Oxford judge dismisses £48k credit hire claim over £7k car
A judge has rejected a £48,000 credit hire claim after a car worth £7,000 was written off in a crash.David Wiltshire, 79, from Grove, Oxfordshire, was given a temporary replacement vehicle through his car insurance on 9 May 2023.However, District Judge Richard Lumb dismissed the claim against the culpable motorist's insurers because of procedural mistakes.Raising the question of reforming the credit hire industry, he told Oxford County Court people might be surprised by the amount claimed, given the car's value.
Credit car hire is a service where a replacement vehicle is provided on credit to a non-fault driver, with the costs claimed from the at-fault driver's insurer.In his written ruling, Judge Lumb said: "The benefit to the credit hire company is that they can charge, often significantly, enhanced rates for providing the credit service and this has become an extremely lucrative and by and large slick business."The case arose after a car reversed from a driveway into Mr Wiltshire's Citroen Picasso in Tenby, Pembrokeshire.He was given a Kia Sportage as a temporary replacement by credit hire firm On Hire Ltd, the court heard.
'Staggering costs'
His insurers, acting through Winn Solicitors, which owns On Hire, tried to reclaim hire charges of £48,000 from the other driver.However, a suitable replacement vehicle could have been hired for three weeks for £1,200, the court heard.Mr Wiltshire only signed a credit agreement a month after the accident, the judge heard.He awarded £1,200 to Mr Wiltshire's insurers, dismissing the rest of the claim due to "mistakes made by the claims handlers and fee earners".The judge added: "Many people... may also question why the courts have not intervened in this industry which, given the figures involved paid out by the insurers of the culpable motorists, must surely have an impact on rising motor insurance premiums. "Only new legislation by parliament could alter the position. Whether that will happen remains to be seen."In another recent case, the judge condemned "staggering" credit hire costs and said the insurance industry appeared to be unwilling to campaign for reform.The Department for Transport, the Association of British Insurers and Winn Solicitors have been approached for comment.The Credit Hire Organisation, which represents the industry, previously said the costs of credit hire only had a "minimal" effect on the average motoring insurance premium.
You can follow BBC Oxfordshire on Facebook, X (Twitter), or Instagram.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
3 hours ago
- Daily Mail
EXCLUSIVE US billionaire dubbed 'the most powerful man on Wall Street' denies neighbours' claims he's plundering Wiltshire's underground water to fill his nine-million-gallon lake
A US billionaire's dream of creating a grand English country estate in the tradition of 18th Century landscape designer Capability Brown is facing a backlash from neighbours convinced he is tapping into their water supply. American financier Stephen Schwarzman bought the magnificent Conholt Park in Wiltshire – described as one of the finest shooting estates in southern England – for £82million three years ago. He has funnelled millions of pounds into transforming the 2,100-acre estate's parkland by building a huge lake that will hold more than nine million gallons of water. But The Mail on Sunday can reveal that Mr Schwarzman, dubbed the most powerful man on Wall Street, is under fire from neighbours who believe he is using a borehole to extract groundwater to fill the lake. This, they allege, could lead to water shortages at their own properties because they rely on a shared aquifer. There is also anger at plans to 'enhance' the estate's pheasant shoots, with local sources claiming Mr Schwarzman is preparing for up to 500 birds to be shot a day. 'I don't like what he is doing,' one local shooting enthusiast told the MoS. 'That's not sport.' Last night a spokesman for Mr Schwarzman, 78, the boss of Blackstone, one of the world's largest private-equity funds, denied the lake is being filled by a borehole and said the estate was instead using a 'highly sophisticated water collection system' that carries rainfall into the lake. The estate will also comply with all local regulations over the organisation of bird shoots and follow recommendations by the Game & Wildlife Conservation Trust about bird stocks, the spokesman added. Mr Schwarzman's blueprint, approved by Wiltshire council last July, involves extending the mansion's south lawn, planting hundreds of trees and creating a 'ha-ha' (a sunken fence). Sources close to the tycoon, who is worth an estimated £32 billion and is married to Christine, a lawyer, say he loves the UK and highlight how he has donated around £200 million to the University of Oxford. But his relationship with some Wiltshire neighbours became strained after his landscaping scheme began and construction lorries allegedly started thundering along the narrow roads surrounding the estate. Relations soured further when excavators completed the construction of a lake, covering three acres. Farmers and landowners became suspicious by the sight of the lake filling up with water after it was finished in early March – despite months of dry weather. The MoS understands a neighbouring country estate has written to Conholt's managers on behalf of nearby farms demanding reassurances that groundwater is not being abstracted to fill the lake. One resident claimed the lake already appeared half full, adding: 'How could it have filled that much if it's not being filled from a borehole? It's the farmers around who are so worried as these resources are not infinite.' Another long-standing resident told the MoS: 'I've built lakes in the past during my time in agriculture and I can tell you it takes a hell of a lot of water to fill one that size. In recent months we've had pretty much no proper rain. This is why people are confused and there's mistrust.' A local farmer said: 'The worry is that if the aquifer runs dry then loads of people round here are going to have nothing coming out of the tap. We've got livestock – they'll have nothing to drink.' Last night Mr Schwarzman's spokesman said the lake is only 27 per cent full and claims that a borehole was being used to fill it were 'false'. They highlighted planning documents which detail how the lake will be filled 'through rainfall and a drainage system'. The new drainage system collects rainwater from the main house, outbuildings and paved areas, which then flows downhill into the lake, the spokesman added. 'The lake was installed under full compliance with planning regulations to ensure local residents' water supply would remain unaffected. Groundwater extraction is not being used to fill the lake.' They did concede that on a very limited number of occasions water from a borehole on the estate had entered the lake. This had been when water was used to test a new drainage system or, on one occasion when a faulty valve led to leak that lasted for a weekend. The volume of water was very limited, they said. The planning documents show Mr Schwarzman wants shooting on the estate to be 'further developed and enhanced'. A spokesman for Mr Schwarzman said the estate will be used for shooting 28 days a year 'as opposed to local commercial shoots which operate more than 70 days per year'. The spokesman added: 'The new owners of Conholt Park are committed to the restoration and preservation of a landmark estate of national heritage importance. 'Every aspect of the project is advancing with the highest regard for local planning regulations and a steadfast commitment to environmental stewardship. Any suggestion to the contrary is false and misleading.'
The Sun
5 hours ago
- The Sun
Inside Pink Floyd star's super car collection worth £200million including rare Ferrari and motor from Steve McQueen film
A ROCK legend boasts a supercar collection to die for that includes a rare Ferrari and a motor from a Steve McQueen film. The Pink Floyd star also owns the world's most expensive motor worth a staggering £40 million. 5 5 5 Legendary drummer, Nick Mason, and his wife Anette showed off the impressive collection ahead of opening up the gardens of his 18th century home to visitors this weekend. A rare 1962 Ferrari 250 GTO took pride of place among the collection as its one of only 36 ever built. It's understood Mason paid £37k for it back in 1978 but it is estimated to be worth over £40 million today. The car finished third in the 1962 Le Mans 24 Hours race before he bought it and has never been restored. His fleet of rare Ferraris also includes the 512S which featured in the making of Steve McQueen's Le Mans before it was badly damaged by fire and then completely restored. Others on display included an F40, a GTB/4 Daytona, 1953 Ferrari 250MM, and a LaFerrari hybrid. It is estimated there are 40 sports cars in his garage worth a total of around £200 million. Other rare vehicles include a 1901 Panhard 5-liter, a 1927 Bugatti Type 35B, a 1957 Maserati 250F, a Birdcage Maserati, a 1955 Jaguar D-Type and a 1996 McLaren F1 GTR. He also owns several Aston Martins including an Ulster, and an LM17, LM18 and LM21. Mason hosted the Middlewick House Open Garden this weekend that saw thousands attend and admire his stunning collection of vehicles. The annual event in Corsham, Wiltshire, is a favourite among car aficionados and owners of Jaguars, Ferraris, Aston Martins, and more, who bring their vehicles to complement Mr Mason's collection. Wiltshire Bobby Van Trust, one of the charities that benefit from the event, described it as a "Mecca for car clubs and owners of Jaguars, Ferraris, Aston Martins, Lotus, Maclarens, Bugattis and Porsches." The event's other beneficiary, Wiltshire and Bath Air Ambulance, said more than 10,000 tickets have already been sold for the open garden and the attendance record is expected to be smashed this year. Last year, more than 11,000 people attended, raising a whopping £124,000 for charity. As well as the extensive car collection, guests were also able to view the air ambulance's Bell 429 helicopter with its operation aircrew due to be on-site to give people a closer look. The event also featured stalls manned by local artisans and food vendors, as well as live music, children's activities, and a play area. The event's website said: "Wander around the beautiful gardens and menagerie of animals, as well as seeing a selection of Pink Floyd drummer Nick Mason's classic and high performance cars. "The family-friendly weekend includes plenty of stalls to browse, with lots of items for sale, including jewellery, plants, candles, and art." And if you haven't had enough of car collections, F1 star Lando Norris lifted the lid on his luxury car collection last month. It includes an ultra-rare £2 million Lamborghini and iconic £1 million Ferrari. 5 5
BBC News
18 hours ago
- BBC News
Traffic changes to ease queues for Pink Floyd star open garden event
New traffic arrangements are being put in place to cut the queues of visitors flocking to Pink Floyd drummer Nick Mason's Open Garden 11,000 people are expected to visit the rock star's 18th Century country home near Corsham, Wiltshire, on 7 and 8 annual event, which features the musician's collection of Ferraris and hundreds of supercars and classic vehicles, attracts owners and enthusiasts from all over the UK and further proceeds are in aid of Wiltshire and Bath Air Ambulance Charity and the Wiltshire Bobby Van Trust. Organisers have responded to past traffic issues by working with Wiltshire Police, Wiltshire Council and local landowners to create a new entry route. "Thanks to the co-operation we've had we are now able to open a separate entrance for cars heading on to the site from Chippenham," said Jennie Shaw, Director of the Bobby Van Trust. "We've listened to the feedback we've had from residents, visitors and exhibitors and we think this will make it much easier for everyone."Cars arriving from Chippenham will now turn into a field before Middlewick Lane, with hopes the change will ease congestion. AA signs will also help divert non-event event will run from 10:00 to 17:00 BST, opening an hour earlier than before. More caterers have been added to reduce queues and offer a wider food selection. A special highlight this year is the presence of Wiltshire Air Ambulance's Bell 429 helicopter and operational crew, offering guests a rare chance to see the aircraft up close and meet the emergency the car displays, the event includes live music, food stalls, children's activities, artisan shopping, and other year, the event raised £124,000 for the two charities."We're incredibly grateful to Nick and Annette Mason," said Adam Baker from Wiltshire Air Ambulance. "They've been amazing ambassadors and their generosity makes a huge difference to our work."The Wiltshire Bobby Van Trust provides free home security support for older and vulnerable residents, as well as cyber safety education through its Stay Safe Online programme.
