Human rights group loses legal challenge over exports of jet parts to Israel
Al-Haq took legal action against the Department for Business and Trade (DBT) over its decision to continue licensing exports of components for F-35 fighter jets, telling a hearing in May that it was unlawful and 'gives rise to a significant risk of facilitating crime'.
In September last year, the Government suspended export licences for weapons and military equipment following a review of Israel's compliance with international humanitarian law in the conflict.
But an exemption was made for some licences related to parts for F-35s, which are part of an international defence programme.
The DBT defended the challenge, with its barristers telling a four-day hearing in London that the carve-out is 'consistent with the rules of international law'.
In a 72-page ruling on Monday, Lord Justice Males and Mrs Justice Steyn dismissed the legal challenge.
The senior judges said that 'the conduct of international relations' is a matter for the executive, rather than the courts, and that it would be unnecessary to decide whether there was a 'significant risk' that the carve-out could facilitate crimes.
Defence Secretary John Healey had said a suspension would impact the 'whole F-35 programme' (PA)
They added: 'The grave risk to life in the ongoing military operations in the Gaza Strip is not created by the F-35 carve-out, and would not be removed by suspension of the export from the UK of F-35 parts into the F-35 programme.'
The High Court was previously told that the decision to 'carve out' licences related to F-35 components followed advice from Defence Secretary John Healey, who said a suspension would impact the 'whole F-35 programme' and have a 'profound impact on international peace and security'.
The F-35 programme is an international defence programme which produces and maintains the fighter jets, with the UK contributing components for both assembly lines and an international pool.
Israel is not one of the 'partner nations' of the programme, the court heard, but is a customer and can order new F-35 aircraft and draw on a pool for spare parts.
The two judges later said they agreed with barristers for the DBT, who said it was not possible for the UK to 'unilaterally' ensure that UK-made parts did not reach Israel.
Demonstrators outside the Royal Courts of Justice, central London during an earlier hearing (PA)
Lord Justice Males and Mrs Justice Steyn said: 'In short, the Secretary of State reasonably concluded that there was no realistic possibility of persuading all other partner nations that F-35 exports to Israel should be suspended.'
'Accordingly he was faced with the blunt choice of accepting the F-35 carve-out or withdrawing from the F-35 Programme and accepting all the defence and diplomatic consequences which would ensue,' they added.
The two judges also said the case was about a 'much more focused issue' than the carve-out itself.
They continued: 'That issue is whether it is open to the court to rule that the UK must withdraw from a specific multilateral defence collaboration which is reasonably regarded by the responsible ministers as vital to the defence of the UK and to international peace and security, because of the prospect that some UK manufactured components will or may ultimately be supplied to Israel, and may be used in the commission of a serious violation of international humanitarian law in the conflict in Gaza.
'Under our constitution that acutely sensitive and political issue is a matter for the executive which is democratically accountable to Parliament and ultimately to the electorate, not for the courts.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Reuters
23 minutes ago
- Reuters
Copper's tariff high fails to lift other LME metals
LONDON, July 1 (Reuters) - Doctor Copper hasn't been quite the same since U.S. President Donald Trump announced an investigation into U.S. imports back in February. The resulting tariff trade has pulled the global supply chain out of shape, creating feast in the U.S. and famine everywhere else. London Metal Exchange (LME) copper is set to close out the first half of the year with a gain of 12%, beaten only by the wild tin market. The rest of the LME complex, however, is still recovering from the shock of Trump's broader "Liberation Day" tariffs. Trade and geopolitical turbulence have lit a fire under the precious metals, but industrial metals are largely treading water at the mid-year mark as concern grows about the tariff-related drag on global manufacturing activity. Here's the LME score-card at the end of the first half of 2025. The CME's U.S. copper contract is currently trading at a spot premium of $1,200 per metric ton over the LME's international price. The tariff trade has been extraordinarily volatile over the last few months, but the open arbitrage window continues to suck in metal from the rest of the world. CME stocks are booming and LME stocks are falling as physical copper is redirected to the U.S. LME time-spreads have become turbulent as available inventory shrinks. The cash-to-three-month period is in steep backwardation. The market is expecting Chinese smelters to lift exports to help fill the supply-chain gaps, but until they do the London copper market is a dangerous place for bears. Everything will change again when the U.S. administration decides whether to impose import tariffs. That presages more turbulence ahead of the November deadline for the Section 232 investigation into U.S. imports to be completed. The London tin market has been a roller-coaster ride so far this year. Three-month tin hit a three-year high of $38,395 per ton in early April before slumping to $28,925 after the "Liberation Day" metals meltdown. Tin is currently back above $33,500 per ton thanks to persistent supply pressures. Although one disruption has been resolved with the swift reopening of the Bisie mine in Democratic Republic of Congo, the longer-term disruption at the Man Maw mine in Myanmar rumbles on. The Wa State authorities in control of the Man Maw mine have been negotiating new licenses to allow it to reopen after an absence of almost two years. But the cross-border flow of tin concentrates to China's smelters remains no more than a trickle. China's tin concentrate imports fell by 36.5% in the January-May period and the country's smelters are feeling the squeeze. Refined production was down 15% on a year-over-year basis in June, according to local data provider Shanghai Metal Market. Shanghai Futures Exchange stocks of tin have been creeping lower since the middle of April, while LME inventory has halved over the first half of the year. Tin is the only LME metal other than copper to be trading in sizeable backwardation, attesting to the underlying supply stress in this market. The aluminium market has been fractured by Trump's 50% import tariffs but the impact is being seen in the U.S. Midwest premium rather than arbitrage between the look-alike CME and LME futures contracts. U.S. consumers are now paying around $1,250 per ton over the LME price to get their metal. Premiums everywhere else are sinking, partly due to displaced metal flows and partly due to weak demand in Europe and parts of Asia. Most of the recent action on the London market has been a mega tug-of-war for available metal against a backdrop of falling exchange stocks. As ever with aluminium, it's hard to discern the signal from the noise. Although the LME three-month price has recovered from its April trough of $2,335 per ton to $2,600, the year-to-date gain stands at a modest 3%, failing to match analysts' high expectations at the start of 2025. LME nickel also closes out the first half of 2025 little changed from its January starting point. LME nickel stocks fell in May for the first time since March 2024, in a sign that the relentless build in inventory may be abating. For how long, though, remains to be seen. Nickel's electric dreams have faded as Chinese electric vehicle manufacturers switch to non-nickel battery chemistry. Indonesia, meanwhile, continues to ramp up production, generating more surplus metal. LME three-month nickel is trading just above the $15,000-per-ton level, which is close to the cost of making refined metal from Indonesian nickel pig iron, according to analysts at Macquarie Bank. However, while the downside may be limited at current price levels, any significant recovery is going to be dependent on whether Indonesia can restrain its booming nickel production sector. No-one's holding their breath. The lead market's close relationship with the automotive battery sector has cushioned the heavy metal from this year's tariff turbulence. The replacement battery sector follows its own cycle and lead is now entering one of its peak seasonal demand periods, when high northern hemisphere temperatures cause a spike in battery failures. LME lead is up 6% since the start of the year, closing the gap with sister metal zinc, which remains the persistent under-performer among the LME metals. World zinc mine production rose by a robust 5.1% on a year-over-year basis in January-April, according to the International Lead and Zinc Study Group. That supply surge is feeding through to higher refined production, particularly in China, and the Group assesses the global refined metal market registered a hefty 151,000-ton supply surplus in the period. Look no further to understand why the galvanising metal is so out of favour, down 6% since the start of 2025. The opinions expressed here are those of the author, a columnist for Reuters.
The Independent
23 minutes ago
- The Independent
Doing this can help reduce your car insurance by hundreds of pounds
A survey by consumer group Which? revealed that around six in 10 (59 per cent) of UK motorists successfully negotiated with their car insurer. Among those who haggled, 61 per cent secured a reduction on their renewal quote, with some savings exceeding £200 and an average annual saving of £64. While nearly half of drivers experienced premium increases at renewal, vulnerable customers faced greater difficulty in the haggling process, often needing to change policies for lower prices. Which? questioned the fairness of initial insurance offers, suggesting that many customers might be overpaying if they do not negotiate their renewal quotes. The Association of British Insurers attributed price variations to individual factors, while rules implemented in 2022 aim to ensure existing customers do not pay more than new ones for equivalent policies.
The Independent
23 minutes ago
- The Independent
Openreach expands full fibre broadband rollout to another 21 locations
Openreach has added a further 21 locations to its full fibre broadband rollout as part of a plan to connect up to five million more homes and businesses by next March, the company announced. The new locations cover around 80,000 rural and urban premises across the country including: Belmont, in Lancashire; Cheriton Bishop, in Devon; Didcot, in Oxfordshire; Innsworth, in Gloucestershire; Silverdale, in Lancashire; and Woburn Sands, in Buckinghamshire. The company is reaching an average of 85,000 new premises every week. Clive Selley, chief executive of Openreach said: 'This is a UK infrastructure success story, so it makes sense for us, and the country, to push hard on the accelerator pedal. 'Our new network is helping to drive economic growth, create jobs, and will be the backbone of a prosperous, globally connected and competitive UK. 'Last year was our biggest year of build ever – reaching well over four million homes with this life changing technology.'
