Canadians say Carney government failed them as Iranian missiles landed in Israel
The Carney government largely failed to help Canadian citizens safely and quickly exit Israel as Iran began its deadly bombardment of civilian areas late last week, according to two evacuees.
Article content
Two Canadians who spent several days sheltering intermittently in bomb shelters say they found safe passage via Birthright, an organization that brings members of the Jewish diaspora to Israel on a 10-day sponsored trip to learn more about the country.
Article content
Article content
Article content
'The messaging has been all over the place,' Pe'er Krut told National Post. 'What I can tell you for sure is that Birthright took it in their own hands completely to help Canadian students get out of Israel.'
Article content
Ottawa finally announced an evacuation plan on June 20 as Krut and others fled the Iranian bombs with Birthright's help.
Article content
Hi @AnitaAnandMP
As you know, most countries operating diplomatic missions in Israel have been getting their citizens out for days now. As you also know it's really not that complicated to mount an overland evacuation operation to Jordan. And as you should know, there are other… https://t.co/gEPGfdXEht
— Vivian Bercovici (@VivianBercovici) June 21, 2025
Article content
Article content
Krut, a Torontonian in Jerusalem doing a legal internship over the summer, said she got word on June 16 from her program organizers, Onward — which falls under the umbrella of Birthright — that plans were in motion to evacuate her and others from Israel. Over the intervening days while the logistics were ironed out, Krut recalls spending hours running back and forth to a bomb shelter as Iranian missiles struck Israel.
Article content
Article content
'We were going up and down every few hours for a few days, it felt like I started to get to know every face, their personalities. People would bring food for the community. The same person would hold the door open for all the people in wheelchairs, the same baby would always be crying in the corner, comforted by some random other neighbour who would help out.'
Article content
On June 20, Krut boarded a cruise ship in Ashdod, a town just south of Tel Aviv, with hundreds of Birthright participants from the United States, Canada and the United Kingdom bound for Cyprus. 'We all signed waivers and they bussed us to the boat,' she said. 'This is like a Mission Impossible escape plan, what they pulled off.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Globe and Mail
20 minutes ago
- Globe and Mail
Iranian-Canadians fear escalation in Middle East conflict after U.S. strikes on nuclear sites
Iranian-Canadians say they fear an escalation in the Middle East conflict after U.S. President Donald Trump led the United States into conflict with Iran, ordering air strikes against three nuclear sites. Fakhreddin Jamali, co-founder of the Iranian Heritage Society of Edmonton and a professor emeritus in the School of Pharmacy at the University of Alberta, said most of his family is in Iran. He has maintained daily communication with family members who are on edge, expecting more to happen. 'I have an older sister who has mobility problems and is in an apartment in Iran,' Dr. Jamali said in an interview from Vancouver. 'We are very worried about her. I don't know how long this is going to last, especially with supplies, grocery stores, medical attention, all these things.' He said he worries that the escalation will overshadow what is happening in Gaza – 'because that is more of a tragedy than Iran' – and is hopeful for a diplomatic resolution. As Iranians take shelter or flee, some also hope for the end of a repressive regime Opinion: Regime change in Iran would lead to chaos The conflict has reverberated through his social circles. 'Last night I was having dinner with a bunch of Iranians, and almost everybody was depressed, everybody was down,' he said. 'Everybody is thinking about it, in the back of their minds.' The Pentagon said the three nuclear sites sustained 'extremely severe damage and destruction' in the air strikes, which came after more than a week of attacks by Israel on Iran. Iran has vowed to retaliate, with Foreign Minister Abbas Araghchi saying his country would respond 'based on our legitimate right to self-defence.' Mona Ghassemi, president of the Iranian Canadian Congress, said her tight-knit circle is deeply concerned and looking for unity in the face of aggression. Her group strongly condemns the U.S. attacks, and is dismayed that Prime Minister Mark Carney did not do the same. Mr. Carney said in a post to X Sunday morning that 'Iran's nuclear programme is a grave threat to international security, and Canada has been consistently clear that Iran can never be allowed to develop a nuclear weapon.' He added that the situation in the Middle East remains highly volatile, and called for diplomatic talks to resume immediately. 'Carney ran on a platform that he will stand up to the U.S., but when it comes to these military aggressions, he is supporting them,' Ms. Ghassemi said in an interview from Montreal. She called a statement by Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre – in which he said American and Israeli actions to stop Iran's 'genocidal regime' from acquiring a nuclear weapon are '100% justified' – even more egregious. She cited the International Court of Justice's January, 2024, ruling, which found that there is a plausible case that Israel may be committing genocidal acts in Gaza. 'This is a reversal of the facts,' Ms. Ghassemi said of Mr. Poilievre's statement. Nima Machouf, a member of a Montreal Iranian women's association, said family members in Iran are living 'from one bomb to another.' The epidemiologist and former NDP candidate worries the strikes will only lead to more violence and hurt the people who are fighting to free themselves from Iran's repressive regime. Kaveh Shahrooz, a lawyer and a senior fellow at the Macdonald-Laurier Institute, said many Iranians are worried about the impact the U.S. decision to join Israel's war on Iran could have on citizens. But he said some opponents of the regime are celebrating the U.S. strikes, happy to see Iran's nuclear program 'effectively dismantled.' With a report from The Canadian Press
CBC
22 minutes ago
- CBC
Members of Iranian, Jewish communities in Manitoba react to escalating conflict after U.S. attacks on Iran
A day after the U.S. bombed three nuclear sites in Iran, one Iranian Canadian group came out in condemnation of the attacks as an escalation of hostilities, while a community organizer viewed the strikes as a pathway to regime change in Iran. Iranian nuclear facilities in Fordow, Isfahan and Natanz were struck by the U.S. on Saturday in what officials hailed as an overwhelming success that obliterated Tehran's nuclear ambitions. The operation comes more than a week after Israel targeted Iran's Defence Ministry headquarters, igniting an exchange of missile attacks between the two countries. Washington's involvement in the Israel-Iran war pushes the Middle East to the brink of a major new conflict, in a region already aflame for more than 20 months with wars in Gaza and Lebanon and a toppled dictator in Syria. Iran's Foreign Ministry said the U.S. had "betrayed diplomacy" with the military strikes in support of Israel. Arian Arianpour, a community organizer and former president of the Iranian Community of Manitoba, said he doesn't view the U.S. airstrikes on the nuclear facilities as an attack on Iran and its citizens, but on the rulers of the Islamic Republic — and said the strikes may be a pathway to break away from them. Arianpour said elections, protests and reform efforts haven't resulted in political changes, even as they have put Iranian citizens that speak out at risk of retaliation from the regime's leaders. "This war, as painful as it might be, might present an opportunity to finish the job that ... people have started decades ago," Arianpour said. "They [Iranians] have been suffering under a regime that they did not want, and now they are suffering from a war they did not choose." Iran's only viable path forward is to ensure a dismantling of its ruling regime, Arianpour said. External attacks to Iran might weaken the government's capacity to also crack down on internal dissent, he added. "Iranians, whether inside or outside the country, do want to see this regime end," Arianpour said. On Sunday, a national Iranian-Canadian advocacy group condemned the U.S. attacks on Iran. In a statement, the Iranian Canadian Congress (ICC) said the strikes "recklessly ran the risk of untold harm to Iran's population with nuclear fallout by bombing civilian nuclear infrastructure sites." The national non-profit organization called on Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney to help de-escalate the conflict and take a stand against the strikes. "We strongly urge Mark Carney's government to show some backbone, listen to Canadian citizens' calls to not involve our country in U.S. and Israeli aggression, and act in accordance with Canadian and International law to avert further escalation of war," the ICC wrote. On Sunday, Carney said in a statement on social media that Iran's nuclear program is "a grave threat to international security", and while the U.S. military action was designed to alleviate the threat, the situation in the Middle East remains highly volatile. The Canadian government is calling for a diplomatic solution to end the crisis, Carney's statement said. 'Not an easy time for Jews in Winnipeg' Jeff Lieberman, the Jewish Federation of Winnipeg's CEO, said Iran's government has been a threat to Israel's security and the organization supports the U.S. bombing of nuclear sites in an effort to make the world "a safer place for everyone." He also said the organization wants peace in the region and it "would be a good thing if they could start to try to negotiate." "The last thing that I think that anybody wants is to see innocent people, whether they're Iranians or they're Israelis, get hurt or killed," Lieberman said. In the meantime, Lieberman said Israel is still in danger from Iranian missiles evading the country's air defences and slamming into civilian areas. "It's not an easy time for Jews in Winnipeg," Lieberman said. Gustavo Zentner, vice-president for the Centre for Israel and Jewish Affairs (CIJA), said Iran's nuclear program also poses a threat to Canada and its allies. "It is critical to remind Canadians that the Iran issue is not just about Israel or the Jewish community," he said. "It's about the safety of Canada." Hours after the American attacks, Iran's paramilitary Revolutionary Guard said it launched 40 missiles at Israel. Officials reported more than 80 people suffered mostly minor injuries. Lieberman said the Jewish federation is helping Winnipeggers stranded in Israel to come to Canada through Jordan and Cyprus.
Globe and Mail
2 hours ago
- Globe and Mail
As Iranians take shelter or flee, some also hope for the end of a repressive regime
It was 3 a.m. when a deafening noise shattered the silence of homes in the affluent Saadat Abad district in northern Tehran earlier this month. Windows shook. Children woke up crying. Panicked residents ran into the street. Abideh, a mother of two young children, thought their building was collapsing. Everyone was screaming, she said. Explosions kept going off. She ran to the rooftop and saw a nearby building on fire. That was the night of Israel's first attack on the Iranian capital. With her ten-year-old son and six-year-old daughter, Abideh was forced to leave her home and seek shelter with relatives on the outskirts of the city. 'We're basically homeless now. We don't even know where we'll be tomorrow,' Abideh told The Globe and Mail by phone last week. The Globe is using only first names for the Iranians who were interviewed to protect their security at a time of growing unrest. As Israeli air strikes continue to pound the city of almost 10 million, many residents of Tehran have chosen to flee. Long lines at gas stations, skyrocketing food prices, and severe medicine shortages have only worsened the anxiety. Abideh says that the sounds of the attack on her neighbourhood are still alive in her mind. 'My hands shake, my heart races. The fear hasn't left me,' she said. 'Every night, after my kids fall asleep, I sit and think about the future … a future with no sense of safety.' But inside basements, parking garages and other places where people are looking for safety, it's not just fear that echoes, but also voices rooted in decades of pain. Abideh said that in the shelter where she and her family have been staying, there are women praying for the death of Iranian Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, whose regime has executed their sons. 'Some said maybe this war would finally bring down the government,' Abideh said. She hears chants ringing out in the streets, even in the dead of night: 'Death to the dictator!' 'An end to 46 years of tyranny!' Despite their overwhelming fear, Abideh said people are still clinging to hope: 'Hope for change. Hope that maybe all this pain will finally wake people up.' The main cause of the unrest and the current atmosphere of repression, she said, is the Islamic Republic regime, which has spent taxpayers' money on its proxy forces, pushed the country into isolation and ultimately paved the way for a foreign attack. 'The Iranian people do not want war with anyone; rather, they seek peace with all nations — including Israel,' she said. Only way to topple Iran's regime is through popular movement, Shirin Ebadi says Opinion: Regime change in Iran would lead to chaos But fear among the Iranian population is not confined to Tehran. Reza, a 23-year-old international relations student in Isfahan, the country's second-largest metropolitan area, described a city hollowed out by fear, with deserted streets and shuttered stores. 'It's like the city has died. Everyone's afraid. No one knows what's going to happen tomorrow.' For Reza, life has turned into a sleepless nightmare. 'Every moment, I'm waiting for a missile to hit. I can't sleep from the stress,' he told The Globe last week. What haunts him even more is the uncertainty. 'We don't even know what's hidden in our neighbourhoods. Maybe that grey wall near my house is hiding a drone factory. Who knows?' Like Abideh, Reza also speaks of an end — not just to war, but to dictatorship. 'People hate this regime. Without internal co-operation, Israel couldn't have struck so precisely.' He says that now, more than ever, there's a strange, cautious hope among Iranians. 'There are rumours everywhere. That Khamenei is dead. That tomorrow the revolution begins. Even if they're not true, just the fact these rumours spread shows how desperately people want this regime gone.' In streets that just days ago were full of life, silence now dominates. Storefronts are dark. Sirens wail sporadically. Mothers whisper prayers in the shadows. 'Today the roads are empty,' Reza said. 'Shops are closed. People are anxious. Worried about a future they can't see – and don't know will ever come.'
