logo
Can Hawaiiʻs child welfare system be fixed?

Can Hawaiiʻs child welfare system be fixed?

Yahoo08-04-2025

Attorney Laurie Tochiki joins producer/host Coralie Chun Matayoshi to discuss the Malama 'Ohana Working Group's recommendations to the Legislature to improve the child welfare system, and how we can and must do a better job in supporting families and preventing child abuse and deaths.
Laurie Tochiki is an attorney, mediator, consultant, and principal of Pilina Pathways. She previously served as Executive Director of Epic Ohana (a non-profit organization serving families in the child welfare system) and Associate Dean for Student Services at the William S. Richardson School of Law. She currently serves as Vice-Chair of the University of Hawaii Board of Regents and Co-Chaired the Mālama 'Ohana Working Group, established by the legislature in 2023 to recommend improvements to the child welfare system.
In the last fiscal year (July 1, 2023, through June 30, 2024), five Hawaii children including Ariel Kalua, Geanna Gradley, Sarai Perez and Azaeliyah Pili-Ah You have tragically died due to abuse and neglect at the hands of their parents, relatives or legal guardians. All but one were known to the Child Welfare Services (CWS).
Q. First, what is Child Welfare Service and when do they get involved?
The 'child welfare system' is broad and ill-defined. Child Welfare Services (CWS) is an agency, not a system. In Hawaii, CWS is the branch of the Department of Human Services (DHS) responsible for the protection, care, and permanency of abused and neglected children. The broader child welfare system includes CWS, family courts, the Department of the Attorney General, law enforcement officers, and nonprofit service providers. It intersects with the education system, criminal justice system, healthcare systems, crisis response systems, and many other systems. In all our community meetings and working group meetings, we emphasized that our hope is for shared kuleana in the child welfare system for our families and children. In this report, 'child welfare system' refers to the broader system, while 'CWS' refers to the state agency. Malama 'Ohana Working Group Report, December 2024.
These are all such sad situations, and it is the responsibility of all of us to keep children safe. Government and the Family Court steps in to protect children when the actions of parents are deemed to be unsafe. CWS is a branch of the DHS with offices on every island. Government becomes involved when there is harm or threat of harm either because of abuse or neglect – most cases that CWS handles are neglect rather than abuse.
Q. How does CWS find out about problems?
Hotline: (808) 832-5300
There is a mandatory reporting requirement for teachers, doctors, military, etc. and failure to report can result in criminal liability
Anyone who is concerned about something they see should make a report. For those who are not mandatory reporters, reports can be made confidentially.
If the report requires an investigation, then an investigator will go out to the home to investigate.
Q. What if a child is harmed or in imminent danger of being harmed? Can they be removed from their home?
Hawaii Revised Statutes Section 587A – children are removed when children are harmed or are in danger of imminent harm. Police will remove or assist CWS with the removal. If CWS is doing an investigation without the police there, the parent does not have to let the investigator in, but if they don't cooperate and CWS is concerned about the safety of the children then they can call the police, and the police have the right to remove without notice or a court order.
No prior notice is required because police are using their police power at that point.
Most are neglect cases but there are cases of physical, sexual or psychological harm.
Most cases involve substance use disorder, domestic violence and/or mental health issues. Poverty is also a factor that makes families unstable.
Children should not be removed if the only problem is that the family is houseless but securing a safe and stable place for the children is a factor in reunification.
Q. What did the Malama 'Ohana Working Group recommend to the Legislature?
Transforming Hawaii's child welfare system requires deep, systemic change across three levels:
• Commitment, values, and mindset: The foundations of our work
• Policies, laws, and resources: The fundamental structures that govern our system
• Practice and relationships: How we work with and support families and system partners
This transformation must rest on three foundational elements:
A system grounded in traditional Hawaiian values
A trauma-informed and culturally responsive approach
Excellent workforce, sustainable funding and modern data systems
Recommendation 1: Address Historical Trauma and Persistent Disproportionality
System Critique: State and social services systems, particularly those involving CWS, lack adequate awareness of historical contributors to current situations and appropriate trauma informed responses to both historical and present trauma.
Full Recommendation: Acknowledge and address historical and present conditions and barriers that perpetuate the overrepresentation of Native Hawaiian and Pacific Island people in categories of need or distress.
Path Forward:
• Ground child welfare work in the values and culture of Hawaii.
• Incorporate traditional Hawaiian practices into the system.
• Support collaborative innovation with the Office of Hawaiian Affairs and Native Hawaiian and Pacific Islander organizations.
• Provide comprehensive cultural competency training.
• Improve outcomes for all families through culturally responsive approaches.
Recommendation 2: Build Family Resilience
System Critique: Hawaii has a shortage of resources dedicated to prevention, especially primary prevention and universal supports. Many struggling individuals are unaware of available services or how to access them.
Full Recommendation: Prioritize thriving families above all other commitments by providing universal family supports aimed at ensuring a stable foundation and opportunities for growth.
Path Forward:
• Shift our mindset and value to prioritize 'mandatory supporting.'
• Create accessible pathways to concrete supports like food and shelter.
• Establish community-based resource centers (Ka Piko) staffed by individuals with lived experience.
• Meet families' basic needs for housing, childcare, and physical and mental healthcare.
• Expand Family First Hawaii services.
Recommendation 3: Provide Comprehensive Specialized Support Services
System Critique: Seeking help for substance use disorders, mental health issues, domestic violence, and even basic supports feels too risky due to mistrust of systems and fear of CWS involvement. The process of accessing these services is often overly complicated.
Full Recommendation: Provide accessible, trauma-responsive, specialized supports and interventions outside the child welfare system for parents facing intense challenges.
Path Forward:
• Create accessible pathways to services that minimize the risk of family separation when parents are facing challenges or crises such as: severe poverty, substance use disorders, domestic violence, serious mental and physical health conditions.
• Enhance CWS workers' abilities to properly understand and address these issues and support families with a trauma-responsive and culturally informed approach.
Recommendation 4: Develop a Trauma-Informed System
System Critique: Families involved with CWS find it challenging to navigate the complicated system and related services. The experience often feels adversarial, confusing, secretive, and isolating for both children and parents, causing further trauma.
Full Recommendation: When CWS intervenes in a family, ensure that the intervention is respectful and supportive, minimizes trauma, and does not create more harm than the original issue they hoped to address.
Path Forward:
• Create a comprehensive trauma-informed culture throughout CWS.
• Build expertise in trauma-informed care and cultural competence throughout the child welfare system from front-line staff to top leaders, including in CWS, courts, and service providers.
• Transform policies and procedures to prioritize family support and communications.
• Address secondary trauma among helping professionals.
Recommendation 5: Build Excellence Through Accountability
System Critique: The child welfare system and related systems are not user-friendly for staff or families, lack sufficient accountability measures, and suffer from fragmentation and isolation between different components.
Full Recommendation: Ensure that systems, services, processes, and procedures are coordinated, accountable, and efficient with robust oversight, adequate funding, appropriate staffing, and high operational standards.
Path Forward:
• Improve core CWS processes, staffing, training, supervision, data systems, and technology.
• Ensure a commitment to excellence from the legislature, the Governor and Lt. Governor, and the DHS Director.
• Prioritize supporting the child welfare system through the Departments of the Attorney General, Accounting and General Services, and Human Resources Development office.
• Maximize state and federal resources and eliminate waste.
• Establish independent oversight mechanisms, such as an independent ombudsperson, Child Advocate, or grievance office.
• Create robust advocacy systems for children, parents, and families.
Q. What bills recommended by the Working Group are still alive at the Legislature?
There were more than 15 bills introduced relating to various aspects of the Malama Ohana report. Bills ranged from training for domestic violence and trauma informed care, a pilot project to test some of the ideas for community based prevention and community collaboration, the definition of child abuse and neglect, and a bill that would work to develop a program where children in child welfare cases would have an attorney representing them. A few bills await either final committee, or possible conference committee decisions. Eliminating poverty from the definition of abuse and neglect was scheduled for a final committee hearing on April 3. The pilot project was passed by the finance committee and will not head to conference. Trauma informed care training is still working through the legislature with a decision from the Senate Ways & Means Committee. We are grateful for the support of Representative Lisa Marten and Senator San Buenaventura. The Legislature is very concerned about the negative effect of federal executive orders on child welfare funding. Senator San Buenaventura has scheduled another information briefing on the issues on April 9.
The working group is not able to address the legislature because sunshine law prohibits members of the group from discussing the issues outside public meetings, and the group itself completed its work when the report was published. Therefore, co-chair Venus Rosete Medeiros and I, as well as other individual members of the working group, and community members who were very active in the working group process, have been testifying as individuals.
Q. Could the 5 recent child abuse deaths have been prevented? Most of these children were known to CWS and some had come through the foster system. Weren't there red flags that should have been prioritized for intervention?
Ariel Kalua (6 years old) – was in foster care then got adopted by foster parents who are accused of starving and abusing her. Known to CWS.
Geanna Bradley (10 years old) – foster parents and grandmother accused of starving and physically abusing her. Known to CWS.
Azaeliyah Pili-Ah You (11 years old) – was in foster care then got adopted by foster parents, mother accused of beating her and father is under investigation. Known to CWS.
Sarai Perez-Rivera (3 years old) – biological mother and her girlfriend accused of starving and beating her. Grandmother reported suspected abuse to CWS.
3 year old boy- no prior reports to CWS.
To some extent, tragedies like these might be avoided with a child welfare services agency that is well trained, adequately staffed, and where accountability processes are in place. Many of our recommendations address the culture of CWS, and the imperative need for training, staffing and accountability. For instance, there are requirements for regular face-to-face visits with children and resource caregivers. But if staff members are so stretched that they have to address crisis after crisis, they cannot keep up. Our report suggests that solutions need to address root causes of the many concerns raised. There are no simple solutions. There are many administrative barriers for nonprofit organizations working with CWS as well including contract delays, late payments, and contracts that do not cover the cost of the work performed. There are some bills that are still alive in the Legislature to address this, as supported by a coalition of nonprofit organizations called the True Cost Coalition. And we do not have a good process for addressing grievances and concerns. So, the heart breaking stories of family members who begged for help but did not receive it are not adequately addressed. We also do not have a good process for death reviews. But even with these interventions, there will still be situations we do not address in time, people who disappear from the safety net of school, medical care, or community.
The tragedy of those deaths at the hands of who were entrusted with the children after CWS involvement does put a light on many places where CWS practice needs improvement. But I want to end this segment with an emphasis that our community meetings and interviews and conversations included many stories of individual heroes. Social workers who go above and beyond and continue to work in excruciatingly difficult situations. Foster parents who year after year open their hearts and homes to children and become loving forever family. Birth parents, grandparents, aunties and uncles who keep showing up and are doing the best they can to protect their children. So much more could be done with prevention. Families want help and they need specialized services. It is our kuleana that all children in Hawaii can be safe and healthy.
Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

A DHS Official Tried To Pick A Fight With Kim Kardashian After She Spoke Out Against ICE
A DHS Official Tried To Pick A Fight With Kim Kardashian After She Spoke Out Against ICE

Yahoo

time38 minutes ago

  • Yahoo

A DHS Official Tried To Pick A Fight With Kim Kardashian After She Spoke Out Against ICE

One Department of Homeland Security official seems to think she can throw down with a woman raised by Kris Jenner. On Wednesday, Tricia McLaughlin, the DHS assistant secretary for public affairs, decided to pick a fight with Kim Kardashian after the reality TV star simply exercised her freedom of speech. Amid the ongoing anti-deportation protests in Los Angeles that were sparked by a rash of terrifying U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement raids, Kardashian made it clear on her Instagram story Tuesday that her values align with the demonstrators. 'When we're told that ICE exists to keep our country safe and remove violent criminals — great,' Kardashian began her statement. 'When we witness innocent, hardworking people being ripped from their families in inhumane ways, we have to speak up. We have to do what's right.' She continued, 'Growing up in LA, I've seen how deeply immigrants are woven into the fabric of this city. They are our neighbors, friends, classmates, coworkers, and family.' 'No matter where you fall politically, it's clear that our communities thrive because of the contributions of immigrants,' she wrote. The beauty mogul concluded, 'We can't turn a blind eye when fear and injustice keep people from living their lives freely and safely. There HAS to be a BETTER way.' Related: Here's Why People Are Raising Their Eyebrows Over Chris Pratt's Post About The Fatal Shooting Of His 'Parks And Recreation' Costar Jonathan Joss When Kardashian's statement made its way to X, formerly Twitter, Wednesday, it seemed to really get McLaughlin's Skims in a twist. '.@KimKardashian, which one of these convicted child molesters, murderers, drug traffickers and rapists would you like to stay in the county? These are just a few of the convicted illegal criminals who have been picked up in the last 72 hours,' McLaughlin wrote on X, alongside images of a few men who have been detained by ICE in Los Angeles, per some very colorfully worded DHS press releases that include quotes from McLaughlin. Although McLaughlin didn't like Kardashian's statement, plenty of social media users did. Related: 21 Times Celebrities Revealed Wildly Juicy, Shady, Or Even Disturbing Things In Interviews Kardashian, who graduated from law school in May, has an interesting history with the Trump family. In 2018, she met with President Donald Trump during his first term to advocate for prison reform, and later claimed she helped soften his stance on crime (which, apparently, did not work). In 2023, the president's eldest daughter, Ivanka Trump, was pictured at Kardashian's birthday party, upsetting many of Kardashian's fans. The American Horror Story alum also seemed celebratory on Trump's inauguration day in January, posting a caption-less photo of first lady Melania Trump's outfit to her Instagram story that same day. This article originally appeared on HuffPost. Also in Celebrity: Chrissy Teigen Posted The Results Of Her Hairline Lowering Surgery, And Ouch Also in Celebrity: 18 Celebrities Who Called Out Other Celebs On Social Media For Bad, Problematic, Or Just Plain Mean Behavior Also in Celebrity: Here Are 16 Actors Who Saved Their Skin By Turning Down Roles In Movies That People Notoriously Hated

Federal judge sides with anti-Israel ringleader Mahmoud Khalil, halts Trump administration's deportation bid
Federal judge sides with anti-Israel ringleader Mahmoud Khalil, halts Trump administration's deportation bid

Fox News

timean hour ago

  • Fox News

Federal judge sides with anti-Israel ringleader Mahmoud Khalil, halts Trump administration's deportation bid

A federal judge sided with Mahmoud Khalil, an anti-Israel ringleader detained by the Trump administration, blocking the government from continuing to hold him on "foreign policy" grounds. U.S. District Judge Michael Farbiarz granted Wednesday a preliminary injunction preventing the government from detaining or removing Khalil, 30, based on a memorandum issued by Secretary of State Marco Rubio. The memo asserted that Khalil's presence "compromises a compelling foreign policy interest." "The government cannot claim an interest in enforcing what appears to be an unconstitutional law," Farbiarz wrote, adding that the threat to free speech raised serious First Amendment concerns. The ruling is a significant legal setback for the administration's efforts to deport Khalil, who has been held at a detention facility in Louisiana following his involvement in anti-Israel demonstrations at Columbia University. While the ruling grants a preliminary injunction against Khalil's removal, it stops short of ordering his release. The court's decision will remain on hold until Friday morning, giving the government time to appeal. READ THE RULING – APP USERS, CLICK HERE Khalil, a green card holder, was arrested after leading student protests on the Ivy League campus. He has argued that his free speech rights were being "eroded" by the Trump administration. Department of Homeland Security (DHS) attorneys have argued that Khalil's free speech claims were a "red herring," saying that the 30-year-old green card holder lied on his visa applications. Khalil, they said, willfully failed to disclose his employment with the Syrian office in the British Embassy in Beirut when he applied for permanent U.S. residency. The agency also accused Khalil of failing to disclose his work with the United Nations Relief and Works Agency for Palestine Refugees and membership in Columbia University Apartheid Divest. Rubio has cited a provision in the Immigration and Nationality Act of 1952 to justify Khalil's removal from the U.S. The provision allows the secretary of state to deport noncitizens if the secretary determines their presence in the U.S. "would have serious adverse foreign policy consequences." Rubio accused Khalil of participating in "antisemitic protests and disruptive activities, which foster a hostile environment for Jewish students in the United States." "Condoning antisemitic conduct and disruptive protests in the United States would severely undermine that significant foreign policy objective," Rubio wrote. Khalil has Algerian citizenship through his mother, but was born in a Palestinian refugee camp in Syria. As of Wednesday evening, no further hearings are scheduled in Khalil's immigration case. "We're just waiting for the judge to issue her ruling," Johnny Sinodis, a partner at Van Der Hout LLP who is representing Mahmoud Khalil in immigration proceedings, said during a press conference following the hearing. Meanwhile, the federal court's preliminary injunction will prevent Khalil's removal until at least June 13.

ICE ramps up arrests of convicted criminals as riots rage in blue city: 'You will not stop us'
ICE ramps up arrests of convicted criminals as riots rage in blue city: 'You will not stop us'

Yahoo

time2 hours ago

  • Yahoo

ICE ramps up arrests of convicted criminals as riots rage in blue city: 'You will not stop us'

The Department of Homeland Security (DHS) announced that several convicted criminals who are in the U.S. illegally were arrested as part of Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) operations in Los Angeles on Monday and Tuesday. The ICE operations in Los Angeles triggered protests and riots in parts of the city, and President Donald Trump deployed National Guard troops to protect the federal immigration officers while they continued arrests. "Murderers, pedophiles, and drug traffickers. These are the types of criminal illegal aliens that rioters are fighting to protect. How much longer will Governor Newsom and Mayor Karen Bass continue to prioritize these criminal illegal aliens over their own citizens?" Assistant Secretary Tricia McLaughlin said in a statement on Wednesday. California Sheriff Says Newsom 'Encouraged' La Riots As Ice Arrests Violent Illegal Aliens "Secretary Noem has a message to the LA rioters: you will not stop us or slow us down. ICE will continue to enforce the law and arrest criminal illegal aliens," McLaughlin added. DHS highlighted nine arrests — all of whom the agency says are in the country illegally. Read On The Fox News App Mexican national Gerardo Antonio-Palacios had been deported before but was previously convicted of burglary and homicide. Cambodian national Mab Khleb, 53, was convicted of transporting and possession of a controlled substance, battery, and "lewd action with a child," according to DHS. Laotian Sang Louangprasert was criminally convicted of "lewd or lascivious acts with a child under 14" and "inflicting corporal injury, spouse or cohabitant." Dozens Of Anti-ice Rioters Arrested In La As Trump Sends In National Guard To Quell Violence Mexican national Antonio Benitez-Ugarte was convicted on drug trafficking charges, and Alberto Morales-Mejia, also from Mexico, was convicted for amphetamine production. Click Here For More Immigration Coverage Honduran national Carlos Alberto Escobar-Flores was also arrested, and he was previously convicted of grand theft. Another Honduran national, Jose Jimenez-Alvarado, was also arrested after a prior conviction of "two counts of theft." Mexican national Jesus Romero-Retana, 52, had prior convictions of "threatening crime with intent to terrorize and battery." Another Mexican national, Raul Teran-Guillen, was previously arrested for "human smuggling and money laundering" before his ICE arrest this week. Ice Arrests 'Worst Of The Worst' Illegal Aliens In Los Angeles While Protesters Advocate For Criminals: Dhs The Trump administration has a goal of 3,000 ICE arrests daily in hopes of fulfilling the campaign trail promise of mass deportations following millions of people being let in during the Biden administration. The ICE efforts have received scrutiny from Democrats in California and nationwide, and saying that Trump's decision to deploy the guard and conduct ICE sweeps is instigating. "Donald Trump's government isn't protecting our communities. They're traumatizing our communities," Gov. Gavin Newsom said in a brief address on Tuesday night. "Angelenos are trying to live their lives—going to work, caring for their families—while facing the constant threat of sudden immigration crackdowns," Los Angeles Mayor Karen Bass posted to X on Wednesday morning. "This fear paralyzes communities. We saw it before: kids too scared to go to school, families torn apart without warning. Let's not pretend this is about public safety. It's political retribution—plain and simple." Fox News Digital reached out to the offices of Newsom and Bass for comment, but they did not immediately article source: ICE ramps up arrests of convicted criminals as riots rage in blue city: 'You will not stop us'

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store