She stopped to help at a car crash and ended up cuffed. Now her lawsuit will head to trial
PROVIDENCE – A Newport woman's allegations that South Kingstown police officers violated her rights by assaulting and arresting her after she stopped to help two young men involved in a car crash in February 2023 can head to trial.
U.S. District Court Judge Mary S. McElroy ruled June 9 that the civil rights lawsuit brought by Claire and James Hall can proceed to trial.
'Taking the record in the light most favorable to Mrs. Hall, a reasonable jury could conclude that she was ordered to move and subsequently arrested and leg-swept without a legal basis while trying to fulfill a duty that she thought was required under Rhode Island's Good Samaritan laws,' McElroy said in the 32-page ruling.
Chief Matthew Moynihan and Officers Matthew White and Anthony Souza are named as defendants. Moynihan declined to comment because the matter is in litigation.
The Halls' lawyer, Todd D. White, said "my clients are pleased to be going forward with their case."
According to the ruling, the case began with a car crash on Feb. 9, 2023 on Route 1 in South Kingstown, when Claire Hall pulled over to check on the two young men involved. One of the young men, Van Limoges, was 'frantically walking' around and 'shaking,' with 'blood on his leg,' the ruling said.
Hall lent Limoges her phone so that he could call his father, Jim, who asked Limoges if there was an adult on the scene, and Limoges handed the phone back to Hall. The father wanted to know where to meet his son: at the scene of the accident or at the hospital.
Souza and White arrived as Hall continued to speak with the man's father. The officers directed her to move her car off the highway. Hall said she was about to leave and tried to hand the phone to White.
White responded by stating: 'I'm working. Can you please go sit in your car? You have nothing to do with this,' according to the ruling.
Hall said that Limoges was a minor, that she was a lawyer, and that White 'needed to tell her' where Van's father should meet them. White retorted, 'I don't need to tell you anything. I'm going to arrest you in a second if you don't get in your car. Do you understand me?'
'Oh, you're kidding me,' Hall said.
White pointed to Hall's car and raised his voice, saying, 'You are impeding an investigation right now and you are really bothering me. Go sit in your car.'
Hall raised her voice to match his and asked, 'What should I tell his father? What should I tell his father?' White responded, 'I will talk to him in a minute,' and then screamed, 'GET IN YOUR CAR, NOW!' Hall tried again to hand the phone to him.
The officers grabbed Hall by the arms as she flailed and told them to stop. As she screamed, the officers leg-swept her, pushed her into the ground, and put her in handcuffs. She asked the young men to record the interactions.
'Why am I under arrest?' she asked. 'Because you weren't listening to anything we were saying,' White said. Hall continued to yell, and Souza told her to 'take a breather.' She told him to take one.
White told dispatch that they had a woman in custody for disorderly and resisting.
Hall said, 'No! I cannot even believe this. This is so ridiculous. I just wanted to know I could tell his father I was going to the hospital. I'm not even involved in this. I can't believe this.' White responded, 'This was our point the whole time.'
Hall shouted, 'I'm a good Samaritan who stopped to help a kid and this is what happens.' The officers picked her up as she yelled, and walked her to the police SUV over her protests.
Hall was charged with obstruction, disorderly conduct and resisting arrest – charges that were dismissed via not guilty filings five months later at the state's recommendation.
The Halls sued the Police Department and the officers in 2023 in U.S. District Court alleging assault, battery and police brutality. In addition, the Halls sued Moynihan for damages based on his alleged failure to properly supervise White and Souza.
The South Kingstown police asked the court to rule in their favor short of trial, arguing that probable cause existed to arrest Hall and that they used only reasonable force during the arrest. They also asserted that qualified immunity insulates them from the lawsuit.
The court rejected those arguments, ruling that the matters were best left to a jury to decide.
'Without probable cause, qualified immunity is inappropriate under these circumstances. But because the Court has held that the remaining questions of probable cause should be left to the jury, it will reserve the question of qualified immunity for after trial, too,' McElroy said.
This article originally appeared on The Providence Journal: Lawsuit alleging brutality by South Kingstown police can head to trial
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
3 hours ago
The longest-serving legislative leader in US history will be sentenced on corruption charges
SPRINGFIELD, Ill. -- Michael Madigan's stunning political collapse is expected to culminate Friday when the longest-serving legislative leader in U.S. history is sentenced on federal bribery, conspiracy and wire fraud convictions tied to a scheme to push legislation in exchange for jobs and contracts for his associates. The former Illinois House speaker was convicted in February on 10 of 23 counts in a remarkable corruption trial that lasted four months. The case churned through 60 witnesses and mountains of documents, photographs and taped conversations. Madigan will appear in U.S. District Court Friday in Chicago, where Judge John Robert Blakey will determine his sentence. Federal prosecutors are seeking a 12 1/2-year prison term. Madigan's attorneys are seeking probation, contending the government's sentence would 'condemn an 83-year-old man to die behind bars for crimes that enriched him not one penny.' During a legislative career that spanned a half-century, Madigan served nearly four decades as speaker, the longest on record for a U.S. legislator. Combined with more than 20 years as chairperson of the Illinois Democratic Party, he set much of the state's political agenda while handpicking candidates for political office. More often than not, he also controlled political mapmaking, drawing lines to favor his party. Meanwhile, prosecutors said, the Chicago Democrat built a private legal career that allowed him to amass a net worth of $40 million. Madigan was convicted on 10 counts of bribery, conspiracy, wire fraud and other charges for ensuring approval of legislation favorable to utility giant ComEd in exchange for kickbacks and jobs and contracts for loyalists, including a Chicago alderman seeking a paid job on a state board after retiring from government. The jury deadlocked on six counts, including an overarching racketeering conspiracy charge, and acquitted him on seven others. 'Madigan's criminal activity spanned nearly a decade and was particularly egregious because it involved efforts to enrich himself — both by maintaining his political power by securing do-nothing jobs for his political allies and by attempting to line his own pockets with legal business,' prosecutors wrote in a court filing. 'In so doing, Madigan served his own personal interests and not the interests of Illinoisans.' Defense lawyers called the government's recommended sentence 'draconian' and, given Madigan's age, a life sentence. They asked Blakey to consider the totality of Madigan's life and work and the need to care for his wife in requesting a sentence of five years' probation, with one year of home confinement, a requirement to perform community service and a 'reasonable fine.' In a video submitted to the court, Madigan's wife, Shirley, asks for a sentence of probation, explaining that Madigan is her caregiver and she would have to seek outside help if he is imprisoned. And, she says, 'I'm a part of him.' 'There's some days I keep him going,' Shirley Madigan says on the video. 'He keeps me going sometimes, too, but I think that the impact that I have on him has been much, much larger.' The court received more than 200 letters of support for Madigan, many from constituents, friends, leaders of nonprofits and other organizations that interact with the state. Some noted asking him for help just once. Most lauded him for dedication, integrity or a personal touch. 'Mike Madigan is a good man who has selflessly done an exceptional amount of good for others,' his lawyers wrote in a separate filing. 'He is widely respected for his dedication to honesty and integrity.' Tried alongside Madigan was his former legislative colleague and longtime confidant, Michael McClain. The jury couldn't reach a decision on any of the six counts against McClain. He was convicted, though, in a separate trial over the ComEd conspiracy last year.
Hamilton Spectator
4 hours ago
- Hamilton Spectator
The longest-serving legislative leader in US history will be sentenced on corruption charges
SPRINGFIELD, Ill. (AP) — Michael Madigan's stunning political collapse is expected to culminate Friday when the longest-serving legislative leader in U.S. history is sentenced on federal bribery, conspiracy and wire fraud convictions tied to a scheme to push legislation in exchange for jobs and contracts for his associates. The former Illinois House speaker was convicted in February on 10 of 23 counts in a remarkable corruption trial that lasted four months . The case churned through 60 witnesses and mountains of documents, photographs and taped conversations . Madigan will appear in U.S. District Court Friday in Chicago, where Judge John Robert Blakey will determine his sentence. Federal prosecutors are seeking a 12 1/2-year prison term . Madigan's attorneys are seeking probation , contending the government's sentence would 'condemn an 83-year-old man to die behind bars for crimes that enriched him not one penny.' During a legislative career that spanned a half-century , Madigan served nearly four decades as speaker, the longest on record for a U.S. legislator. Combined with more than 20 years as chairperson of the Illinois Democratic Party, he set much of the state's political agenda while handpicking candidates for political office. More often than not, he also controlled political mapmaking, drawing lines to favor his party. Meanwhile, prosecutors said, the Chicago Democrat built a private legal career that allowed him to amass a net worth of $40 million. Madigan was convicted on 10 counts of bribery, conspiracy, wire fraud and other charges for ensuring approval of legislation favorable to utility giant ComEd in exchange for kickbacks and jobs and contracts for loyalists, including a Chicago alderman seeking a paid job on a state board after retiring from government. The jury deadlocked on six counts, including an overarching racketeering conspiracy charge, and acquitted him on seven others. 'Madigan's criminal activity spanned nearly a decade and was particularly egregious because it involved efforts to enrich himself — both by maintaining his political power by securing do-nothing jobs for his political allies and by attempting to line his own pockets with legal business,' prosecutors wrote in a court filing. 'In so doing, Madigan served his own personal interests and not the interests of Illinoisans.' Defense lawyers called the government's recommended sentence 'draconian' and, given Madigan's age, a life sentence. They asked Blakey to consider the totality of Madigan's life and work and the need to care for his wife in requesting a sentence of five years' probation, with one year of home confinement, a requirement to perform community service and a 'reasonable fine.' In a video submitted to the court, Madigan's wife, Shirley, asks for a sentence of probation, explaining that Madigan is her caregiver and she would have to seek outside help if he is imprisoned. And, she says, 'I'm a part of him.' 'There's some days I keep him going,' Shirley Madigan says on the video. 'He keeps me going sometimes, too, but I think that the impact that I have on him has been much, much larger.' The court received more than 200 letters of support for Madigan, many from constituents, friends, leaders of nonprofits and other organizations that interact with the state. Some noted asking him for help just once. Most lauded him for dedication, integrity or a personal touch. 'Mike Madigan is a good man who has selflessly done an exceptional amount of good for others,' his lawyers wrote in a separate filing. 'He is widely respected for his dedication to honesty and integrity.' Tried alongside Madigan was his former legislative colleague and longtime confidant, Michael McClain. The jury couldn't reach a decision on any of the six counts against McClain. He was convicted, though, in a separate trial over the ComEd conspiracy last year. Error! Sorry, there was an error processing your request. There was a problem with the recaptcha. Please try again. You may unsubscribe at any time. By signing up, you agree to our terms of use and privacy policy . This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google privacy policy and terms of service apply. Want more of the latest from us? Sign up for more at our newsletter page .
Yahoo
5 hours ago
- Yahoo
The longest-serving legislative leader in US history will be sentenced on corruption charges
SPRINGFIELD, Ill. (AP) — Michael Madigan's stunning political collapse is expected to culminate Friday when the longest-serving legislative leader in U.S. history is sentenced on federal bribery, conspiracy and wire fraud convictions tied to a scheme to push legislation in exchange for jobs and contracts for his associates. The former Illinois House speaker was convicted in February on 10 of 23 counts in a remarkable corruption trial that lasted four months. The case churned through 60 witnesses and mountains of documents, photographs and taped conversations. Madigan will appear in U.S. District Court Friday in Chicago, where Judge John Robert Blakey will determine his sentence. Federal prosecutors are seeking a 12 1/2-year prison term. Madigan's attorneys are seeking probation, contending the government's sentence would 'condemn an 83-year-old man to die behind bars for crimes that enriched him not one penny.' During a legislative career that spanned a half-century, Madigan served nearly four decades as speaker, the longest on record for a U.S. legislator. Combined with more than 20 years as chairperson of the Illinois Democratic Party, he set much of the state's political agenda while handpicking candidates for political office. More often than not, he also controlled political mapmaking, drawing lines to favor his party. Meanwhile, prosecutors said, the Chicago Democrat built a private legal career that allowed him to amass a net worth of $40 million. Madigan was convicted on 10 counts of bribery, conspiracy, wire fraud and other charges for ensuring approval of legislation favorable to utility giant ComEd in exchange for kickbacks and jobs and contracts for loyalists, including a Chicago alderman seeking a paid job on a state board after retiring from government. The jury deadlocked on six counts, including an overarching racketeering conspiracy charge, and acquitted him on seven others. 'Madigan's criminal activity spanned nearly a decade and was particularly egregious because it involved efforts to enrich himself — both by maintaining his political power by securing do-nothing jobs for his political allies and by attempting to line his own pockets with legal business,' prosecutors wrote in a court filing. 'In so doing, Madigan served his own personal interests and not the interests of Illinoisans.' Defense lawyers called the government's recommended sentence 'draconian' and, given Madigan's age, a life sentence. They asked Blakey to consider the totality of Madigan's life and work and the need to care for his wife in requesting a sentence of five years' probation, with one year of home confinement, a requirement to perform community service and a 'reasonable fine.' In a video submitted to the court, Madigan's wife, Shirley, asks for a sentence of probation, explaining that Madigan is her caregiver and she would have to seek outside help if he is imprisoned. And, she says, 'I'm a part of him.' 'There's some days I keep him going,' Shirley Madigan says on the video. 'He keeps me going sometimes, too, but I think that the impact that I have on him has been much, much larger.' The court received more than 200 letters of support for Madigan, many from constituents, friends, leaders of nonprofits and other organizations that interact with the state. Some noted asking him for help just once. Most lauded him for dedication, integrity or a personal touch. 'Mike Madigan is a good man who has selflessly done an exceptional amount of good for others,' his lawyers wrote in a separate filing. 'He is widely respected for his dedication to honesty and integrity.' Tried alongside Madigan was his former legislative colleague and longtime confidant, Michael McClain. The jury couldn't reach a decision on any of the six counts against McClain. He was convicted, though, in a separate trial over the ComEd conspiracy last year.
