
Complaint backfires for accountant who sued neighbour over fence that ‘interfered with picnic'
An accountant who sued her neighbours, claiming their new fence interfered with her back garden picnics has been ordered to rip out the central heating system and patio from her and her husband's £375,000 cottage after the complaints backfired.
Helen Faber and her partner Dominic Miles saw red in 2021 when returning to their idyllic country cottage in Oxfordshire after a period living in France to find a fence put in by next door neighbours, Richard and Katherine Reid, had "narrowed" a path leading to part of their back garden by 40cm.
They complained the fence was a "nuisance" because any narrowing of the 4-foot wide path would make it difficult for them to carry a "large picnic tray laden with food and drinks...without spilling the drinks" to their patio and second garden area at the end.
After angry scenes, including an incident in November 2021, "during which Mr Miles was very aggressive towards Mrs Reid," they sued their neighbours asking Judge Melissa Clarke at Oxford County Court to rule that the new fence created a "substantial interference" with their use of the shared right of way.
But the move backfired after the judge not only ruled that there was no "nuisance" caused by the fence, but additionally ordered them to rip up their back patio and remove an oil pipe feeding their central heating system - rendering it useless - after finding that both constituted "trespasses" on the Reids' property.
The two couples are now facing off in London's High Court, with lawyers for Ms Faber and Mr Miles appealing and arguing that it was wrong for the judge to order them to remove the pipe - leaving them with no heating and hot water system - and the patio, as well as continuing to insist the fence is moved.
But Mr and Mrs Reid say the county court judge got it right when ordering their neighbours to scrap their patio and heating system and dismissing their gripes about the fence.
High Court judge Mr Justice Richard Smith last week heard that Mr and Mrs Reid's home, Forge Cottage, in Wardington, Oxfordshire, adjoins Ms Faber and Mr Miles' house, Pear Tree Cottage next door, which online sources estimate to be worth £375,000.
The fence which sparked the row lies alongside part of a path which runs up the side of Pear Tree Cottage before turning and running along the back of both neighbours' main back gardens and ending at the second garden belonging to Pear Tree Cottage.
The path itself belongs to the owners of Forge Cottage, but both sets of neighbours have a right of way over it.
Ms Faber and Mr Miles complained that because of the "narrowing" of the shared right of way they were unable to "conveniently" use the path whilst carrying "a large picnic tray laden with food and drinks" to their second garden.
At the end of the Oxford County Court trial, Judge Melissa Clarke, while noting that "Mr Miles was very aggressive towards Mrs Reid" at one point during the row, ruled that the new fence "did not substantially interfere with the right of way".
Going on to order them to take out the oil pipe, disabling their heating system, she said: "An oil line running from an oil tank in the Pear Tree Cottage second garden is on, over and under parts of the right of way.
"The claimants now accept that the right of way is owned by Forge Cottage. The installation by the claimants of an oil line over the right of way is a trespass on the land of Forge Cottage and the defendants are entitled to an injunction requiring the claimants to remove it."
She said the pipeline is "susceptible to damage" and that, if damaged, any oil leaks would contaminate the Reids' land, which is a risk they "should not have to tolerate from trespass."
Last week, arguing that Judge Clarke made the wrong decision, Stephen Taylor, for Ms Faber and Mr Miles, said that the couple had informed their previous neighbours at Forge Cottage before installing the heating system and they had not objected.
He insisted that means their current neighbours cannot now demand its removal.
The court heard that there is no gas supply in the village and that Mr Miles and Ms Faber claim "modern" heating systems like heatpumps are "not suitable for use in a stone-built property more than three centuries old."
Mr Taylor told the judge that previous owners of the Reds' house had done nothing when the oil system was installed and "acquiesced" in Mr Miles and Ms Faber's actions.
"In those circumstances an estoppel arose, estopping the neighbours at the time from later raising an objection," he argued. "That estoppel binds Mr and Mrs Reid in the same way.
"By thanking the claimants for telling them about and not objecting to their plans regarding the installation of an oil pipe, the defendants' predecessor in title created an expectation in the claimants that they could lay their oil pipe under the right of way and not later face any complaint.
"It was their neighbours' tacit representation that laying an oil pipe was 'okay'. The defendants' predecessors created the estoppel which stops the defendants from complaining about the oil pipe now."
In relation to the fence, he added: "The judge wrongly concluded that by creating the two near 90 degree bends in the right of way and by narrowing it by about 33% there was no substantial interference.
"The judge was wrong because ...it cannot be said to be unreasonable for the claimants to insist on being able to use the disputed way when carrying a 1m wide chattel, for example a picnic tray with full glasses thereon.
"The pre-existing fence respected the 4ft width of the disputed way.
"The 2021 fence had reduced the disputed way to 2ft 3in at its narrowest point (and) rendered it difficult to traverse, particularly when transporting logs, garden waste and wheelie bins."
He argued that a 1944 plan showed that the right of way should be 4ft wide all along.
"A 4ft way can be conveniently used, for example to carry a large box along the way or a large picnic tray laden with food and drinks. If the box or tray is 3ft 11in wide it can just get through without spilling the drinks.
"It is submitted that even a small reduction in the width of a 4ft walkway amounts to a substantial interference...It cannot be described as unreasonable for the claimants to insist on being able to use the disputed way conveniently...when carrying a chattel."
He also claimed the judge was wrong in defining the boundary so that part of Ms Faber and Mr Miles' patio was on their neighbours' land and deemed a "trespass" which would have to be removed.
But Anya Newman, for Mr and Mrs Reid, argued that Judge Clarke was right in her ruling at the county court and that the fence should stay and the patio and pipe should be removed.
"The dispute arose after the respondents (Mr and Mrs Reid) replaced an old fence at the rear of their garden," she said.
"It was agreed that the route of the fence was somewhat different to the previous fence, it is now dog-legged instead of running at one angle.
"After initially being happy with the replacement fence, the appellants raised issue about its positioning.
"The respondents denied that the new fence, save for one small section, had changed position from the previous fence. However, they asserted that this change did not substantially interfere with the right of way.
"The judge concluded that...there was no substantial interference with the right of way, which was specified as a right to pass and re-pass on foot because the right of way 'on foot' does not give rise to a right to use bicycles, push-wheeled vehicles, carts or barrows along it.
"In any event, the factual evidence...was accepted that a wheelchair user could substantially and practically use the right of way as conveniently as before.
"There is an oil line running from the appellants' oil tank in their secondary garden to the appellants' property. The line runs under and over the right of way, on the respondents' property.
"The oil line was a trespass...The expert evidence was that the oil line is susceptible to damage and the judge accepted this, ordering the removal of the line.
"It cannot be the case that even if previous neighbours acquiesced to the oil line, they now have a right in perpetuity to site an oil line on their neighbours' land.
"Further, the appellants had also commandeered the end of the right of way, raising and re-paving it for use as a patio to their secondary garden. The respondents also claimed in trespass to remove the patio.
"Due to the decision on the boundary, the patio of the appellants' which they had used to place patio furniture and a gas canister was a trespass. The raised patio ought to be removed by the appellants."
Mr Justice Smith has now reserved his ruling on the case, to be given at a later date.

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


BBC News
13 minutes ago
- BBC News
West Yorkshire Police receive thousands of bad driving videos
More than 10,000 clips of alleged bad driving have been submitted to police in the past 12 Yorkshire Police said the footage had been used to take action against 7,500 drivers, including issuing fines, court summons and education force uses an online submission form to allow road users to upload video recordings of poor driving and possible Jeffrey, police lead for the West Yorkshire Safety Camera Partnership, said the clips helped to "support other forms of enforcement activity aimed at preventing crashes and loss of life". The force said action was taken against drivers featured in 71% of submissions made to the Operation Snap Jeffrey said footage should include the offending vehicle's number plate and should be submitted as soon as possible after the incident and no later than 10 days should also include the whole incident and, wherever possible, should include one minute prior and one minute after the alleged Lowe, chair of the West Yorkshire Vision Zero Partnership and the region's deputy mayor for policing and crime, said they were grateful for the public's contribution."We recently launched our West Yorkshire Vision Zero Strategy which seeks to end road death and serious injury in the county by 2040," she said."At its heart is the message that road safety is everyone's responsibility, and by submitting dashcam footage you can play a crucial role." Listen to highlights from West Yorkshire on BBC Sounds, catch up with the latest episode of Look North.


The Independent
18 minutes ago
- The Independent
Riot police respond to second night of violence in Ballymena
Police came under attack as violent disorder erupted for a second night in a row in Northern Ireland on Tuesday. Multiple cars and properties were set on fire in Ballymena while rioters hurled petrol bombs, fireworks and masonry at police officers. The Police Service of Northern Ireland (PSNI) deployed riot police, fired plastic baton rounds, and used water cannons as well as dog units as part of its response to the disorder. In a statement, the PSNI said calm had been restored in the Clonavon Terrace, North Road and Bridge Street areas by around 1am on Wednesday. The force said there had also been 'sporadic disorder' in Newtownabbey and Carrickfergus, as well incidents in north Belfast. It came after similar violent disorder around Clonavon Terrace in the town on Monday night, following an earlier peaceful protest in the day which was organised in support of the family of a girl who was the victim of an alleged sexual assault in the area. The Prime Minister's official spokesman described those events – which saw police and ethnic minorities targeted – as 'very concerning'. A senior police officer condemned the disorder as 'racist thuggery'. Assistant Chief Constable Ryan Henderson issued a public appeal for information and said the PSNI was actively working to identify those responsible for the 'racially motivated disorder in Ballymena and bring them to justice'. He said the service would deploy significant resources to any further disorder during the week. On Tuesday evening, riot police were deployed to residential streets around Clonavon Terrace on Tuesday as hundreds of people gathered in the area from approximately 7pm. The PSNI formed barricades while officers wearing armour and shields also responded to the disorder. Some masked protesters shouted abuse and threw objects at the police, including fireworks, glass bottles and pieces of metal. The PSNI advised those present to disperse and warned that water cannon would be deployed against those participating in violent activity. Police fired plastic baton rounds at some of those gathered and also used water cannons to disperse the crowd. Many young children were present among those gathered near police lines. As rioters were dispersed into other parts of the town as the evening progressed into night, a property on Bridge Street and a home on Queen Street were set on fire. Other properties had windows smashed as some residents chose to display signs about the nationalities of those normally resident, including one saying 'British household' and another with 'Filipino lives here'. Multiple cars were also set on fire as part of blazes set by rioters, including near a car wash and tyre centre off Bridge Street and on Larne Street. The clothing of at least one participant caught fire during the disorder. The PSNI cleared streets and allowed gaps in its barricades for firefighters to tackle fires in the town as chaotic scenes continued past midnight. Officers also used a drone as part of the response to illegal activity, which saw some rioters kick in doors and ransack homes. The Northern Ireland Secretary has said there is 'no justification' for attacks on police officers or vandalism. In a social media post, Hilary Benn said: 'The terrible scenes of civil disorder we have witnessed in Ballymena again this evening have no place in Northern Ireland. 'There is absolutely no justification for attacks on PSNI officers or for vandalism directed at people's homes or property.' During Monday's disorder, 15 police officers were injured and several PSNI vehicles were damaged. In Clonavon Terrace, several houses had their windows smashed and two which suffered significant smoke damage remained sealed off on Tuesday. A 29-year-old man was charged with riotous behaviour after being arrested on Monday night. Mr Henderson said other arrests are expected following the examination of video footage. The earlier peaceful protest formed in support of the family of the girl. Two 14-year-old boys appeared in court on Monday charged with attempted rape. The charges were read to the teenagers by a Romanian interpreter. On Tuesday, the PSNI said it had made a third arrest in connection with the incident and reiterated a public appeal for information. Detective Inspector Olphert from the PSNI's public protection branch said: 'A 28-year-old man was arrested yesterday evening, Monday June 9. 'He has been unconditionally released from police custody following questioning.' At a press conference on Tuesday, Mr Henderson said the attacks should be 'loudly condemned by all right-thinking people'. 'Any attempt to justify or explain it as something else is misplaced,' he said at a press conference at Ballymena police station earlier on Tuesday. He said members of the minority ethnic community 'felt fear' and there will be a significant policing operation in the town in the coming days to reassure the community. Mr Henderson said that police officers from England and Wales will be brought to Northern Ireland if needed to help the PSNI in the wake of the Ballymena disorder. The Prime Minister's official spokesman said: 'The disorder we saw in Ballymena is very concerning. 'Obviously, the reports of sexual assault in the area are extremely distressing, but there is no justification for attacks on police officers while they continue to protect local communities. 'PSNI and the justice system must be allowed to carry out their jobs and our thoughts are with the victims of the assault as well as the police officers who were injured.'


Sky News
22 minutes ago
- Sky News
Ballymena riots: Fireworks, petrol bombs and glass bottles thrown at police as serious disorder deepens
Fireworks, petrol bombs and glass bottles have been thrown at riot police as unrest in Ballymena continued for a second night. Water cannon and plastic baton rounds were used to disperse hundreds in the Co Antrim town - with officers wearing armour and carrying shields. Several blazes were reported in the worst-affected areas, with cars set alight and house windows smashed. Police sirens continued to blare throughout the town past midnight. Clothes belonging to at least one protester caught fire during the disorder. Some properties displayed signs about the nationality of the residents inside - including one saying "British household". Sky correspondent Connor Gillies, who is in Ballymena, says some families have had to barricade themselves into the attics of their homes as the clashes worsen. "The talk here in this town is that it could go on for weeks yet," he added. The violent disorder started on Monday, following a peaceful protest supporting the family of a girl who was allegedly sexually assaulted in the area over the weekend. Two 14-year-old boys were charged with attempted rape and were remanded in custody when they appeared at Coleraine Magistrates' Court on Monday. The charges were read to them by a Romanian interpreter. The Police Service of Northern Ireland said on Tuesday that it had made a third arrest in connection with the alleged rape, and is continuing to urge anyone with information to come forward. The 28-year-old man has since been unconditionally released from custody following questioning. PSNI Assistant Chief Constable Ryan Henderson described the scenes in Ballymena as "racist thuggery" and said the force was "actively working to identify those responsible" for the "racially motivated disorder". Mr Henderson said people from ethnic minorities have "felt fear" - and there will be a significant policing operation in the town in the coming days to reassure the community. At least 15 police officers were injured on Monday. A 29-year-old man was arrested during the unrest on Monday night and charged with riotous and disorderly behaviour, attempted criminal damage and resisting police. Mr Henderson said other arrests are expected following the examination of video footage. Local MP Jim Allister said tensions over immigration had been building for some time. Mr Henderson said there was no intelligence suggesting the disorder was orchestrated, but added that some at the protest were "clearly intent on violence" and had prepared petrol bombs and masonry to use as missiles. Downing Street said there was "no justification" for the violence. Sir Keir Starmer's spokesman said: "The disorder we saw in Ballymena is very concerning." He added: "Obviously, the reports of sexual assault in the area are extremely distressing, but there is no justification for attacks on police officers while they continue to protect local communities. "PSNI and the justice system must be allowed to carry out their jobs and our thoughts are with the victims of the assault as well as the police officers who were injured." Hilary Benn, secretary of state for Northern Ireland, said on X that the "terrible scenes of civil disorder" seen on Monday and Tuesday night "have no place in Northern Ireland".