Europe rights court condemns France over racial profiling
STRASBOURG: A top European court on Thursday condemned France for failing to protect the rights of a Frenchman who had accused his country's police of racial profiling.
The European Court of Human Rights was unable to determine discrimination in the case of five other French plaintiffs.
But it found that the government had provided no 'objective and reasonable justification' for police stopping Karim Touil three times in 10 days in the eastern city of Besancon in 2011.
The court said it was 'very aware of the difficulties for police officers to decide, very quickly and without necessarily having clear internal instructions, whether they are facing a threat to public order or security'.
But in the case of Touil, it presumed 'discriminatory treatment' that the French government was not able to refute.
It ordered the French state to pay him 3,000 euros ($3,500).
Human Rights Watch and Amnesty International last year said racial profiling was 'widespread throughout the country and deeply rooted in police practices'.
HRW said young men and boys perceived as black or Arab, some as young as 10, were often subjected to 'abusive and illegal identity checks'.
The rights groups said they had lodged a complaint with the UN Committee on the Elimination of Racial Discrimination.
France's rights ombudsman in 2017 found that a young person 'perceived as black or Arab' was 20 times more likely to face an identity check than the rest of the population.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Free Malaysia Today
5 hours ago
- Free Malaysia Today
Thai teen says he jumped out of window to escape Cambodian scam farms
Trafficked workers were forced to work from morning until midnight at the scam compounds. (AP pic) BANGKOK : Lured to Cambodia, tortured and forced to defraud strangers online, a Thai teenager said he barely survived after he threw himself from an eighth-floor window last year in a desperate bid to escape one of the Southeast Asian nation's prison-like scam compounds. The 18-year-old, who asked to be identified only by the nickname Louis, told Reuters he endured brutal conditions for about a year, alongside children as young as 13, in an operation run by Chinese criminals. Trafficked workers lived like 'slaves', he said, forced to work from early in the morning until midnight in buildings surrounded by high walls and barbed wire where they were subjected to brutal punishments and guarded by men with electric batons. The transnational scam industry emerged in Southeast Asia during the pandemic and is believed to generate billions of dollars a year for organised crime as people across the globe are defrauded of their life savings. Louis spoke to Reuters in the Thai capital of Bangkok, a day before London-based rights group Amnesty International published a report today accusing the Cambodian government of 'deliberately ignoring' human rights abuses by cybercrime gangs, allegations the Cambodian government rejected, saying the report was 'exaggerated'. Reuters was unable to independently verify Louis' account but details matched other accounts by trafficking survivors published by numerous groups including United Nations agencies. While Louis declined to share his full name, he was willing to be interviewed by Reuters TV. A highly paid job A softly-spoken teenager, Louis said he was 17 when a woman contacted him on Facebook offering him a well-paid role, meals and accommodation after he posted that he was looking for work. She persuaded him to travel to Bangkok – the first time he had left his rural home province – but he was then told to go to the border where he was taken to one of at least 53 scam compounds in Cambodia identified by Amnesty. Louis was put to work using deepfake video software to dupe Thai women into sending money. He said he 'felt pressured' and after a week he was sold to another compound near the Vietnamese border that looked 'like a prison'. Escape In a room with eight Thai men and women, Louis said they were ordered to scam at least 1 million baht a month (about US$30,000) and shocked with electric batons if they were late, rested too much, or failed to meet the quotas. Louis said he decided to escape after he was confined to a dark room. Breaking through a window, he crashed down several storeys and smashed his chin. 'My mouth filled with blood, it was everywhere, and my teeth were broken. Then I passed out,' he said. The bosses stripped him naked, but took him to hospital. From there he managed to get home. Louis said he wanted to tell Thai people looking for work not to go to Cambodia. 'It's for your own safety… You might never come back.'
The Sun
9 hours ago
- The Sun
Spain PM calls Gaza situation ‘genocide' as death toll rises
GAZA CITY: Spanish Prime Minister Pedro Sanchez has described the ongoing conflict in Gaza as a 'genocide,' marking the strongest condemnation yet by a European leader. The statement comes as rescuers report 65 people killed by Israeli forces in the territory on Thursday. Sanchez urged the European Union to suspend its cooperation agreement with Israel, citing a recent EU report indicating potential breaches of human rights obligations. 'Gaza is in a catastrophic situation of genocide,' he said ahead of an EU summit in Brussels. Israel swiftly rejected the accusation, with its Madrid embassy accusing Sanchez of 'demonising' the country and stating Spain was 'on the wrong side of history.' The Spanish government deemed the embassy's response 'unacceptable' and summoned its charge d'affaires. The conflict, now in its 20th month, has left Gaza's two million residents facing severe shortages of food and medical supplies. Despite Israel easing its blockade in late May, aid distribution remains chaotic, with frequent reports of Israeli forces firing on civilians awaiting rations. Mohammad Al-Mughair, Gaza's civil defence agency medical supplies director, confirmed 65 deaths on Thursday. The Israeli military stated its troops fired 'warning shots' near the Netzarim corridor to deter approaching suspects. Since October 2023, Israel's military campaign has claimed at least 56,259 lives, mostly civilians, according to Gaza's Hamas-run health ministry. The UN considers these figures reliable. Residents describe dire conditions. 'My children have nothing to eat. I haven't had flour for nearly two months,' said Imad al-Attar from Khan Yunis. Another resident, Khaled Rashwan, lamented, 'We are dying, and no one is paying attention to us.' The US has approved $30 million in funding for the Gaza Humanitarian Foundation (GHF), a controversial aid group operating in the territory. The UN has criticised the 'weaponisation of food' in Gaza, while the WHO delivered its first medical shipment since March, calling it 'a drop in the ocean.' Efforts for a ceasefire continue, with Qatar announcing renewed mediation attempts. US President Donald Trump hinted at progress, while Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu faces mounting pressure to end the war.
The Star
9 hours ago
- The Star
No known intelligence that Iran moved uranium, US defense chief says
WASHINGTON (Reuters) -U.S. Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth on Thursday said he was unaware of any intelligence suggesting Iran had moved any of its highly enriched uranium to shield it from U.S. strikes, amid continuing questions about the state of Iran's nuclear program. U.S. military bombers carried out strikes against three Iranian nuclear facilities early Sunday local time using more than a dozen 30,000-pound bunker-buster bombs. The results of the strikes are being closely watched to see how far they may have set back Iran's nuclear program, after President Donald Trump said it had been obliterated. "I'm not aware of any intelligence that I've reviewed that says things were not where they were supposed to be, moved or otherwise," Hegseth told an often fiery news conference. Trump, who watched Hegseth's exchange with reporters, echoed his defense secretary, saying it would have taken too long to remove anything. "The cars and small trucks at the site were those of concrete workers trying to cover up the top of the shafts. Nothing was taken out of (the) facility," Trump wrote on his social media platform, without providing evidence. Several experts have cautioned that Iran likely moved a stockpile of near weapons-grade highly enriched uranium out of the deeply buried Fordow site before the strikes, and could be hiding it in unknown locations. They noted satellite imagery from Maxar Technologies showing "unusual activity" at Fordow on Thursday and Friday, with a long line of vehicles waiting outside an entrance to the facility. A senior Iranian source told Reuters on Sunday most of the 60% highly enriched uranium had been moved to an undisclosed location before the attack. WHEREABOUTS OF URANIUM The Financial Times, citing European intelligence assessments, reported that Iran's highly enriched uranium stockpile remains largely intact since it was not concentrated at Fordow. Hegseth's comments denying such claims came at the news briefing where he also accused journalists of downplaying the success of the strikes following a leaked preliminary assessment from the Defense Intelligence Agency suggesting they may have only set back Iran by months. He said the assessment was low confidence, and, citing comments from CIA Director John Ratcliffe, had been overtaken by intelligence showing Iran's nuclear program was severely damaged and would take years to rebuild. U.S. senators briefed later on Thursday by Ratcliffe, Hegseth, Secretary of State Marco Rubio and General Dan Caine, chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, said it was clear the strikes had damaged Iran's nuclear facilities, though it would take time to assess by how much. "I will say it was not part of the mission to destroy all their enriched uranium or to seize it or anything else," Republican Intelligence Committee Chairman Tom Cotton of Arkansas told reporters after the classified briefing, adding that he was confident the mission was "extraordinary." Senator Mark Warner of Virginia, the top Intelligence Committee Democrat, said the only way to be certain about Iran's nuclear capabilities was to have inspectors on the ground. "It was clear, and again, this is long before this brief, that some of the enriched uranium was never going to be taken out by a bunker-buster bomb, so some of that obviously remains," Warner said. Tulsi Gabbard, who normally would conduct such briefings as director of national intelligence, did not participate. Trump said last week that she was wrong in suggesting there was no evidence Iran was building a nuclear weapon. The four officials were due to brief the House of Representatives on Friday. Senators are expected to vote this week on a resolution that would require congressional approval for strikes against Iran, which is not expected to be enacted. At the Pentagon news conference, Hegseth described the strikes as "historically successful." His comments came after Iranian Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei said Iran would respond to any future U.S. attack by striking American military bases in the Middle East. Khamenei claimed victory after 12 days of war, and promised Iran would not surrender despite Trump's calls. MEDIA 'HATRED' During the news conference, Hegseth criticized the media, without evidence, for having an anti-Trump bias. "It's in your DNA and in your blood to cheer against Trump because you want him not to be successful so bad," Hegseth said. "There are so many aspects of what our brave men and women did that ... because of the hatred of this press corps, are undermined," he said. Trump praised Hegseth's news conference as: "One of the greatest, most professional, and most 'confirming' News Conferences I have ever seen!" On X, Hegseth thanked Trump for his praise. During the press conference, Caine, the top U.S. general, largely stuck to technical details, showing a video testing the bombs on a bunker like the ones struck on Sunday. Caine declined to provide his own assessment of the strike, deferring to the intelligence community. He denied being under pressure to present a more optimistic view of the U.S. strikes and said he would not change his assessment due to politics. Uniformed military officials are supposed to remain apolitical. "I've never been pressured by the president or the secretary to do anything other than tell them exactly what I'm thinking, and that's exactly what I've done," Caine said. (Reporting by Idrees Ali, Phil Stewart and Patricia Zengerle; Additional reporting by Susan Heavey; Editing by Chizu Nomiyama, Daniel Wallis and Michael Learmonth)
