
‘I hope one of your family members dies': when artists bite back at their critics
In 1973, the theatre critic John Simon wrote a negative review of a performance by Sylvia Miles, mocking the actress as 'one of New York's leading party girls and gate-crashers'. Unfortunately for Simon, he happened to be dining in the same restaurant as Miles soon afterwards. On seeing him, she dumped her plate of steak tartare and brie over his head. 'Now you can call me a plate-crasher, too,' she said.
Childish? Funny? A fair response to an overly harsh personal comment rendered in print for the world to see? Or maybe… all of those things? Sure, nobody likes being criticised. But, for artists and performers, it generally comes with the job. The question is how, and whether, to respond.
I've spent more than a decade as a journalist writing about arts and culture, most recently as this newspaper's radio critic. I've also written about the unique power dynamics between performers and critics in Bring the House Down, my debut novel about a theatre critic who experiences a sensational comeuppance from an actress at the Edinburgh Fringe who decides to give him a taste of his own medicine. The events of the novel and its characters are pure fiction, but gut-churning human responses to personal criticism are a fact of life.
There have been plenty of times when I've reviewed a show in a way that the person behind it has hated. Sometimes, they've let me know about it. I've had comedians cheerfully mock me, my family and my personal life on stage for months and even years after I've reviewed them. I've received long, anguished emails from TV presenters calling me 'disappointingly shallow' after I'd said their documentaries were opaque and navel-gazing.
To some extent – and somewhat paradoxically – receiving criticism is an inevitable part of being a critic. But sometimes, a negative critical response can drive creative people into the realm of irrational fury.
For instance, both Robbie Collin and Tim Robey, this newspaper's film critics, have experienced their share of vicious bite-back over the years. After writing a few less-than-positive reviews of films released by a major film studio in the US, Collin learned from a friend that he was being referred to by marketing executives over there as 'that British c---'. Robey, on the other hand, once so annoyed Harry Enfield by questioning the artistic merit of Kevin & Perry Go Large (2000) that he received a stiff letter from Enfield himself angrily defending the film.
The theatre critic Kate Wyver gave one production three stars out of a possible five, which most critics would agree is a positive review. The production team, however, didn't see it that way. When the show began touring shortly afterwards, the performers handed out badges to the audience emblazoned with the slogan: 'Don't be like Kate Wyver.'
Some responses are more extreme. When The Guardian's Phil Daoust gave Tim Minchin a one-star review, the comedian responded on stage with a freshly minted composition called The Song for Phil Daoust, in which he called Daoust a 'poo-face' who 'should quit and get a job that you'd be better at / Like killing yourself', continuing with 'I hope one of your family members dies'. Daoust took exception to the cruelty of that last line, but overall his response was philosophical: 'I slagged him off in the platform I had access to, and he did the same to me. What's sauce for the goose, etc. And he took the trouble to spell my name correctly, which was nice.'
That's a more generous response than that given by the French critic Stéphane Capron last year after Angélica Liddell, the Spanish theatre-maker, called him a 'bastard' and demanded that he 'face [his] own vileness' on stage at the Avignon performing arts festival, before exposing her bare behind to the crowd. Capron sued her for defamation.
Sometimes, critic-performer spats become a drawn-out war of words, such as the famous feud between Vincent Gallo and the film critic Roger Ebert. Ebert negatively reviewed Gallo's explicit film The Brown Bunny at Cannes in 2003, singling it out as 'the worst film in the history of the festival'. In response, Gallo called Ebert 'a fat pig' and said he had put a curse on Ebert's colon. 'I am not too worried,' Ebert responded in print. 'I had a colonoscopy once, and they let me watch it on TV. It was more entertaining than The Brown Bunny.'
It's understandable that artists, who put great stores of effort and energy into their work, are hurt by such critical reviews, even though most would also concede that if every single review was a five-star rave, they would lose all value. Bad reviews can cripple the fortunes of a piece of creative work. Just look at the film Cats (2019), which essentially sparked a contest among the critics to see who could write the most devastating review. It was 'an all-time disaster', according to The Telegraph's Robey in his zero-star drubbing. The New York Post's Johnny Oleksinski begged someone to 'please wipe this movie from my Memory', while The Boston Globe's Ty Burr reported that 'My eyes are burning. Oh God, my eyes'. NPR's headline was, simply, 'Spay it'. The film bombed at the box office.
Or take Elton John 's stage musical Tammy Faye, which the New York Post called 'god-awful' and 'a disaster of biblical proportions', and which closed on Broadway last year just five days after opening. Or Andrew Lloyd Webber's Bad Cinderella, the Broadway run of which was cut short in 2023 after a review in The New York Times that began with the line: 'First: bring earplugs', before going on to add 'for that matter, bring eye plugs'.
Negative criticism doesn't always spell doom, however. The Great Gatsby, on publication in 1925, famously met a lukewarm initial response, and, well, look how that turned out. The original stage production of Phoebe Waller-Bridge's Fleabag at the Edinburgh Fringe, likewise, had an unenthusiastic early reception, but still went on to become an international television mega-hit.
Would any of those works' fortunes, good or bad, have been improved by their creators lashing out at the critical naysayers? Or would it just have made things worse?
And how far is too far? The Stranglers are said to have once gaffer-taped the French rock magazine editor Philippe Manoeuvre to the Eiffel Tower, with bassist Jean-Jacques Burnel describing him as 'an annoying little oik'. In 2023, the ballet director Marco Goecke was suspended from his post at Hanover State Opera after he smeared dog excrement in the face of critic Wiebke Hüster, in retaliation for a review in which she described his work as boring. The police got involved with that one. And the journalist Bernard Levin once reportedly feared for his life when he found himself on a railway platform with the late playwright John Osborne, who famously hated critics, and threatened to push Levin under an oncoming train.
Emotions and tempers can run high in the arts and in journalism, but it's hard to argue that this means cultural criticism shouldn't exist at all. The alternative is a world in which only adoring quotes from anonymous social media users adorn theatre, film and comedy posters. And would that tell us anything useful?
It's never enjoyable to receive a bad review, nor is it nice for a critic to feel that they've suddenly become a target. Perhaps the relationship between performance and criticism was healthier in Ancient Greece, where writers largely lampooned one another through their actual plays, with the critical conversation playing out on stage as part of the entertainment. A modern equivalent might be the German film director Uwe Boll's approach, which involved challenging each of his five fiercest critics to face him in the boxing ring in 2006. In a filmed event dubbed 'Raging Boll', Boll won all five matches. In a press conference afterwards, he said 'I now like the critics... Everybody who was in the ring showed guts.'
Surely nobody should be throwing actual punches at all – but maybe artists aren't the only ones who suffer for art. Maybe straddling the line between honesty and cruelty is the hardest job a critic has to undertake, and maybe accepting criticism with grace is, likewise, the hardest part of any artist's work. But, when both of them achieve it, we all benefit from a rich cultural conversation.
Still, there's a good reason that the word 'theatre' is applied to war zones and surgical operating rooms as well as to performance spaces: it's an easy place to draw blood.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


The Sun
10 minutes ago
- The Sun
YouTuber Finny Da Legend named as Las Vegas shooting victim killed on livestream after 2 shot dead near Bellagio casino
A YOUTUBER has been named as a victim in a Las Vegas shooting that saw two people killed. Finny Da Legend was shot dead near the famous Bellagio hotel and casino on the Las Vegas strip on Sunday night. 2 2 Another victim, believed to be Finny's partner, was also killed in the shooting, as reported by the Fox affiliate KVVU-TV. Finny, who had more than 3,000 subscribers on YouTube, was live streaming when a man, another content creator, came up to him. At least seven shots were fired in footage shared online. Finny's partner could be heard screaming after the shots, yelling, "Are you f**king kidding me?" before the camera was thrown to the ground. Tributes have been paid to the content creator. Devastated pal Derek Ware described Finny as a "good father" and a "friendly guy." "If something was wrong, he would just always check up on me," he told KVVU-TV. "He's donated to people that needed help online." Ware revealed Finny's partner was known as Bubbly and paid tribute to her "infectious" personality. "She would have fun everywhere she went," he said. Cops revealed that the shooter and one of the victims had an argument on social media before the horror unfolded. Manuel Ruiz, 41, turned himself into police hours after shots were fired on the Las Vegas Strip. "At this point, we believe we have the suspect identified and that this is an isolated incident, knowing that the suspect and the victim had previously engaged in some type of conflict using a variety of social media platforms," cops said at the time. The Bellagio is a luxury five-star resort on the Strip and is known for the famous Fountains of Bellagio attraction. The shooting comes almost eight years after 60 people were killed when Stephen Paddock opened fire at a music festival on the Las Vegas Strip. He fired more than 1,000 rounds from his room on the 32nd floor of the Mandalay Bay hotel. More than 800 people were injured.


BBC News
15 minutes ago
- BBC News
From festivals to weddings: Why drone shows are booming
The wedding ceremony was almost over when newlywed Bobby Underwood stepped on a napkin-covered glass to break it, as is Jewish tradition, and everyone shouted "Mazel Tov!". But as he and his new wife Siobhan turned to walk back down the aisle, their wedding officiants said, "Wait." There was a surprise. "All of these drones started rising up," recalls Mrs Underwood. "It was honestly remarkable, very overwhelming – and incredibly emotional for us." She estimates that between 100 and 150 drones appeared in the night sky, displaying lights of various colours, and forming images chosen to represent the bride and groom. These included a baseball player hitting a ball – as Mr Underwood is a big baseball fan – and a diamond ring being placed on a finger. The couple were married on New Year's Eve 2024, in New York State. Mrs Underwood's mother had arranged the surprise drone show with help from the couple's wedding planner – who had suggested it as a "wow factor" component of the day. It seemed to have the desired effect. "It was kind of just shock – 'Is this really happening right now?'," says Mrs Underwood. "I can't believe my mom did this for us." Chris J Evans Drone shows are becoming ever more popular. Once rarities, they are now appearing at occasions ranging from birthday parties and weddings, to major sporting events. Some theme parks even have resident drone shows that take place multiple nights in a row. Glastonbury music festival had its first drone show in 2024. And record-breaking displays are pushing the technology to its limits – the biggest drone show in history took place in China last October. It featured a total of 10,200 drones and broke a record set only the previous month. So, does all this spell the end for fireworks? "They are really beautiful – they are art," says Sally French, a US-based drone industry commentator known as The Drone Girl. She says that drone shows have appeared at baseball games, corporate conferences, and even at ports, to celebrate the launch of cruises. Drone displays are becoming highly sophisticated, she explains, with some drone shows featuring thousands of flying devices, allowing them to animate figures or patterns in incredible detail. "I saw a Star Wars-themed drone show where there was a full-on lightsabre battle," adds Ms French. One barrier might be the price tag, however, with the cost per drone at around $300 (£220) in the UK, says Ms French, citing industry data from market research firm SPH Engineering: "A 500 drone show would be over $150,000." Mrs Underwood does not have an exact figure, but estimates that her wedding drone show cost tens of thousands of dollars. The sky's the limit, actually. Skymagic, one of the world's largest drone show companies, has put on major displays that cost north of $1m says Patrick O'Mahony, co-founder and creative director. Skymagic's shows have taken place in various countries – including the 2023 Coachella music festival in California. The company has also performed drone shows in the UK, including as part of the King's Coronation concert, which was broadcast by the BBC. Mr O'Mahony has experience in designing fireworks displays and other, similar events. But drones have revolutionised outdoor public displays, he says. His company has a fleet of 6,000 custom-designed drones. Each one can reach speeds of up to 10 meters per second. The drones sport LED lights and have batteries that allow for 25 minutes of flight time. To make them easier to transport, the drones are stored in flight cases and unpacked at venues in a giant marquee before they are laid out in the take-off area, half a metre apart, in a grid pattern. "Once the drones have received their 'go' command [they] fly the entire show," adds Mr O'Mahony, explaining that a single human pilot on the ground controls thousands of the devices at once. The drones are geo-fenced, based on Global Positioning System (GPS) data, which prevents them from straying beyond the allotted flight area. In windy conditions, though, they can get blown off course. In such cases, they automatically return to a landing spot on the ground, says Mr O'Mahony. Fireworks have a "boom" factor that drones generally don't, notes Ms French. However, Bill Ray, an analyst at market research firm Gartner, says that some drones can now launch pyrotechnics, for a firework-like effect. For instance, a stream of sparks raining down from the lower portion of an image created by a group of drones. Plus, Mr Ray says it is much easier to accurately synchronise drone movements with music during a show, which could be another reason behind their appeal. But the cost of shows remains prohibitive to some, and in part comes down to the fact that laying out the devices and gathering them all up again after the performance is still a relatively slow, manual process, adds Mr Ray. Pedro Rosário is chief executive of Drone Show Animations, a company that designs drone show performances for other companies that supply the drones themselves. Mr Rosário says that one challenging aspect of his work is in coming up with displays that adhere to various regulations applying to drone flights, since these rules differ from country to country. England has stricter regulations than countries in the Middle East, for example, he says. Mr Rosário adds that drone shows, which might be paired with pyrotechnics, traditional fireworks or even lasers, allow for a huge degree of creative freedom: "You can really build something that has emotional value, it can tell a story." In Mrs Underwood's case, that seems to have worked. Her guests enjoyed the spectacle too, she adds: "We've heard compliments about our wedding in general – but, consistently, the drone show is something people bring up as something they never expected to see."


The Sun
25 minutes ago
- The Sun
Country star Conner Smith, 24, ‘struck & killed elderly woman, 77, as she was crossing road'
COUNTRY star Conner Smith allegedly struck and killed an elderly woman as she was crossing the road. The artist was driving his Chevrolet Silverado truck when the accident happened in Nashville on Sunday night. 2 The victim has been identified as Dorothy Dobbins, 77. He has been accused of not giving way to her while she was crossing the road, according to cops in Nashville. He has not yet been charged with any crime. "On June 8th, Mr. Smith was involved in a car accident that tragically claimed a life," his lawyer told TMZ. "His heart goes out to Ms. Dobbins' family during this incredibly difficult time. "Mr. Smith continues to cooperate fully with the ongoing investigation." Sources told TMZ he was not distracted by his phone. They also revealed he was not under the influence. Smith is signed to Big Machine Records - the label that was founded in 2005. Big Machine Records was bought by Scooter Braun's firm, Ithaca Holdings, in 2019. Big Machine Records is Taylor Swift's former record label and Scooter bought it in a deal worth $300 million. Smith rose to prominence when he released the track I Hate Alabama, which surged on TikTok. It was that particular track that helped him secure the deal with Big Machine Records. In 2023, he released the song Creek Will Rise, which reached 89 in the US music charts. It reached number 12 in the US Country Airplay charts, which are released weekly by Billboard. He was nominated in the New Male Artist of the Year category ahead of last year's ACM Awards. The accident happened just weeks after he released his song Country in the Clouds. Smith is yet to comment on the accident. On Monday, he shared pictures of himself on stage in front of his fans in Nashville. "Hometown hits different," he captioned the social media post. 2 More to follow... For the latest news on this story, keep checking back at The U.S. Sun, your go-to destination for the best celebrity news, sports news, real-life stories, jaw-dropping pictures, and must-see videos.