Australia immigration detainees preventative detention: Burke says high legal threshold may prevent jailing
Home Affairs Minister Tony Burke has conceded the incredibly high threshold on a preventative detention regime for criminal former immigration detainees means it's possible none will ever be locked up under it.
But he says his preference is to remove them from the country as soon as possible anyway.
The minister's comments come after Victorian police last week charged Yarraville man Lominja Friday Yokoju over a fatal assault in Melbourne.
Mr Yokoju was among the group of immigration detainees known as the NZYQ cohort
released from the Yonga Hill
centre in 2023 after the High Court ruled that keeping non-citizens locked up indefinitely when they couldn't be deported was unconstitutional.
He is due to face court again in October over the alleged murder.
Mr Burke's ministerial predecessor rushed preventative detention laws through Parliament in December 2023 to establish a regime where those in the NZYQ cohort deemed a danger to the broader community could be subject to a 'community safety detention order'.
However, more than 18 months later, no such orders have been issued.
'The reality is, the legal thresholds that we are stuck with because of some decisions of the High Court are more difficult to be able to reach than I want them to be,' Mr Burke told Sky News on Sunday.
'I've got a lot of resources that I've dedicated to this. No one has come close to reaching the threshold that is in that legislation.
'So I'm not giving up. I'm going to keep doing it, but I'll tell you, to be honest, I would much prefer the individuals out of the country altogether.'
Mr Burke passed laws last year enabling Australia to pay third countries to take non-citizens it wants to deport, where it's not possible to return to their home country.
The first three visas under that plan are currently being challenged through the High Court.
'As they go through the High Court, we've been winning the (other NZYQ-related) cases, which I've been really happy about, which is giving me more confidence that we're going to be able to start getting these people offshore,' Mr Burke said.
'My view is this: if you're on a visa, you are a guest in the country. And almost everybody who is a guest in Australia is a good guest, and a whole lot of them end up calling Australia home and becoming Australian citizens, and that's a great thing.
'But for people who breach that trust, you're entitled as a nation to say, well, your visa is cancelled and it's time for you to leave.'
Shadow defence minister Angus Taylor said it was 'an imperative' that the Government keep dangerous people off the streets.
'The job for Tony Burke is to make sure that he is able to do that… We'll do whatever we have to do support that, but we'll also hold him to account on making sure he achieves that,' he said.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Sky News AU
an hour ago
- Sky News AU
MAGA fan Holly Valance seen without her wedding ring after splitting from husband of 13 years, property tycoon Nick Candy
Holly Valance has been seen without her wedding ring for the first time since splitting from her husband of 13 years, property tycoon Nick Candy. The Australian and British actress, 42, was photographed on Sunday at London's Heathrow Airport Terminal 5, where she cut a casual figure. Pictured obtained by The Sun show Valance sported baggy blue jeans and a black top and cardigan, which she paired with leopard print trainers. She carried with her a large black suitcase and a £2,500 (AUD $5,249.11) Christian Dior tote bag as she made her way to a waiting car. Close-ups show Valance's lavish wedding band clearly missing from her finger as she strolled to the pickup point. The sighting comes after Valance and Candy, 52, who is the treasurer of the Reform UK party, split in recent weeks, The Sun reported on Friday. A family friend told the publication their separation has been "very difficult" for the right-wing couple and their two daughters, aged 12 and 8. 'This has been a very difficult period for both Nick and Holly, and they are keeping things private out of respect for their family," the friend said. 'The joint parenting of their two amazing daughters remains their top priority. 'They've had to juggle a demanding lifestyle. Between family, public life, and Nick's intense work commitments, it's been a tough balance.' The pair played a pivotal role in the rise of Reform UK after Candy defected from the Conservative Party to the right-wing group last year. Valance said she too was a member of Reform UK and would vote for the party in the 2024 general election. "I support anybody that sticks to what they believe in and isn't a turncoat, and doesn't do a million flip-flops and U-turns," she said at the time. Speaking further about her political views, Valance said: "Everyone starts off as a leftie and then wakes up at some point after making money, working, trying to run a business, trying to buy a home. Then realises what crap ideas they all are." The model is friends with Nigel Farage and helped the politician return as leader of Reform UK, having raised £1.5 million (AUD $2,295,612.55) within days of his comeback. In December 2024, it was then announced Candy would become treasurer of Reform UK. Valance and Candy have made no attempts to hide their support for Mr Farage as well as US President Donald Trump. After staying at Trump's Mar-a-Lago resort in 2022, Valance last year became the "UK poster girl" for the 78-year-old's presidential campaign. She and her now ex-husband also hosted an extensive re-election campaign for the President out of their posh London townhouse. The actress began dating Candy, who co-founded the property development and interior design firm Candy & Candy with his brother, Christian, in the early 1990s, in 2010. The couple tied the knot in 2012 in a million-dollar ceremony in California before 300 high-profile guests, including music star Simon Cowell. In 2018, Holly and Nick were even among the high-profile guests at Princess Eugenie's royal wedding at Windsor Chapel. Valance rose to fame playing the role of Felicity Scully on the hit TV series Neighbours from 1999 to 2002. She went on to star in several other popular series and made her mark in music, releasing the album Footprints with her hit single Kiss Kiss.
Sky News AU
an hour ago
- Sky News AU
ABC journalist Patricia Karvelas pushes Liberal Party to adopt gender quotas as public broadcaster pledges impartiality
Star ABC journalist Patricia Karvelas has called on the Liberal Party to impose controversial gender quotas or face electoral backlash despite the public broadcaster's renewed promise to uphold editorial impartiality. Ms Karvelas called for gender quotas in a fiery opinion piece on Monday, claiming voters would 'turn their backs' on the Liberal Party if it refused. ABC journalists are bound by strict impartiality policies which 'requires news and information to be gathered and presented with due impartiality'. They are also forbidden from 'unduly' favouring 'one perspective over another'. However, these rules didn't stop the ABC's star reporter from attacking the Liberal Party's refusal to establish gender quotas. 'Vibes don't get women elected, and if women are not at the table in large numbers Australian voters will continue to turn their backs on the Liberal Party,' she wrote, in a scathing opinion piece, published by the ABC on Monday. She compared the Liberal Party's failure to implement gender quotas to an inability to climb a 'cultural mountain'. 'The issue of gender quotas is the one philosophical and cultural mountain that the Liberal Party has never been prepared to climb. And even by the party's own reckoning, it is failing,' she said. 'Beyond the hard arithmetic of imposing quotas, every other strategy is little more than vibes and positive thinking.' Ms Karvelas also attacked former Liberal Leader Peter Dutton for refusing to appear before the National Press Club. 'Opposition Leader Sussan Ley is approaching it as if there's a giant sign above her head that screams, 'I'm not Peter Dutton',' she wrote. 'Her speech at the National Press Club this week was loaded with hints that fit this thesis 'Even the decision to address the National Press Club itself — a forum Dutton viewed as a space of the Canberra journalistic elite and snubbed consistently — was a signal.' Ms Karvelas also took aim at Australians on social media who deemed gender quotas and regular Welcome to Country speeches 'woke', dismissing the critics as 'right wing'. 'If you swim in right wing algorithms — especially on X — you'll see that all of these choices by Ley are being mocked as symbols of 'Labor Party-light',' she wrote. 'In the subterranean online world Ley's leadership is being painted as too 'woke'.' She even warned Ley's leadership could be under threat by those in the Liberal Party who agreed with the criticism. 'Ley's job over the next year is fraught with danger,' Ms Karvelas wrote. 'She might be given a period of brief peace but most Liberals you speak to privately concede that it will be difficult to keep that peace for the entire term.' Ms Ley suggested she was open to gender quotas at her National Press Club address, quickly before shadow defence minister and former leadership rival Angus Taylor rejected the proposition. "If some state divisions choose to implement quotas, that is fine. If others don't, that is also fine," she said. It comes after revealed the extraordinary lengths ABC journalists were forced to go through in order to achieve radical race, gender and disability targets. The quotas — which included specific targets for women, disabled people and culturally diverse individuals — prompted criticism of the ABC. Following the public broadcaster's high-profile court loss to Antoinette Lattouf, the ABC managing director doubled down on the ABC's commitment to impartiality. 'I wish to stress the particular and fundamental obligations the ABC and its employees have to be independent and impartial in our work,' he said in a statement. Ms Ley has suggested that gender quotas could be a good idea if state divisions of the party wanted to pursue them. However, Mr Taylor has publicly rejected quotas, arguing they would 'subvert democracy'. 'I've never been a believer in quotas to achieve that, but it's clear we have to take proactive action to achieve (female representation),' he told Sky News on Sunday.
Sky News AU
2 hours ago
- Sky News AU
Barnaby Joyce says ‘bipartisan concern' in US about PM meeting Trump
A Coalition heavyweight has called on Anthony Albanese to lock in a meeting with Donald Trump after two of the staunchest supporters of the US-Australia alliance urged the Prime Minister to visit Washington. Six months have passed since Mr Trump's inauguration and Mr Albanese is yet to secure an in-person meeting with the US President. Australian producers have been slugged with tariffs on most exports to the US, including duties of up to 50 per cent on steel and aluminium, and doubts loom large about the Trump administration's commitment to AUKUS. The Albanese government has also made Australia an outlier in the West on defence spending, refusing to budge after Washington's request to hike it to 3.5 per cent of GDP amid alarm bells over China's military build-up. Speaking to Australian media, Republican representative Michael McCaul and Democrat colleague Joe Courtney said Mr Albanese would benefit from a one-on-one with Mr Trump. 'For (Albanese) to come to the White House would be a great gesture on the Prime Minister's part, that I think would go over very well,' Mr McCaul told the Australian Financial Review. 'That would be very sound advice for him to do that.' Mr McCaul and Mr Courtney are co-chairs of a congressional working group on AUKUS, which the Trump administration is reviewing. Asked about the comments on Monday, Social Services Minister Tanya Plibersek said she was 'sure the Prime Minister's very much looking forward to' meeting Mr Trump. 'We're awaiting confirmation of a suitable time, and I'm sure when that confirmation comes through, the Prime Minister will be very happy to visit Washington,' she told Seven's Sunrise. 'He's had a number of calls with President Trump.' Ms Plibersek noted there had been numerous meetings at the ministerial level, including Foreign Minister Penny Wong's upcoming Quad summit in Washington. She also praised Australia's ambassador, Kevin Rudd. 'Ambassador Rudd … is the Energiser Bunny of diplomacy,' Ms Plibersek said. 'He will be meeting with all of the members of the congress and Senate and people close to Donald Trump. 'There's a lot of communication going on both ways, but it's not the sort of thing where you just pop in with a plate of scones, hoping someone's home.' But appearing opposite the senior minister, Nationals MP Barnaby Joyce took a different view. He said the approach was not good enough. 'Ambassador Rudd might be the Energiser Bunny, but he hasn't energised a meeting between President Trump and the Prime Minister of Australia,' Mr Joyce said. 'We've gotta do that. When two people either side of the political fence in the United States say 'you better get over here' – they've obviously got a genuine bipartisan concern.' He also blasted Mr Albanese for having 'four meetings with the leader of China but no meetings with the President of the United States'. Mr Albanese is finalising details for his state visit to China mid next month. It will be his fourth meeting with Xi Jinping since winning power in 2022. Asked at an early morning press conference if a meeting with Mr Trump was in the works, Mr Albanese replied: 'Yes.' Originally published as 'Genuine bipartisan concern' in US about when PM will meet Donald Trump, Barnaby Joyce says
