NSW auditor-general Bola Oyetunji warns NSW failing to reduce harm from gaming machines
The NSW government is failing to reduce harm from the pervasive gaming machines that fill out the state's pubs and clubs, a troubling new report has found, with punters losing a massive pot of $8.4bn in just one year.
Auditor-general Bola Oyetunji's Regulation of Gaming Machines report, released on Thursday morning, also reveals that the number of gaming machines across the state has increased in the past two years despite an explicit legislative push to reduce the number of machines.
'NSW had 87,749 gaming machines in operation in clubs and hotels at June 2024,' the report states.
'This means the total number of machines operating in clubs and hotels could increase by almost 8000 and remain within the current legislative cap.
'The total number of gaming machines operating in clubs and hotels has increased in each of the last two financial years by a total of 958 machines.'
The push to reduce the number of machines comes from the passage of the Gaming Machines Act in 2001.
At that time, there were more than 100,000 machines in operation.
Despite the fall to about 88,000 machines today, NSW continues to far outstrip other jurisdictions in the number on offer to punters and the decline rate is slow at about 598 machines per year.
'At this rate, it will take more than 55 years for NSW to reach parity with the national average for gaming machines per 1000 adults,' the report states.
In 2023-24, the machines generated $8.4bn in profit for pubs and clubs, with the patron losses 'disproportionately concentrated' in lower socio-economic areas in Greater Sydney.
The Independent Liquor and Gaming Authority and the Department of Creative Industries, Tourism, Hospitality and Sport are responsible for regulating machines, and the auditor-general found the agencies were failing to effectively support 'harm minimisation' outcomes.
'The department's strategy for regulating gaming machines is not based on a clear understanding of current levels of gambling harm and it does not set any targets for reducing harm associated with gaming machines,' the report states.
'The department does not have benchmarks, targets or other performance measures in place to assess outcomes against key measures of harm minimisation.
'There have been no evaluations of its compliance programs to measure their impact on harm minimisation outcomes.
'As a result, the department does not know whether its regulatory strategy is effective in minimising gambling harm.'
In one example, the auditor-general found regulators had not conducted 'frequent inspections' of regional venues.
'The majority of gaming machines and gaming machine losses are in the Greater Sydney region but there is also a high risk of gambling harm in some regional and rural areas,' the report states.
The state has 12 inspectors, all of whom are based in Greater Sydney.
Gambling harm levels were not falling, the report also stressed.
'For example, calls to the GambleAware Helpline increased by 8.5 per cent in 2023-24 and gaming machine losses have increased in each of the last three years,' the report states.
'The results of the 2024 NSW Gambling Survey did not indicate a reduction in the level of gambling harm in NSW.'
The auditor-general recommends several changes to improve compliance and reduce harm, setting a June 2026 deadline for the government.
For the department, the report recommends 'establishing baselines and targets' for gambling harm minimisation.
It also calls for a review into the state's gaming machine forfeiture scheme to ensure it is achieving the legislative objective of reducing the number of machines in the state.
The scheme requires the compulsory forfeiture of some gaming machine entitlements when they are transferred between venues.
For the Liquor and Gaming Authority, the auditor-general recommends it begin periodic reviews of licence conditions for venues that host machines in the highest risk locations to make sure they align with gambling harm minimisation.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
ABC News
37 minutes ago
- ABC News
Virtual bail court risks access to justice in regional NSW, experts warn
Legal experts are predicting "dire consequences" for people applying for bail in regional NSW who will soon be forced to appear via an online hook-up with a magistrate in Sydney. From early next month, defendants in regional NSW will face their first bail hearings via video link while in police custody. Former magistrate and Southern Cross University Dean of Law David Heilpern said the new system ran the risk of lawyers accepting bad bail conditions "The Sydney magistrates and the Sydney prosecutor and the Sydney defence lawyer might not have any idea of the local geography," Professor Heilpern said. Under the current system, people arrested in NSW would typically have their bail application heard in a courtroom within 24 hours. Defendants usually meet their lawyer face-to-face before the hearing, and family members often travel to the courthouse as a show of support. But since October 2024, bail applications made on a weekend have been done via an audio-visual link with Sydney's Parramatta Local Court. From July 7, six virtual courtrooms will organised into regional hubs, with defendants appearing from police stations and lawyers dialling in remotely. Professor Heilpern said during his 22-year career he regularly witnessed technical issues involving defendants appearing online. "We've all had our nternet and Zoom and Teams meetings drop out, but when it's in court that can be really critical," he said. Professor Heilpern said technology could not replace the benefits of face-to-face justice. "[As a magistrate] I found it was much more difficult to make assessments of people's honesty, integrity and facial expressions over AVL in comparison to being physically in court," he said. "The truth is that often in bail applications, family can help and make the difference between people getting bail and not getting bail. "The human effect and physical interaction should occur [in court] wherever possible." Under the new system, solicitors will be paid to represent online defendants on the day the virtual court sits, but will be prohibited from appearing in a physical courtroom on the same day. Karly Warner, CEO of the Aboriginal Legal Service (ALS) for NSW and the ACT, said the system would reduce ALS lawyers' capacity to offer legal advice to Indigenous people in person. She said the ALS might have to turn down 300 clients a week across NSW. "It is not unusual for our solicitors in regional locations to be doing bail hearings and then to be doing a list of 20-plus Aboriginal people," Ms Warner said. "They can't just shift into a virtual online court when they're still servicing courts locally at the same time." Ms Warner said the new online system "could have incredibly dire consequences". A spokesperson for NSW Attorney General Michael Daley said in a statement that "all government agencies" were working to ensure the virtual court system was ready by July. "[Centalised bail hearings] will improve the handling and oversight of decisions while allowing matters to be heard faster and more efficiently," the spokesperson said. "The Department of Communities and Justice will continue working with legal service providers to ensure accused persons receive legal support."
ABC News
37 minutes ago
- ABC News
Broken Hill man found guilty of stabbing older brother with kitchen knife in family home
A 29-year-old Broken Hill man has been found guilty of intentionally causing grievous bodily harm to his brother when he stabbed him at the family home two years ago. After a trial lasting more than a week, the jury concluded Kyle Ross Henderson had intended to cause serious harm to his brother, Dwayne Henderson, when he plunged a large kitchen knife into his leg during an altercation in June 2023. Dwayne's leg had to be amputated shortly afterwards due to his injuries. The trial centred around whether Henderson intended to cause "serious" injury to his brother and whether he was acting in self-defence when he stabbed him. Throughout the trial, defence counsel Caitlan Akhtar argued her client was acting in self-defence, which he and his partner Megan Bock referred to in their evidence. "He [Dwayne] struck me with a chair … he grabbed me into a headlock and kept hitting me," Henderson said on the witness stand. Prosecutor Shane Drumgold SC told the court this contrasted with evidence from the brothers' father, Mark, who did not recall Dwayne charging Henderson with a chair, nor having him in a headlock when he was stabbed. "I'm going to suggest to you that you made this up," Mr Drumgold put to Kyle Henderson. Henderson denied the allegation. Mr Drumgold told the court his father was reluctant to give evidence against his son, and he was a credible witness. "This was a man in significant emotional pain," he told the court. The court heard that shortly before the stabbing, Henderson punched a hole in the games room door, flipped a table and had an argument with his mother, Jennifer, and a family friend, Bianka Davey, who was also Dwayne's ex-partner. Mr Drumgold told the court Henderson's increasingly aggressive state led Ms Davey to ask the victim to check on his mother. During his account to the jury, Dwayne said the events were "a blur". He said he only recalled phoning his girlfriend while being driven to hospital to tell her he was dying, before later waking up in an Adelaide hospital without his leg. The jury also heard from the Henderson parents, both of whom said they remembered little from the night. "The whole thing has done my head in. I can't even think straight these days," Jennifer Henderson said while giving her evidence. From the start of the trial, the defence never contested that the stabbing occurred, instead arguing the points of intention as well as Henderson's cause for self-defence. While cross-examining Dwayne, Caitlin Akthar asked him about an incident when he smashed a car window with his brother inside, which he confirmed. Separately, one of the prosecution's main witnesses, Kyle Henderson's partner Megan Bock, said the argument with Mrs Henderson agitated the accused and claimed Dwayne Henderson had instigated the fight between the brothers. After five hours and 54 minutes of deliberation, the jury returned a guilty verdict to the charge of causing grievous bodily harm with intent. Henderson will be sentenced at a date to be determined.
Daily Telegraph
39 minutes ago
- Daily Telegraph
Huge change coming to Aussie car market in 2025
Don't miss out on the headlines from On the Road. Followed categories will be added to My News. Australia's car market is undergoing one of its biggest shake-ups in decades, with some experts calling it the most dramatic shift in automotive history. From surging Chinese car brands and a cooling electric vehicle market to aggressive discounting and oversupply, the car industry is in for a bumpy ride. Federal Chamber of Automotive Industries data shows 1,237,287 new cars were delivered in 2024, a 1.7 per cent increase on the previous year. But that growth is not expected to continue. Cox Automotive Australia corporate affairs manager and analyst Mike Costello said flagging sales should improve in the second half of the year. 'Rate cuts from the RBA will help turn this around in H2, as will an uplift in government fleet post Federal Election,' Mr Costello said. While the first half of 2024 was strong, the closing months revealed a slowdown as manufacturers cleared Covid-era backlogs and Australian buyers felt the economic pressure, from inflation and rising interest rates. Now, in the lead-up to June 30, brands are rolling out aggressive discounts and generous drive-away deals. The discounting we're seeing isn't just due to softening demand but is being driven by improved vehicle supply, global overproduction and intensifying competition. The Hyundai Santa Fe is a smart pick for a family-oriented SUV thanks to its three rows of seating and ample room for people and cargo. Picture: Hyundai Motor America via AP During the Covid-19 pandemic, stock shortages meant car dealers could sell vehicles with little or no negotiation but those days are defiantly over. Mr Costello said the industry is at a real 'turning point'. 'We've moved from a seller's market in Covid to a buyer's market now – more in line with historical norm, there's been an improvement in vehicle supply, which has led to the return of incentives and discounting,' he said. Global factories are also playing a role with Chinese automakers facing oversupply in their home market and tightening trade restrictions in Europe and the Unites States. BYD has built it's own carrier vessels to transport EVs globally. Picture: AFP Australia has become a viable market for Chinese car manufacturers which has lead to aggressive local pricing, especially from brands such as BYD, Chery and GWM. data services Director Ross Booth said much of the automotive growth is coming from electric and electrified vehicles. 'We're seeing a clear shift towards more fuel-efficient vehicles, with strong growth in New Energy Vehicles – which include hybrids, plug-in hybrids, and battery electric vehicles,' Mr Booth said. Hybrid and electric vehicle sales made up just 8 per cent of new cars in 2021, jumping to 25 per cent by the end of 2025. 'Looking ahead, we're predicting NEVs to account for up to 35 per cent of the new vehicle market by the end of 2025, driven largely by increased demand for hybrids and PHEVs,' Mr Booth said. Conventional hybrids like the Toyota RAV4 seem to be a sweet spot for buyers. Picture: AFP Conventional hybrids seem to be the sweet spot for buyers not ready to take the full EV jump. In 2024, more than 172,000 hybrid vehicles were sold in Australia, a 76 per cent year-on-year increase, according to Federal Chamber of Automotive Industries (FCAI) data. EV uptake is slowing down despite new models reaching showrooms each month. The biggest shake-up for the industry comes from China. New brands such as BYD, Xpeng, Zeekr and Chery appeal to cost-conscious buyers. BYD sales are up 103 per cent this year, Chery is up 234 per cent and GWM is up 14 per cent. Despite the growth, Mr Costello said some buyers still have reservations. 'It's clear that while a subset of buyers still have reservations, perhaps in part because of their broader opinions on the Chinese State, an ever-growing cohort are opting for more affordable Chinese cars, swayed by their long warranties, cutting-edge tech, and modern designs,' Mr Costello said. 'People are also learning that these vehicles are often no less reliable or capable than other products.' Originally published as Huge change coming to Aussie car market in 2025
