitoring Officer. "They would then have been in a position to decide whether to contact the police or been able to respond to enquiries from them, had the complainant contacted the police as advised by the Business Manager." Mr Dunion also goes on to point out that the email containing the complaint mentioned the 15-year-old had previously suffered sexual abuse. The investigator states: "This was information which should have been provided to the Council, to decide whether to conduct its own enquiries." He adds: "An unintended and unexpected consequence of not sharing the complaints with the Chief Executive and Monitoring Officer, and retaining the email exchanges only in the individual mailboxes of the recipient, meant that they became vulnerable to loss, and thus significantly diminished the quality of evidence once a report was made to the police." Later on in his recommendations, Mr Dunion highlights the need to properly record complaints. Mr Dunion does, however, find that a complaint made to the Chief Executive in relation to Councillor Day in December 2023 regarding a Ukrainian refugee was "properly considered and investigated in line with the Council's policies and procedures." He also notes that the handling of the two whistleblowing disclosures made in 2023 were "well-handled and properly considered in line with the Council's policies". Recommended measures to improve the complaint system include improved awareness by councillors and staff of what constitutes bullying and harassment and a need for clear routes of the complaint, with expectations as to line management response. Mr Dunion also recommends greater emphasis on providing HR support for staff experiencing poor behaviour from councillors and better record keeping of complaints, informal as well as formal, so that patterns of poor behaviour may be recognised. He also suggests there should be a review of the whistleblowing policy and role of Whistleblowing Sub- Committee. Responding to the review, Chief Executive Paul Lawrence said: 'I want to thank Kevin Dunion for leading this sensitive review and for his report, not least given the complexity of the brief and tight timescales. 'I know this must have been challenging and a difficult experience for many people and I particularly want to thank those who came forward to be interviewed or provided information to the review. Your input is very much appreciated." Subject to approval by councillors next Thursday, the council is expected to bring a further report in August outlining their "proposed actions" in response to Mr Dunion's recommendations Mr Day led the city council's minority administration from 2022 and was deputy council leader for the five-year term preceding that. Concerns surrounding his behaviour had been raised twice through the council's external whistleblowing service, and directly with his former senior coalition partner, the SNP's Adam Nols-McVey. Following this, councillors unanimously agreed to commission a review of how all complaints were handled. Police also opened an investigation into an allegation of inappropriate behaviour against the 50-year-old. However, the police have since said their enquiries uncovered no criminality. Following the allegations, Mr Day claimed to have been the victim of a 'political attack' co-ordinated by his opponents in the City Chambers. Asked if she shared Mr Day's view the allegations that led to his resignation were part of a political plot, Council leader Jane Meagher told The Herald she was unable to comment, however, she did say there were people who want to "undermine" others. Ms Meagher said: 'I don't feel I've got enough information about that. 'I think that inevitably in politics there are people who work away to undermine, but I don't want to make any comment about that. What I want to say is that I am really looking forward to having the former council leader back in the party. 'He's been cleared by the police. I am so looking forward to welcoming him back because he's a very experienced and committed councillor." Pressed on whether she had concerns about the behaviour alleged in various press reports, the Scottish Labour council leader said she "prefer[s] to go with facts rather than allegations.'
Daily Record
2 hours ago
- Daily Record
Cops release CCTV images of man after brutal Edinburgh street attack
Police have released images of man they want to trace after a brutal 2am assault on a busy Edinburgh street. Do you recognise him? Police have released CCTV images of a man they want to trace after a serious assault on a busy Edinburgh street. The incident happened around 2.05am on Saturday, April 26, on Lothian Road in the capital. Officers believe the man in the images could help with their investigation into the violent attack. He is described as being of South Asian appearance, slim build, 5ft 6in to 5ft 9in tall, and in his late teens to early twenties, with short dark hair. At the time of the assault, he was wearing a dark hooded jacket, dark trousers, and dark trainers. Detective Constable Christopher Stewart said: 'I would urge this man, or anyone who recognises him, to come forward and contact us as soon as possible. 'We're also appealing to anyone who witnessed the incident, or who may have information that could help our investigation, to get in touch.' Join the Daily Record WhatsApp community! Get the latest news sent straight to your messages by joining our WhatsApp community today. You'll receive daily updates on breaking news as well as the top headlines across Scotland. No one will be able to see who is signed up and no one can send messages except the Daily Record team. All you have to do is click here if you're on mobile, select 'Join Community' and you're in! If you're on a desktop, simply scan the QR code above with your phone and click 'Join Community'. We also treat our community members to special offers, promotions, and adverts from us and our partners. If you don't like our community, you can check out any time you like. To leave our community click on the name at the top of your screen and choose 'exit group'. If you're curious, you can read our Privacy Notice. Anyone with details is asked to call Police Scotland on 101, quoting incident reference 1272 of 27 April 2025. Alternatively, you can contact Crimestoppers anonymously on 0800 555 111.
Scotsman
2 hours ago
- Scotsman
Detective release image of man that could help with serious assault in Edinburgh
Police have released images of a man they believe may be able to assist officers with an ongoing investigation into an assault in Edinburgh city centre in April. Sign up to the daily Crime UK newsletter. All the latest crime news and trials from across the UK. Sign up Thank you for signing up! Did you know with a Digital Subscription to Edinburgh News, you can get unlimited access to the website including our premium content, as well as benefiting from fewer ads, loyalty rewards and much more. Learn More Sorry, there seem to be some issues. Please try again later. Submitting... The Friday night assault occurred at around 2.05am in the early hours of Saturday, April 26, on Lothian Road, Edinburgh. The man in the images is described as being of South Asian appearance, slim build, 5ft 6in to 5ft 9in tall and aged late teens to early 20s, with short dark hair. He was wearing a dark hooded jacket, dark bottoms and dark trainers. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad The man in the images is described as being of South Asian appearance, slim build, 5ft 6in to 5ft 9in tall and aged late teens to early twenties, with short dark hair. | Police Scotland Detective Constable Christopher Stewart said: 'I would urge this man or anyone who recognises him to please make contact with us. I would also ask anyone who witnessed the incident, or anyone with information relating to the incident, to please speak to officers via 101, quoting reference 1272 of 27 April 2025. 'Alternatively, information can be passed anonymously to Crimestoppers on 0800 555 111.'
