logo
Blue city faces calls for corruption probe in teacher's 'suicide' by 20 stab wounds case

Blue city faces calls for corruption probe in teacher's 'suicide' by 20 stab wounds case

Yahoo16-02-2025

The former Pennsylvania state trooper and private investigator who spent more than a decade digging into the suspicious death of Philadelphia teacher Ellen Greenberg wants President Donald Trump's Justice Department to launch a corruption probe into Philadelphia as he slammed Gov. Josh Shapiro over his involvement in the controversial case.
The remarks come shortly after the forensic pathologist who conducted the autopsy finally abandoned his highly disputed finding that her death from 20 stab wounds was a suicide.
Half of them came from behind, including one that experts say was likely inflicted after she was already dead. Dr. Marlon Osbourne, a former member of the Philadelphia Medical Examiner's Office who has since moved to Florida, initially ruled her death a homicide but changed his finding to suicide days later, after a closed-door meeting with police, according to court records. Details about that meeting have never been made public, and the lawyer for Greenberg's parents said no record of who took part from the police department or what was discussed inside exists.
That meeting alone is enough for a federal corruption probe, according to Tom Brennan, the family's private investigator for nearly a decade and a former Pennsylvania state trooper.
Death Of Teacher With 20 Stab Wounds To Be Reexamined As Parents Settle With City
Greenberg's parents have demanded a new investigation for years. Philadelphia District Attorney Larry Krasner, citing a conflict of interest due to a past attorney-client relationship with the family, kicked the case up to the state attorney general's office headed by Shapiro at the time.
Read On The Fox News App
Nothing happened for years under Shapiro's office, according to Brennan.
"I can't stand a lying politician," he told Fox News Digital.
Teacher's Unlikely 'Suicide' Ruling Called Out As Web Sleuths Dig Into Surveillance Video
Brennan spent 25 years with the state police, including eight as an undercover detective investigating white-collar crime in Philadelphia.
"Don't tell me about corruption in Philadelphia," he said. "These people are foul. They are really foul."
Watch 'Teacher Death Mystery' On Fox Nation
As recently as last week, Shapiro said his office's investigation "pointed toward a suicide" in an interview with WHTM-TV.
In July 2022, an independent journalist named Gavin Fish posted a YouTube video alleging that AG Shapiro had "a clear conflict of interest" in the case and that Greenberg's fiancé's family was among his campaign donors. The AG's recusal from the case was announced three days later. He denied having "an actual conflict" but acknowledging the "appearance" of one.
On top of that, he had hired a former Philadelphia prosecutor who had overseen Greenberg's case in the city and assumed leadership of it in his office, Brennan said, another conflict when she was tasked with reviewing her own work.
But the alleged motivation to do nothing with the case may have been as simple as winning votes, Brennan said.
"Who needed the Philadelphia police and the Philadelphia vote in order to get into the governor's office? Attorney General Shapiro," Brennan said. "This guy puts politics above everything."
Despite offering public sympathy to Greenberg's parents, Brennan said Shapiro has never had a conversation with them or their investigative team about the case.
Follow The Fox True Crime Team On X
The case ultimately went to investigators from the Chester County District Attorney's Office, who spent two years reexamining it under Democratic DA Deb Ryan. They ultimately said they did not have enough evidence to bring criminal charges against anyone.
Much of the physical evidence was destroyed by a crime scene cleanup crew before police arrived at the apartment with a search warrant. Digital evidence may have been tainted after it was removed from the crime scene by prominent Pennsylvania Judge James Schwartzman, the uncle of Greenberg's fiancé.
"This guy's a judge and an attorney. He disciplines attorneys for doing things wrong," Brennan said. "What the hell was he thinking of?"
Neither Goldberg nor Schwartzman have been accused of any wrongdoing, but multiple judges have slammed the handling of the crime scene and the forensic investigation as part of the parents' two lawsuits.
Judge Tied To Ellen Greenberg's Fiancé Took Items From Her 'Suicide' Scene Before Police Search
Greenberg died Jan. 26, 2011, after Goldberg called 911 and said he found her dead in the kitchen of their Philadelphia apartment during a snowstorm. There was a half-prepared fruit salad on the countertop above her, she had just sent out save-the-date notices for their expected wedding and friends and family said she had not seemed suicidal.
Goldberg said he found her after returning from the gym in their building. However, according to Brennan, the first responders who arrived found him wearing different clothes than the athletic wear he had on in surveillance video downstairs.
WATCH: Sam Goldberg, fiancé of Ellen Greenberg at the time, seen in 2011 surveillance footage
Judge Dumbfounded By Error At Site Of 'Suicide' Where Teacher Was Found Stabbed 20 Times
The 27-year-old teacher was covered in bruises at various stages of healing, and half of her 20 stab wounds had been inflicted from behind. There was evidence that at least one wound was inflicted after her death, the scene had been staged and that her body had been moved, according to Brennan. He said dried blood would not have dripped sideways across her face if she'd died in the position she was found. And an outside autopsy found signs of manual strangulation on top of the other injuries.
"Reviewing the file and the crime scene photographs and the medical examiner's photographs, I don't know how you come to that conclusion [of suicide]," Guy D'Andrea, a former homicide prosecutor with the Philadelphia District Attorney's Office, told Fox News Digital previously.
SIGN UP TO GET True Crime Newsletter
Police have been heavily criticized for their handling of the crime scene, which was left unsecured and cleaned up by a crew called in by building management before they returned with a search warrant.
After more than a decade of trauma for the parents and a pair of lawsuits, Dr. Osbourne finally walked back the controversial suicide finding in a letter to a Pennsylvania court last month.
"It is my professional opinion Ellen's manner of death should be designated as something other than suicide," he wrote. "Since issuing the amended death certificate, I have become aware of additional information I did not have at the time of issuing the amended death certificate which may have impacted my opinion."
GET REAL-TIME UPDATES DIRECTLY ON THE True Crime Hub
Days later, the City of Philadelphia settled a lawsuit with Greenberg's parents, Dr. Josh and Sandee Greenberg, that accused local officials and the medical examiner's office, including Osbourne, of participating in a "concealed conspiracy for the purpose of disguising Ellen's homicide as a suicide," according to legal documents.
Brennan is calling for a federal probe into the investigation and city officials by President Donald Trump's new Justice Department.
"You have people who are actually trying to hide a homicide," he told Fox News Digital. "Don't you think the federal government would be interested in the corruption?
"I hope, and I pray that Trump appoints a Republican U.S. attorney in Philadelphia."
Shapiro's office did not immediately respond to a request for comment.
Fox News' Mollie Markowitz contributed to this report.Original article source: Blue city faces calls for corruption probe in teacher's 'suicide' by 20 stab wounds case

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Donald Trump Suffers Double Legal Blow in California
Donald Trump Suffers Double Legal Blow in California

Newsweek

time2 hours ago

  • Newsweek

Donald Trump Suffers Double Legal Blow in California

Based on facts, either observed and verified firsthand by the reporter, or reported and verified from knowledgeable sources. Newsweek AI is in beta. Translations may contain inaccuracies—please refer to the original content. President Donald Trump has just been issued two legal blows in California over his anti-LGBTQ+ executive orders. U.S. District Judge Jon Tigar ruled in San Francisco that the president cannot legally withhold funding to programs that promote diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI). And California Attorney General (AG) Rob Bonta has launched a pre-enforcement suit against the Trump administration's attempt to ban transgender children from playing on sports teams that don't align with the gender assigned at birth. The Justice Department has been contacted for comment via email. President Donald Trump signs executive orders in the Oval Office of the White House, Jan. 20, 2025, in Washington. President Donald Trump signs executive orders in the Oval Office of the White House, Jan. 20, 2025, in Washington. Evan Vucci, File/AP Photo Why It Matters One of the president's first acts in office was to attempt to pull funding from programs that receive government funding and may engage in promoting "DEI." This has been challenged by many states, which argue that government funding decisions are within Congress' purview, not the President's. The Trump administration has also attempted to eradicate transgender people from public life by passing an executive order on needing to have their gender assigned at birth on their passports and firing transgender people from the military. This California lawsuit represents a legal pushback on behalf of transgender children. What To Know The lawsuit against Trump's executive order regarding DEI and public funds states that the president cannot remove funds without the consent of Congress. One of the plaintiffs in the case against funding loss is the San Francisco AIDS Foundation. This organization was told by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) that it would lose its funding as it promotes "DEI" and/or "gender ideology." Funding for the program comes from a five-year grant given in 2023, which the judge determined cannot be unilaterally removed by the president. The second lawsuit has also been filed in San Francisco regarding the Trump administration's executive order over funding to be halted to schools that allow transgender children to participate on sports teams that do not align with their gender at birth. California is arguing in this case that removing a transgender child's ability to participate in school sports in alignment with their gender identity violates their equal protection under the law and would force California schools to violate anti-discrimination laws. The lawsuit states: "Allowing athletic participation consistent with students' gender identity is substantially related to the important government interests of affording all students the benefits of an inclusive school environment, including participation in school sports, and preventing the serious harms that transgender students would suffer from a discriminatory, exclusionary policy." Conversely, the Justice Department (DOJ) has said that allowing transgender children to participate in sports according to their gender identity violates the equal protection rights of cisgender children. Actress Jess Elgene, author of Less of a Man spoke with Newsweek about the Trump administration's impact on transgender people in the U.S., saying: "It has definitely caused a certain amount of paranoia and just discomfort with the fact that I am trans and that I've been outspoken about my trans identity on stage. "It feels like I followed all the rules. I waited until I was well into my adult years, remained open about my identity, and put myself in a financially independent situation worthy of some respect - I'm an upright, taxpaying citizen! And yet, there is so much vitriol and determined confusion about what it means for me to simply move through life. I'm constantly battling between doom scrolling on social media because I need to stay informed and going completely off the grid because everything on the internet suggests I flee the country ASAP." Elgene added: "A huge talking point for folks tends to be what a "small portion of the population" trans people are, and I don't think that's as compelling a point as some people might think. "I think minimizing the amount of trans people in the world aids in making it feel like people won't be missing much if we are 'eradicated' from public life. I grew up in a deeply conservative town in Texas and still found myself as a trans girl when I was a young child. We are everywhere." Liv Y., center, holds a transgender pride flag as people gather to protest against the Trump administration and Project 2025 near the Washington State Capitol building Wednesday, Feb. 5, 2025, in Olympia, Washington. Liv Y., center, holds a transgender pride flag as people gather to protest against the Trump administration and Project 2025 near the Washington State Capitol building Wednesday, Feb. 5, 2025, in Olympia, Washington. Lindsey Wasson/AP Photo What People Are Saying Attorney General Bonta said in a press release: "The President and his Administration are demanding that California school districts break the law and violate the Constitution – or face legal retaliation. They're demanding that our schools discriminate against the students in their care and deny their constitutionally protected rights. "As we've proven time and again in court, just because the President disagrees with a law, that doesn't make it any less of one. As California's chief legal officer, I'll always fight to uphold and defend the laws of our state, especially those that protect and ensure the civil rights of the most vulnerable among us." President Donald Trump's Executive Order on Defending Women from Gender Ideology Extremism: "Across the country, ideologues who deny the biological reality of sex have increasingly used legal and other socially coercive means to permit men to self-identify as women and gain access to intimate single-sex spaces and activities designed for to eradicate the biological reality of sex fundamentally attack women by depriving them of their dignity, safety, and well-being." Actress and transgender advocate Jess Elgene told Newsweek: "I would encourage folks to consider why this has been made into such an issue. It's clear this is a slam dunk among certain vulnerable demographics of people who are susceptible to having marginalized groups vilified for them, and that's a disservice to those a complete disservice to them to blame every way in which this administration fails them on some hypothetical transgender athletes across the country." What Happens Next Although the plaintiffs won their case in San Francisco, their decision will likely be appealed to a higher court. This is one of many cases against the Trump administration that could find itself in the Supreme Court. The second case in San Francisco is asking for "declaratory and injunctive relief" when it comes to allowing the full participation of transgender children in sports.

Victory for Gardens officer who held unarmed man at gunpoint in viral 'unhinged cop' video
Victory for Gardens officer who held unarmed man at gunpoint in viral 'unhinged cop' video

Yahoo

time2 hours ago

  • Yahoo

Victory for Gardens officer who held unarmed man at gunpoint in viral 'unhinged cop' video

WEST PALM BEACH — A federal appeals court has dismissed a civil-rights lawsuit against a Palm Beach Gardens police officer whose viral arrest of an unarmed man drew national scrutiny, upholding a lower court's ruling and marking the latest in a series of victories for officer Bethany Guerriero. In a 13-page opinion, the panel of judges said Guerriero was not in the wrong during her May 2023 encounter with Ryan Gould, a then-resident of Palm Beach Gardens' Sabal Ridge apartment complex. Gould called 911 to report a neighbor who threatened him with a gun, only to be arrested at gunpoint himself when Guerriero mistook him for the suspect. Surveillance-camera footage in the apartment complex's parking lot showed Guerriero ordering Gould to the ground with her weapon drawn, ignoring his insistence that he was the victim. The video, posted to YouTube under the title 'Innocent Man Arrested by Unhinged Cop,' went viral. The city fired Guerriero in January 2024. Gould sued Guerriero soon afterward, accusing her of excessive force and false imprisonment. Guerriero, a 20-year veteran with the department, invoked qualified immunity, which, under Florida law, shields officers from personal liability unless they act with 'malicious purpose or in a manner exhibiting wanton and willful disregard.' U.S. District Judge Donald M. Middlebrooks dismissed the lawsuit in August, ruling that Guerriero did have probable cause to arrest Gould, and that her actions did not violate clearly established law. He found that the body-camera footage supported her version of events, including Gould's failure to follow commands. 'Any reasonable officer who was called to a scene due to a man brandishing a concealed weapon would have been aware of the danger of a man reaching into his pocket after being instructed not to,' Middlebrooks wrote. The appellate court agreed, concluding that Guerriero's decision to draw her firearm and arrest Gould was constitutional, given the conflicting 911 calls and uncertainty about who was armed. 'It is not clearly established law that drawing a gun on an unidentified individual thrice disobeying the reasonable commands of an officer … constitutes excessive force,' the court wrote. The judges noted that Guerriero repeatedly told Gould to keep his hands out of his pockets and to drop his phone, and only escalated when he failed to comply. The court's decision, finalized with a mandate on June 3, effectively ends Gould's federal lawsuit, barring an appeal to the U.S. Supreme Court. Though Guerriero was initially fired for violating department policy — including policies on conduct, courtesy and response to resistance — she was reinstated months later through arbitration. The arbitrator ruled that her conduct warranted serious discipline, but not termination, and she returned to duty without back pay. In his ruling, arbitrator Richard J. Miller found that Guerriero's behavior — including escalating the encounter with verbal taunts, drawing her weapon and violating several department policies — was serious enough to warrant discipline but not dismissal. He noted Guerriero admitted to violating policies on response to resistance, conduct unbecoming and professional courtesy. Still, the arbitrator rejected the city's argument that her actions and past record— three prior disciplinary incidents over her two-decade career — justified ending her employment. He emphasized the principles of progressive discipline and determined that a suspension without pay was more appropriate. 'Termination is too severe a punishment in this case,' Miller wrote. 'This award gives Officer Guerriero another chance and, at the same time, does not become a financial liability to the city.' City officials had maintained that Guerriero's conduct undermined public trust and departmental credibility. The incident drew more than 60,000 views online and sparked hundreds of calls and emails to the police department, many of them critical. Gould's attorney, Eric Rice, did not return a request for comment. Hannah Phillips is a journalist covering public safety and criminal justice at The Palm Beach Post. You can reach her at hphillips@ This article originally appeared on Palm Beach Post: Lawsuit dismissed against Florida officer in "unhinged cop' video

Russian MPs back new state messaging app to combat WhatsApp and Telegram
Russian MPs back new state messaging app to combat WhatsApp and Telegram

Yahoo

time2 hours ago

  • Yahoo

Russian MPs back new state messaging app to combat WhatsApp and Telegram

By Alexander Marrow (Reuters) -Russian lawmakers on Tuesday voted for the development of a state-backed messaging app that would be closely integrated with government services, as Moscow strives to reduce its dependency on platforms like WhatsApp and Telegram. Russia has long sought to establish what it calls digital sovereignty by promoting home-grown services. Its push to replace foreign tech platforms became more urgent as some Western companies pulled out of the Russian market following Moscow's February 2022 invasion of Ukraine. Anton Gorelkin, deputy head of the Russian parliament's information policy committee which wrote the draft legislation, said Russia's app would offer messaging and calls, as well as other functionality that Telegram and Meta Platforms' WhatsApp do not have. "The main competitive advantage of the platform will be the deep integration with government services," Gorelkin wrote on Telegram. The draft legislation must still pass through the upper house of parliament and be signed by President Vladimir Putin to become law. Digital Development Minister Maksut Shadayev last week proposed integrating government services with a national messaging app at a meeting with President Vladimir Putin, highlighting Russia's shortcomings compared to other countries in this area. He praised state-controlled technology company VK, whose VKontakte social media site is accessed by almost 80 million Russians every day, for developing home-grown services such as VK Video, a Russian rival to Alphabet's YouTube. VK has been spending heavily on producing content and improving its technical expertise to boost its audience, lurching to a 94.9-billion-rouble ($1.21 billion) loss in 2024. YouTube's audience in Russia has dropped sharply in the last year to fewer than 10 million daily users from more than 40 million in mid-2024, as slower download speeds have made it harder for people to access. Russian officials have blamed the slowdown on Google, accusing it of failing to invest in Russian infrastructure and criticising it for refusing to reinstate blocked Russian channels. YouTube has said the slowdown was not caused by any actions or technical issues on its side. Mikhail Klimarev, director of the Internet Protection Society, a Russian digital rights group, said on Telegram that he expected Russia to slow the speeds of WhatsApp and Telegram to make space for the new state messenger, which he has warned may violate personal freedoms. ($1 = 78.4205 roubles)

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store