logo
The Senator Who Failed America on Vaccines

The Senator Who Failed America on Vaccines

The Atlantica day ago

It's easy to forget that Robert F. Kennedy Jr.'s assault on vaccines—including, most recently, his gutting of the expert committee that guides American vaccine policy—might have been avoided. Four months ago, his nomination for health secretary was in serious jeopardy. The deciding vote seemed to be in the hands of one Republican senator: Bill Cassidy of Louisiana. A physician who gained prominence by vaccinating low-income kids in his home state, Cassidy was wary of the longtime vaccine conspiracist. 'I have been struggling with your nomination,' he told Kennedy during his confirmation hearings in January.
Then Cassidy caved.
In the speech he gave on the Senate floor explaining his decision, Cassidy said that he'd vote to confirm Kennedy only because he had extracted a number of concessions from the nominee—chief among them that he would preserve, 'without changes,' the very CDC committee Kennedy overhauled this week. Since then, Cassidy has continued to give Kennedy the benefit of the doubt. On Monday, after Kennedy dismissed all 17 members of the vaccine advisory committee, Cassidy posted on X that he was working with Kennedy to prevent the open roles from being filled with 'people who know nothing about vaccines except suspicion.'
The senator has failed, undeniably and spectacularly. One new appointee, Robert Malone, has repeatedly spread misinformation (or what he prefers to call 'scientific dissent') about vaccines. Another appointee, Vicky Pebsworth, is on the board of an anti-vax nonprofit, the National Vaccine Information Center. Cassidy may keep insisting that he is doing all he can to stand up for vaccines. But he already had his big chance to do so, and he blew it. Now, with the rest of America, he's watching the nation's vaccine future take a nosedive.
So far, the senator hasn't appeared interested in any kind of mea culpa for his faith in Kennedy's promises. On Thursday, I caught Cassidy as he hurried out of a congressional hearing room. He was still reviewing the appointees, he told me and several other reporters who gathered around him. When I chased after him down the hallway to ask more questions, he told me, 'I'll be putting out statements, and I'll let those statements stand for themselves.' A member of his staff dismissed me with a curt 'Thank you, sir.' Cassidy's staff has declined repeated requests for an interview with the senator since the confirmation vote in January.
With the exception of Mitch McConnell, every GOP senator voted to confirm Kennedy. They all have to own the health secretary's actions. But Cassidy seemed to be the Republican most concerned about Kennedy's nomination, and there was a good reason to think that the doctor would vote his conscience. In 2021, Cassidy was one of seven Senate Republicans who voted to convict Donald Trump on an impeachment charge after the insurrection at the Capitol. But this time, the senator—who is up for reelection next year, facing a more MAGA-friendly challenger—ultimately fell in line.
Cassidy tried to have it both ways: elevating Kennedy to his job while also vowing to constrain him. In casting his confirmation vote, Cassidy implied that the two would be in close communication, and that Kennedy had asked for his input on hiring decisions. The two reportedly had breakfast in March to discuss the health secretary's plan to dramatically reshape the department. 'Senator Cassidy speaks regularly with secretary Kennedy and believes those conversations are much more productive when they're held in private, not through press headlines,' a spokesperson for Cassidy wrote in an email. (A spokesperson for HHS did not immediately respond to a request for comment.)
At times, it has appeared as though Cassidy's approach has had some effect on the health secretary. Amid the measles outbreak in Texas earlier this year, Kennedy baselessly questioned the safety of the MMR vaccine. In April, after two unvaccinated children died, Cassidy posted on X: 'Everyone should be vaccinated! There is no treatment for measles. No benefit to getting measles. Top health officials should say so unequivocally b/4 another child dies.' Cassidy didn't call out Kennedy by name, but the health secretary appeared to get the message. Later that day, Kennedy posted that the measles vaccine was the most effective way to stave off illness. ('Completely agree,' Cassidy responded.)
All things considered, that's a small victory. Despite Kennedy's claims that he is not an anti-vaxxer, he has enacted a plainly anti-vaccine agenda. Since being confirmed, he has pushed out the FDA's top vaccine regulator, hired a fellow vaccine skeptic to investigate the purported link between autism and shots, and questioned the safety of childhood vaccinations currently recommended by the CDC. As my colleague Katherine J. Wu wrote this week, 'Whether he will admit to it or not, he is serving the most core goal of the anti-vaccine movement—eroding access to, and trust in, immunization.'
The reality is that back channels can be only so effective. Cassidy's main power is to call Kennedy before the Senate health committee, which he chairs, and demand an explanation for Kennedy's new appointees to the CDC's vaccine-advisory committee. Cassidy might very well do that. In February, he said that Kennedy would 'come before the committee on a quarterly basis, if requested.' Kennedy did appear before Cassidy's committee last month to answer questions about his efforts to institute mass layoffs at his agency. Some Republicans (and many Democrats) pressed the secretary on those efforts, while others praised them. Cassidy, for his part, expressed concerns about Kennedy's indiscriminate cutting of research programs, but still, he was largely deferential. 'I agree with Secretary Kennedy that HHS needs reform,' Cassidy said.
Even if he had disagreed, an angry exchange between a health secretary and a Senate committee doesn't guarantee any policy changes. Lawmakers may try to act like government bureaucrats report to them, but they have limited power once a nominee is already in their job. Technically, lawmakers can impeach Cabinet members, but in American history, a sitting Cabinet member has never been impeached and subsequently removed from office. The long and arduous confirmation process is supposed to be the bulwark against potentially dangerous nominees being put in positions of power. Cassidy and most of his Republican colleagues have already decided not to stop Kennedy from overseeing the largest department in the federal government by budget. Now Kennedy is free to do whatever he wants—senators be damned.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Trump's military parade, in photos and videos
Trump's military parade, in photos and videos

Washington Post

time21 minutes ago

  • Washington Post

Trump's military parade, in photos and videos

President Donald Trump held a military parade through the streets of Washington to celebrate the Army's 250th anniversary on Saturday, which was also Trump's 79th birthday. The massive military parade drew tanks and thousands of soldiers and coincided with nationwide protests against Trump and his policies. The three-hour parade featured troops dressed in historical uniforms, bombers doing flyovers, and members of the Golden Knights parachute team falling from the sky. The parade was designed to compete with the grandeur of parades and other spectacles Trump has witnessed in foreign countries. 'We want to show off a little bit,' he said Tuesday. On the National Mall, there were displays of weaponry and other military equipment, and fitness competitions among soldiers, staged as part of the Army's 250th anniversary. Combat medics demonstrated how they treat injuries in conflict zones, and children waited in line to sit in attack helicopters and armored vehicles. Many attendees sported MAGA hats and other pro-Trump paraphernalia: J6 hats, a Trump 2028 banner, even a sign declaring Trump king — a stab at the numerous 'No Kings' rallies taking place across the country in opposition to what organizers see as Trump's widening authoritarianism. The parade also drew protesters of all ages, both local residents and visitors from across the country. Hundreds streamed down 14th Street on a march from Logan Circle to the White House. Amid a sea of MAGA hats or those that said 'Trump 2028,' a few lone protesters stood along 15th Street NW near the Washington Monument. Eric Slutz, 73, reached his arms up to hold a pink laminated paper that said 'NO KINGS.' 'This army that is marching by us was founded to fight a king,' he said, pointing to the military ranks rolling past on the street. 'And that's what we're doing 250 years later,' added his wife, Laurie Slutz, 71. But some attendees just wanted to enjoy the spectacle of the largest show of military might in the capital in more than three decades. 'We're celebrating 250 years of incredible service that guaranteed our freedom,' said Jeffrey Marquardt, 60, who drove from Scranton, Pennsylvania, to attend the Army festival and parade. June 14 marks the 250th anniversary of the Continental Congress vote to establish the Continental Army. Many attendees also celebrated Flag Day by wearing the U.S. flag on T-shirts, shorts, dresses, visors, cowboy hats and headbands. Overall, a total of 150 vehicles, 50 aircraft and 6,600 soldiers were expected during the parade. The cost for the massive event was estimated at $25 million to $45 million, an Army spokesperson said. The Army has vowed to foot the bill for any damage to city streets, with heavy tanks a particular concern. The military parade concluded as the procession of tanks reached Independence Avenue, where the tree foliage obscured their exit. The crowd gathered at the National Mall cheered as the event turned into a concert. Country singer Lee Greenwood performed his signature song 'God Bless the U.S.A.' as attendees followed the song with chants of 'U-S-A!' Vice President JD Vance took the stage, praised the Army and wished Trump a happy birthday, before noting it was also his wedding anniversary with Usha Vance. Trump took the stage last, joined by first lady Melania Trump, where he gave a speech thanking soldiers for their service and touting U.S. military prowess. 'Because our soldiers never give up, never surrender, and never, ever quit. They fight, fight, fight, and they win, win, win,' Trump said. At the end of the speech, a member of the Army Golden Knights presented Trump with the American flag, and a fireworks display over the National Mall closed out the festivities.

Photos: A Military Parade in D.C.
Photos: A Military Parade in D.C.

Atlantic

time22 minutes ago

  • Atlantic

Photos: A Military Parade in D.C.

Yesterday, the American public witnessed one of the most extravagant and unusual displays of patriotic pageantry in recent memory: an Army festival and military parade in the nation's capital. Nearly 7,000 soldiers, 28 Abrams tanks, 50 helicopters, 34 horses, two mules, and a single dog marched through a cloudy and drizzling Washington, D.C. The event, a celebration of the Army's 250th anniversary, also fell on President Donald Trump's 79th birthday—and took place against a backdrop of fierce immigration crackdowns and nationwide protests against the administration. While millions demonstrated across the country, crowds in the capital appeared lower than expected as thunderstorms threatened in the forecast.

Search Broadens as Investigators Race to Track Down Minnesota Suspect
Search Broadens as Investigators Race to Track Down Minnesota Suspect

Miami Herald

time26 minutes ago

  • Miami Herald

Search Broadens as Investigators Race to Track Down Minnesota Suspect

EDITORS NOTE: EDS: SUBS 2nd graf to update with possible found vehicle; TWEAKS graf 3 and graf starting "-- The suspect: ..." Investigators expanded their search across Minnesota on Sunday as they raced to track the footsteps of a man suspected of assassinating a Democratic state lawmaker and trying to kill a second. Police found what they believe is a vehicle belonging to the suspect, Vance Boelter, 57, in Sibley County, near a listed address for him and about an hour's drive southwest of where Saturday's shootings occurred. Officials have pleaded for help from the public, offering a $50,000 reward for information leading to Boelter's arrest. At the same time they urged caution, saying that he was believed to be armed, dangerous and willing to kill. "He is someone that no one should mess with, except for law enforcement," Sen. Amy Klobuchar of Minnesota said Sunday morning on NBC's "Meet the Press." Communities were on edge around the Minneapolis suburbs where authorities say the suspect went to the homes of two lawmakers early Saturday, pretending to be a police officer. Wearing a ballistic vest, gloves and an identity-disguising mask, investigators say he killed Rep. Melissa Hortman and her husband, Mark. The police almost caught the suspect at the home, but he escaped on foot after exchanging gunfire with officers. State Sen. John A. Hoffman, a fellow Democrat, and his wife, Yvette, were also shot in a separate attack but survived. Klobuchar said Sunday that the couple was "hanging in there." Hoffman, she said, "may face some additional surgeries, but he is also in stable condition right now, from what I know." Investigators have been examining surveillance footage, bank records, Boelter's associations and his movements from before the shootings. He had been politically engaged: A friend said he opposed abortion and had supported President Donald Trump, and he previously served on a state workforce development board alongside Hoffman. Here's what else we know: -- The victims: Hortman served as speaker of the Minnesota House for a six-year period that ended this year and helped pass several key policies on abortion rights, marijuana legalization and medical leave. Hoffman is a fourth-term state senator from Champlin, another Minneapolis suburb, and leads the Senate's Human Services Committee. -- The suspect: Boelter and his wife run a private security company that promotes the usage of SUVs similar to those used by police departments, according to its website. The couple also appears to have run a religious nonprofit. An archived version of the organization's website described Boelter as an ordained minister who had preached overseas. It said that he "sought out militant Islamists in order to share the gospel and tell them that violence wasn't the answer." -- Political violence: Slowly but surely, violence has moved from the fringes to become part of the political landscape. Threats and even assassinations, attempted or successful, have become a steady undercurrent of American life. This article originally appeared in The New York Times. Copyright 2025

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store