5 days ago
I tried Jaffa Cake dupes from Dunnes Stores, Lidl, Aldi and Tesco – and €1.59 winner was BETTER than original
JAFFA Cakes are one of those treats that everyone seems to love – whether it be with a cuppa or by themselves, they are always welcome in Irish households.
And I set out to find which ones are the best from Aldi, Tesco, Lidl and Dunnes Stores.
Advertisement
3
I taste tested Jaffa Cake dupes from Ireland's top four supermarkets
Credit: Journalist Collect
3
One of them was a clear winner
Dunnes Stores
I started with
The packaging looked promising and the cakes themselves had that familiar shape - chocolate top, sponge base and the all-important orange jelly in the middle.
The first bite was nice but a little bit underwhelming - the cake was a little dry and the orange filling lacked punch.
And although it tasted more sugary than citrusy, it went well paired up with the dark
Advertisement
READ MORE IN MONEY
I certainly wouldn't say no if they were offered to me and I might even find myself eating quite a few in one sitting.
All in all, I would rate these a solid 6.5/10.
Aldi Ireland
Next up were the Belmont Jaffa cakes from Aldi, a pack for only €1.59 - and this is where things took a turn.
Straight away, the dark chocolate was a real standout and the cake was light and spongy.
Advertisement
Most read in Money
There was also the perfect amount of
They didn't just taste good – might I say they tasted even better than the original.
The Sun tries Wetherspoons' new menu
Aldi's version was the only one I paused mid-bite to check the box again.
They absolutely nailed it and I would rate them a solid 9/10.
Advertisement
Tesco Ireland
Then came Tesco, where you'd get the
The largest versions I have seen so far, I'll admit that I had mild hopes for them - but they fell flat.
At first taste, the sponge was dense and extremely dry - it tasted like it had been left in someone's cupboard for quite a few years.
And unfortunately for my taste buds it didn't get any better after that.
Advertisement
The chocolate tasted extremely low quality and the orange filling was more like diluted jam — sweet, but with none of that bright citrus flavour you want.
I would say it seemed like an afterthought, but I don't know what
I didn't feel the need to go back for another and would rate these a 4/10.
Lidl Ireland
Finally,
Advertisement
These were a pleasant surprise - the sponge was soft, the chocolate had a decent taste and the filling had a good citrusy flavour - not too sweet or sugary.
Although they lacked what Aldi's version had, in a blind test I might have mistaken them for something far more
I would happily indulge myself in them all day and I would rate them a solid 8/10.
In the end, Aldi's Belmont Jaffa cakes are the clear winner - full of flavour, balanced texture and left you wanting more.
Advertisement
3
Aldi Ireland's Jaffa Cakes placed first overall
