20-05-2025
Refusing drug test results in probation being revoked
Thomas Donald Smith, despite his best efforts and unfortunate twists and turns in life, did the one unforgivable condition of his probation — he refused to submit to a drug test.
As a result, Smith's probation was revoked during a hearing last Tuesday.
Criminal Court Judge Wesley Bray, expressing sympathy for Smith's loss of his brother in a traffic crash, also found refusing to submit to the drug screen could not be overlooked.
On Dec. 2, 2022, Smith pleaded guilty to possession of less than .5 grams of meth with intent and received a three-year suspended sentence with 180 days to serve and the balance on supervised probation.
Tennessee Department of Corrections/Board of Pardon and Parole Officer Kyla Cook testified on April 14, 2023, Smith was found in violation of conditions of probation by testing positive for meth and served an additional 45 days in jail.
On June 21, 2023, Smith's probation was revoked again and this time he was granted furlough to attend Adult and Teen Challenge in Kentucky. Smith successfully completed the program and returned to supervised probation on Aug. 13, 2024, Cook testified.
The next drug screens, from August 2024 to Nov. 30, 2024, Smith tested negative for drugs on weekly screens. Cook testified at no time did Smith ask for help with his addiction struggles.
On March 20, Smith declined to take a drug test despite being advised a warrant would be signed for probation violation. When made aware of the warrant, Smith turned himself in to authorities at the Justice Center, leading up to Tuesday's hearing.
Smith's mother, Donna Smith, testified that her other son, Hunter Smith, 25, was killed in an August 2024 traffic crash in Pikeville by a motorist now charged with vehicular homicide.
She said her surviving son, Thomas, was deeply affected by the family loss and was going to grief counseling sessions.
'He was coping with a lot,' Mrs. Smith testified, and added she contacted the probation officer expressing concern that the tragedy was leading her son to return to meth use.
Assistant Public Defender Janis Mize, noting Smith's original probation would have expired in December, urged the judge to let him serve six or seven months in jail and then terminate probation.
Assistant District Attorney Allison Null asked the court to revoke Smith's probation, citing three violations of conditions of the supervised probation.
In issuing his ruling, Bray expressed sympathy for Mrs. Smith and Thomas Smith's loss of his brother. But, he also noted that turning to drugs was not the answer.
'You do have the sympathy of the court … drugs and the demon and life changing … you should have taken the test,' Bray said in revoking Smith's probation.
He added testing positive, while not a result favorable for Smith, would have been better than refusing to take the test.
In other cases on the docket, the following took place:
Deadline docket
•James Michael Cain, possession of a weapon by a felon and domestic assault, continued to July 8.
•Jacob Ryan Edmonds, evading arrest, continued to June 17.
•John Christopher Garland, aggravated assault and vandalism of $2,500 to $10,000, continued to June 17.
•Curtis Richard Hood, aggravated child abuse, neglect or endangerment, continued to Aug. 12.
•Kelly Scott Hood, burglary, aggravated burglary, theft of property of $1,000 to $2,500 and joyriding, motion for evaluation granted and continued to July 8.
•Rebecca Leann Ladd, possession of meth with intent and possession of a firearm during commission of a dangerous felony, continued to June 17.
•Tyler Ray Owens, possession of .5 grams of fentanyl or more, continued to June 17.
•Derek Brandon Parrott, theft of property of $2,500 to $10,000, vandalism of $1,000 to $2,500 and simple possession of meth, continued to June 17.
•William Rix Schuyler Jr., burglary and theft of property of $10,000 to $60,000, continued to June 3.
•Brandi Rena Stokes, simple possession of meth and simple possession, continued to June 3.
•Lisa Marie Wilson, vehicular homicide by intoxication, continued to June 17.
Probation violations
•Cody Allen Dickenson, probation violation, capias and attachment issued for failure to appear, 10 days in jail and ordered held for bond hearing.
•Raylee Kay Hawkins, pleaded guilty to a probation violation of positive drug screen, to serve 15 days in jail at 75% and will keep judicial diversion with reinstatement back on probation after sentence is served.
•Timothy Wayne Martin, 90 days to serve at 75% after which probation will be terminated.
•Donnie Lynn Rector, probation violation, continued to June 3.
•Sunshine Angelia Schoonhoven Thomas, probation violation hearing continued to June 3.
•David Jack Williams, Public Defender's Office appointed to represent Williams and probation violation hearing continued to June 3.
Continued boundover
•Robert Alva Sardella, one case, continued to May 20.
