After another call with Putin, it looks like Trump has abandoned efforts to mediate peace in Ukraine
After a two-hour phone call with Russian leader Vladimir Putin on May 19, US president Donald Trump took to social media to declare that Russia and Ukraine will 'immediately start negotiations' towards a ceasefire and an end to the war. He did, however, add that the conditions for peace 'will be negotiated between the two parties, as it can only be'.
With the Vatican, according to Trump, 'very interested in hosting the negotiations' and European leaders duly informed, it seems clear that the US has effectively abandoned its stalled mediation efforts to end the war in Ukraine.
It was always a possibility that Trump could walk away from the war, despite previous claims he could end it in 24 hours. This only became more likely on May 16, when the first face-to-face negotiations between Ukraine and Russia for more than three years predictably ended without a ceasefire agreement.
When Trump announced shortly afterwards that he would be speaking to his Russian and Ukrainian counterparts by phone a few days later, he effectively mounted the beginning of a rearguard action. This was further underlined when, shortly before the Trump-Putin call, Vice-President J.D. Vance, explicitly told reporters that the US could end its shuttle diplomacy.
Trump and Ukraine's president, Volodymyr Zelensky, had a short call before the former spoke with Putin. Zelensky said he told Trump not to make decisions about Ukraine 'without us'. Photo: Leon Neal/PA
The meagre outcomes of the talks between Russia and Ukraine – as well as between Trump and Putin – are not surprising. Russia is clearly not ready for any concessions yet. It keeps insisting that Ukraine accept its maximalist demands of territorial concessions and future neutrality.
Putin also continues to slow-walk any negotiations. After his call with Trump, he reportedly said that 'Russia will offer and is ready to work with Ukraine on a memorandum on a possible future peace agreement', including 'a possible ceasefire for a certain period of time, should relevant agreements be reached'.
The lack of urgency on Russia's part to end the fighting and, in fact, the Kremlin's ability and willingness to continue the war was emphasised the day before the Trump-Putin call. Russia carried out its largest drone attack against Ukraine so far in the war, targeting several regions including Kyiv.
There has been no let-up in the fighting since. And the fact that Putin spoke to Trump while visiting a music school in the southern Russian city of Sochi does not suggest that a ceasefire in Ukraine is high on the Russian leader's priority list.
US-Russia reset
A large part of the Kremlin's calculation seems to be its desire to strike a grand bargain with the White House on a broader reset of relations between the US and Russia. It is signalling clearly that this is more important than the war in Ukraine and might even happen without the fighting there ending.
This also appears to be driving thinking in Washington. Trump foreshadowed an improvement in bilateral relations by describing the 'tone and spirit' of his conversation with Putin as 'excellent'. He also seemed pleased about the prospects of 'large-scale trade' with Russia.
Abandoning European allies, Trump is on record as saying that there would be no progress towards peace in Ukraine until he and Putin get together. But it is worth bearing in mind that very little movement towards a ceasefire in Ukraine – let alone a peace agreement – occurred after the last phone call between the two presidents in February.
Part of this lack of progress has been Trump's reluctance to put any real pressure on Putin. And despite agreement in Brussels and preparations in Washington for an escalation in sanctions against Russia, it is unlikely that Trump will change his approach.
In this context, the sequence in which the calls occurred is telling. Trump and Ukraine's president, Volodymyr Zelensky, had a short call before the former spoke with Putin. Zelensky said he told Trump not to make decisions about Ukraine 'without us'.
But rather than presenting Putin with a clear ultimatum to accept a ceasefire, Trump apparently discussed future relations with Putin at great length before informing Zelensky and key European allies that the war in Ukraine is now solely their problem to solve.
This has certainly raised justifiable fears in Kyiv and European capitals that, for the sake of a reset with Russia, the US might yet completely abandon its allies across the Atlantic.
China
However, if a reset with Russia at any cost really is Trump's strategy, it is bound to fail. As much as Putin seems willing to continue with his aggression against Ukraine, Zelensky is as unwilling to surrender. Putin can rely on China's continued backing while Zelensky can count on support from Europe.
Supporting Russia's war in Ukraine is essential for China to keep Moscow on side in its rivalry with the US. And for Europe, supporting Ukraine has become an existential question of deterring and containing a revisionist Russia hell-bent on restoring a Soviet-style sphere of influence in central and eastern Europe.
In a world that has been in flux since Trump's return to the White House, these are some of the emerging constants. And they make a US-Russia reset highly improbable.
Even if it were to happen, it would not strengthen Washington's position with Beijing. Walking away from Ukraine and Europe now will deprive the US of the very allies it will need in the long term to prevail in its rivalry with China.
By abandoning his mediation between Moscow and Kyiv, Trump may have broken the deadlock in his efforts to achieve a reset with Russia. But getting this deal over the line will be a pyrrhic victory.
Stefan Wolff is Professor of International Security, University of Birmingham
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Journal
40 minutes ago
- The Journal
Russia and Ukraine resume peace talks in Istanbul following major airbase attack
RUSSIAN AND UKRAINIAN officials will meet in Istanbul today to exchange proposals on how to end the war, just one day after Ukraine struck dozens of Russian strategic bombers at airbases deep inside Russian territory. Prompted by US President Donald Trump, Moscow and Kyiv have resumed direct negotiations for the first time since the early months of Russia's invasion. However, progress toward a peace agreement remains limited. Today's discussions follow one of Ukraine's most audacious and successful attacks on Russian soil. Ukraine said it damaged around 40 long-range bombers worth an estimated $7 billion at airbases located far from the front lines. Ukraine's security services said the 18-month operation involved smuggling drones into Russia, which were launched from inside the country. At last month's initial round of talks in Istanbul, the two sides agreed to a large-scale prisoner exchange and shared outlines of their respective visions for a peace deal. The second round is set to begin at 1pm (10am Irish time) at the historic Ciragan Palace, an Ottoman-era mansion now operating as a luxury hotel on the Bosphorus. Russia says it will present a 'memorandum' outlining its terms but has refused to send its demands in advance, despite pressure from Ukraine. Despite this new round of diplomacy, the two sides remain far apart. Ukraine is demanding an immediate and unconditional ceasefire, the release of prisoners, and the return of abducted children, President Volodymyr Zelensky said yesterday. Advertisement Zelensky also called for a direct meeting with Russian President Vladimir Putin, saying, 'The key issues can only be resolved by the leaders.' The Kremlin has rejected that idea, insisting a summit could only follow progress in lower-level negotiations. Russia continues to question Zelensky's legitimacy and has pushed for sweeping demands, including limits on Ukraine's military, a ban on NATO membership, and large territorial concessions – conditions Kyiv and Western allies have strongly rejected as imperialist. Tens of thousands have died since Russia's 2022 invasion. Large parts of eastern and southern Ukraine have been destroyed, and millions have been displaced. Negotiation figures Russia will be represented by Vladimir Medinsky, a close Putin ally and nationalist ideologue who led failed negotiations in 2022. Ukraine's delegation is headed by Defence Minister Rustem Umerov, seen as pragmatic but currently facing domestic scrutiny over alleged misconduct. Diplomatic advisors from Germany, France, and the UK will be present in Istanbul to support Ukraine's delegation, a German government spokesperson said. Meanwhile, fighting continues on the ground. Russian forces are advancing in the northeastern Sumy region, where President Putin has ordered the creation of a 'buffer zone' along the border. Russia has demanded that Ukraine cut ties with Western military support and surrender territory. Ukraine, however, insists on holding its ground and says only a full ceasefire will allow space for longer-term peace talks. Though Kyiv acknowledges that some territory may only be regained through diplomacy, not war, it continues to demand strong Western security guarantees – such as NATO protection or foreign troops on the ground – measures Moscow has firmly rejected.
The Irish Sun
43 minutes ago
- The Irish Sun
Nato must be ready for war with Russia by 2029 – Putin is ALREADY planning attack, Germany warns as Starmer pledges subs
NATO must be ready for war in the next four years, Germany's defence chief warned, as he claimed Russia is gearing up to attack more European nations. Keir Starmer meanwhile announced 12 new nuclear submarines to combat the "immediate and pressing threat" from Putin. 7 Flames and destruction after a Russian attack in Chernihiv Oblast, Ukraine on Monday morning Credit: Getty 7 A huge crater blown into the ground by a Russian ballistic missile on Monday Credit: EPA 7 Russian Belaya Air Base in Irkutsk region, Siberia, was ablaze after a major Ukrainian drone strike over the weekend Credit: East2West 7 General Carsten Breuer said Nato is facing a "very serious threat" from Russia - the most severe he has seen in his 40 years of service. Breuer explained that Russia is producing weaponry at a rapid pace - with around 1,500 battle tanks and four million rounds of artillery each year. Crucially, not all of this is being directed to Ukraine - possibly indicating munitions are being stockpiled for use against Nato countries. He said: "There's an intent and there's a build up of the stocks." Breuer Russia 's potential timeframe for an assault, concluding: "We have to be ready by 2029". "If you ask me now, is this a guarantee that's not earlier than 2029? I would say no, it's not. So we must be able to fight tonight," he said. In April, the general warned that Putin will have next year, and that he wants to "weaken and destroy Nato as an alliance and discredit our Western form of society". The Baltic states of Lithuania, Latvia and Estonia are particularly vulnerable, he said. Most read in The Sun Breuer said: "The Baltic States are really exposed to the Russians, right? "And once you are there, you really feel this [...] in the talks we are having over there." At least seven killed & dozens injured after bridge collapses and crushes passenger train in Russia The Estonians reportedly use the analogy of being close to a wildfire and being able to "feel the heat, see the flames and smell the smoke". Germany and other European nations "probably see a little bit of smoke over the horizon and not more," Breuer said. The general added a call to action, urging fellow Nato nations to rebuild their militaries. He said: "What we have to do now is really to lean in an to tell everybody: 'Hey, ramp up [...] get more into it because we need it. "We need it to be able to defend ourselves and therefore also to build up deterrence." Recognising this need, the British government announced that the UK will build a dozen new nuclear submarines armed with Tomohawk missiles. The will also be bolstered, with saying the deterrent is 'what Putin fears most'. The government is in talks with US officials over the move, which would be the UK's biggest deterrent development since the . The news came as part of the strategic defence review , designed to get Britain moving "to war-fighting readiness". 7 General Carsten Breuer, Germany's Chief of Defence, said Europe must be ready to defend against Russia by 2029 Credit: Rex 7 Pictures show a huge stockpile of FPV drones hidden inside a secret compartment in a container Credit: 24 TV/SBU 7 Russian Tu-95 bombers burning 'en masse' during Ukraine's drone sting Credit: Ukraine's Security Service Starmer will say during a trip to Scotland: 'From the supply lines to the front lines, this government is four-square behind the men and women upholding our freedom and security.' Up to 12 nuclear-powered subs will be built under the AUKUS security partnership with the US and Australia. They are conventionally-armed with They can also deploy special forces and drones . Russia's weapon stocks took a hit over the weekend when a daring Ukrainian drone plot blitzed 34 percent of Putin's cruise missile carriers, according to Read more on the Irish Sun And a raging Putin is now said to be preparing for a terrifying revenge attack. What was 'Operation Spiderweb'? OVER the weekend, Ukraine launched a highly-sophisticated, meticulously-planned drone attack inside Russia. It marks Kyiv's longest-range operation of the conflict so far. The plot involved 117 drones which had been smuggled into Russia inside trucks. President Zelensky revealed it took over 18 months to pull off the masterful attack and hailed it as one for the "history books". Over 100 drones were involved, each with their own pilot. Zelesnsky also revealed the headquarters of the operation were "right next to the FSB", Russia's security service. At least 40 aircraft were attacked, and Zelensky claimed that 34 percent of Putin's cruise missile carriers at the targeted airfields were blasted. A £260million AWACS aircraft and bombers capable of dropping nuclear weapons were also struck. Ukrainian sources say that more than £1.5billion worth of damage has been inflicted on the Russian air force.
Irish Independent
an hour ago
- Irish Independent
Explainer: Why new right wing Polish president is on EU collision course
Polish nationalist candidate Karol Nawrocki won the second round of the country's presidential election with 50.89pc of the votes. his election is a blow to the reform agenda of the pro-European government.
