MSD workload behind partial scrap of govt work programme: documents
By Lauren Crimp of RNZ
The government has scrapped part of a work programme designed to prevent people ending up in emergency housing because the social development ministry cannot cope with the workload, official documents show.
A December MSD report to Associate Housing Minister Tama Potaka said that was partly because it was too busy with work related to changes to the Jobseeker benefit.
But Potaka said while he agreed to end the first phase of the "early interventions" work to stop people needing emergency housing, the second phase would still go ahead, and he was due to receive advice on that "shortly".
The report showed phase one involved looking at what could be improved within the MSD system to help people struggling to get into, or remain in, a stable home.
Officials said they had started the work, but were too stretched to carry on.
"We do not recommend progressing further with phase one work at this time due to insufficient frontline capacity and wider organisational pressures," the report said.
"MSD's frontline capacity is currently oversubscribed, and there are wider organisational pressures because of the focus on implementing initiatives to support other government targets, including the Jobseeker target."
The government's plan to slash the number of people on the Jobseeker benefit includes MSD staff offering phone-based case management to 10,000 people and creating 'Individual Job Plans' for more than 70,000 people.
To do that, MSD had to drop the emergency housing early interventions work, the report said.
"If phase one were to continue, because it would require resources from across the organisation, there would need to be a trade-off against other MSD work programme priorities, including supporting the Jobseeker target."
MSD had made some headway on phase one, including gathering feedback from community housing providers and organisations supporting homeless people.
One of the themes that emerged was that a person's need for emergency housing was more likely caused by "systemic failures" - for example, poor communication between agencies like MSD, Health and Corrections - rather than the person themselves.
The report pointed to a dramatic decrease in the number of people in emergency housing, and said MSD had made a range of changes to help people into suitable homes.
That included tightening the criteria for emergency housing eligibility.
But MSD needed more time for those changes to bed in to see what impact they had, it said.
"We will be better placed to fully understand potential need and whether any new processes or changes are required, if more time is given to understand how the changes are interacting with each other and once planned evaluations have taken place."
Phase two work did not depend on phase one being completed, Potaka said.
"I did not agree to stop work on early interventions but rather chose not to further progress phase one of the workstream, which was focused only on MSD interventions within the current system," he said.
"The Ministry of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) is due to provide advice to me shortly on phase two of the work, which is expected to take a more holistic approach to reduce the likelihood of people requiring emergency housing (EH) support."
It is not clear what that holistic approach is.
Potaka's office said he would receive information on phase two in late April, and further details would be available "once decisions around phase two have been made".
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Otago Daily Times
3 hours ago
- Otago Daily Times
Thousands sign petition to ban fireworks
MPs Greg Fleming and Jenny Marcroft, and Animates' Nathalie Moolenschot, with Frankie the golden doodle in the centre. Photo: RNZ / Samuel Rillstone More 90,000 humans - and tens of thousands of animals - have signed a petition in support of a ban on the public sale of fireworks. The Pawprint Petition was presented to Parliament and was received by National MP Greg Fleming. As well as the human signatures, the petition was supplemented by nearly 80,000 additional paw, hoof prints and marks from pets of concerned owners. Petition organisers Animates said loud explosions from the letting off of fireworks - purchased around the celebration of Guy Fawkes night - created "extreme stress", leading to injuries, fatalities and missing animals. They said banning the sale of fireworks was crucial to protect animals from unnecessary fear, distress and harm. Fireworks impact pets, livestock, zoo animals and wildlife - vets association The New Zealand Veterinary Association spokesperson Sally Cory said fireworks caused stress and anxiety in pets, livestock, zoo animals and wildlife. "Every year, veterinarians are called to see horses that have been badly injured by panicking and running through fences, attempting to jump out of paddocks, or have run on to roads, endangering themselves and motorists. "Cats and dogs often get anxious and try to flee when fireworks are going off. As a result many each year are injured. Large animals in general suffer from fear and stress related to fireworks and the impact of fireworks on wildlife is also a recognised issue," Corry said. Pawprint Petition 'a world's first' Animates general manager of marketing Nathalie Moolenschot told RNZ the signatures were gathered over six months and the inclusion of the animals pawprints and marks was likely to be "a world's first". "Just having [fireworks] available in New Zealand for sale for a couple of days a year enables people to stockpile them which means that they're being lit all throughout the year. "Owners are unable to protect their pets and livestock during those times," Moolenschot said. She said she was thrilled that the large response to the petition was now a matter of official record.
Otago Daily Times
5 hours ago
- Otago Daily Times
Watch: How does Jacinda Ardern see her time as PM?
Former New Zealand prime minister Jacinda Ardern says her dad wasn't sure she could handle politics, but Ardern says she led with empathy, and now talks to others about how to do the same. Ardern's father thought she didn't have thick enough skin to get into politics, the former PM recalls. 'Dad really worried … 'Politics? Not for Jacinda she's too thin-skinned' and he was right,' Ardern tells RNZ's Jesse Mulligan, sitting in the JFK School of Government at Harvard University where she is leading a fellowship on empathetic leadership. Ardern, whose memoir A Different Kind of Power hit shelves this week, recalls in the book the time she was accosted in an airport bathroom and thanked for "ruining the country". 'I put it into the book not to give a singular personal experience but to speak to what I've noticed is an exchange in a political environment generally, and I don't mean just in New Zealand. 'The conversations I have with leaders past and present, they've noticed a shift in the last five years in particular.' But Ardern, who juggled first time motherhood while in power (becoming just the second woman in history to have a baby in office), says the skin her father feared would let her down, defined the kind of leader she became. 'I think the lesson for me was maybe we need thin-skinned people in politics because usually that is emblematic that you are empathetic that you're motivated to do the right thing by people and it really deeply offends you if you're critiqued for not doing your job well.' During her time at the helm of New Zealand, Ardern led the country during the March 2019 Christchurch mosque attacks, then the Whakaari White Island tragedy soon after. During these 'darker moments' Ardern describes herself as agnostic, but acknowledges her religious background did shape her take on things. 'I think it also gave me a respect for people who do have faith in their lives, and an understanding of faith communities,' she says. And unpacking all of that during writing the book was one of the hardest parts of the experience, which she says someone described as 'therapy with a deadline'. 'Because it's an unusual career path people are often interested in where your motivation and your values come from, and when you write a memoir you're digging back a little bit and giving a bit of an explanation of how you came to be on the path that you were. 'The thing that I ended up finding the trickiest was going back and talking about the role that faith had for me. Not because I hadn't disclosed it, it was very much on the record that I had been raised on the LDS church. The thing I found difficult was, after I left, I put that away in a box and didn't reflect on that again. 'When I came to write I had to pull it all back out again.' Ardern's tumultuous term was then hit with the Covid-19 pandemic and criticism that came with the decisions she was forced to make. A recent Royal Commission concluded that the government was too harsh with mandates and lockdowns at the time, Mulligan points out. 'The one thing I would say … is my goal from the outside of this horrific experience was save people's lives and keep people together,' Ardern says. 'I think we did one, and the other we didn't. But when I look around the world, we weren't the only ones that struggled with the second part. Places who had very different strategies are having the same experience in the aftermath. 'We were operating on certain information in a certain environment but with now the ability to reflect back, and I wouldn't' argue with that.' To those who say Ardern's government did not get enough done during that tenure: 'I would strongly disagree with you. Did Covid dominate internationally? Of course it did … it's hard for a pandemic not to … The idea that we haven't had an impact, I disagree'. She lists their work improving the lives of New Zealander's living in poverty, easing the burden on families during cost of living struggles, changes made to benefit rates, school lunches and climate change framework amongst some wins. And always circling back to the importance of kindness: 'I wouldn't underestimate the difference it makes when you demonstrate that the way you do government can be different as well,' Ardern adds. 'We set out to do things differently … we set out to be an empathetic government, a kind government, one that didn't make personal attacks. I hope we raised expectations that you can do things differently.'
Otago Daily Times
6 hours ago
- Otago Daily Times
Watch: How does Jacinda Ardern see her time as leader?
Former New Zealand prime minister Jacinda Ardern says her dad wasn't sure she could handle politics, but Ardern says she led with empathy, and now talks to others about how to do the same. Ardern's father thought she didn't have thick enough skin to get into politics, the former New Zealand Prime Minister recalls. 'Dad really worried … 'Politics? Not for Jacinda she's too thin-skinned' and he was right,' Ardern tells RNZ's Jesse Mulligan, sitting in the JFK School of Government at Harvard University where she is leading a fellowship on empathetic leadership. Ardern, whose memoir A Different Kind of Power hit shelves this week, recalls in the book the time she was accosted in an airport bathroom and thanked for "ruining the country". 'I put it into the book not to give a singular personal experience but to speak to what I've noticed is an exchange in a political environment generally, and I don't mean just in New Zealand. 'The conversations I have with leaders past and present, they've noticed a shift in the last five years in particular.' But Ardern, who juggled first time motherhood while in power (becoming just the second woman in history to have a baby in office), says the skin her father feared would let her down, defined the kind of leader she became. 'I think the lesson for me was maybe we need thin-skinned people in politics because usually that is emblematic that you are empathetic that you're motivated to do the right thing by people and it really deeply offends you if you're critiqued for not doing your job well.' During her time at the helm of New Zealand, Ardern led the country during the March 2019 Christchurch mosque attacks, then the Whakaari White Island tragedy soon after. During these 'darker moments' Ardern describes herself as agnostic, but acknowledges her religious background did shape her take on things. 'I think it also gave me a respect for people who do have faith in their lives, and an understanding of faith communities,' she says. And unpacking all of that during writing the book was one of the hardest parts of the experience, which she says someone described as 'therapy with a deadline'. 'Because it's an unusual career path people are often interested in where your motivation and your values come from, and when you write a memoir you're digging back a little bit and giving a bit of an explanation of how you came to be on the path that you were. 'The thing that I ended up finding the trickiest was going back and talking about the role that faith had for me. Not because I hadn't disclosed it, it was very much on the record that I had been raised on the LDS church. The thing I found difficult was, after I left, I put that away in a box and didn't reflect on that again. 'When I came to write I had to pull it all back out again.' Ardern's tumultuous term was then hit with the Covid-19 pandemic and criticism that came with the decisions she was forced to make. A recent Royal Commission concluded that the government was too harsh with mandates and lockdowns at the time, Mulligan points out. 'The one thing I would say … is my goal from the outside of this horrific experience was save people's lives and keep people together,' Ardern says. 'I think we did one, and the other we didn't. But when I look around the world, we weren't the only ones that struggled with the second part. Places who had very different strategies are having the same experience in the aftermath. 'We were operating on certain information in a certain environment but with now the ability to reflect back, and I wouldn't' argue with that.' To those who say Ardern's government did not get enough done during that tenure: 'I would strongly disagree with you. Did Covid dominate internationally? Of course it did … it's hard for a pandemic not to … The idea that we haven't had an impact, I disagree'. She lists their work improving the lives of New Zealander's living in poverty, easing the burden on families during cost of living struggles, changes made to benefit rates, school lunches and climate change framework amongst some wins. And always circling back to the importance of kindness: 'I wouldn't underestimate the difference it makes when you demonstrate that the way you do government can be different as well,' Ardern adds. 'We set out to do things differently … we set out to be an empathetic government, a kind government, one that didn't make personal attacks. I hope we raised expectations that you can do things differently.'
