27-02-2025
City Council considers study on feasibility of rebuilding or moving obelisk
The City Council unanimously voted to approve spending $100,000 from the city's general fund for a study assessing the feasibility of rebuilding or moving the Soldiers' Monument at Wednesday's City Council meeting.
The study was directed from an October resolution passed by the council in a 5-4 vote. Originally intended to explore the feasibility of moving the obelisk to the Santa Fe National Cemetery, the resolution was later modified to direct the city manager to explore the feasibility of moving it to any new location or rebuilding it on the Plaza without taking any further action.
Constructed in 1867 in honor of Civil War Union soldiers, the obelisk has long been controversial because of a plaque also honoring soldiers who died in battles with 'savage Indians' during the same period. The word 'savage' was chiseled away in 1974 and on Indigenous Peoples Day in 2020 the monument was partially toppled by protestors.
Less than two months after the October resolution's passage, state District Court Judge Matthew Wilson rendered his decision in a lawsuit the Hispanic fraternal organization Union Protectiva de Santa Fe filed against the city in 2021 seeking for the monument to be rebuilt.
Wilson's Dec. 19 ruling required the city to remove the box that had been surrounding the base of the obelisk since it was torn down within 30 days and to either rebuild the obelisk within 180 days or to follow a little-used process outlined by the State Historic Preservation Office.
City Attorney Erin McSherry has said previously her understanding of the ruling also includes the option that the city take no further action after removing the box.
The city decided not to appeal Wilson's ruling and in January removed the box surrounding the obelisk and cleaned it of graffiti but had not taken any other action until now.
Wednesday's vote was to allocate funding for the study but was not an approval of an actual contract, which is still in the process of being negotiated. A request for qualifications was published on the city's website earlier in the year and received one response, city spokesperson Regina Ruiz wrote in a Wednesday email.
'There wasn't a robust response to that but there is a firm that's been identified that's capable of doing that work," City Manager Mark Scott said Wednesday.
A scope of work document states the study would include conducting a structural assessment of the obelisk and use that to determine the "services, timelines, and costs" required to rebuild it to either a "like or similar condition" to its pre-2020 state or its pre-2020 condition without the "savage Indians" plaque. It would also evaluate the feasibility and costs of moving the monument to the National Cemetery or another location, "including all logistics or minimizing damage" and to summarize all the findings in a written report.
At a Feb. 19 Quality of Life committee meeting, Scott said the contract is still being negotiated and the scope of work will include some type of public engagement process.
In response to a question at the committee meeting, he said his understanding is that the study can be completed within 60 to 90 days. Its unclear if the city would be penalized if the city did ultimately decided to rebuild the obelisk but did so past the 180 day limit.
"There is an understanding that timing is very critical," he said.
On Wednesday, Scott said the study will likely cost less than $100,000 but that future actions would likely cost much more.
"We don't believe that the initial work is going to cost that much, maybe even as little as half that much, but we don't know where it goes," he said.
At the committee meeting, several councilors said they would like to have either a special meeting to discuss the obelisk or to receive a presentation at a regular council meeting regarding the city's options, something Scott said he will accommodate.
