Michigan Republican unloads on Nessel over failure to provide Flint water documents
State Rep. Angela Rigas (R-Caledonia) speaks on the Michigan House floor. May 1, 2025. | Kyle Davidson
Rep. Angela Rigas, chair of the Michigan House Oversight Subcommittee on the Weaponization of Government, released a scathing statement Wednesday evening blasting Attorney General Dana Nessel over continued delays in producing requested documents related to the Flint water criminal prosecutions.
Nessel's office delivered numerous documents to Rigas's office on Wednesday, but the representative said it was not at all what she requested.
'Dana Nessel's office sent us an incomplete, incoherent mess of documents on a password-protected flash drive like they were bringing us the Holy Grail,' Rigas said.
Rigas had requested documents related to the legal battles that ensued during Nessel's term and in the aftermath of Flint's water supply being contaminated in 2014. The contamination occurred due to a switch of the water supply without proper lead contamination prevention.
SUBSCRIBE: GET THE MORNING HEADLINES DELIVERED TO YOUR INBOX
Former Attorney General Bill Schuette began an investigation and prosecution, the latter of which began in 2016. Schuette charged a city of Flint employee and two employees with what was then known as the Michigan Department of Environmental Quality [now known as the Department of Environment, Great Lakes and Energy].
Nessel became attorney general in 2018 and scuttled Schuette's investigation and prosecution to begin anew in 2021. She formed a Flint water prosecution team led by Wayne County Prosecutor Kym Worthy and former Michigan Solicitor General Fadwa Hammoud while Nessel spearheaded the civil litigation side, which resulted in a mammoth settlement.
The criminal cases resulted in charges against former Governor Rick Snyder and several members of his administration, but those charges were later dismissed after the Michigan Supreme Court ruled that the prosecutorial team had used a one-man grand jury process to indict them without at first holding a preliminary examination that would have given the defendants a chance to poke holes in the attorney general's presentation of probable cause.
Justices of the high court ruled the process as unconstitutional, and the charges were dismissed shortly thereafter.
Rigas (R-Caledonia) as the chair of the House Oversight subcommittee, requested records from Nessel on March 12 with a deadline of March 25 to give the subcommittee various documents. The request included a comprehensive itemized list of all billable hours, legal fees and associated costs incurred during Nessel's tenure as attorney general, including personnel time, outside counsel and expert witnesses; a breakdown of all state funds allocated and expended on these cases; copies of contracts and invoices or memorandums of understanding with third parties retained by her office; and a summary of reimbursements, settlements or cost recoveries tied to the cases.
Nessel requested an eight-week extension, which Rigas granted, with a deadline of Tuesday.
Rigas in a news release issued Wednesday evening said the attorney general's staff brought a password protected flash drive to Rigas' office, which was also shared with some members of the Lansing Capitol press corps. Nessel's office also shared a copy of a letter sent to Rigas' office on Tuesday indicating that the document haul was just one half of those requested by Rigas and that the other portion would be delivered to the representative on or before June 17.
Rigas said that the flash drive contained 'a mass array of unrelated documents that were never requested, mostly from [former Attorney General] Bill Schuette's tenure.' The documents delivered to Rigas mostly contained contracts with attorneys and appointed special counsel Todd Flood and various invoices from Flood's office.
Needless to say, Rigas was unhappy with what was turned over to her office.
'[Nessel] and her office have consistently failed to meet deadline after deadline, and it's unacceptable,' Rigas said. 'She has failed to follow simple directions and comply with what has so clearly been requested. There will be no more extensions. No more games. This ends now.'
A request for comment was sent to the Attorney General's office, but has yet to be returned.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
4 days ago
- Yahoo
Former Michigan House Speaker and wife heading to trial on embezzlement charges
Former Michigan House Speaker Lee Chatfield (left) and his wife Stephanie Chatfield (right) stand at the first day of their preliminary exams as the couple face multiple charges related to embezzlement on Feb. 26, 2025 | Photo: Anna Liz Nichols Former Michigan House Speaker Lee Chatfield and his wife were bound over for trial on embezzlement felonies and other criminal charges Friday, after an investigation by the Michigan Attorney General's Office found the pair funneled money from their political nonprofit to fund their personal purchases. Ingham County Judge Molly Hennessey Greenwalt heard arguments from the defense for Lee and Stephanie Chatfield and the Michigan Attorney General's Office in February, determining this week that there was probable cause for the charges and the case should proceed to trial. The Michigan Attorney General's Office contends that through investigatory efforts by authorities beginning in 2021, it was discovered that the Chatfields had for years used nonprofit money to reimburse themselves for purchases at souvenir shops at Universal Studios during a family trip, transactions at retail stores like Coach and expenses at a strip club, amongst other expenditures. The Chatfields' attorney Mary Chartier has asserted that the charges brought against the former House Speaker, a prominent Republican in Michigan who raised millions of dollars while he was Speaker, are rooted in the political agenda for Michigan Attorney General Dana Nessel, a Democrat. The investigation into Lee Chatfield began back in December 2021, when his sister-in-law, Rebekah Chatfield, reported to police in Lansing that he had sexually assaulted her for years, starting when she was 14 or 15 years old. Michigan State Police opened an investigation into the report, also looking into financial behavior, which was later taken over by Nessel's office which did not find sufficient evidence to pursue charges for criminal sexual conduct. Lee Chatfield faces 13 felony counts of crimes related to conducting a criminal enterprise, conspiracy and embezzlement, while his wife faces two felony counts. Nessel released a news statement Friday expressing gratitude that the efforts of her office led to the case moving forward to trial after a long investigation period and legal process. 'Our investigation uncovered extensive evidence of elaborate schemes to embezzle and misappropriate private and public funds to bankroll Lee Chatfield's lifestyle during his time as Speaker of the House,' Nessel said in the statement. 'My office will continue to pursue public corruption with every tool at our disposal and push for stronger transparency and good governance in our state.' SUBSCRIBE: GET THE MORNING HEADLINES DELIVERED TO YOUR INBOX
Yahoo
4 days ago
- Yahoo
Ex-Speaker Lee Chatfield, wife to stand trial over alleged misuse of political money
Former Michigan House Speaker Lee Chatfield and his wife will stand trial over the alleged mishandling of thousands of dollars raised through political funds, a district judge ruled May 30. Chatfield, a Levering Republican who held the most powerful position in the Michigan House of Representatives in 2019 and 2020, faces 13 embezzlement, conspiracy and larceny charges. Michigan Attorney General Dana Nessel's office claims he knowingly used money from political funds to pay for vacations, dinners at upscale restaurants and other non-permitted items when he was a lawmaker. Prosecutors also claim Chatfield submitted mileage reimbursement requests from the House for trips he did not take. His wife, Stephanie Chatfield, is charged with two counts of felony embezzlement. Both have pleaded not guilty to all charges. A preliminary exam for both Lee and Stephanie Chatfield was held in February. In a 20-page opinion published May 30, East Lansing 54B District Judge Molly Hennessey Greenwalt ruled there is enough evidence to send them to a jury trial. Unlike at trial, where prosecutors must prove a crime beyond a reasonable doubt, the standard of evidence at a preliminary exam is to establish probable cause that a crime may have occurred. Hennessey Greenwalt denied a motion from prosecutors to include an additional larceny charge against Lee Chatfield. She wrote that there is not enough evidence Lee Chatfield took money from associates, including his brothers and a childhood friend who worked on his state House campaigns, without their approval. The Chatfields are set to be back in court June 11 for an arraignment hearing in Ingham County 30th Circuit Court. 'Our investigation uncovered extensive evidence of elaborate schemes to embezzle and misappropriate private and public funds to bankroll Lee Chatfield's lifestyle during his time as Speaker of the House,' Nessel said in a statement. 'I am glad to see this case finally move forward to a trial in circuit court. My office will continue to pursue public corruption with every tool at our disposal and push for stronger transparency and good governance in our state.' At the center of the charges against the former Speaker and his wife are a series of political nonprofits Lee Chatfield used to raise money. For politicians, a 501c(4) fund can be advantageous because the organizations are subject to fewer public disclosure requirements and contribution limits than traditional candidate committees, allowing for greater fundraising and less scrutiny. Lee Chatfield was considered a proficient fundraiser for his political causes. He raised "millions and millions" of dollars with the funds, his attorney Mary Chartier said at the conclusion of his preliminary exam in February. Though 501c(4) social welfare funds are allowed to pay for certain political causes, Nessel's office alleges the Chatfields used the funds to pay for things personal in nature. Witness testimony from the preliminary exam stated that one such fund controlled by Lee Chatfield, the Peninsula Fund, paid off nearly the entirety of a $153,000 credit card balance. A forensic accountant hired by prosecutors testified many of the purchases on the card didn't appear to line up with the Peninsula Fund's stated goals. Chartier argued that it was up to the law firm managing the fund, the Dykema firm in Lansing, to make sure the spending remained in compliance. The most serious charge Lee Chatfield faces carries a maximum 20-year prison sentence, if convicted. Stephanie Chatfield's charges each carry a maximum sentence of 10 years in prison, if convicted. In Dec. 2021, Rebekah Chatfield, Lee Chatfield's sister-in-law, told Lansing police she had been sexually assaulted by Lee Chatfield from the time she was 15 years old and a student at the northern Michigan religious school where Lee Chatfield taught. She also reported misuse of campaign funds at the time, according to her court testimony in the case. Lee Chatfield has denied any sexual assault. Chartier previously said a years-long consensual affair took place between Lee Chatfield and Rebekah Chatfield when both were adults. Michigan State Police began investigating Lee Chatfield, and were later joined by Nessel's office in the investigation. When Nessel announced the financial charges against Lee and Stephanie Chatfield in April 2024, she said the investigation into the sexual assault allegations was closed without charges. Contact Arpan Lobo: alobo@ This article originally appeared on Detroit Free Press: Ex-Speaker Chatfield, wife to stand trial over embezzlement charges
Yahoo
4 days ago
- Yahoo
Gov. Whitmer names roads, chips as her top priorities before she leaves office
MACKINAC ISLAND — Gov. Gretchen Whitmer said she wants to see Michigan secure a semiconductor plant by the end of 2026, calling it an issue she has advocated for at the federal level, during a May 29 speech at the Mackinac Policy Conference. "Being able to make chips top to bottom in America will allow us to stay on the cutting edge of AI. Whoever dominates this technology from design to production will dominate the 21st Century," Whitmer said. "This is an inter-generational investment that makes an entire region an economic magnet." Whitmer told business and political leaders attending the Detroit Regional Chamber's annual policy that she has been advocating for federal support to land such an advanced manufacturing project with President Donald Trump's administration. During her speech, she also laid out other policy goals she said would necessitate bipartisan cooperation. She reiterated her call for a sustainable, long-term plan for funding roads. "We're inching closer toward a deal," she said. The Michigan House has passed a road funding proposal but Michigan Senate Majority Leader Winnie Brinks, D-Grand Rapids, has described it as a nonstarter, saying that a road funding plan needs to be developed in tandem with state budget negotiations. Whitmer also said she wants to tackle literacy among Michigan's children. Only a quarter of Michigan fourth graders can read proficiently, Whitmer said. "That's not acceptable," she said. "Knowing how to read is an ordinary superpower that we all deserve to have." Michigan Politics: Duggan's $4.5B education plan includes firing unsuccessful principals, superintendents Whitmer in her speech pointed to past bipartisan policies she has crafted with lawmakers as evidence that they can continue to bridge partisan divides. "We can do hard things," she said, adding that to succeed, state leaders must work across disagreements. "To find what you can do together, it's the harder path to take in the moment, but it's always the right now," she said. Contact Clara Hendrickson at chendrickson@ or 313-296-5743. This article originally appeared on Detroit Free Press: Gov. Whitmer says roads and chips top priorities for Michigan
