Comment: Why Melbourne Cup champion Knight's Choice is no certainty to win Queensland Horse of the Year honour
Queensland produced its first Melbourne Cup winner but there is a chance that not even the history-making feat of Knight's Choice will be enough to clinch Horse of the Year honours in his own state.
When $91 bolter Knights's Choice stunned the world to become the first Queensland-trained Melbourne Cup winner last November, he would have been hot favourite to become the Queensland Horse of the Year.
The credentials of Knight's Choice may still be impossible to ignore – it is the Melbourne Cup after all.
But Antino says hello.
Given the Horse of the Year is for the 2024/25 racing season, Antino's astonishing 6½-length Group 1 Toorak Handicap romp last spring, with an out-of-the-box ride from Blake Shinn, counts towards voting.
So too do Antino's two Group 1 placings in the Melbourne spring.
And recent in our minds is Antino's devastating Group 1 Doomben Cup romp which was so authoritative that Tony Gollan's star is now the $6 second pick for the Cox Plate and behind only Via Sistina in betting markets.
What did we just witness?! 🤯
KNIGHT'S CHOICE holds on to win the 2024 Lexus Melbourne Cup!
🎥 @wwos | #MelbourneCup | #MelbCupCarnival pic.twitter.com/Ok2GKUTm0I
— Victoria Racing Club (@FlemingtonVRC) November 5, 2024
•
Antino also conjured an incredible Hollindale Stakes triumph on a bog track which didn't seem to worry him or Shinn.
The other horse to consider in the Queensland Horse of the Year race is the new kid on the block Cool Archie.
It is entirely possible young colt Cool Archie could win Australian 2YO Horse of the Year, yet finish third in the Queensland Horse of the Year title.
Chris Munce was scratching his head to try to think of the last Australian two-year-old to win five races in a row, culminating in a Group 1 triumph.
Cool Archie WINS the G1 J.J. Atkins! � @munceracing pic.twitter.com/X0oBUWkZB0
— SKY Racing (@SkyRacingAU) June 14, 2025
• 'He could be anything': Munce hot on Cool Archie's future
That's exactly what his JJ Atkins champion did and he has been unbeaten this campaign on wet and dry tracks and a variety of distances from 1000m to stretching to the 1600m of the JJ.
Clearly, he is a freak.
Even if you believe the Melbourne Cup winner should win Queensland Horse of the Year, you must at least concede it's at least a fascinating topic of conversation.
The voting is done by a panel of about 25 industry stakeholders and they will have a nice problem on their hands when they sit down to vote in the coming months, with the award to be announced later this year.
Antino is an absolute star! The Queenslander dominates the Doomben Cup for @tonygollan � @blake_shinn pic.twitter.com/3GtDfiSKFB
— SKY Racing (@SkyRacingAU) May 24, 2025
In some previous years, it has been a barren wasteland for Queensland horses in terms of Group 1 wins.
But this season has been an outstanding one for horses from the Sunshine State performing at the elite level.
Sometimes, Horse of the Year honours nationally and in various states can be a one-horse race and largely a bit of a snore-fest.
But not this year in Queensland.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
News.com.au
an hour ago
- News.com.au
NRL world turns on Billy Slater over State of Origin comment
Rugby league commentators have labelled Billy Slater's response to former NSW rival Aaron Woods a 'disgrace'. The Queensland coach on Tuesday caused uproar in his final press conference before Wednesday night's do-or-die State of Origin Game 2 in Perth. The Storm icon's public appearance in front of fans in Perth was dominated by his response to a personal sledge fired by Woods last week. The former NSW forward called Slater a 'grub' while also criticising the premiership-winning fullback for his decision to axe former captain Daly Cherry-Evans after the Maroons were blown off the park in the series opener. The former Wests Tigers captain was heavily criticised by some Queensland figures, including Broncos icon Gorden Tallis, for his public swipe at Slater. But there has been a dramatic twist in the public relations battle since Slater's response in Perth. Slater was visibly emotional when he made reference to former Cowboys and Queensland coach Paul Green, who tragically took his own life in 2022 — one year before Slater took the job. The 41-year-old scolded Woods by suggesting the comments were in poor taste, considering the potential impact such comments can have on people's mental health. Woods, who retired at the end of the 2024 NRL season, on Wednesday morning responded by calling Slater's comments about Green 'completely unnecessary'. 'It's a hard position he's in at the moment,' Woods said on Triple M. 'He's lost game one of the series up in Queensland. 'He's coming off a losing series which was a decider in Queensland as well. 'So he's under a lot of pressure. 'But one in particular comment that he did make. I just thought Billy went a little bit over the boundary. I just think it was completely unnecessary for the situation.' Slater has been facing a backlash since his press conference with commentators going public with criticism of the coach. Fox League commentator Andrew Voss said on his SEN Breakfast show Slater had missed the mark. 'I think Billy was out of order referencing the late Paul Green. He went too far,' he said. 'Deal with your own response but don't bring others into it. That was beyond talking about Origin. 'Maybe Billy regrets that but the way he delivered it, it wasn't off the cuff.' Newcastle icon Matthew Johns was visibly staggered when first hearing Slater's comments. SEN has shared a video on X showing Johns' jaw dropped when audio from Slater's press conference was played. 'Whether it's in banter, theatre, whatever it is - if you do say something about someone, and it is personal, then you hand them immediately a right of reply,' Johns told SEN 1170. 'Billy's used that right of reply and he's certainly taken a long handle to it. I have no doubt that Woodsy's building up the theatre. 'When he said, first of all, Billy's a grub, I sort of thought - it's a bit of fun - and then I thought this is sort of starting to get into the personal area. 'In his heart of hearts, Woodsy just meant it purely as banter but it hasn't been taken that way and when you say something like that - then you run the risk of that.' Johns is one of many to suggest Slater had a pre-prepared answer knowing he was going to be asked about Woods during the public appearance. 'He's certainly taken the long handle to it,' Johns said. 'I did laugh when Pete (journalist Pete Badel) asked him the question and he (Slater) said, 'Do you really want me to answer that?' 'He had a very well thought out answer.' Slater's stance has clearly irked others in the game with fans quick to point out times he caused offence with his comments. The legendary fullback was in 2010 forced to admit he 'overstepped the mark' by taunting Newcastle's Cory Paterson over his battle with depression It was reported at the time Slater told Paterson during a skirmish on the field: 'Go and have a cry in your room'. Paterson had the previous year taken a step away from the game to manage his mental health. Slater finished his career as one of the greatest players of the modern era, but his stature in the game has somewhat been diminished by his record of being cited for 10 offences by the NRL Match Review during the course of his 319 games. He was suspended for a total of 13 matches. That behaviour has been questioned again in light of Slater's apparent offence to the term 'grub'. Aussie sport commentator Alcia Newton posted on X the term 'grub' means 'nothing'. 'And Slater was a grub in his playing days which is what Woods was talking about in the first place,' she wrote. 'It's just weird to bring Green's name up in what's been a very boring Origin series so far. Wasn't required but desperate times.' She went on to post: 'Feel for Paul Green's family, absolutely no need to bring his name into it. Slater running out of answers if that's how he wants to fire up Queensland. 'Was OK for Blues player to be labelled a grub three weeks ago… the hypocrites in rugba league are astonishing.' Veteran Australian sport journalist Bernie Cohen wrote: 'Billy Slater may be a legend to some people in rugby league but imo bringing up Paul Green at today's presser was a bloody disgrace'. One NRL fan posted: 'Billy Slater is not only a grub, he's a hypocritical grub of the highest order to also bring Paul Green into it'. Another fan suggested: 'Billy Slater exploiting Paul Green's passing to claim some lame moral high ground over a contrived #origin sledge is quite frankly pathetic and probably highlights the reason why he was called a grub during his playing days'. Slater earlier called Woods' position in the media into question. 'When you hold a position in the media or in our game, I feel that's a privilege and with that privilege comes a responsibility,' the Channel 9 commentator began. 'I sit in that position most weeks and you amplify your voice to millions of people. You're not talking to your mates in the pub. 'Now, I know Aaron Woods. I actually ran into him about three or four weeks ago at a footy game and he didn't voice that opinion then. 'He actually brought his son over and introduced him to me. 'And I get the attention in our game. I get that. Our game creates attention, but there's a responsibility with that attention, all right? 'When you degrade someone personally in a derogatory manner, you probably don't deserve one of those privileged positions that you're all in, that we're all in.' The press conference was held in a public, outdoor forum and Slater's comments received some applause from the crowd. But the 41-year-old wasn't finished and gave some insights into his emotional response when he referenced former Maroons coach Green, who held the position for one year before Slater and tragically took his own life in 2022. 'I'm not done yet,' Slater continued. 'You don't know what people are going through and although I might be able to handle it, the next person mightn't be. 'Maybe our last coach (Green) didn't. 'I believe the character of a person is judged more on what they say about people and how they treat people than what an individual says to create attention about someone. 'There's your answer.'
News.com.au
an hour ago
- News.com.au
Benny Elias previews State of Origin II
State of Origin: Former NSW Blues hooker Benny Elias joined Fox Sports News to preview State of Origin II in Perth.
News.com.au
2 hours ago
- News.com.au
Senior AFL players could be involved in the re-born AFL Competition Committee
The AFL has made another big move towards leaning on clubs to guide the league future by reinstituting the AFL Competition Committee which could be loaded with senior players. Three years after leading players including Geelong captain Patrick Dangerfield were part of the committee, first introduced in 2018 to guide discussion around decision-making on key aspects of the future of the game, it's back. It comes after AFL CEO Andrew Dillon added two club bosses, Brisbane's Greg Swann and Sydney's Tom Harley, to the league executive, evidence of a nod to the information and experience coming out of clubland. Swann, the AFL's new football performance boss, football operations boss Laura Kane and AFL commissioner and veteran administrator Andrew Ireland will be key members of the new-look committee. That trio will be joined by a strong representation of names and faces from around the game to 'make assessments, canvass views, test theories and provide comments and recommendations regarding the AFL Competition'. Those views would then go to the AFL Commission, the ultimate decision maker. 'During its time, the AFL Competition Committee previously provided great insight and thinking around all aspects of the game and has helped shape the evolution of the game,' Dillon said. 'There is no one closer to the game than our players, coaches and key club personnel, and I'm keen for our football department to continue building on these relationships across the board. 'Beyond the members of the committee, I want to continue to engage a broader group consisting of past players and media, to provide their feedback and insights so we can collect as much information as we can and workshop it. Then, from a head office point of view, we can move quickly and appropriately on the things that are most important and need to be implemented going forward.'
