17-04-2025
A New Hampshire judge is deciding whether to block Trump's anti-DEI directive to schools
The National Education Association and American Civil Liberties sued the department in
Get N.H. Morning Report
A weekday newsletter delivering the N.H. news you need to know right to your inbox.
Enter Email
Sign Up
But during a hearing Thursday, Deputy Associate Attorney General Abishek Kambli argued the teachers' union lacks standing to sue because the guidance is aimed at schools, not teachers. And educators who are 'self-censoring' due to misunderstanding the letter aren't being harmed, he said.
Advertisement
'You can't manufacture harm simply by inflicting harm on yourself,' he said.
Kambli also suggested a temporary halt to enforcement was unnecessary because there is a lengthy, multi-step process to determine whether a school should lose funding, with ample opportunity to challenge findings. But Judge Landya McCafferty read passages from the Education Department press release announcing the recent cancellation of grants and contracts to
Advertisement
'It doesn't describe any sort of process, it says immediate,' she said.
The directive does not carry the force of law but threatens to use civil rights enforcement to rid schools of DEI practices. Schools that continue such practices 'in violation of federal law' can face Justice Department litigation and a
Sarah Hinger, an attorney for the ACLU, pushed back against Kambli's claim that the letter was not a final action that can be challenged in court but rather an explanation of the department's enforcement priorities.
'It requires. It orders. It dictates,' she said. 'The chill from that is happening now, and plaintiffs are not required to wait until they're hauled into court to challenge an unconstitutional law.'
Education officials in some Democratic-led states have indicated they will not comply with the order to submit certification of their schools' compliance. Hinger told reporters after the hearing that in addition to fear, educators have also expressed bravery.
'We are seeing folks across the education community stand up and assert their rights and really being brave in indicating how contrary this 'Dear Colleague' letter is to sound educational practices from K-12 through higher education,' she said.
