logo
‘I hope one of your family members dies': when artists bite back at their critics

‘I hope one of your family members dies': when artists bite back at their critics

Telegraph24-05-2025

In 1973, the theatre critic John Simon wrote a negative review of a performance by Sylvia Miles, mocking the actress as 'one of New York's leading party girls and gate-crashers'. Unfortunately for Simon, he happened to be dining in the same restaurant as Miles soon afterwards. On seeing him, she dumped her plate of steak tartare and brie over his head. 'Now you can call me a plate-crasher, too,' she said.
Childish? Funny? A fair response to an overly harsh personal comment rendered in print for the world to see? Or maybe… all of those things? Sure, nobody likes being criticised. But, for artists and performers, it generally comes with the job. The question is how, and whether, to respond.
I've spent more than a decade as a journalist writing about arts and culture, most recently as this newspaper's radio critic. I've also written about the unique power dynamics between performers and critics in Bring the House Down, my debut novel about a theatre critic who experiences a sensational comeuppance from an actress at the Edinburgh Fringe who decides to give him a taste of his own medicine. The events of the novel and its characters are pure fiction, but gut-churning human responses to personal criticism are a fact of life.
There have been plenty of times when I've reviewed a show in a way that the person behind it has hated. Sometimes, they've let me know about it. I've had comedians cheerfully mock me, my family and my personal life on stage for months and even years after I've reviewed them. I've received long, anguished emails from TV presenters calling me 'disappointingly shallow' after I'd said their documentaries were opaque and navel-gazing.
To some extent – and somewhat paradoxically – receiving criticism is an inevitable part of being a critic. But sometimes, a negative critical response can drive creative people into the realm of irrational fury.
For instance, both Robbie Collin and Tim Robey, this newspaper's film critics, have experienced their share of vicious bite-back over the years. After writing a few less-than-positive reviews of films released by a major film studio in the US, Collin learned from a friend that he was being referred to by marketing executives over there as 'that British c---'. Robey, on the other hand, once so annoyed Harry Enfield by questioning the artistic merit of Kevin & Perry Go Large (2000) that he received a stiff letter from Enfield himself angrily defending the film.
The theatre critic Kate Wyver gave one production three stars out of a possible five, which most critics would agree is a positive review. The production team, however, didn't see it that way. When the show began touring shortly afterwards, the performers handed out badges to the audience emblazoned with the slogan: 'Don't be like Kate Wyver.'
Some responses are more extreme. When The Guardian's Phil Daoust gave Tim Minchin a one-star review, the comedian responded on stage with a freshly minted composition called The Song for Phil Daoust, in which he called Daoust a 'poo-face' who 'should quit and get a job that you'd be better at / Like killing yourself', continuing with 'I hope one of your family members dies'. Daoust took exception to the cruelty of that last line, but overall his response was philosophical: 'I slagged him off in the platform I had access to, and he did the same to me. What's sauce for the goose, etc. And he took the trouble to spell my name correctly, which was nice.'
That's a more generous response than that given by the French critic Stéphane Capron last year after Angélica Liddell, the Spanish theatre-maker, called him a 'bastard' and demanded that he 'face [his] own vileness' on stage at the Avignon performing arts festival, before exposing her bare behind to the crowd. Capron sued her for defamation.
Sometimes, critic-performer spats become a drawn-out war of words, such as the famous feud between Vincent Gallo and the film critic Roger Ebert. Ebert negatively reviewed Gallo's explicit film The Brown Bunny at Cannes in 2003, singling it out as 'the worst film in the history of the festival'. In response, Gallo called Ebert 'a fat pig' and said he had put a curse on Ebert's colon. 'I am not too worried,' Ebert responded in print. 'I had a colonoscopy once, and they let me watch it on TV. It was more entertaining than The Brown Bunny.'
It's understandable that artists, who put great stores of effort and energy into their work, are hurt by such critical reviews, even though most would also concede that if every single review was a five-star rave, they would lose all value. Bad reviews can cripple the fortunes of a piece of creative work. Just look at the film Cats (2019), which essentially sparked a contest among the critics to see who could write the most devastating review. It was 'an all-time disaster', according to The Telegraph's Robey in his zero-star drubbing. The New York Post's Johnny Oleksinski begged someone to 'please wipe this movie from my Memory', while The Boston Globe's Ty Burr reported that 'My eyes are burning. Oh God, my eyes'. NPR's headline was, simply, 'Spay it'. The film bombed at the box office.
Or take Elton John 's stage musical Tammy Faye, which the New York Post called 'god-awful' and 'a disaster of biblical proportions', and which closed on Broadway last year just five days after opening. Or Andrew Lloyd Webber's Bad Cinderella, the Broadway run of which was cut short in 2023 after a review in The New York Times that began with the line: 'First: bring earplugs', before going on to add 'for that matter, bring eye plugs'.
Negative criticism doesn't always spell doom, however. The Great Gatsby, on publication in 1925, famously met a lukewarm initial response, and, well, look how that turned out. The original stage production of Phoebe Waller-Bridge's Fleabag at the Edinburgh Fringe, likewise, had an unenthusiastic early reception, but still went on to become an international television mega-hit.
Would any of those works' fortunes, good or bad, have been improved by their creators lashing out at the critical naysayers? Or would it just have made things worse?
And how far is too far? The Stranglers are said to have once gaffer-taped the French rock magazine editor Philippe Manoeuvre to the Eiffel Tower, with bassist Jean-Jacques Burnel describing him as 'an annoying little oik'. In 2023, the ballet director Marco Goecke was suspended from his post at Hanover State Opera after he smeared dog excrement in the face of critic Wiebke Hüster, in retaliation for a review in which she described his work as boring. The police got involved with that one. And the journalist Bernard Levin once reportedly feared for his life when he found himself on a railway platform with the late playwright John Osborne, who famously hated critics, and threatened to push Levin under an oncoming train.
Emotions and tempers can run high in the arts and in journalism, but it's hard to argue that this means cultural criticism shouldn't exist at all. The alternative is a world in which only adoring quotes from anonymous social media users adorn theatre, film and comedy posters. And would that tell us anything useful?
It's never enjoyable to receive a bad review, nor is it nice for a critic to feel that they've suddenly become a target. Perhaps the relationship between performance and criticism was healthier in Ancient Greece, where writers largely lampooned one another through their actual plays, with the critical conversation playing out on stage as part of the entertainment. A modern equivalent might be the German film director Uwe Boll's approach, which involved challenging each of his five fiercest critics to face him in the boxing ring in 2006. In a filmed event dubbed 'Raging Boll', Boll won all five matches. In a press conference afterwards, he said 'I now like the critics... Everybody who was in the ring showed guts.'
Surely nobody should be throwing actual punches at all – but maybe artists aren't the only ones who suffer for art. Maybe straddling the line between honesty and cruelty is the hardest job a critic has to undertake, and maybe accepting criticism with grace is, likewise, the hardest part of any artist's work. But, when both of them achieve it, we all benefit from a rich cultural conversation.
Still, there's a good reason that the word 'theatre' is applied to war zones and surgical operating rooms as well as to performance spaces: it's an easy place to draw blood.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Nicole Scherzinger and Sarah Snook win top prizes at Tony Awards
Nicole Scherzinger and Sarah Snook win top prizes at Tony Awards

BBC News

timean hour ago

  • BBC News

Nicole Scherzinger and Sarah Snook win top prizes at Tony Awards

Succession star Sarah Snook and former Pussycat Doll Nicole Scherzinger were among the big winners at Sunday's Tony was named best actress in a musical for her role in Sunset Boulevard, Jamie Lloyd's minimalist reboot of Andrew Lloyd Webber's musical. In an emotional acceptance speech, Scherzinger reflected on her recent Broadway success, which came two decades after shooting to fame with the Pussycat Dolls. "Growing up, I always felt like I didn't belong, but you all have made me feel like I belong and I have come home, at last," she said. "If there's anyone out there who feels like they don't belong or your time hasn't come, don't give up." "Just keep on giving and giving because the world needs your love and your light now more than ever. This is a testament that love always wins."The singer and former X Factor judge won the same prize at the UK equivalent of the Tonys, the Olivier Awards, for her performance in the show's original West End also performed As If We Never Said Goodbye during the ceremony, and was introduced by Glenn Close, who played Desmond in Sunset Boulevard when it played on Broadway in Tony Awards, hosted by Wicked star Cynthia Erivo at Radio City Music Hall in New York, celebrate the best in US theatre, and particularly Broadway. Snook won best leading actress in a play, for performing all 26 roles in a one-woman stage adaptation of Oscar Wilde's novel The Picture of Dorian her acceptance speech, the actress said: "This means so much for a little Australian girl to be here on Broadway."[The Picture of Dorian Gray] is billed as a one-person show, and I don't feel alone any night that I do this show. There are so many people on stage making it work and behind the stage making it work."Other winners included Maybe Happy Ending, which took home best musical, while Purpose was named best Boulevard also won best musical revival, while Eureka Day won best revival of a play. Tony Awards: The main winners Best musicalWINNER: Maybe Happy EndingBuena Vista Social ClubDead OutlawDeath Becomes HerOperation Mincemeat: A New MusicalBest playWINNER: PurposeEnglishThe Hills of CaliforniaJohn Proctor is the VillainOh, Mary!Best revival of a playWINNER: Eureka DayRomeo + JulietOur TownYellow FaceBest revival of a musicalWINNER: Sunset BoulevardFloyd CollinsGypsyPirates! The Penzance MusicalBest actress in a musicalWINNER: Nicole Scherzinger, Sunset BoulevardMegan Hilty, Death Becomes HerAudra McDonald, GypsyJasmine Amy Rogers, BOOP! The MusicalJennifer Simard, Death Becomes HerBest actor in a musicalWINNER: Darren Criss, Maybe Happy EndingAndrew Durand, Dead OutlawTom Francis, Sunset BoulevardJonathan Groff, Just in TimeJames Monroe Iglehart, A Wonderful World: The Louis Armstrong MusicalJeremy Jordan, Floyd CollinsBest actress in a playWINNER: Sarah Snook, The Picture of Dorian GrayLaura Donnelly, The Hills of CaliforniaMia Farrow, The RoommateLaTanya Richardson Jackson, PurposeSadie Sink, John Proctor is the VillainBest actor in a playWINNER: Cole Escola, Oh, Mary!George Clooney, Good Night, and Good LuckJon Michael Hill, PurposeDaniel Dae Kim, Yellow FaceHarry Lennix, PurposeLouis McCartney, Stranger Things: The First ShadowBest direction of a musicalWINNER: Michael Arden, Maybe Happy EndingSaheem Ali, Buena Vista Social ClubDavid Cromer, Dead OutlawChristopher Gattelli, Death Becomes HerJamie Lloyd, Sunset BoulevardBest direction of a playKnud Adams, EnglishSam Mendes, The Hills of CaliforniaSam Pinkleton, Oh, Mary!Danya Taymor, John Proctor is the VillainKip Williams, The Picture of Dorian Gray Further updates to this story to follow.

Want to see some big American trucks drag race? Course you do
Want to see some big American trucks drag race? Course you do

Top Gear

timean hour ago

  • Top Gear

Want to see some big American trucks drag race? Course you do

Advertisement Video Meet the man who bought a track just to drag race semi trucks. Yup, really 10 minutes 27 seconds Top Gear's tuning correspondent Rob Dahm heads to northern Michigan to meet Mike Sturgill, a lifelong trucker who got a taste for drag racing semi trucks and decided to buy a track and bring it to the masses... Advertisement - Page continues below You might like Advertisement - Page continues below Thank you for subscribing to our newsletter. Look out for your regular round-up of news, reviews and offers in your inbox. Get all the latest news, reviews and exclusives, direct to your inbox.

Jared Leto accused of sexual misconduct by MULTIPLE women... and several were allegedly minors
Jared Leto accused of sexual misconduct by MULTIPLE women... and several were allegedly minors

Daily Mail​

timean hour ago

  • Daily Mail​

Jared Leto accused of sexual misconduct by MULTIPLE women... and several were allegedly minors

Jared Leto is facing allegations from nine women of inappropriate behavior, including with teenage girls. The frontman of 30 Seconds to Mars and star of films including House Of Gucci and Suicide Squad, 53, is alleged to have inflicted the behavior on them over the course of nearly two decades, and the accusations involve women who say they were teenagers at the time of the alleged incidents. According to an exposé published by Air Mail, the claims, which have apparently circulated in Hollywood for years, have now been brought into the open, with one woman stating to the outlet: 'It's been an open secret for a long time.' Reps for Leto haven't yet responded to request for comment, but a representative denied all of the women's claims in a statement to Air Mail. The accusations came to light after Los Angeles–based DJ Allie Teilz, 30, re-shared a 2012 Facebook post on her Instagram Stories, in which she alleged Leto — who was previously called out by other Hollywood stars for being 'full of himself' — assaulted her when she was 17. 'You're not really in LA until Jared Leto tries to force himself on you backstage… in a kilt… And a snow hat,' she claimed. 'I was assaulted and traumatized by this creep when I was 17.' The accusations in a story by Air Mail include allegations of sexual assault, while others claim Leto made unwanted sexual advances at them, even after he allegedly knew they were underage; pictured in September 2024 in Paris She further alleged that Leto 'knew' her age but 'didn't care,' describing his actions as 'predatory, terrifying and unacceptable.' A second woman, whose name was not revealed, told the publication that Leto approached her in 2006 when she was 16 at Urth Caffé in Los Angeles. At the time, he was allegedly visiting the popular cafe with Ashley Olsen, whom he had been rumored to be in a relationship with at the time. 'I looked down and it was Jared Leto. We had a quick conversation, and he got my number,' she claimed. The woman alleged that he called her days later, adding: 'I don't know if he was on drugs or what… it was the weirdest, grossest voice… [but] for me, it's Jared, you know?' The woman alleged their late-night conversations 'turned sexual,' and she claimed that Leto asked questions including, 'Have you ever had a boyfriend?' and 'Have you ever sucked a d***?' Model Laura La Rue, 33, also alleged that she met Leto in 2008, when she was 16 and he was 36, at a Yes! on Prop Two animal rights benefit. 'He asked how old I was,' she alleged. 'I said, "I'm 16. How old are you?"' La Rue claimed to Air Mail that Leto still asked for her number despite knowing her age, and she said he later invited her to his Los Angeles home, where he was 'flirting' and 'teasing [her] the whole time [she] was there.' She even alleged that Leto walked into a room she was in while completely naked at one point, as if 'it was normal.' 'I thought maybe this was just what adult men do,' La Rue added. Leto's representative denied all of the women's accounts in a statement to Air Mail: 'Their communications contain nothing sexual or inappropriate and Ms. La Rue later applied to work as Mr. Leto's personal assistant, further underscoring the absence of anything inappropriate in any of their interactions.' But La Rue denied applying for such a role. Sources quoted in the article described parties at Leto's Los Angeles home and said they had a ratio of 60 'very young women to four or five men,' and they claimed that guests were encouraged to go skinny dipping at the events. Jared's publicist stated that the actor 'has not had a drink or used drugs in over 35 years.' A fourth woman who went nameless claimed she met Leto at an 18-plus club when she was 20. However, it was his assistant who allegedly approached her to ask for her phone number. She said they 'hook[ed] up a little' while still at the club, and she alleged that she subsequently spent time at his home on multiple occasions, but she described Leto as being 'weird.' 'I know some people are kinky, and that's fine,' she said, before adding that 'his kind of kink ... just didn't feel right.' Another unnamed accuser said she began a flirtatious back-and-forth over text messages with Leto when she was still a minor. During her alleged visits to his home, he would ask her sexual questions, including, 'Do any of the little boys you hang out with f*** you?' She said their relationship escalated after she turned 18, and Leto allegedly 'pulled his penis out and started masturbating' during a subsequent visit to his home. She claimed that the Blade Runner 2049 actor put her hand on his penis and told her, 'I want you to spit on it.' In 2016, Leto was reported to have sent his Suicide Squad costars used condoms as a gift that might have been sent by his character in the film, the Joker. But Leto subsequently denied that part of the report in a 2017 SiriusXM interview. 'There were some things that were mentioned about gifts and the fact that I was giving used condoms to people, which was not true. It was not true,' he said. However, the actor did admit to sending them gifts that were 'funny,' 'absurd or outrageous.' In a 2016 interview with E! Online, his costar Adewale Akinnuoye-Agbaje, who played Killer Croc, said that Leto had sent him 'sticky Playboy magazines' as part of his character's gift, and he also allegedly sent the entire cast a 'dead pig.' 'That was a good gift because it had the effect of unifying us as a group because then it became us against him,' Akinnuoye-Agbaje said. 'We sent the messenger back with the dead pig and our own personalized message. It got the ball rolling.'

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store