Kerala backs off from enacting black magic law, cites policy decision in High Court
The Left government in Kerala has told the High Court that it will not proceed to enact a law to ban black magic, sorcery, and other inhuman practices, citing a policy decision made by the State Cabinet.
In an affidavit filed before a Division Bench of Kerala High Court, headed by Chief Justice Nitin Jamdar, Kerala said a draft bill titled 'The Kerala Prevention and Eradication of Inhuman Evil Practices, Sorcery and Black Magic Bill, 2022' had been prepared based on recommendations from the Law Reforms Commission.
However, after deliberations, the Council of Ministers decided on July 5, 2023, not to go ahead with the legislation, it said.
The government submitted that while the court may have noted the social concerns raised in the PIL, it cannot compel the legislature to pass a law.
"A writ of mandamus will not lie against the legislature directing it to legislate on a particular subject," the affidavit said.
Meanwhile, the High Court asked the State government to clarify the steps it intends to take to control sorcery and black magic, especially in light of the government's stand that no legislation is currently under consideration.
The court noted that although the K.T. Thomas Commission report had recommended legislation to curb black magic and related inhuman practices, the government had not taken any follow-up action on the report.
The court has now asked the State to clearly explain how it plans to prevent the practice of black magic and sorcery, even in the absence of a law.
It also directed the government to file a detailed affidavit within three weeks.
The Kerala Home department had filed the affidavit on June 21, 2025, stating that the Council of Ministers had initially discussed the matter but later decided not to proceed with legislation.
The court had earlier asked the State to clarify its position after a public interest litigation (PIL) filed by the Kerala Yukthivadi Sangham sought a law similar to those enacted in Maharashtra and Karnataka to prohibit harmful rituals conducted in the name of supernatural powers.
The PIL, first filed in 2022, was dismissed in June 2023 due to the absence of representation from the petitioner. It was later restored, prompting the High Court to seek the government's latest stance.
The Yuktivadi Sangham, in its plea, has stated that the Law Reforms Commission, headed by Justice (retired) K.T. Thomas, had submitted a comprehensive report to the State of Kerala in the year 2019, with legislative recommendations based on new social conditions.
"The Kerala Prevention and Eradication of Inhuman Evil Practices, Sorcery and Black Magic Bill-2019, is one of the recommended statutes. But so far, no attempt has been made on the part of the state on the matter," the organisation has claimed.
The plea was filed in 2022 in the wake of a ritual human sacrifice of two women in the Pathanamthitta district of Kerala by three people, including a couple.
The petition has claimed that the states of Kerala and Maharashtra have passed laws against sorcery and black magic.
It has also sought a declaration that "films on big screens and OTT platforms, and several serials and other telefilms, aired on television channels and YouTube, having content of superstitious beliefs, including sorcery and occult practices, exempting those having good intentions and having good artistic values, are illegal".
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Indian Express
3 hours ago
- Indian Express
Reading the Emergency: 50 years on
Fifty years ago, on June 25, 1975, India was plunged into its darkest democratic crisis, the Emergency. Declared by then-Prime Minister Indira Gandhi, it suspended civil liberties, censored the press, and saw mass arrests of opposition leaders. The 21-month period remains a defining chapter in India's political history, raising urgent questions about power, authoritarianism, and resistance. To mark its 50th anniversary, we recommend seven books that capture the Emergency's complexities: from firsthand accounts and political analyses to literary retellings. These works illuminate not just the past but also its echoes in contemporary India. A former IAS officer and close associate of Jayaprakash Narayan (JP), Devasahayam offers a searing critique of the Emergency and draws parallels with India's current political climate. As the custodian of JP during his imprisonment, the author provides rare insights into the resistance movement. The book interrogates who truly safeguards democracy: politicians, institutions, or citizens? Devasahayam's personal narrative, combined with political analysis, makes this a compelling read for those examining the fragility of democratic norms. A gripping memoir by veteran journalist Coomi Kapoor, this book recounts the terror of the Emergency through her family's ordeal. Her husband was jailed under draconian laws, her brother-in-law (Subramanian Swamy) went underground, and she faced constant surveillance. Kapoor's vivid storytelling exposes the human cost of authoritarianism: forced sterilizations, slum demolitions, and press censorship. A must-read for its raw, personal perspective on the darkest chapter in Indian democracy. Raghavan's meticulously researched biography examines Indira Gandhi's premiership, with a significant focus on the Emergency. Rather than reducing her to a dictator, he contextualises her decisions within India's turbulent 1970s: economic crises, political instability, and her centralisation of power. The book challenges simplistic narratives, offering a nuanced portrait of one of India's most polarising leaders. Veteran journalist Kuldip Nayar, a fierce critic of the Emergency, compiles a detailed chronicle of the events leading to its imposition. Drawing from interviews and reportage, he highlights JP's anti-corruption movement, Indira Gandhi's electoral malpractice, and the crackdown on dissent. Nayar's work remains vital for understanding the media's role, and its suppression, during the crisis. This academic yet accessible study dissects the structural underpinnings of the Emergency. Jaffrelot and Pratinav explore Sanjay Gandhi's unchecked power, the complicity of bureaucrats and business elites, and the surprising regional variations in repression (South India faced fewer excesses). A rigorous analysis of how authoritarianism takes root in democracies. It is a blow-by-blow account of the 1975 case Indira Gandhi v Raj Narain in which the High Court, for the first time in the history of independent India, set aside the election of a Prime Minister. Using court documents, Bhushan etches a tapestry of the backdoor dealings and abuses of legislative power that allowed Gandhi to impose and maintain a state of Emergency. Though a novel, Mistry's Booker-shortlisted masterpiece captures the Emergency's human toll like no nonfiction account can. Through the lives of tailors, students, and beggars, he portrays state brutality, forced sterilizations, and the resilience of ordinary people. A haunting, deeply moving work of fiction that makes history visceral.
Time of India
4 hours ago
- Time of India
Outline steps planned to tackle inhuman practices like black magic, Kerala HC directs state govt
Kochi: High court on Tuesday directed the state govt to file a detailed affidavit outlining the steps it proposes to take against inhuman practices such as black magic. The bench of Chief Justice Nitin Jamadar and Justice Basant Balaji issued the direction in light of an affidavit submitted by home department deputy secretary, which stated that the council of ministers, on July 5, 2023, had decided not to proceed with the Kerala Prevention and Eradication of Inhuman Evil Practices, Sorcery, and Black Magic Bill, 2019. The affidavit further stated that this was a policy decision of the state govt and may not be interfered with by the court. The state made this submission in response to a petition filed by the Kerala Yukthivadhi Sangham, seeking the enforcement of legislation to prohibit black magic, witchcraft, sorcery, and other inhumane practices carried out under the guise of supernatural powers. Upon perusing the affidavit, the division bench orally asked whether the state govt was endorsing such evil practices. While the court agreed with the state's submission that it cannot be compelled to enact legislation on a particular subject, it expressed dissatisfaction with the affidavit, noting that it failed to clarify whether the state had endorsed such practices or had chosen not to eradicate them. You Can Also Check: Kochi AQI | Weather in Kochi | Bank Holidays in Kochi | Public Holidays in Kochi The court further observed that, though it had expected a detailed affidavit, the one submitted merely asserted that no direction could be issued to enact a law. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like 5 Stocks for Monthly Dividends Seeking Alpha Read Now Undo Accordingly, the court directed the state to file a comprehensive affidavit detailing its stand on the issue and the steps it proposes to take in the matter. The petition was adjourned to July 15. The petition was filed in 2022 following the twin human sacrifice incident in Pathanamthitta. Subsequently, in April 2024, three individuals — Naveen Thomas and his wife Devi Madhavan, both natives of Kottayam, and their friend Arya Nair from Thiruvananthapuram — were found dead with cut marks on their wrists. It was suspected that they had taken their own lives while engaging in black magic rituals.
The Hindu
5 hours ago
- The Hindu
Kerala HC directs Home Secretary to file affidavit on steps to curb black magic, sorcery
With the State government stating before the Kerala High Court that it was not enacting a legislation to curb black magic, the court on Tuesday asked whether it endorsed the practice of black magic and sorcery. It directed the Home Secretary to file an affidavit in this regard, in a public interest litigation filed by the Kerala Yukthi Vadhi Sangam, an organisation spearheading campaigns against black magic, witchcraft, and sorcery and other social evils. It sought a court directive in the nature of recommendation, suggestion, judicial advice or a reminder call to the government and other respondents, pointing out the urgent need to enact a statute like the ones passed in Maharashtra (the Maharashtra Prevention and Eradication of Human Sacrifice and Other Inhuman, Evil and Agori Practices and Black Magic Act, 2013) and in Karnataka to curb such practices. In an affidavit, the Deputy Secretary in the Home Department said the government had proposed a Bill – The Kerala Prevention and Eradication of Inhuman Evil Practices, Sorcery and Black Magic Bill, 2022 — based on a report of the Law Reforms Commission. But after deliberations, the Council of Ministers decided on July 2023 not to proceed with the Bill. It was a policy decision of the government and was hence beyond court intervention. To this, the court said there was no absolute bar on court interference in the issue, although the court could not direct the readying of a legislation in this regard. The court sought details of the action that the government intended to take in order to curb such vices in society. While posting the case for hearing on July 15, the court said the Home Secretary ought to clearly state in an affidavit within three weeks the curbs that the government intended to place on such vices.
