Readers react to Dundee bypass idea amid A90 delays
Readers have had their say on a Dundee bypass after the idea resurfaced following chaos at the Swallow Roundabout.
New traffic lights at the junction have caused long delays, while road markings and signs have caused confusion.
Some, including The Courier's columnist Steve Finan, believe a bypass is the obvious solution to reducing congestion here and on the Kingsway.
After The Courier explained the history of the bypass idea and why one has never been built, readers had their say on the proposal. Dundee bypass would 'unlock economic potential'
Several readers have thrown their support behind a bypass, citing the benefits it could bring to Dundee and north-east Scotland.
Courier website user 'Detective Pikachu' said: 'Any proposed Dundee bypass will come with upfront costs, but the long-term economic and infrastructural benefits far outweigh the short-term costs.
'We should view it as an investment in connectivity and prosperity for the entire region.
'A bypass would ease congestion in Dundee, improve freight and commuter flow, and unlock economic potential not just for the city, but for northern towns and even Aberdeen.' The AWPR Aberdeen bypass has cut journey times for traffic in the north-east. Image: Darrel Benns/DC Thomson
Others cited the Aberdeen Western Peripheral Route (AWPR) as an example of the benefits a Dundee bypass could bring.
The final stretch of the AWPR opened in February 2019.
'JP's Ghost' wrote: 'This Dundee western bypass ought to have been a joined-up project together with Aberdeen's AWPR project, which has made a huge difference to traffic all over the Aberdeen area.
'It took 20 minutes off my pre-retirement, 90-minute commute into the south side industrial estate from western Aberdeenshire and 30 minutes off my Dundee to centre of Aberdeen trips.' 'Dundee badly needs this bypass'
There has also been criticism of the existing Kingsway and its suitability as an outer ring road.
'Claypotts boy' likened the road – which is also called the A90 – to a 'horse and cart track'.
Meanwhile, 'Karen' said: 'Dundee badly needs this bypass.
'The A90 is a nightmare, especially since free-flowing roundabouts at Swallow, Morrisons and Forfar Road have been removed.
'The Swallow 'improvement' just strangles traffic flow, reducing eastbound traffic to one lane. It's very badly designed.' A map showing the approximate route a bypass could take. Image: DC Thomson
'Guthrie' posted: 'It's a gap in the route between north-east Scotland and the rest of the UK.'
Meanwhile, 'Ross' said: 'Wasting millions of pounds on 'upgrades' to the Kingsway etc isn't actually solving the problem and as time goes by it just gets worse and worse.'
'What's going on' said having 'better transport links' with free-flowing traffic was better than cars sitting 'idle' on multiple occasions on their journey across Dundee. Dundee bypass prompts environmental concerns
However, some Courier readers oppose the idea of a Dundee bypass.
A key concern is the impact the road would have on the countryside and the environment.
'Gphillips' said: 'Continuing to build huge roads, with massive environmental impact, is absolutely the wrong thing to be doing.
'For the cost of a bypass, you could install high-quality cycle routes on most roads in Dundee.
'That would do far more to relieve traffic and have far-reaching environmental, social and economic benefits.' Drivers have faced delays at the Swallow Roundabout since lights were introduced in March. Image: Ellidh Aitken/DC Thomson
Other readers are not hopeful about the prospects of a bypass being built.
'Speug' said: 'Forget it – there would be thousands of objections to that route and it would cost billions.'
'Stewart B' wrote: 'Remember how long it took to get the Aberdeen bypass and the debacle of dualling the A9?
'I will not be holding my breath.
'(I'm) pretty sure I will be pushing up the daisies before a Dundee bypass ever happens.' Should an alternative bypass route be considered?
Others, including the Dundee Civic Trust, have called for an upgrade of existing roads that already bypass the city.
The A94 connecting Perth to Forfar has been put forward as a possible option.
Courier reader 'Stobie Ferret' is behind this idea, saying: 'Why not just upgrade the A94 from Perth to Forfar with a couple of much smaller bypasses around Coupar Angus and Meigle?
'Especially now you've got the new Tay crossing bypass onto the A94 at Perth.'
'Gregor McIntosh' proposed a different alternative, which would mean reversing some of the brutal Beeching cuts to railways in the 1960s.
He said: 'How about (we) rebuild all the railways that got closed in the 60s rather than reinforce the already god awful car dependency in Dundee and Angus?'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Courier
a day ago
- The Courier
Top 5 things to do in Kinross & Loch Leven
Just south of Perth, and only 30 minutes from Edinburgh, the beautiful area of Kinross and Loch Leven is the perfect base for holidaymakers in the heart of Scotland, or an ideal spot for enjoying a day out of the city. Some Courier online content is funded by outside parties. The revenue from this helps to sustain our independent news gathering. You will always know if you are reading paid-for material as it will be clearly labelled as 'Partnership' on the site and on social media channels, This can take two different forms. This means the content has been paid for and produced by the named advertiser. This means the content has been paid for and approved by the named advertiser but written and edited by our own commercial content team. The town itself is one long street, full of gorgeous independent shops and cafes, selling everything from books to bangles! You'll also find a host of tasty tearooms, restaurants and cafes selling freshly prepared meals and a mouthwatering selection of home baking. Venture a little further and you will discover a town steeped in history, surrounded by stunning landscapes, and offering a generous mix of activities and attractions. We've pulled together our top five ideas for planning your trip to this gorgeous wee corner of Scotland. Small but perfectly formed, Kinross High Street offers a wonderful selection of independent retailers and specialist shops, ranging from a traditional haberdashery to second-hand books, a proper little pet shop and fabulous gifts, jewellery and clothing. Loch Leven's Larder. Just three miles out of town, this unique family-run farm, restaurant, deli and retail experience is an unexpected shopper's haven in a scenic rural setting. Take a break from shopping with a stop at one of the cafés, bars, hotels and restaurants. From big breakfasts to flavourful Indian meals and authentic Italian pizza, you'll find a warm welcome from the many cooks, chefs and servers ready and waiting to keep you fuelled and happy. Unorthodox Roasters Coffee Shop, where carefully selected coffee beans are roasted right there in front of you before being supplied to many of the other cafes on the street. Extra points for delicious home baking! A huge expanse of open water, Loch Leven provides an ideal home for countless birds. Watch the quiet persistence of tufted duck and teal dabbling for food or marvel at the awe-inspiring sight of the summer ospreys. Keep your nose alert too, and it may lead you to the sweetly scented holy grass, an ancient form of incense. The Royal Society for the Protection of Birds (RSPB) runs a visitor centre on its section of the reserve which has a shop, café, educational facilities, toilets, and marked trails leading to three bird hides that look out over the wetlands. Loch Leven Castle holds much in the way of historical significance as the tower house where Mary Queen of Scots was held. Built in the 1300s, it is one of Scotland's oldest fortresses. See the tower house rooms where Mary was held against her will and the 16th-century Glassin Tower (a charming residential extension), and enjoy the quiet island setting. Take a boat ride over to the castle and follow in the footsteps of Mary Queen of Scots and Robert the Bruce. Running daily from 10am to 4.30pm during April to September, pick up is at Kinross Ferry. The Gin Laboratory is the perfect place for gin aficionados to have fun, learn and create their own gin. Take your place in the centre of the laboratory, which is full of metal, glass and copper distilling gizmos where you can sample over 40 botanicals, distilled one-at-a-time. : Book a Gin Experience for you and up to seven friends and during the 90-minute hands-on class you will blend three personalised gins to enjoy with tonic and leave with a 25cl bottle of your own recipe gin. To discover more Kinross shops, eateries and attractions, visit the Kinross and Loch Leven section on the Perth City and Towns website.
The Courier
a day ago
- The Courier
Bellaty Lodge: I explore abandoned shooting lodge in Glenisla built for dowager Lady Kinloch
Hidden deep in woodland in Glenisla, you would never know Bellaty Lodge existed. Built in the early 1900s for the Dowager Lady Kinloch, today the huge mansion lies in ruins. That doesn't mean it's lost all its grandeur: what remains of Bellaty stands proudly, if a little forlornly. I drove deep into the heart of Glenisla on a mission to explore the decaying shooting lodge for the first time last week. I'd driven past it countless times, but had no clue it was there, just a few minutes' walk from the B951 running through the glen. Having seen a post about it on social media, I was determined to track it down. And tracking it down turned out to be my first stumbling block. Without giving too much away – because finding such hidden gems for yourself is a huge part of the appeal – I hit the jackpot after a botched first attempt. Here's a hint – don't type 'Bellaty' into Google Maps and expect to find it. There's a farm called Bellaty and that is certainly not the old shooting lodge. There's a derelict house close to the farm, too, but I wouldn't advise exploring that. It's in a seriously precarious condition, and there are gates, fences and scratchy bushes galore to put off would-be explorers. Suffice to say, I found Bellaty Lodge not too far away, and my goodness, what a feast for the eyes. It's an enormous, roofless shell, but there are loads of fascinating features. I was drawn to the building's many fireplaces, some on upper levels and full of birds' nests, a curious wooden shed, a rusting fire grate, and fallen bricks, marked 'Muir Armadale'. I also located the stone steps at the front of the house, although they're completely overgrown. And outside, I almost tripped over an old, strange-looking metal bucket with holes in it. The lodge has been pretty much reclaimed by nature: huge trees have taken root within, and nettles dominate. I was stung numerous times. It was constructed for the Dowager Lady Kinloch – the widow of Lord Kinloch – in the early 1900s. A story in The Courier on May 23, 1904, reported that she was building a shooting lodge on her 'recently bought estate of Bellaty'. It's thought she left the lodge around 1916, when the entire contents were sold at various public auctions over the following years. A report in The Courier on June 3, 1919, stated that she sold Bellaty Lodge to Mr L. R. Melville, of Melville & Graham, solicitors, Dundee and Errol. The estate came complete with 'splendid shooting' and the fishing of nearby Auchentaple Loch. The following month, a report told how the lodge's furniture and furnishings – belonging to Lady Kinloch – were to be sold on July 7, 1919, in Alyth Town Hall. Among the contents included: a piano in a black ebony case, a rosewood bookcase, mahogany chairs, tables, desks and knife boxes, a Persian carpet, an oak dinner wagon, Duchess chests, a butter churn, a typewriter, various garden tools and machinery, milk 'luggies', plus trunks, handbags, and leather travel luggage. Following the sale, a report said: 'There was keen competition, and good prices were realised. The drawing-room carpet brought £49.' Bellaty was then sold to new owners, the Nicols. One of the family members, Miss Anne Nicol, featured in the local news after attending a society dance in Kirriemuir in January 1922. She was described as a 'charming' member of the party, 'whose red golden hair was prettily set off by her graceful frock of soft cream chiffon over gold tissue'. Also reported in January 1922 was a New Year party, held by the Nicol family at Bellaty, and attended by friends. The staging of the 'humorous' plays of Mechanical Jane and Cinderella were said to have cause 'great merriment'. Meanwhile, guests were also treated to 'splendid dancing exhibitions'. In January 1925, the Nicols held a whist drive and dance during which 'about 40 ladies and gentlemen sat down to a pleasant tea'. Highland fling, sword dances and fortune telling were also included in the entertainment. However, in the 1930s and 40s, Bellaty was rented out to tenants during the shooting and fishing seasons, complete with linen, cutlery, plates and maids 'if desired'. Adverts in newspapers offered those who rented it an 'exceedingly comfortable' house, with access to unlimited trout fishing and 350 acres of shooting. I'll be honest though – I don't think Bellaty Lodge was the most beautiful building. I managed to find an old photo of it in its heyday via Angus Archives (we can't use this here, alas), and my goodness, it was, in my humble opinion, borderline ugly. Essentially, it was a two-storey, flat-roofed, rectangular block coated in white render, with a three-storey 'tower' stuck on to a rear corner. It boasted 18 rooms, including five public rooms, seven bedrooms and two bathrooms – plus a garage. The views would have been stunning – down to the River Isla and across the glen. Those views still exist, although they've become obscured by trees and out-of-control vegetation. Alas, Bellaty was only in use for just over half a century. Dundee-based demolition company Charles Brand dismantled it in 1954, with roof slates, floorboards, fireplaces and woodwork salvaged and sold. It was then used for agricultural storage – and it was being used to store straw when a fire ripped through it in August 1986. Firefighters were there for almost 24 hours carrying out 'damping operations'. It continues to fall further into decay and it might not be long before another chimney pot crashes to the ground, or an entire wall collapses. It may be fading into obscurity but it still bears faint echoes of the past. It's fascinating to imagine the lives of those who lived here – and who enjoyed Bellaty's lavish parties and entertainment.
The Courier
2 days ago
- The Courier
Inside the £150-a-night converted private jet on an Angus farm
A private jet has been converted into a £150-a-night short-term holiday let on an Angus farm. Conservative councillor and farmer Iain Gall bought the Hawker 700 on eBay for £25,000 in 2022. The 37-year-old estimates he has spent an additional £50,000 on the jet as he prepares to welcome his first guests. Iain hoped to have the getaway up and running in 2023, but due to a busy period on the farm and other holiday accommodations to manage, the project was delayed. He told The Courier: 'We have the planning permission and now we are just waiting for the short-term let licence. 'We intended to open in 2023, but I ended up taking on some other houses, and the farm has been really busy; it is one of those things that has dragged on. 'The plane was already converted, but we have had the cockpit walls wrapped in tweed. 'I wanted to keep the original interior with the captain's chairs and the leather. 'The only thing is the cockpit where the tweed boards have been put in to make it feel more cosy.' The jet sits on Iain's family's Glenskinno Farm near Montrose. The twin-engined British Aerospace aircraft was formerly owned by a Russian tycoon and featured on the TV show George Clarke's Amazing Spaces as it was converted into a living space in 2020. Iain says there was initially confusion with securing the short-term let licence due to the farm's land ownership titles being old, however, he expects it to be approved soon. He added: 'There has been a large amount of interest and people trying to book. 'I wanted to make sure it was ready. 'If you are in the plane, it is really nice, but it is quite small and difficult to stand up inside, so I decided to add a garden room. 'Even if it is a horrible day with the rain, guests can sit in there and look out onto the countryside. 'It is all well and good for me to think it is a good idea, but how do you actually live there for a couple of nights? 'There was never a rush, it was always going to be ready when it was ready.'
