Anti-poverty: Stormont in legal breach over strategy
Stormont's Executive Committee has been found in breach of its legal obligation to adopt an anti-poverty strategy at the Royal Courts of Justice.The strategy was first committed to 18 years ago in an effort to tackle poverty, social exclusion and deprivation.The human rights group, the Committee on the Administration of Justice (CAJ), took the case against the Stormont Executive, the communities minister and the first and deputy first ministers.The judge said there was no evidence that the communities minister or the first and deputy first ministers were in breach of their duties.
The court heard while the Communities Minister Gordon Lyons had "abandoned" work done for the strategy, it did not amount to a "deliberate attempt to thwart" publication of the anti-poverty strategy.
Una Boyd KC, representing the human rights group, said while the judgement had not gone entirely their way, it was a "significant victory"."What is very important about the outcome is it reiterates that an anti-poverty strategy isn't a policy decision, it isn't something that's nice to have. "It's a legal obligation, and that legal obligation simply has not been filled."The court heard a timeline of the delays in adopting the anti-poverty strategy, which was included in the Northern Ireland Act following the St Andrews Agreement in 2006.
The case, brought by the CAJ, is also supported by members of the Equality Coalition including Unison, Barnardo's NI and the Northern Ireland Anti-Poverty Network.Gerry Murphy, from the Irish Congress of Trade Unions, said the outcome showed there was a "malaise affecting decision making" at Stormont."Poverty is widespread across our community," he said. "On top of all of that, it's affecting people who are never affected by poverty before."
John Patrick Clayton, from Unison, was involved in the design of the anti-poverty strategy and he said the delay in adopting the strategy was frustrating."Poverty is an urgent issue," he said."It would have made a difference in people's day-to-day lives. "I should say we haven't seen the content of the executive draft strategy so it's hard in the abstract to say specifically what the executive might have done that would have made a difference. "But there's a whole range of things that had been recommended previously."He said this includes recommendations to introduce a new child payment, building on the model that is used in Scotland."We had advocated within my own union for the introduction of universal free school meals so there are measures there that could make a tangible difference in people's lives," he added.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BBC News
18 hours ago
- BBC News
Stormont strategy to tackle poverty 'not fit for purpose'
The first draft strategy agreed by the Northern Ireland Executive to tackle poverty is "not fit for purpose", according to a children's anti-poverty strategy was first proposed in 2006, with the aim of reducing social exclusion and March, Stormont's Executive Committee was found by a court ruling to be in breach of its legal obligation to adopt the News NI has now seen a leaked copy of the document, which was agreed by executive ministers earlier in May, but has yet to be made public. 'No new actions' Trása Canavan of Barnardo's NI, who is also chair of the Anti- Poverty Strategy Group, was among groups who met Communities Minister Gordon Lyons earlier this week about the said she had "serious concerns that it will not make any difference to the lives of the children, families and communities that our organisations support every day, and we raised this with minister Lyons this week"."The current draft of the Anti-Poverty Strategy is not fit for purpose. "It clearly shows that the government has committed no new actions or funding to tackle poverty in Northern Ireland."The 28-page paper sets out the executive's approach to tackling poverty over the next 10 outlines efforts already being taken by various departments to help minimise the risks of people falling into poverty in Northern Ireland, as well as reducing its impacts and ways to help people get out of poverty. The document states that poverty is "not a problem which the executive can solve in isolation", but one that requires community groups, business, councils and voluntary groups to adds that the strategy will be accompanied by a programme of delivery to be updated on an ongoing Canavan added that earlier this year her group had outlined what it wanted to see in the document in order for it to be effective."This included clear and time-bound targets, a lifecycle approach, new actions and clear funding commitments, rather than counting work that is already under way."Unfortunately, the draft strategy does not meet any of these key principles."It is quite simply not good enough for the people of Northern Ireland. "Our group remains committed to working constructively with the government to eradicating poverty in Northern Ireland." 'Deeply underwhelmed' The SDLP, Stormont's official opposition, said it is "impossible to be anything other than deeply underwhelmed" by the H Durkan said the executive should be "embarrassed to present a document that reads more like a list of vague hopes than a plan of action".The paper sets out measures already being taken by the executive and says it will "continue to deliver a package of welfare mitigations" while lobbying Westminster on reforms and to maintain the triple lock on adds that legislation being brought by Education Minister Paul Givan will ensure all school uniforms are affordable, and that strategies on fuel poverty will be also promises that "everyone, including those in or at risk of poverty, has access to good quality, affordable and sustainable homes".But Durkan said: "This document acknowledges the direct link between housing and poverty and yet the Executive have confirmed they will only build half of the homes intended this year."The strategy also fails to confront one of the most damaging policies hitting low-income families: the two-child limit. Ministers have the power to address these issues, but once again they've chosen not to."When it was agreed last month by the executive, First Minister Michelle O'Neill said the plan probably could "go further" but denied there was a row between Sinn Fein and the DUP over it. 'Fiscal challenges' Communities Minister, Gordon Lyons, whose department oversaw the design of the draft strategy, said it had "drawn heavily on the work that has already been carried out".The DUP minister succeeded Sinn Féín's Deirdre Hargey in the role when Stormont was restored in 2024 after a two-year Department for Communities said: "The draft Strategy reflects the Executive's priorities in the context of the ongoing fiscal and other challenges we face."The minister has listened to a wide range of views ahead of the consultation launch, which will give people from all communities a chance to have their say on how we tackle poverty and transform lives in Northern Ireland. "Minister Lyons would encourage all stakeholders in this area to provide their feedback when the consultation formally opens."It added that officials were working to launch the consultation as soon as possible.
The Herald Scotland
4 days ago
- The Herald Scotland
Value of Stormont Executive's office in Beijing questioned
The Executive also has offices in Washington DC and Brussels. It has had a presence in Beijing since 2014, before then-first minister Arlene Foster opened an Executive bureau in December 2016. Executive Office chair Paula Bradshaw (Brian Lawless/PA) Executive Committee chair Paula Bradshaw said she had concerns around its value for money, after the committee heard from the three bureaux during a meeting last month. Executive Office official Brenda Henderson said she appreciated there is frustration around transparency and accounting for what they do. 'One of the things that I want to do is to get that coherency across all three bureaux and with the international relations team in Belfast to make sure that we have a clear narrative, that our communications plans can let you see, and let our ministers see, exactly who we're meeting, what is the outcome of that, what does it mean, the 'so what' question in terms of the Programme For Government,' she told MLAs. 'Work is already under way on that.' Ms Bradshaw followed up by asking at what point would they conclude it is not value for money, and that they could be doing other things with that money. Ms Henderson said there are different ways to measure value for money. 'One of the things that I know that the overseas offices do is that they build relationships, you have to build those relationships before you utilise them, but there are things about companies, investment, increased student places they bring,' she said. 'I think what we need to do is be more absolutely transparent about that and be clear about the metrics, what we can measure and that we stand in front of those.' Permanent Secretary David Malcolm said he can 'see behind the curtain', and knows what the Beijing office is doing, He expressed frustration it was not communicated. He said last month the vice minister for education in China visited Northern Ireland and signed an agreement with the Confucious Institute in Belfast and the Department for the Economy for a £34 million programme over the next 10 years. He also said in Beijing this St Patrick's Day, there were two community organisations led by Chris Hazzard, including young people who had never left Ireland before. 'There is significant work we're doing,' he said. 'We are also talking to the Chinese Consul about a mini conference here later on,' he said. 'The Chinese have agreed to fund three placements in Beijing through the Arts Council to give people the opportunity to break into the Chinese market. There is a tremendous amount we're doing.' He added: 'Not just in Beijing, in Washington, we punch miles above our weight in the representational role we get, and indeed in Brussels.'
North Wales Chronicle
4 days ago
- North Wales Chronicle
Future of formerly at-risk tower house dating to 1800s secured
Culmore Fort in Co Londonderry has been converted for community use and is set to accommodate mental health support for youth in the area, and host meetings for a variety of sports, heritage and cultural organisations. The work was completed by Culmore Community Partnership thanks to funding of £265,000. Communities Minister Gordon Lyons hailed the move to provide a vital community resource for Culmore and the surrounding area. 'We are seeing more and more communities applying to Village Catalyst and I am pleased that my department is able to support projects where at-risk heritage properties are being revitalised and restored for the benefit of the local community,' he said. Agriculture, Environment and Rural Affairs Minister Andrew Muir said it was part-funded through his department's Tackling Rural Poverty and Social Isolation (TRPSI) Programme. 'The programme tackles rural poverty and social isolation by refurbishing neglected community-owned historic buildings for locally identified uses which provide access to services and address core community needs,' he said. 'The provision of a multi-functional community facility in the Culmore area is a significant development and I'm delighted that this project will help support the local rural community for many years to come.' Culmore Community Partnership chairman Neil Doherty thanked all the funders, which also include the Architectural Heritage Fund and the Northern Ireland Housing Executive. He said historically the fort was held by the Crown until 1840, when it and its surrounding lands were sold to The Honourable The Irish Society, who remain its owners to this day. 'We are pleased to share that Culmore Community Partnership (CCP) has now assumed the lease to facilitate the restoration of this historic building and to open it up for wider community use,' he said. Meanwhile, Una Cooper, strategic manager for the partnership, said they are excited to see the fort go from being a reminder of the past to a 'cornerstone for the future of Culmore'. 'We're preparing to launch vital mental health and emotional wellbeing programmes for children and young people, offering them a safe and supportive environment to thrive,' she said. 'The fort will also become a place for cultural and heritage events that celebrate our community's identity. 'The work at the fort was carried out by dedicated professionals whose craftsmanship and care brought this conservation project to life. 'We would like to extend our thanks to We Build Ireland for their tireless commitment, precision and ability to bring out the best in every stone, beam and brick. Their work has preserved the soul of this fort for generations to come. 'Our architect Mark Hackett's vision and sensitivity to the fort's historic character ensured that every decision respected the past while making room for the future. 'His attention to detail has been nothing short of extraordinary. Culmore Fort has been transformed into a vibrant community space — a place where history meets hope.'
