Movie review: 'Dogma' re-release highlights thoughtful script

UPI

23-05-2025

1 of 5 | Ben Affleck (L) and Matt Damon star in "Dogma," returning to theaters June 5. Photo courtesy of Triple Media Films
LOS ANGELES, May 23 (UPI) -- Dogma, returning to theaters June 5, comes from a decade where indie writer/directors were celebrated for the words in their screenplays. Kevin Smith was one of the major voices that emerged in the era of Quentin Tarantino, Richard Linklater and Sofia Coppola.
In his first film, Clerks, Smith had his convenience store clerks express all of his thoughts about Star Wars, retail and relationships. Dogma, his fourth film, was the work of a writer who grew up Catholic and had thoughts about faith.
Exiled angels Bartleby (Ben Affleck) and Loki (Matt Damon) find a way to get back into heaven. As part of a Catholicism outreach campaign, New Jersey Cardinal Glick (George Carlin) promises forgiveness to anyone who passes through his church's arch.
If the angels gain forgiveness, then take human form and die, God will have no choice but to allow them back into heaven. What they don't realize is that invalidating God's decree will cause the end of all existence.
So God's Metatron (Alan Rickman) visits Planned Parenthood employee Bethany (Linda Fiorentino) and gives her the task of preventing Loki and Bartleby from entering the church. Smith regulars Jay (Jason Mewes) and Silent Bob (Smith) are sent as prophets to help Bethany in her quest.
This is a story that adapts Catholic scripture into a modern apocalyptic story, but it is really a vehicle for characters to talk about religion, the way characters in other Smith movies talk about movies and comic books.
That dialogue is performed emphatically, and more subtly it's well edited by Smith and producer Scott Mosier. Smith's biblical figures would use the F word while making their profound points, but maybe they learned it from millennia of humans, or at the Tower of Babel.
The film's messages challenge some of the oldest doctrines of Catholicism. No one has to base their values on a movie, but as an artistic exploration of this thesis, all of Smith's questions are backed up by a creative interpretation of the scripture.
The message is ultimately that God doesn't care which religion you follow as long as you believe. That would offend organized religion, but the film unabashedly believes in God.
Jesus' unsung 13th apostle Rufus (Chris Rock) tells Bethany that God wants people to think for themselves. As bold a take on religion as that might be, it is ultimately optimistic.
Bethany is a character seeking to regain her faith. She remembers the feelings that church gave her as a child.
Yet she no longer feels that as an adult, which is understandable with painful life experience. But she's open to restoring her faith and this adventure gives her a reason.
Of course, Smith has a mischievous spark. Loki likes to talk nuns out of their faith when he's literally an Angel with knowledge of God herself (Alanis Morissette).
Smith speculates on eras of Jesus' life that were not in the Bible as characters speak of their time with him. Those extrapolations show empathy towards the burden of being the son of God for a teenager.
They're also not meant to be canonical. Smith's point is to get viewers thinking as they laugh, not launch a religion himself.
Exposure to biblical figures certainly does not make Jay any more wholesome, but his ability to keep making vulgar sexual innuendo amid crises of faith of apocalyptic proportions is impressive.
There is a little bit of gay panic when Bethany mistakes Bartleby and Loki for lovers, and Rufus exposes Jay's secret desires for men. Characters also use the R-word, because 1999 was unfortunately before many people learned it was a slur, but Smith has addressed both of those issues in subsequent work.
The complicated release history of Dogma, passing between several studios, has made it difficult to see since its Blu-ray release. Now out of print and not streaming anywhere, the re-release is a welcome return of one of Smith's seminal works.
Fred Topel, who attended film school at Ithaca College, is a UPI entertainment writer based in Los Angeles. He has been a professional film critic since 1999, a Rotten Tomatoes critic since 2001, and a member of the Television Critics Association since 2012 and the Critics Choice Association since 2023. Read more of his work in Entertainment.