Waitangi Tribunal already doing exactly what it was originally intended to do, Treaty law experts say
Members of Te Rūnanga Nui, the Waitangi Tribunal and the Ministry of Education being welcomed onto Hoani Waititi Marae in 2023.
Photo:
Pokere Paewai / RNZ
Treaty law experts say the Waitangi Tribunal is already doing exactly what it was originally intended to do.
A government
review announced last week
- part of the coalition agreement between New Zealand First and National - is set to refocus the "scope, purpose and nature" of the Tribunal's inquiries back to its "original intent".
The review will be led by an Independent Technical Advisory Group of four chaired by Bruce Gray KC.
The other members of the group are lawyer and former Waitangi Tribunal member David Cochrane, Te Kotahitanga o Te Atiawa chief executive Dion Tuuta and senior public servant and former chief executive of Te Kohanga Reo National Trust Kararaina Calcott-Cribb.
Te Hunga Rōia Māori, the Māori Law Society co-president Natalie Coates said it would be a big task to conduct a wide sweeping review within the timeframe.
Engagement on the review will begin in mid-2025 and advice will be provided to ministers by September.
Coates was not adverse to an
independent review
taking place, given it has been 50 years, but she said there was a deep scepticism amongst the Māori community given the government's approach to te Tiriti and Māori issues in general.
When the Waitangi Tribunal was set up in 1975, it did not have the ability to look backwards, so the original conception of the Tribunal was to respond to contemporary breaches of te Tiriti or Waitangi, she said.
Natalie Coates.
Photo:
Tania Niwa
"I guess I've been a little bit confused about that kind of wording or at least find it interesting and curious because I think what the Tribunal is currently doing is actually focusing on and doing what they were originally set up to do."
Coates said even though its recommendations weren't binding the Tribunal played a critical role as a check and balance on Crown power.
"It should be a good thing to know whether the Crown is breaching te Tiriti o Waitangi so that informed decisions can be made, and I think the idea being [thrown] around of them being activist is just not true.
"They're doing the job that they were set up to do, and they're doing so with the kind of the full intellectual rigour that applies in those spaces."
Treaty Law scholar Carwyn Jones said he hadn't seen the full terms of reference for the review beyond the statement's by Minister Tama Potaka, and what was contained within National and New Zealand First's coalition agreement to refocus the Tribunal back to its "original intent."
"I was always a bit confused by that because as far as I could tell, the Tribunal was doing exactly what was originally intended.
"Its original intent was that it would focus on current or contemporary crown actions or policy," he said.
The Tribunal had played a crucial role over this term of government in scrutinising Crown policy for its impact particularly on Māori, he said.
"What we see is that the government doesn't like the Tribunal asking questions about quite basic things around good government, about what is your policy intended to do, what's the problem you're trying to solve, have you looked at options, do you know what the impact of it is?
"All of these things the Tribunal is making transparent that the government has no answers to across a whole range of policy so of course the government doesn't like that."
Treaty Law scholar Carwyn Jones.
Photo:
RNZ
That's a sentiment that Coates echoed.
"I mean, no government really loves the Tribunal because their whole purpose is to tell it what it's doing wrong on a treaty front," she said.
Jones said David Seymour's comments about the Tribunal becoming "increasingly activist" showed that from the government's perspective, the Tribunal had been too effective in holding the government to account.
"We've seen that time and again through a whole range of government policy, whether it's the removal of section 7AA of the Oranga Tamariki Act or whether it's through Māori wards or even this review itself, the government has not defined what the problem is... because all it is is this kind of 'government by vibe' this evidence free policy development."
As a permanent Commission of Inquiry, the Tribunal actually had a lot of flexibility about its own process and had been very agile and adaptive in changing to meet different needs across its 50 year history, he said.
"So the Tribunal itself is making those changes, it's constantly reviewing what it's doing and whether it's working.
"So I don't think it's particularly helpful for the government to be doing this, really all the Tribunal needs is more support and resources for it to more effectively deliver."
Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero
,
a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Scoop
an hour ago
- Scoop
Macron Talks New Caledonia At Pacific-France Summit
Article – RNZ Macron dedicated a significant part of his address to the situation in New Caledonia. , Correspondent French Pacific Desk French president Emmanuel Macron chaired a Pacific-France summit on Tuesday, in the margins of the UN Ocean Conference (UNOC) held in Nice. In his opening speech, the French head of state touched on several aspects of France's cooperation in the Pacific region, including in terms of environment, defence and geostrategy. €2 million Euros for Pacific Forum's Resilient Facility Pledging to maintain France's diplomacy 'in very close connection with our common interests in the Pacific', including the recent opening of a new Embassy in Apia, Samoa, Macron acknowledged the 'central' role played by the Pacific Islands Forum, which will receive about €2 million Euros as a contribution to the Pacific Resilient Facility fund for the region. He also mentioned the opening of a project to introduce new air links connecting French Polynesia, the Cook Islands, Fiji, Tonga and Samoa. He also touched on France-Pacific cooperation at 'strategic and military' levels, through a recently-created 'Pacific Academy' and regular joint regional exercises in order to foster 'common credibility to protect our zones and fight against illegal fishing'. High on the agenda were key issues such as climate change and its adverse effects on Pacific Island states on human lives and biodiversity, natural disasters affecting the region, breaches of sovereignty and security resulting from illegal fishing, and trans-regional crime, especially the rising problem of drug trafficking. In terms of regional maritime security and fight against criminality, especially illegal, unreported and unregulated fishing (IUU), France, but also Australia and New Zealand Navys are regularly contributing to patrols in the Pacific Islands Forum's Fisheries Agency (FFA) member states' exclusive economic zones (EEZs). Significant part dedicated to New Caledonia Macron dedicated a significant part of his address to the situation in New Caledonia, one year after the deadly riots that broke out in May 2024 (causing 14 deaths and and estimated €2.2 billion Euros in damages). He told Pacific leaders he was aware of Pacific concerns about 'the events that destabilized New Caledonia a year ago '. 'I want to tell you here… The French state has respected its commitments made decades ago by organizing in recent years three referendums with United Nations observers which were validated and noted. 'But a year ago, violence broke out, triggered by several factors… which we took very seriously.' Macron said since then, France has unlocked 'more than €3 billion Euros' for New Caledonia's economic reconstruction. 'And we have spared no effort with the government, in particular the Minister of State [Minister for Overseas Manuel Valls] to restore dialogue between all parties.' Since February Valls has managed to bring all of New Caledonia's political camps around the same table, something that had not happened since 2022. But the proposal he put on the table in early May, during a behind-closed-doors 'conclave', drew ire from parties in favour of New Caledonia remaining a part of France. They objected, saying Valls' project failed to take into account that the three recent referendums had expressed a rejection of independence and that the Minister's 'sovereignty with France' offer (including transfer of key powers from France to New Caledonia, a dual Kanaky-France citizenship and an international standing) was tantamount to some form of independence which they strongly objected to. A 'new project' on the table in July? On discussions about a resumption of talks to find a bipartisan and comprehensive agreement on the French Pacific territory's future political status, Macron also confirmed that he will 'hold a summit in Paris in the coming weeks to bring together all stakeholders again and manage to come up with a new project'. Macron said after holding three referendums between 2018 and 2021 on New Caledonia's sovereignty, he was not in favour of holding yet another one. 'I must say I honestly believe Pacific, Oceanian or Melanesian cultures are more based on consultation and circularity, not really suited for referendums …whereby you're supposed to express a clearcut yes or no.' We won't make the same mistakes again 'We will not make the same mistakes again in the future,' Macron told Pacific islands leaders, including those from the three French Pacific territories of New Caledonia, French Polynesia and Wallis and Futuna. He said building a political solution for New Caledonia was still work in progress 'with a lot of humility, together'. And in this process, he told regional leaders 'we welcome your advice' and 'recommendations'. He mentioned and thanked Pacific Islands Forum leaders for a fact-finding mission that travelled to New Caledonia in late 2024 and gave rise to 'very productive exchanges'. 'We will do all we can to succeed and I am confident we'll do it with respect for everyone and for all (New) Caledonians, for peace, unity and stability in the region. 'But we are trying to hold this dialogue while respecting the various opinions and the principles of democracy.' During the same Pacific-France summit, Macron also held talks with leaders from Papua New Guinea, Palau, Samoa, Tonga, Fiji, Marshall Islands, Kiribati, the Federated States of Micronesia, Solomon Islands and Vanuatu. The Pacific Islands Forum delegation was headed by its secretary-general Baron Waqa.

RNZ News
an hour ago
- RNZ News
Auckland CBD's community engagement model could be used in suburbs
Police Minister Mark Mitchell says a similar model of community engagement as was done in the central city could be implemented in Northcote. Photo: RNZ / Marika Khabazi Social housing, rough sleepers and police responsiveness have been flagged as priorities for Auckland's Northcote community, after a meeting with the police minister this week. The meeting at the Northcote Birkenhead rugby club on Monday night brought together residents and business owners with Police Minister Mark Mitchell, as well as local MP Dan Bidois, police district commander Naila Hassan and other police staff. Mitchell told RNZ the community said to him that they had noticed a change. "I've literally done hundreds of these public meetings around the country over the last few years, and the nice thing is for me is they seem to getting more and more positive in terms of, people are starting to see and notice a real difference in terms of, certainly, on the law and order and pubic safety side of it," he said. Mitchell said managing rough sleepers was a wide issue. "It's been around for a while, we've been working on that in the CBD too," he said. "Often, many of these people have actually got safe homes and beds to go to, it's more of a lifestyle choice where they're coming together as a community, and of course there's all the social issues around them, not only can they cause issues themselves but they can become targets too, for those coming into the CBD." Community members also raised concerns over some residents in local Kāinga Ora housing, with Mitchell focusing on those who did not live up to the "social contract that they have when they're provided tax-payer funded housing". "The government's been far more proactive in making sure that there is actually action taken against those people, because they do cause massive issues in the communities they're in," Mitchell said. There was an expectation that residents in social housing make their communities as safe and harmonious as they could, he said. When it came to the prioritisation of police callouts, a concern voiced by a local shopkeeper, Mitchell said officers had to put greater risk callouts first. "Of course police always have to prioritise, and they always have had to prioritise, it'll be based on risk to human life first and foremost, and then they sort of start working down from there," he said. Mitchell said a similar model of community engagement as was done in the central city could be implemented in Northcote. "I said the model that we used for the Auckland CBD was very effective, and that was bringing all the stakeholders together," he said. "I suggested that [MP for Northcote] Dan Bidois take the lead on that, get everyone together; local board, business associations, residents and ratepayers associations or residents' associations, and the government agencies if they need them, make up a list of what the biggest issues are, and concerns and just start working through it." Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.

RNZ News
an hour ago
- RNZ News
NZ joins allies, puts travel bans on Israeli ministers
New Zealand has joined other countries in putting travel bans on two Israeli government ministers, prompting swift criticism from Israel and a rare rebuke from the United States to its allies. The two men at the centre of the bans: Itamar Ben-Gvir and Bezalel Smotrich are right wing hardliners who's support is essential to Netanyahu's coalition government. Our government said sanctioning the two men was the right thing to do. But opposition parties said it should have gone much further, much faster, accusing the government of cowardice. To embed this content on your own webpage, cut and paste the following: See terms of use.