High Court defers judgment in legal row over Athlone asylum-seeker centre to await draft legislation
A High Court judge has said the Government is obliged to provide alternative accommodation for "innocent" and "vulnerable" asylum seekers at risk of homelessness while legislation aimed at fast-tracking refugee accommodation is drawn up.
Ms Justice Emily Farrell said on Wednesday she would defer judgment in an application by the State to quash an order that struck down a statutory instrument used to develop emergency accommodation at Lissywollen in Athlone, Co Westmeath.
Advertisement
She said she wants to wait for updates and to see draft legislation from the Oireachtas. The government intends to remedy a legal issue over the bypassing of environmental assessments for accommodation that has been categorised as having "emergency" status.
Ms Justice Farrell said there could be consequences and a "real risk of homelessness for innocent third parties and families who may be vulnerable" staying at the centre if they could not be re-homed.
Ms Justice Farrell said that in the interim there was an obligation on the Minister to attempt to provide alternative accommodation and to show the efforts made to do so.
The judge said that nobody but those granted accommodation last February should be offered accommodation at the centre, and that no new works should be carried out at the facility, with only essential maintenance to be undertaken.
Advertisement
Lawyers for the State have told the High Court that there is a "serious risk to the dignity and safety" of asylum seekers if the government is not allowed to use special powers to fast-track refugee accommodation, as the system cannot immediately re-house the 137 residents in the facility.
Earlier this week, Aoife Carroll SC, for the State, asked the court to put a stay on the December quashing of the use of a statutory instrument that had been used to speed up the establishment of the facility at Lissywollen. Ms Carroll said that while environmental and EU law had been complied with, it had not been entered into record, which amounted to an innocent procedural error.
The action was taken by Independent Ireland councillor Paul Hogan, who successfully applied to the court in December for a judicial review, arguing that the expedited development was unlawful. The State has conceded the statutory instrument used was "invalid" and is finalising repairing legislation.
Cllr Hogan is taking the case against the office of the Minister for Children, Equality, Disability, Integration and Youth.
Advertisement
A Statutory Instrument is a secondary legislation, made by a Minister, modifying existing laws.
Cllr Hogan successfully claimed the Minister failed to adequately "screen" the project for potential environmental impacts and that the Minister lacked the expertise to carry out such assessments in an expedited manner.
Protests have been held in Athlone over the plan to further develop army-tent accommodation for a possible 1,000 asylum seekers, in up to 150 tents, on a site to the rear of an existing direct provision centre.
Ms Carroll has said amending legislation was presently to come before the Government and was hoped to be passed in November.
Advertisement
Ms Carroll is applying to put a stay on the December order striking down the use of the statutory instrument used by the office of the Minister in expediting the development of the asylum centre.
Ms Justice Farrell today said she would adjourn the matter to July 21st to allow for sight of the draft legislation that Ms Carroll has said was "imminent".
Ms Justice Farrell said she was conscious of the risk to the residents' safety and dignity should the facility have to be closed.
The judge said the number of people accommodated at the centre should be 'diminished substantially' by July 21st.
In taking the successful judicial review, Cllr Hogan, who secured 4.8 per cent of first preference votes running for Independent Ireland in Longford-Westmeath, claimed the ministerial process was "unlawful, irrational and a breach of fair procedures".
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Leader Live
13 minutes ago
- Leader Live
Trade strategy will protect UK firms from ‘harm' amid global shift
The Department for Business and Trade (DBT) said it was the UK's first Trade Strategy to be published since Brexit. It follows the publication of an industrial strategy earlier this week which set out plans to back UK industries which the Government thinks have the potential to grow. The trade plan aims to make the UK the best-connected country in the world to do business, helping to loosen regulation and expand opportunities for exporters. As part of the plan, the DBT pledged to introduce new tools and safeguards to help protect UK firms against the threat of a shifting global trade environment. This is understood to mean expanding its ability to respond to unfair trade practices, guarding sectors such as steel, and potential powers to respond to deliberate economic pressures against the UK. The decision to strengthen trade defences comes at a time of heightened uncertainty following Mr Trump's tariff announcements in April, which have hiked charges on most US imports and raised concerns over the future of global trade arrangements. The strategy nonetheless follows a trio of major deals struck between the UK and India, the US and the EU in recent months. The agreement with the US is set to implement quotas that will effectively eliminate the tariff on British steel and reduce the rate on UK vehicles to 10%. Meanwhile, the deal with India opened up trade between the two countries by lowering tariffs on exports like gin and whisky. Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer said the trade strategy was a 'promise to British business: helping firms to sell more, grow faster, and compete globally'. Jonathan Reynolds, the Government's Business and Trade Secretary, said: 'The UK is an open trading nation but we must reconcile this with a new geopolitical reality and work in our own national interest. 'Our Trade Strategy will sharpen our trade defence so we can ensure British businesses are protected from harm, while also relentlessly pursuing every opportunity to sell to more markets under better terms than before.' Trade minister Douglas Alexander said the Government was taking 'every step necessary to safeguard British businesses from the increasingly protectionist mood in much of the world by sharpening our defensive toolkit'. Meanwhile, the newly created Ricardo Fund aims to set aside funding to tackle complex regulatory issues and remove obstacles for UK businesses selling abroad – which the DBT said could unlock £5 billion worth of opportunities. It is also expanding the capacity of UK Export Finance – the country's export credit agency – by £20 billion to total £80 billion. The body provides Government-backed loans, guarantees and insurance to help companies trade overseas. Separate to the trade strategy, the DBT said it was calling for views across the steel industry about how future trade measures and protections should be shaped. Steel producers and businesses across the supply chain will be invited to submit feedback over a six-week 'call for evidence' period. Current safeguarding measures – which include tariff-free quotas on steel imports to limit sudden surges – expire in June next year. Mr Reynolds said the Government would 'not sit by idly while cheap imports threaten to undercut UK industry'.
Reuters
19 minutes ago
- Reuters
Brazil lower house nixes Lula's financial transactions tax hike
BRASILIA, June 25 (Reuters) - Brazil's lower house of Congress on Wednesday overturned a May decree from President Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva raising the financial transactions tax (IOF) on certain credit, foreign-exchange and private pension plan operations. The measure now heads to the Senate, where it could ultimately roll back Lula's directive. The move marks a setback for Lula's government, which had opted for the tax hike as a way to boost revenue and limit the size of spending freezes needed to comply with fiscal rules. It also underscores the government's failed strategy to negotiate with Congress, which quickly rejected the tax measure. Much of Lula's economic agenda has snagged in Congress this year - including proposed spending cuts - as his approval ratings, opens new tab slump ahead of next year's presidential election. The tax hike was first announced, opens new tab by decree in late May and was projected to raise 61.5 billion reais ($11.07 billion) through 2026 by raising taxes on a range of transactions, including corporate loans and foreign-currency card payments. The announcement triggered immediate backlash, prompting the government to walk back, opens new tab the tax increase on certain overseas investments within hours, amid criticism, opens new tab that it was effectively introducing capital controls. Earlier this month the government submitted a revised, watered-down decree, opens new tab with lower rates that still affected corporate borrowing, foreign exchange and pension funds. Lula's leftist government has boosted spending on social programs while seeking to shore up public finances by targeting what it views as unfair tax breaks largely benefiting the rich. But Congress, where Lula lacks a solid coalition, has insisted it will not approve new spending without cost-control measures. Lawmakers have also weakened or blocked the few proposals to cut spending that the government has submitted. ($1 = 5.5577 reais)
South Wales Guardian
26 minutes ago
- South Wales Guardian
UK energy and steel to be classed as ‘nationally important' in procurement shift
Public sector buyers would be able to avoid normal requirements to consider overseas bidders and instead give priority to domestic firms under the plans set out in a consultation launching on Wednesday. Ministers would be allowed to designate sectors such as steel, energy and cyber nationally important in order to help grant them more of the £400 billion spent on procurement each year, the Government said. Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster Pat McFadden said the proposals would ensure British industry was supported and 'boost growth'. 'The new rules being considered will give us the power to protect our national industries, ensuring more money goes to them as we buy goods and services in Government,' he said. The Government said the new rules will also ensure buyers exclude companies that cannot provide evidence of a good record of paying companies in their supply chains promptly and on time in a move to protect small businesses. New guidance will also require Government departments to consider British steel products for the £725 billion of UK infrastructure spending over the next 10 years announced in the industrial strategy on Monday. UK Steel welcomed the proposals, describing them as 'unequivocally positive news' that would help safeguard jobs in the industry. Director general of UK Steel, Gareth Stace, said: 'These changes rightly recognise the strategic importance of steelmaking to national security and the vital role of resilient domestic supply chains.' It comes as the industry faces uncertainty over the US-UK trade deal finalised this month, which slashed tariffs on aerospace and auto sectors but left levies on steel standing at 25% rather than falling to zero as originally agreed. The Government has said both sides have agreed to 'make progress towards 0% tariffs on core steel products' in ongoing talks.
