Robinson Superior Treaty annuities case heads back to court after settlement talks fail
Social Sharing
Negotiations to settle a longstanding case involving annuities owed to 12 First Nations along the shores of Lake Superior have broken down.
The Supreme Court of Canada had given the federal and Ontario governments until Jan. 26 to make offers in a case estimated to be worth billions of dollars.
The Anishnaabe Nations of Robinson Superior Treaty entered talks last month expecting a settlement offer in the dozens of billions – a lot more than the $3.6B offer Canada and Ontario made.
"They simply ignored the economic evidence about how much wealth Canada and Ontario took from our lands," said Gull Bay First Nation chief Wilfred King.
According to the Supreme Court of Canada, the failed negotiations mean it will now be up to the courts to decide fair compensation for the Crown having made a "mockery" of the treaty over the last 175 years.
The Robinson treaties promised the Anishinaabe that the annual payments they received from the Crown in exchange for the right to extract resources from their land would increase according to the wealth produced in the territory, but they've been capped at $4 per person per year since 1874.
Superior Court of Ontario Justice Patricia Hennessy will now rule on who should pay the Lake Superior Anishnaabe and how much.
Her ruling could eventually be appealed to another court, adding more years to the already decade-long legal battle.
Federal government says its offer was fair
Eric Head, spokesperson for Crown-Indigenous Relations and Northern Affairs Canada, says the federal government's offer was fair, just and honourable.
"We worked closely [and] in good faith with the First Nations and Ontario over the past six months to try to reach a negotiated agreement," he wrote.
"Unfortunately, the parties could not find the common ground to achieve this goal in the six-month timeline provided by the Supreme Court of Canada."
Head declined to say how much of the $3.6B offer would have come from federal coffers, saying details remain confidential at this time.
"Arriving at the compensation amount, Canada considered the factors set down by the Supreme Court of Canada, our past discussions with our treaty partners, all the facts in this case, and the evidence heard during the trial," he continued.
The other group of plaintiffs in this case, the 21 First Nations of Robinson Huron Treaty territory in northeastern Ontario, settled out-of-court for $10B before the last stage of the trial in 2023, with the provincial and federal governments each paying half.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CBC
5 hours ago
- CBC
Cultural caribou hunts to return to the Yukon for the first time in more than 30 years
First Nations and government leaders signed the Southern Lakes Caribou Relationship Plan on Wednesday. A key commitment in that plan is to bring back cultural caribou hunts. That's something that hasn't happened in more than 30 years.
Toronto Star
5 hours ago
- Toronto Star
Saskatchewan lays charges in wildfires while 1,000 more flee in Manitoba
Prairie wildfires developed on two fronts Friday, as 1,000 more Manitoba residents were forced to flee their homes and Saskatchewan RCMP charged two people with starting blazes. Saskatchewan Premier Scott Moe told a news conference that one charge relates to starting a fire near La Ronge, which has forced 7,000 people from the area. 'The RCMP have informed us that they have now charged a couple of individuals,' Moe said. ARTICLE CONTINUES BELOW An 18-year-old woman from Montreal Lake Cree Nation and a 36-year-old man from Pelican Narrows each face one count of arson, said RCMP. It's alleged the woman set the fire in a rural area near La Ronge. The man is accused of setting fires in a ditch near the turnoff to Snowden, northeast of Prince Albert. As of Friday, Saskatchewan had 24 active wildfires and Moe said between 10,000 and 15,000 people are out of their communities. 'Many if not virtually all of the fires that we're dealing with in Saskatchewan, although not intentionally, are human caused. Some of those have been intentionally human caused,' Moe said. Saskatchewan and Manitoba are both under a state of emergency, which makes it easier for different levels of government to co-ordinate a response. Manitoba has also received help from the military to evacuate residents, mainly in remote First Nations. ARTICLE CONTINUES BELOW ARTICLE CONTINUES BELOW Moe has faced calls from the Federation of Sovereign Indigenous Nations and the Opposition NDP to follow suit. 'Every available resource in Canada must be utilized to combat these wildfires,' FSIN Chief Bobby Cameron wrote in a letter to Moe. 'We cannot afford to let critical assistance go unused.' The premier said while his Saskatchewan Party government is in daily contact with federal officials, provincial emergency crews have so far been able to get evacuees out. Moe said the Canadian Red Cross was also working to set up shelters for evacuees in Regina, Saskatoon and Prince Albert. In Manitoba, the town of Snow Lake issued a mandatory evacuation order Friday due to a large wildfire threatening the area east of Flin Flon. 'You must leave because of the danger to your health and safety,' reads a notice on the town's Facebook page. ARTICLE CONTINUES BELOW ARTICLE CONTINUES BELOW That fire, which had grown to more than 3,000 square kilometres, has already forced out all 5,000 residents of the city of Flin Flon and about 1,000 more in surrounding homes and cottages. With Snow Lake evacuees added in, about 19,000 were out of their homes in Manitoba. About 27 fires were burning in the province, with eight classified as out of control. Earlier Friday, Manitoba Premier Wab Kinew said evacuees have found places to stay with friends or family, in hotels or in congregate shelters. Getting evacuees into private accommodations is tricky, he said, because many hotel rooms are being reserved for people with 'intense' medical issues. 'We just have to do a balancing act,' Kinew said. 'At this point, the big-picture challenge around rooms has largely been addressed. 'It's now just about the daily balancing act of triaging people coming in and people who are already in shelters and matching them up with rooms.' ARTICLE CONTINUES BELOW ARTICLE CONTINUES BELOW Shelters have been set up in Winnipeg, Thompson and Brandon. The City of Flin Flon said on social media that no structures have been lost in the community or across the boundary in nearby Creighton, Sask. 'Winds in the area are now blowing from the south, resulting in heavy smoke and fire moving towards the south side of Flin Flon,' it said. The city added that fire protection, including sprinklers, have been set up and firefighters are working to protect property. Provincial fire officials said evacuations have been completed at First Nations at Pukatawagan and Cross Lake. In northern Alberta, approximately 1,300 residents of the town of Swan Hills were allowed to return to their homes Thursday, about a week after fleeing from a wildfire. But about 340 kilometres west in the County of Grande Prairie, people in the Municipal District of Opportunity were ordered out. This report by The Canadian Press was first published June 6, 2025. — With files from Steve Lambert in Winnipeg
Globe and Mail
6 hours ago
- Globe and Mail
AFN calls emergency meeting to discuss Bill C-5
The Assembly of First Nations will hold an emergency meeting later this month to discuss federal legislation designed to speed up project approvals, amid concerns that the changes could infringe on Indigenous rights. The online meeting will take place on June 16 and all 634 chiefs are invited to participate, AFN National Chief Cindy Woodhouse Nepinak said in an interview. She said she spoke to Prime Minister Mark Carney on Thursday, adding that Parliament needs to ensure they have enough time to review it before it is passed. 'As I said to the prime minister, First Nations support efforts to protect Canada from economic uncertainty and advance resource-revenue sharing agreements,' she said. 'However, First Nations are very concerned that this proposal may violate many collective rights.' The AFN is now reviewing Bill C-5, which was tabled Friday, and will have a full response to it in the coming days, said Ms. Woodhouse Nepinak. Along with the emergency meeting, she said that the AFN national executive will also be meeting to discuss strategy, potential legal implications and next steps ahead of the organization's July general assembly. Bill C-5 would create a federal 'major projects office' that would identify projects 'of national interest' and put them on a list for priority treatment. It looks to speed up decision timelines while still ensuring environmental protections and commitments to Indigenous rights, according to the federal government. Nation-building projects are considered ones that, among other criteria, make a significant contribution to Canada's prosperity and advance the interests of Indigenous peoples, the government said in a statement. Projects would only get the designation following full consultation with affected Indigenous peoples, it added. New federal legislation would cut internal trade barriers, advance 'nation-building' projects The proposed office would include an Indigenous advisory council with First Nation, Inuit and Métis representatives, said the statement, and the government will allocate funding to strengthen Indigenous participation. Officials said the government sent letters to 66 Indigenous groups ahead of the bill's introduction to have a first discussion about its framework. 'Canada will uphold its constitutional obligations to consult Indigenous groups to ensure projects proceed in ways that respect and protect Indigenous rights,' the statement said. 'We are committed to working in a way that respects our commitments to the implementation of the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples Act and the principles of reconciliation, including economic reconciliation.' Earlier this week Justice Minister Sean Fraser said that First Nations do not get a 'veto' over infrastructure projects, but then apologized the next day, saying his comments eroded trust. Mr. Carney said that his government will do everything it can to have the bill passed before the summer break. If Parliament needs to sit longer to do so, it should, he said. Ms. Woodhouse Nepinak said it's important that Parliament take the time needed to make sure First Nations can properly review and propose amendments before it passes. It comes as many communities are also dealing with the wildfires, she said. 'We fear attempts to ram legislation through Parliament may have significant consequences,' she said, adding that rights are at stake and 'failure to obtain free, prior and informed consent will likely result in protracted litigation.' Ontario Regional Chief Abram Benedict, who heads the Chiefs of Ontario, called the federal government's move to introduce the bill 'disappointing' and 'unfortunate.' First Nations, environmental groups denounce passing of Bill 5 in Ontario He said Ottawa is well aware of the criticism of Ontario's recently passed Bill 5, which also seeks to speed up mining and resource development by creating 'special economic zones' where provincial laws can be suspended. That bill, which passed this week, has sparked significant backlash from Indigenous groups, who warned it could reignite a wave of 'Idle No More' Indigenous protests first launched in 2012. Mr. Benedict said in an interview that both the federal government and the province should have reached out to First Nations to draft the bills in conjunction with them, and that Ottawa's outreach to Indigenous communities beforehand was not sufficient. 'The government has to come forward to the table and have conversations with rights holders ahead of the legislation being implemented or even considered, so that they can best understand the concerns we have, and that we can come to some mutual understanding of what the legislation's intent is, and what is going to be possible and what's not,' he said. He said his group was copied on a letter to the national chief from the federal government that solicited feedback on the bill, but his view is that the bill needs to be drafted in conjunction with First Nations. He added that First Nations are considering legal options, advocacy and 'direct action,' including protests. With a file from Stephanie Levitz and Steven Chase
